Side by Side Comparison of: Tonno Pro vs Dee Zee vs Auto Ventshade

Love it. Fits well, easy to take in and out. Getting 17.5-17.6 mph instead of 14.0 before installing. I do a lot of highway driving 25% better gas mileage? Wish I had brought it sooner.

Fits PERFECT! I got this for my 2013 Ford F150 Platinum Edition and MAN WAS I IMPRESSED! Great Quality! It even COMES WITH WORK GLOVES so your hands don't get dirty, COVER PROTECTOR SPRAY to improve longevity of the cover & an LED FLASHLIGHT with velcro to attach into the bed of your truck so you can see at night and pull off in case you need a little light elsewhere. It keeps the bed of the truck dry. No leaks (and we have had a lot of rain lately). It does tend to make a bit of a flapping sound going Highway/Interstate Speeds (70+ mph)... it is a fabric cover, you can't expect anything less.

I would DEFINITELY recommend this product and company to anyone looking for a quality cover.

Bought this cover for a road trip. The instructions were straightforward-no problems with the install. We went through a car wash and some water was in the bed afterwards. It was empty at the time, but I was a little concerned. I should mention that we didn't use any of the sealing foam; we just clamped on the cover. Well, we loaded the truck and drove 8 hours from TX to KS. It rained hard the ENTIRE TIME: severe, flood warning kind of rain. When we unloaded, EVERYTHING was dry in the bed: luggage, toys,and some cardboard boxes. I was shocked (pleasantly)! I highly recommend this product.

Great cover. I've seen a lot of Tonno covers on other trucks in my area and I think that this one looks as good or better than some of the ones that are much more expensive. The installation is super easy. I've had the cover on and off multiple times and it's very easy to remove and put back on. I've also driven through some decent rain with no leaks. On the highway I've been up to a little over 70mph and there is no noise from the cover. If you're looking for a nice affordable cover, I think that this is a good one.

I've wanted a cover on the bed of my F-150 Lariat for quite some time, and have kicked myself for not getting one installed at the dealership when I bought my truck new here a couple years back. In hindsight, it was better that I waited.

I have received so many compliments on this cover that I've lost count. People were in awe when I showed them how it worked (folding vs rolling). All asked where I purchased it, and were even more surprised when I told them the price. It was definitely a great addition to my truck and I have no regrets on this purchase.

Installation really is as easy as they say. As I tend to get slightly OCD installing anything, it took a bit longer than directions advertised when I centered it over the bed. There is no additional hardware to install, and there are no tensioners requiring constant adjustments all year long like those found on roll-up covers.

Folding it up is a breeze....and speaking of breezes....be very careful if you fold this up and strong winds are present. A 30mph gust nearly pulled the tail end of the cover right out of my hands when I was opening it, and had I not grabbed it quick enough, I'm sure the results would have been upsetting to me at the very least.

Even when folded up and locked into place, I've had plenty of room to store items in the bed. I admit, I was hesitant about losing storage space since this cover folds up, but it hasn't been a problem yet. I've removed it completely only once to get an ATV loaded up and tied down. The cover is so lightweight that I just placed it in the back seat and then remounted it later.

The bed has remained dry after runs through the auto car wash, and several nasty rainstorms. The cover performs exactly as it should keeping cargo dry, and unlike other covers, there is no "flapping noise" heard while driving down the interstate or highway.

I am BEYOND thrilled with the increased fuel economy after installing the cover. There has been a drastic increase in my MPG's since then, and I suspect it won't be much longer until the cover has paid for itself. I do a large amount of commuting, and not having to stop for gas every week is refreshing to say the least.

TonnoPro included a "Goodie Bag" with the cover. A bottle of cleaner/protectant, pair of gloves and an LED light to mount in the bed. The light (albeit not an extremely powerful one), does work well enough to illuminate the bed when the cover is closed. As I said it's not "spotlight bright", just enough to help guide your eyes if you're in search of something I the dark.

I would encourage anyone interested in making this purchase,to verify the cover model number for your truck at TonnoPro's website before purchasing, to ensure you receive the correct size. I double checked twice (There goes that pesky OCD again!), for peace of mind, as they have several covers and model numbers vary on the length of your bed and other truck options.

I may upgrade to TonnoPro's hard top folding cover in time, but for now, this one is working perfectly.

If you're looking for a cost-effective cover that gets the job done and looks great, look no further.

Excellent product. I bought mine from Amazon Warehouse "Used, in Like New" condition and that's exactly how it came. Wasn't a mark on it. Fit my 5.5' bed like a glove. It's VERY grippy and will actually take some getting used to. It's both good and bad. I think once the mat gets a bit of dust on it, it wont be so bad. Right now it's almost tacky feeling.So I'm not sure what else to say about it. Maybe I got lucky regarding the cut/fit of the mat as other reviews mentioned very poor cuts/fit. Mine's perfectly symmetrical and fits great. Also, it cuts down on road noise a bit as well.If you just use your bed for carrying "everyday" items, then this product is great. If you're hauling sand, gravel, mulch, etc, or are frequently sliding heavy items in and out of your bed, fork over the $ for a spray in liner and forget this thing. Keep in mind, gravity is holding it in place. If you're having palleted items forked into your bed frequently, they'll have to be dropped straight down. There will be no pushing/sliding them forward with the forks because the mat will just slide and bunch up.I love this thing. Should've been my 2nd accessory after the tonneau cover.

Fit perfectly! I had my tools and a plastic bin in the back that I had to keep strapped down which worked till I hit sharp curve or something then boom I could hear all my stuff slamming around. This thing is like a magical rubber carpet. It's not sticky to walk on but you would think it's made of the same stuff that mouse traps are made of. Your stuff isn't moving an inch. Not an INCH. I love it.

This is just what I was looking for in a bed mat. It's heavy and will not slip on the metal that the bed is made from.. It your looking for a great mat this is what you want!

Totally worth the money, it fit PERFECTLY and was easy to unroll and put into the truck bed. I haven't hauled anything with it yet but just feeling it I can tell it's going to help protect the truck and what I'm hauling.

A real value for the price. It fit very nicely and it just laid in there like it knew what it was doing. No complaints here at all. I had to sweep out the snow and ice from the bed and it went on the floor nicely.

This is an excellent bed mat. Fits perfectly in my 2011 Ford F150 Super Crew with 5.5 ft bed. The mat fits the exact specification of the bed interior and easily rolls out into place. When delivered, it comes rolled up and wrapped in cellophane. I unrolled it and placed the mat in the bed of the truck and then moved my truck into the sun in order for the heat to smooth out the mat and help it to lie flat. A few hours later, it's perfectly flat on the bed of the truck.The grip is very good with this mat. It will definitely keep items secure so they do not slide back and forth across the bed. Excellent product and I'd highly recommend it.

AFTER AWHILE THE RUBBER SEALS CAME OFF

Looks good, but I question the quality of the securing hardware. I've had this on the truck for a couple weeks now, done some highway driving, and I keep an eye on the tightness of the wingnuts that secure the cover to the truck. But, I figure since it has a lifetime warranty if it breaks, they'll take care of things. Time will only tell.

I bought this cover for my 2014 F-150 and have had it now for almost 4 months.

The good news:

My highway gas mileage went UP!

It keeps the water out. I have been through many storms with the cover on my truck and as long as it is on right, it keeps the bed dry.

It comes completely put together. I had a small issue because of the year and make of my truck, but that may not be the case for you.

The cover is easy to get on and off once you get used to it. The initial set up did take a little time though. See below for further explanation.

The bad news:
When you crank down the clamps on the cover, it pulls the support bars down with them. There are 4 clamps, which are attached to the front and rear support bars (2 front, 2 rear). No problem there. However, when you get them good and tight, they pull the support bars down, which loosens the tension on the vinyl cover. This has caused water to pool in the front left and rear corners. It doesn't cause it to leak or anything, it just doesn't look good. After the water goes away there is always residual dirt stuck there.

Also, the 2014 F-150 has two small pieces cut out of the bed rails, which are hidden under the bed rail cover from the factory. I didn't know about this until I tried to install this cover. Those to pieces of cutout metal were exactly where the front two clamps for this cover are located. So, when I tightened the cover down, the hard plastic bed rail cover (from the Ford factory) bent. I called Tonno Pro customer support and left a message. They called me back the same day and said that I could unscrew the front support bar and slide them forward and re-screw them in place. They told me that it would not void my warranty, so I moved them. The cover fits securely on my bed, but I'm not sure if moving the bars is causing the water to pool now.

All-in-all, it is a good cover for the money. However, I have thought about getting another cover from a different manufacturer.

Fits fine. Took two people-but only cause I wanted someone to make sure it was lined up well before tightening down. I like it, but it doesn't sit as flat as I thought it might. Not noisy on my f150 and I have seen enough rain to say that most water stays out during the rain. I have noticed some gets in, but not enough to worry me. I bought this primarily to keep things out of the elements, but still have easy access to the bed for larger hauls.

Pro's
Very easy to install and can be done with one person
Comes with a trial cleaner and tailgate seal
Can be flipped up in seconds

Con's
As with Most, can only be flipped uncovering 2/3 of the bed
The front corners do not seal properly, had to use some of the tailgate seal to get a complete seal at front corners
When flipping up, need to watch the clamps so that they do not stap cover, takes an additional second to run around to the otherside to make sure the clampls lay flat.

Appearance
The cover looks like a $300 cover nothing more, will get a better quality look and fit with a more expensive cover

Works as described, fits very well. Only niggle is I wish the bottom was formed to fit the factory grooves, so that it was smooth when installed. But I honestly didn’t expect that

great mat for my truck fits perfect

I have a 2016 F150 XLT . It does not fit properly. I am planning to cut it to fit. Needs trimming around wheel wells.If not for that I would love. It lays down good and is plenty thick.

I ordered this to save money over Rhino LIning which was in my old truck. The good and bad of this mat is that things do not slide easily on it. But I figured that going in so can't complain. I do (did) like the Rhino Lining better because it allowed for just the right amount of sliding. That said, I'm pleased, would recommend with sliding caveat. Plus this Dee Zee mat is a lot less expensive!

I bought this product to fit my 2012 F-150 pickup. It arrived rolled up like a carpet, and was a breeze to lay out in the truck bed. My truck has the tailgate step option, so I didn't feel I needed a matching mat for the inside of the tailgate. It was not a 100% perfect fit, but it's very close, and just took a bit of jostling to get it centered between the wheel wells. Once installed, it does a great job providing traction to keep cargo from sliding around in the bed. Some other benefits of this type of mat is that it's removable for cleaning, and you can even take it with you to your next truck or sell it on when you sell your truck. For the money this is a fantastic value!Since most loads I haul don't put the bed sides at risk, this is a great solution for me. If your hauling things that will rub on your sides, you might be better off with a spray in or molded liner. So far, I'm very happy with the mat. If it last as long as long as I think it will, I may just have it in my next truck!

The only complaint I have about this mat is it sides flat in the bed and is not lipped on the sides or front so pine straw, sand, and any other materiel still gets in the cracks along all the edges of my bed. I have a spray in bed liner so not really a big deal but it would be nice to be able to pull this thing out spray it off and not have to worry about the cracks getting filled up with debris. It is very think and does a good job not letting items slide around in the back of the truck. It is fairly heavy and takes a little effort getting in and out but can easily be done by one person. Overall a pretty good product.

Purchased ours March 2015 & all of the weather strupping is coming off & it's been difficult to find anything to adhere to it. We mailed in the warranty card, so we'll see what happens next. Other than that, it's been a decent purchase.

Kind of a hassle... Not necessarily failure of the product... just not what I had hoped for....

Good cover, but the buckles flap and bang off cab when driving, which drives us crazy. Needs to have a latch or other fastener. Not as tight as I expected, as you can see the fabric wrinkling at 60 mph and higher. Works decent for the money.

UPDATE: the cover recently broke. The clamps don't work well with the Ford F150 plastic cover that goes over the edge of the bed, and eventually loosen up. My wife was driving the truck for about a week, and probably didn't notice that a clamp or clamps had come loose, so while driving the cover folded up and bent the frame. The cover did increase the fuel mileage though by at least 1-MPG, and maybe a bit more in TX at 80-MPH speeds.

Easy to install however having trouble getting to lay flat on bed of 2010 F150, all 4 corners are raised and not flush with truck bed rails. If they tighten further it doesn't allow the tailgate to close. Overall it keeps everything dry and does what I was hoping to accomplish at an inexpensive price.

We bought this for our 2014 F-150 and it doesn't seem to matter how its installed it makes noise. Also makes the tailgate harder to open and close. We have a Lund Tonneau for our 2012 F-150 and its a much better cover. This one is being returned and I have already ordered a Lund.

Product arrived with discolored patches. It fits 2014 Ford nicely but it's mostly just annoying that it's not all the same color. More of a brown in some spots. My footprints obviously are not how it arrived.

good fit, but most people would have sent it back due to it being terribly finished. there is a spot about two feet long and 3 inches wide that didnt fill the mold . i cant believe this passed qualuty control. has the appearance that something heavy and sharp was dragged across the surface. being farm truck i guess i dont care.

Received wrong mat

Need some slight trimming but overall does the job.

This is a quality product but unfortunately DeeZee uses the same product # for 3 different generations of F-150. I received the one for the 04-08 model year and I needed the 09-2014. There is a slight difference in the way the truck bed is configured so needless to say this did not fit properly. Amazon has been very good at resolving the issue but it is not a convenient item to return.

The mat fits but it is really about an inch short on the length and about 1/2- 3/4" between the wheel wells. If I bought it from a brick and mortar store, I would take it back, but to send this back would cost me more time and money so I can live with the poor fit...

My father has a Tonno cover which is why I went with this product to begin with. As with many things, products change over time. While my fathers and other versions i have seen have spring loaded hold downs this product is now relying on what i would consider a cheaper alternative - threaded rod and plastic only. I received a bunch of "free" stuff like gloves and some stickers that i don't need.....id much rather just have the better hold downs.

On top of that the instructions for installation were WRONG. They contradict each other in text vs photo in at least 2 ways and show you the wrong way to fasten this cover. A separate issue which i guess i will have to advise them about directly.

I'll live with it while it lasts but, certainly wouldn't buy this again.

The site shows that this will fit a 2016 F150 but this model only fits 2009-2014 the fit part of the sight is wrong the quality of the tonno cover is excellent

The saying you get what you pay for is true for this cover. I had a Extang Trifecta on a Nissan Frontier for 6 years and was a great cover. But I decided for the money to buy this cover. When I first received it my first thought was it looked and felt cheap. But I figured I would give it a chance, should have just returned it then. The fit for the F-150 is awful, and the hold downs are very cheap and I have had to tighten down the cover several times in the last month. So I am selling it and buying a Extang.

This cover installed easily and we were happy with it for almost a year. As stated in other reviews, it did have a bumpy look, but it wasn't too bad. Then yesterday, driving on the interstate we heard a loud whoosh and it was gone off into the air and way off into a farmers field. We first thought that we had installed it wrong, but the plastic clips had detached from the cover. Scary experience and we will not be buying something with plastic clips again.

At the hinge points..there is a VERY noticeable hump. Functionality is great..but you really sacrifice the appearance to get it

item was purchased for my 2017 crew cab ford 150 short bed. Expected a better fit it rolls up on wheel wheels so trim is incorrect for pickup bed footprint as well front corners ride up on side of pickup bed. little disappointed in actual fit. Jim

Installed this mat on our 2015 Ford F150 today and had to trim around the wheel wells to make it fit. Product description stated it fit the F150 perfectly, but it didn't. The front part doesn't come to the edge of the bed. Nice heavy mat, but disappointed on the fit.

I have 68" bed on my truck. When I attempted to enter the right size the web site kept telling me the mat would not fit, therefore, the mat is about 12" too short.

Damaged upon receipt. Does not look new.

I have a 2012 Ford F150 FX2 5.5' bed. The mat quality is as expected but the fit is very poor. The fit at the gate end of the bed appears machine cut and is good, but, the fit at the cab end of the bed appears to be manually cut and has gaps that range from 2" to 4". Also, the corners are not rounded, they are cut as triangles (causing part of the gaps).I returned the first order as defective and the replacement was cut differently but did not fit any better. I kept it because it suits my needs to protect the bed from lumber and general construction items and I don't want to deal with scheduling another UPS pickup.I would not keep this if I needed to protect the bed from gravel or needed to fill the bed with scratching items.

The mat I got has a bend along the edge by the tailgate. I thought that it might level out with time but I was wrong. No matter what I do, weights, clamps, etc....the bend will not go away. I am now past the return deadline with Amazon. The bend catches on items when pushing them into the bed. I sent an email to the manufacturer and got no response. I asume that this was a manufacturing defect. Buyer BEWARE!After contacting customer service, Amazon waived the 30 day limit return policy and sent a replacement mat using next day delivery service. The replacement mat fits well and lays flat. I am now 100% satified. Thank you Amazon for great service in dealing with a defective product.

Love it but site says it fits a 2016 F150 Crew cab and it does not.. Would love this one in correct size if possible.

the price for this bed cover is great but the parts that hold the bed cover are junk already had to replace 2 Complete Rear Latch Assembly because the Rear Barrel Nut keeps coming loose spent $60.00 in parts called the company didnt do nothing to help me out

Doesn't seal. Where it mounts to the truck bed there are factory cut outs in the bed keeping it from being able to pull down tight to the rail.

I have had this on my truck now for 8 months. I had one previously on my 2006 Ford and it was great for 2 years. This one however is different. The lateral bars under the canopy that have the sliding connectors for attaching to the bed are bowing considerably down under the tension required to attach. I keep tightening them and they bow more. They are getting so loose I'm afraid it's going to blow off in traffic. I will try to stiffen them somehow. The bar should be stiffer (steel or metal?) instead of flimsy plastic.

The hold down clamps do not fit properly under the rail for the 2013 Ford F-150's. It bends up the rail piece and unless you put added metal backing, it just doesn't set right.

The mat in this pic is not the mat I received. The package shows correct mat but the mat is wrong. Charged $25 to return a mat that was not my mistgake.

this was for a 2017 f-150 crew cab it dose not fix right i will never order from these people, nothing is right about it

Did Not Fit

Wrong size received. Needed for 2016 year model but received the item for up to 2014. Did not fit correctly.

Does not fit 5.5 F150 2016Appears company dumps product on Amazon

This bed mat is cut asymmetrical, quite obviously for a specific truck bed and not the one advertised which is a Ford F150. It does not fit and is useless.