2 items
Compare | ||
Compare All Features Differing |
Side by Side Comparison of: OXO vs Moen
Learn More | ||
Learn More | ||
Rating info | ||
eComparisons Score | ||
eComparisons ScoreThe "Comparison Score" Is calculated based on the average number of times this item was compared with other items in this category by our users | 9.2 | 8 |
User Rating (Amazon) | ||
User Rating (Amazon) | ||
Five Star Reviews: | 77% Won't be without this September 19, 2017 Second purchase of this. I mistakenly threw my first one out while cleaning. I put the original metal one back in the sink and after a few days knew I had to order this silicone one again.It catches the debris and makes it so easy to lift it out and bring it to the trash can for disposal.I like that the sink water can always flow through whereas the metal one would often lock itself in the drain when I didn't want it to.I clean the oxo weekly with spray cleaner with bleach and it holds up nicely.I love OXO products. There clearly is much thought behind their designs which make household chores easier for me. Love it! Would buy another one for the other side! August 14, 2017 Love! I have been searching one to replace my old strainer. Everywhere I look are the cheap ones with bad quality stainless steel, or a expensive one that were made in Japan. When I found this on Amazon, I am so happy! It is good price point, good quality. Ergonomic and functional design. You can push and pull the silicone part to really clean the small holes. The stainless steel part is matte finish, which I really like! Great replacement strainer August 14, 2017 Great sink strainer. I've been buying these for several years. They eventually become difficult to clean, so I replace them from time to time. I really like that you can "turn it inside out" over the garbage to get rid of everything, and your hand doesn't get dirty. Garbage disposals are the best, but we're not allowed to have them, so these are second best. The best! June 6, 2017 I LOVE these! The problem with the last set of sink strainers I had was when I poured a substantial amount of water down the sink, the strainer would float up & all of the food particles would go down the drain completely cancelling out the reason I had them in the first place. These stay in place when I do that & no particles get by! It catches everything & it's also a plus that you don't have to touch the gross stuff when you empty it. I would recommend to anyone. No more clogs! July 1, 2015 Count me among those that never envisioned myself being jazzed enough over a sink strainer that I'd ever leave a review. But I've been battling our kitchen sink ever since we moved in three years ago. This thing clogs constantly! Over the past few months it seems to have gotten worse. Even after a thorough cleaning, water drained at a snail's pace. I finally realized that it was the suction of the water pulling the stopper down that was causing all the backups.Switched over to the OXO, which has no stopper... problem solved. The sink hasn't clogged once in the two weeks since I switched. A new record!The silicone design is also way easier to clean than the old metal one. The only reason I didn't toss the metal strainer in the garbage is that I suppose I might some day have intermittent use for the stopper. Maybe.I noted that some reviewers mentioned the silicone getting funky and slimy. I just make sure to give it a quick scrub with my sink scrubber after I empty it. I only seem to really need to empty it about once a week, but so far this has kept it nice and clean. No slime here. Excellent Design April 18, 2012 It kills me to write this review since I never thought I would be writing a review for a sink strainer. I guess this means that I am officially getting old but, when you come across a well engineered product that solves a problem for you, no matter how simple, it should get credit. This strainer allows full flow down the drain even when it is full of food particles so you can just clean it easily after you are all done. No food can sneak by due to the design and it even looks good.Pros: fits great, looks good, engineered perfectly, solves your kitchen sink drain issuesCons: Makes you re-examine your life now that you are this excited about a sink strainerQUICK UPDATE - 9/5/16a.) It's over 4 years later and this sink strainer still hasn't broken in the kitchen sinkb.) I'm still pathetic enough to update a review for a sink strainer 4 years later | 60% https: //www. amazon. May 22, 2017 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00D82R5T6/ref=cm_cr_ryp_prd_ttl_sol_0m_cr_ryp_prd_ttl_sol_0 A+++++++++++++ December 30, 2016 Shopped many stores before checking out Amazon. I like to see in person before a purchase like this, however I was unable to locate in Lowes, Home Depot or Menards what I was looking for with the depth of sink or rubbed nickel finish to match a facet I had picked out for my kitchen remodel. It is wonderful. Love it..... This is a beautiful sink. The depth is a welcome feature when ... November 24, 2016 This is a beautiful sink. The depth is a welcome feature when one is washing large bowls or pans. Although I use a stainless steel cleaner, I usually just wipe the sink out after use and it remains fresh looking all week. The usual things that cause stains (like coffee) if not rinsed way don't seem to cause a problem, they wipe away also.The ease of installation, maintenance, the depth of sink, and the beauty that it adds to the kitchen have made this purchase well worth the money. |
Four Star Reviews: | 12% Does what it has to do July 27, 2017 This is a great strainer but be forewarned, if you don't like touching "wet food" this isn't for you. Very easy to clean out but you have to hold it into the garbage bin otherwise you're probably going to be spraying the collected food all over the place when you pull the handle to invert the drain and clean it out. Overall though, it works. Sink Strainer with a nuisance problem. April 26, 2017 It's a great product with a minor flaw. First, it fits perfectly in my sink and I'm so glad I got it to get the goo out of current drain. The problem? The stopper is a little too high to put my sink stopper in. It just doesn't work. So I'll have to pull it out and put my current drain stopper in whenever I want to soak my dishes in this sink. A nuisance more than a problem. I think tweaking the center pole will fix it. Great product! March 9, 2017 Love these! This is our second one. They are thin on top and the rubber insert can be inverted to clean. I really like how they made the metal thin enough to almost sit flush with the sink basin. Thicker ones prevent the particles from going into the strainer. This is fine for the money spent on it. March 6, 2017 This strainer looks good in my sink, but it gets grimy looking quickly. Also it's a bit messy when you need to empty out the 'bits', as it drips a lot. I am not sure why the strainer part is flexible, seems a bit unnecessary. However, it does it's job and didn't cost too much. Almost perfect. December 18, 2016 I read a review of this strainer on a blog and it mostly works as it should. It's design works VERY nicely to empty bits of food in the strainer. You just hold it upside down over the trash and flip it inside out and it empties most bits with no messy fingers.The only issue I've had is that it is perhaps too light and sometimes lifts up in the drain and allows items underneath. Otherwise it is a great item! It's worth it, I never thought I would get excited over a sink strainer... November 29, 2016 Ok so the good reviews are accurate, rather than scam for once. I really feel it is a tad expensive, but it's so easy to use, which I hadn't really thought about before. Man metal mesh strainers are so much work! (yes that is hyperbolic) You have to scrub them and they clog. This is actually pretty easy to use, you can pop it inside out into the trash, just make sure that you're popping it into the trash, I've missed and splattered food on the cabinet, the food can eject with force. It's easy to rinse off any remaining food particles on both sides because you can flip it inside out. A relative had one of these and I liked it so much I got one for myself. I felt kinda silly telling them that I loved their sink strainer. | 18% |
Three Star Reviews: | 5% While the design is amazing and they clean very easily October 8, 2017 We have had this sink strainer in both of our homes. While the design is amazing and they clean very easily, the last one that arrived was deformed. The post in the center was way off. We will be exchanging for a duplicate that was hopefully made correctly. Hard to clean August 16, 2017 It works well in the drain, but is pretty hard to clean (even flipped inside out) because the sink gross sticks to the silicone and you have to brush it off. Looks nice ... but July 12, 2017 Looks nice but water does not flow through fast enough. Also has silicone on bottom which I don't think lists on the site. The water backs up because it flows through too slowly. Other than that, would have given it 5 stars because it does look nice. slides in the sink June 20, 2017 works ok, but doesn't really work for slightly larger hole, it slides leaving a gap, even though it has wide rim. As expected, except slimy November 2, 2016 This works really well in my kitchen sink; however, it gets really slimy, really easily. I have to clean it thoroughly every couple of days to stop it from developing a moldy smell. | 9% Three Stars March 25, 2017 This sink appears deeper than it really is. I tried to find that info before buying but couldn't. The sink arrived quickly and in perfect condition. I was pleasantly surprised to see "Made ... March 14, 2017 The sink arrived quickly and in perfect condition. I was pleasantly surprised to see "Made in the USA" stamped on it also.My only complaint is also my own fault- 22ga is very flimsy feeling. If you have in your budget for a thicker sink, get it. Decent Sink - Arrived Rusty March 8, 2017 The sink is pretty good, arrived undented and straight. However, there was a fairly large area of rust shown in the photos. The sink is quiet. Seemed like a decent sink but not as noise dampening as ... March 27, 2016 Seemed like a decent sink but not as noise dampening as I expected from the description. It felt a little too thin, so I opted to upgrade to the 20 gauge Moen sink (see link) and I absolutely love it. Good quality and the extra thickness was worth the price. Moen G202134 2000 Series Double Bowl Drop-in Sink, 20-Gauge, Stainless Steel |
Two Star Reviews: | 3% Clogs Up Quickly and Splatters Debris, Otherwise Well Made September 9, 2017 Well made, has a very nice rim, and works as advertised, however the design is unhelpful. First, it clogs up quickly so if you tend to get a lot of debris in your water it will not serve your purpose. Second, when you pull the handle it pops, splattering the contents. Third, your hand is right there when the contents splatter. I suppose you could push from the other side, but then, why the handle? My main problem, however, was the fact it clogs much faster than wire mesh designs which I got for $1 at the Dollar Tree. If you want good appearance and tend not to have a lot of debris in your water, you would probably be pleased with it. but this one was a disappointment I was originally excited about the "pop out" feature ... September 8, 2017 I am usually thrilled with OXO products, but this one was a disappointment I was originally excited about the "pop out" feature thinking it would make it easier to clean, instead the dirty contents would get sprayed out. It also got a white coating that was probably mold. I reached out to the company & they suggested cleaning it with vinegar & baking soda, but that did not work & neither did anything else I tried. Not recommended June 6, 2017 I guess perhaps I misunderstood, but while the upper part of this thing is metal, the strainer part is plastic, and what seems to be delicate plastic at that. Appears that they can be easily torn or separate from the metal, and if that happens, that's the end of the strainer. Remember to duck when you turn it inside out to empty! April 2, 2017 When you turn this inside out to empty it, it fairly explodes with waste inside the cup. Spent more time cleaning up around my wastecan than acceptable. I've moved on.... July 23, 2016 This strainer was part of my journey to discover the best way to filter food from my dishwater. Unfortunately, it stank. Literally. The tiny holes get clogged with food and grime and mold. This is not entirely unexpected given the purpose of this product. However the soft silicone proved very hard to clean. You can't really scrub it with serious elbow crease since it folds and contorts.I'm quite happy with this very similar rigid model: RSVP Endurance® Sink Strainer - Large-2-1/2 to 3-1/4By the way, don't waste your time with this one either. I bought it and it didn't even fit my drain. It just sat loosely on top and moved around constantly. It was useless: Danco 9D00010427 Garbage Disposal Strainer It's okay, it works. Won't buy again January 2, 2016 In sum: looks nice, inexpensive, drains slow, hard to clean.Our old strainer had gotten pretty nasty, so I replaced it with this, and I'm already thinking about replacing this one. It fits well and looks nice, but the design isn't really working for me. It doesn't function as a stopper - not a function we use often, but it's nice to have on occasion. The bowl is pretty small, fills up fast, and drains slowly, even when mostly unimpeded. The bowl flips/reverses out - maybe to help with cleaning? But it really snaps out there if you're not careful, and can fling nasty food and/or sink gunk all over the place. Wet food etc. seems to just sort of smear into the silicone, rather than break apart and rinse through (like it did in our previous metal unit). | 10% If converting from porcelain BEWARE!! April 17, 2017 The sink arrived and looked great when unpacked. The trouble started when we wanted to install it. Long metal bars run along the underside right where my countertop was! No way was this getting in without removing the welded bars (not an option, they help secure the sink) or cutting my countertop. Very, very disappointed!!! but I expected more from a company like Moen. October 14, 2016 Despite being the same dimensions as the cast iron sink I just removed for this, the inner dimensions are not even close thanks to the tacked on metal bars underneath. Not to mention a small kink in the metal near the bottom lip and a huge dent in the bottom left corner of the sink. To make matters worse, it included NO template and NO installation hardware/clips. Unfortunately I'm on a time crunch and can't RMA this one and wait for a new sink to arrive, but, I expected more from a company like Moen. It can have the right measures from de outside but ... August 20, 2016 It can have the right measures from de outside but the bars attached underneath could cause you problems if the counter top already has the hole. That was my problem. |
One Star Reviews: | 3% Soon to be thrown out October 1, 2017 Collects ugly stuff. Rubber hard to clean. Metal edge stains sink chrome edge. Waste of money May 15, 2016 The underside of this thing is coated with something black. It's not shiny and silver like the photo. And this black stuff comes off on your hands when you try to clean the slimy thing or handle it at all. Big black flakes. I hate buying something based on glowing reviews only to have to throw it in the garbage. But that's what this is--garbage. This feel apart a few days after the return period ... April 14, 2016 This feel apart a few days after the return period had expired. The rubber part completely came off of the metal ring. You're better off buying this kind of things in the store ... April 2, 2016 The catcher part is way too small so it tends to move around, once it moves around, it leaves enough room for things to fall through. It defeats the purpose. You're better off buying this kind of things in the store where you can see it. | 3% Rusted in two weeks March 1, 2017 I have had this installed for only 2 weeks and it is already rusted. Do Not Buy. Worst quality I've ever had. How hard is it to make a sink. This sink had scratches on it less than two weeks ... March 28, 2016 This sink had scratches on it less than two weeks after we paid to have it installed. By then we couldn't return it because we could not afford to have it reinstalled. |
Vote for Me | Vote for Me | |
Pricing info | ||
Old Price | ||
Old Price | - | - |
Price | ||
Price | $7.95updated: Mar 18, 2020 | $164.56updated: Mar 20, 2020 |
Features | ||
Answered Questions | ||
Answered Questions | ||
Article Number | ||
Article Number | 0719812020822 | 0026508240748 |
Binding | ||
Binding | Kitchen | Tools & Home Improvement |
Brand | ||
Brand | OXO | Moen |
Color | ||
Color | Gray | Stainless |
Currency | ||
Currency | USD | USD |
Department | ||
Department | Housewares & Cleaning Aids | - |
Formatted Price | ||
Formatted Price | $7.99 | $173.25 |
Height | ||
Height | 63.8 in | 315.0 in |
Length | ||
Length | 172.4 in | 1299.2 in |
Manufacturer | ||
Manufacturer | OXO | Moen |
Model | ||
Model | 1308200 | G222133 |
MPN | ||
MPN | 1308200V7MLNYK | G222133 |
Number of Items | ||
Number of Items | 1 | 1 |
Number of Parts | ||
Number of Parts | 1308200V7MLNYK | G222133 |
Product Group | ||
Product Group | Home | Home Improvement |
Product Type | ||
Product Type | HOME | PLUMBING_FIXTURE |
Publisher | ||
Publisher | OXO | Moen |
Quantity | ||
Quantity | 1 | 1 |
Release Date | ||
Release Date | 2008-04-03 | - |
Reviews | ||
Reviews | ||
Score | ||
Score | 9.2 | 9.6 |
Size | ||
Size | - | 1.5 |
Studio | ||
Studio | OXO | Moen |
Warranty | ||
Warranty | Satisfaction Guaranteed! If for any reason you are not satisfied with an OXO product, return it for replacement or refund. | - |
Weight | ||
Weight | 0.7 oz | 0.5 oz |
Width | ||
Width | 186.6 in | 866.1 in |
Feature | ||
Feature | Easy to clean silicone can invert to empty Effectively traps debris Stain resistant Silicone underside will not scratch sink Dishwasher safe | Double bowl Stainless steel Features sound shield, assuring exceptional noise reduction and quiet dependability Limited lifetime warranty |
Comparisons by Other
Users
Kraus KHU100-30 30 inch...
Moen G222173 2200 Series Double...
GOLDEN VANTAGE New 31"x20" Under...
Moen 22036 3-1/2-Inch Composite...
Kraus KHU100-32 32 inch...
Kraus KBU14 31 1/2 inch...
Kraus KGD-433B 33 1/2 inch Dual...
Kraus KGD-412B 31 1/5 inch Dual...
Moen G222133 2200 Series 22...
OXO Good Grips Silicone Sink...
Sorry, there's no review at this time. Try changing the filter or leaving one.
Share your opinion