Side by Side Comparison of: Lilly Brush vs Scotch-Brite

This is a great little brush for getting out pet hair. I use it on my blankets on the bed, on the couch, and on rugs and it gets so much hair out, even when it doesn't look like any hair is there, this brush finds it and gets it out. I love it and wouldn't be without it. I first heard about this brush after a review that was done on Floppycats.com and I was convinced to try it. I am glad I did as this brush really does a great job at getting the hair out and with a Ragdoll cat, there is plenty of hair everywhere. Highly recommended.

It is seriously amazing how well this brush works! I have 5 cats and a little long haired dog so a lot of pet hair is dealt with in my house. I tried this out on the sofa and recliner with excellent results and little effort but what really impressed me was how well it worked on the carpet covered cat 'condos' that had layers of really hard to remove cat fur on. I've used vacuums and sticky pet hair remover tapes on these but was never able to get them very clean. The brush worked SO well and now my cat condo/scratcher stands are the cleanest they've been in a long long time. Really pleased with this product and so glad I ordered it!

I have an expensive microfiber couch and a small dog that lays all over it. My big dog brushes against the sides and sneaks to lay on it at night. SO THIS THING IS GREAT! I use it every morning to push the chihuahua and boxer hair to a pile and then pick it up with a damp cloth, or brush it onto the floor to vacuum up. I am getting everyone I know one with pets of these for stocking stuffers because they are great for pet hair. It doesn't pick it up but it pushes it into a perfect pile for me to grab. I wish it wasn't so expense but it is well worth the price.

...you move the brush in a circular motion. The pet hair forms a neat strip on the brush that's easy to grasp and discard. No real need to moisten if you go at it this way. I have an old, short-bristled vacuum attachment that I've used for years, many times I've used it without the vacuum! The short, stiffer bristles do the job of grabbing that cat hair! No complaints here...

I bought this specifically to remove hair from the chair my dogs have taken over (4 long-haired & 3 short-haired); even with a blanket over the chair there's still hair on it. This little brush works amazingly well - and quickly - to remove the hair and the hair is retained in the bristles until I remove it. The brush seems to work well either dry or rinsed and shaken out. I've also used it to quickly clean up hair on the bed spread and in the carpet of the car. It doesn't work as quickly on clothing while I'm wearing it, unless the fabric is denim, but that wasn't why I purchased this brush in the first place. If you need to clean upholstered furniture, I definitely recommend this brush....expensive, but worth it.

I have a velour corduroy-ish couch and it's accumulated years of cat hair. I DO clean it, but the fur seems to almost get woven into the fabric. The BFF works really well! It definitely made a difference; way better than sticky rollers and easier than busting out the vacuum and upholstery attachment. I discovered that by spraying the fabric with Febreze (or a mixture of a little fabric softener with water) it works even better, as it cuts the static charge. I also tried it on the quilt on my bed and was amazed at what came up! It's easy to use and comfortable to hold. My only gripe is it's not the easiest to clean while you're using it. But still - probably the best & easiest fur solution yet.

Wow! These Scotch-Brite Lint Rollers can really get lint off of clothes! I was thoroughly satisfied the first time that I used these rollers! They do a remarkable job getting dirt, lint, hair, almost anything off of clothing! For example, my black, dress suit had a lot of lint and hair on it, so I used the Scotch-Brite lint rollers, and my suit almost looked brand new when I was done cleaning it off with these lint rollers! I'd recommend these lint rollers to anybody! They are worth every dollar spent!!

These lint rollers are excellent. We have a long haired, white cat and despite constant cleaning, still manage to get little hairs stuck to me. This is the first time I've purchased lint rollers off of Amazon, but did so because of Prime and my lack of motivation/time to go to the store for a few days. Anyway, I'm really glad I bought these because they work better than anything I've ever used in the store. First, they are quite large and strong so you can get your entire outfit cleared off in one sticker (normally it takes 2 stickers to get everything "off"). Secondly, they turn easily, so you're getting an even removal of lint/fur/whatever. I would recommend and will order this product again in the future.

I love these for cleaning up pet hair and keep them handy wherever my cat likes to sleep. Cleaning hair off furniture is a breeze with them, but one day, I decided to go to the source. Now my cat comes running for a "massage" whenever she hears the roller! I don't press hard so it doesn't pull hair. It has definitely helped cut back on her hair on my bed, chairs, couch, and so on...

After several months using these, now my cat comes running when she hears me take the cover off! Loves her massage...

With 4 pets in the house we can accumulate a lot of hair on furniture and clothing that is hard to vacuum. Using a lint roller seems to work the best. We had been buying them at WalMart but they are kind of pricey. Amazon seems to have the best pricing of anywhere if purchased in this 5-pack. As far as the quality and functionality goes.....the Scotch-Brite rollers have outperformed any off brand or store brand rollers we have used in the past many years. They are plenty sticky, you can actually find the sheet edge and peel and tear off used sheets quite easily. The next sheet stays put while rolling until you decide to tear it off. Also, unlike off brand rollers that usually do not even roll, the Scotch-Brite rollers actually do roll on clothing and furniture. We even roll them over the cat to collect loose fur before it falls off (she thinks it's a "roller massage"). It's hard to find cheep rollers and since you gotta pay good money for them, might as well get the good ones.

I am really happy with these Scotch Brite Lint Rollers which come in a bundle of five.I started out with one cat and now and then I would need a Lint Roller to get some hair off my clothes or orr the furniture. I increased the cat count to two and one roll around the house was still adequate to control things. THEN I adopted two homeless kittens to finish out "my family" and was still OK with a roller or two UNTIL SUMMER CAME.Who knew cats could shed so much. Two of my cats were traumatized when I decided that shaving that hair off was the best idea in town. Like nitwits, the two did not recognize each other without their poufy hair and I thought I would go crazy during the two months it took them to regain their senses and become friends again. I thought of taking all four to be shaved this summer and just let things roll as they would, but after the feline hysterics of the previous summer, I rethought that and purchased this Lint Roller Special. It has become a staple in my home.1. My cats all love to be brushed with it and it saves oodles of random hair from ending up on furniture, the carpet, the wall, me or my friend's black pants. Three to five sheets are allotted to each cat each day and it makes a HUGE difference in the amount of stray hair flying around. Yes, I also use a Furminator, but all equate this with petting and cuddling and like it best. FURminator Long Hair deShedding Tool for Large Cats2. My furniture is grateful for these rollers: No matter the means I use to keep the cats off the furniture, or the covers I put on the furniture so the cats can do as they please, stray hairs still abound. So, every 3 days, I go over all my furniture and get the fur off. If company is coming, the furniture gets an extra run over and is very thankful for the care. One friend just said "I can't believe your furniture stays in such good condition considering you have four cats. Other measures are employed from time to time such as anti scratching tape, furiture covers, especially on the back of the couch and chairs [ASIN:B0006NE4QC Sticky Paws]]and sometimes and sometimes K&H Furniture Pet Cover for Couch, Tan, but the most consistently used thing is the tape in the 5 roll pack.3.Lint rollers kept in guest rooms, all bathrooms, kitchen and laundry room. Like Kleenex, these Lint Rollers are now found in all my extra rooms. Guests can make sure they are not leaving with hairs hiddend here or there in their clothing, or on their luggage. Many times I just roll the roll across a bathroom floor. I cannot believe how much cats shed, but have you ever noticed how much HUMANS shed? People loose an average of 100 hairs a day from their heads. In my need to clear the place of cat hairs, I have become amazed at how many human type hairs abound!!!4. Use before sending things to the Dry Cleaner. Sometimes I feel like a babe in the woods because of the minor points I have missed in life. Several years ago, I fell in love with a Navy Blue Christmas Vest. It was DRY CLEAN ONLY. I put it in with my things to be cleaned and forgot about it. The next year I took it out to wear and it was COVERED with cat hair. It never occurred to me that Dry Cleaning Fluid, unlike water, would not remove hair. So, I spent forever getting the hairs off the vest. Now I know. If there are hairs on things going to the dry cleaner, Use the Scotch Roller before sending them off.5. Crevaces and Corners. If you are one of those blessed with a hairy pet who adores you, you know that his adorable hair floats gracefully through the air as you pet him, groom him, or as he trots about your home. Therefore, you have probably also found that the nooks and crannies in your house, the books in the book cases, and edges of rugs etc etc abound with hair you never thought about. The Scotch roller is a great solution. It will pick those up in no time flat.I have found These Scotch Roles of Tape to be indespensible in my home of felines and people. You can always drag out the vaccumn, or a brush if you have the time, but these rollers are life savers under all conditions. Before you depart the house, roll the extra hair off you, the children, your husband, and guests. If people are dropping over, quickly clean the furniture of stray hairs before they arrive. Black slacks are SO unattractive with long silver cat hairs abiding! Kitties in a tussle on the bathroom floor, then roll over it with this tape and all is well. Small spaces trap hairs. When you have time, get them clean. I use these day in and day out and think they are marvelous. I always have an extra roll of 5 on hand since I am so well blessed with loving kitties. If you have fur friends of any type, I think you will find that these keep you defurred and help keep your house a home by swiftly getting that lovely hair OUT OF THE WAY AND OUT OF THE HOUSE!

Works well. I have a long haired dog and it seems to pick up all the fur from the couch.

This product works great for couch pillows and fabric furniture. It works okay on clothes but not as well as it works on furniture. I have yet to find something that works great on clothes. I have the tape rollers that work okay, but the only thing that works great on clothes for me is packing tape. I have to longer fur cats and their fur seem to stick to everything. We use this brush daily on the furniture and pillows to keep the house as fur free as possibly. I would recommend this product to anyone looking to use it on furniture or pillows. The only reason I did not give it five stars is it does not get all the fur off of my clothes. But for furniture use it's a 5 star product.

We recently went from only having leather furniture to adding a microfiber couch. With 4 large, fluffy, white cats the fur is everywhere especially right now going from Winter to Spring. This removes the fur from both the couch and our large cat tree amazingly well!I have used it on a few different items of clothing and it doesn't work as well, however, the fact that it removes the hair from the furniture helps it not get on our clothing as much. I'll keep having to use packing tape for my clothes.

This is amazing!!!! We have three cats, and one of them is long haired so we have a LOT of hair to contend with. This swipes the hair right off our couches (slipcovered in a cotton canvas) no problem. I also like running it over the (egyptian cotton) duvet cover before tossing in the wash. This works less well on some clothing fabrics (on my wool pants, it seems to just brush the hair/lint all in one direction - so I suppose it is less noticeable), but it is perfect for furniture! I also love that it creates no extra waste like a sticky papered lint roller.

I'd go ahead and say it's probably indeed the best pet hair remover I've tried and owned so far, in most cases it's far better than the sticky lint roller or those red cloth textured "magic lint remover", but again it's not without restrictions! I attached a few pictures to demonstrate.So first off on the general texture it works pretty great, so far I've tried it on my cotton bed sheets and fleece feeling fabric armchairs from IKEA, I saw some Youtube videos where people use it on the carpet or pet beds/ cat tree houses and it all works great. As in the first picture, the brush will gather the hairs in a string lump and it's pretty easy to remove.However, it doesn't quite work on my 100% cotton underwear, nor on those microfiber texture cloth (see second and third photo, a microfiber sheet sets from Target; I forgot to take pictures of my cotton underwear/ pajamas but it's about the same).And though in general it's easy to pull off the aggregated hair strings, there will always be some lint / fiber balls stuck at the bottom of brush's bristle (see 4th and 5th pics), which may not be a big deal but for someone who's a bit of a clean freak or has a bit of OCD, can really drive one crazy. I asked around and even posted a question here at Amazon's question section but didn't seem to get much out of it. And I tried a few different ways that other people suggested and didn't see any result (like people said to "lift it out with fingers/ rub fingers over/ wash it in running water and rub it on the palm and etc). In the end I rinse it in running water and run it through a comb multiple times to finally get most of the lint balls out of the brush. (see the last three pics)From the way I see it, I can hardly imagine this is a problem only to me (see how many disgusting lint balls I pull out from "combing the brush"!) And I had to comb the brush rather slowly and gently so I won't damage the bristle. I would've hope the cleaning job (to clean the tool itself after cleaning) would be much easier. Otherwise it's like owning a great vacuum machine but difficult to clean up. Then it's kinda only halfway there.

White hair, from my two Westies , on my black wool dress coat has been a lingering frustration. I've tried several of the sticky tape products, but none have been effective - typically taking 4 or 5 sheets to do a half-way decent job. The lilly brush removes all but a few of the most stubborn of hairs. It's not perfect, but far better than sticky products and other brushes I've tried. Besides pet hair, it does an excellent job.

These are decent. We use em to mainly remove cat hairs from our clothes. they are not so sticky that they unwind themselves yet still do a wonderful job at what they are intended for. I use em while cleaning the car interior on the back dash where it is hard to reach. Also use em by taking one off the roller and attaching to a yard stick to obtain cat toys under the curio. And with 95 sheets per roll in a 5 pack they last quite a while.

Works well. Picks up all the kitty fur on my black leggings.I keep on in my bedroom, one in my bathroom, and one near the front door for those last-minute pick-ups. Oh, the car is also a great place to keep one. Not only do they work great on clothes, but on cloth car seats as well.The only annoying thing is sometimes, the paper will stick, and unwrap a few times, wasting a few sheets. But they're big enough, it's not a major flaw. Also, most of the time, I can use those stray sheets to pick up some hair that I missed.

The sheets generally rip cleanly, the adhesive picks up lint and other small debris without damaging fabrics, everything rolls smoothly, and the package is relatively cost effective.I personally use lint rollers to keep my oversized cloth mouse pads clean and debris free, although I do occasionally use them on cloths. They work both for my atypical use, and for the more common removal of lint.Interesting note: the sheets are made of a plasticy fabric rather than the typical paper sheets you find on other lint rollers.

I really like the quantity of this entire package. It was whole a lot bigger than I thought it would be. I am currently living in a dorm and I think this amount will save me some for next year. But these Scotch-Brite Lint Rollers are too sticky!--let me clarify this: of course it needs to be sticky, that I know, but they are often not separatable once the both sticky sides are attached. I hope that the company makes it less sticky. Another thing is that these are too much paper-like quality. I was using other lint roller that had was much thicker than that of Scotch. Thicker sticky plastic papers are easier to use and much more efficient to clean. But overall, I'd like to say that I like this item.

At the time I bought this, the amazon picture showed the pink cancer-benefit product, but I actually received the standard scotch-branded version in the mail. Fine with me.I like the stickiness of these rolls - they do a good job compared to some knock-off brands. The two things that I'm NOT crazy about compared to others I've used: 1) The individual sheets require a little bit of effort to tear off. If you don't start the tear yourself, you will just pull the next sheet off with it. Another roller I had from a different brand tore PERFECTLY without any effort. You just yanked the old one and it would come off leaving the next one intact. Not a big deal, but just thought I'd mention it. 2) The rolls themselves seem a little loose on the handle, and if you use too much pressure or are too rough in your rolling, the rolls will work themselves OFF the handle. Once this happens with a roll, it will be prone to continue doing it for the rest of the roll. So just don't be too overzealous with the rolling!The main benefit to this product is it's value compared to buying it in the store where they are priced for crazy people.

Not sure it works as well as stated to remove cat hair. But I'll keep trying.

Not great on cat hair.

Not as effective as the travel size of this same brush.

It doesn't work as well as others said, IMO. It's just okay. I would get a refund if I could, but we've already used it.

Not bad. I got this larger brush for our furniture and it seems to pull up the air and loosen it but does not get it all. It is also a little hard to them get the hair out of the brush but it does help. I also got the smaller brush for clothes but a lint roller seems to work just as good if not better. Not worth it to send back though so will probably keep in vehicle for on the go grab.

The brush seems to do a really great job on my couches, removing hair and it seemed dust and dander as well. But on clothes it seems to be pretty average at best at removing dog hair. Lots of hair is left over and going over the same area, while the standard sticky rollers seem to do a better job. For clarity, I have a collie who sheds quite a lot and has longer hair.

Not sure what was done to this product since I last purchased however I'm not happy when trying to roll the tape it unravels while rolling. When purchased in the past I never had that problem and now I do.

They stick and roll just fine, but they tear horribly. The sheets are more plastic-like as opposed to paper, so tearing off each used sheet doesn't go smoothly. I could use one hand and my pinkie finger to quickly rip off a sheet from my old generic rollers, but with these I literally have to stop and use both hands to look for the connnection then break them apart. I suppose the price was worth it though; it's just a matter of inconvenience.

These seem to want to sell themselves on the sheets not tearing... which really just means they don't have insane stickiness? They get off most lint with one or two passes, so I'll keep using the ones I got - but I have certainly used other rollers with better performance.

This works good but not great. Its awesome you get so much in a pack but I wish it pick up more lint and pet hair. It works but you would need a few past to get the job done. The most annoying thing about this roller is how hard it is to remove the old sheet for the new one, it would work better is the cut is diagonal and not just straight vertical cuts.

I wasted half of the rolls before I discovered a little trick. When you tear into a new sheet and it doesn't stay attached to the rest of the roll-instead of tearing that section off to get to the next one-roll it in the opposite direction a few times and the sheet will adhese to the rest of the roll. I was pretty annoyed by how often this was happening until I discovered this trick.

I expected more than I got. I accept that most lint rollers don't do the greatest job, and that's okay.I would not buy these again, the paper base seems so thin that they can't put that much adhesiveon it. That's how they feel to me. I've used only a couple of lint rollers that really made me say WOW,and unfortunately I can't find them any more. For about $.08 to get that last second dog hair off of yourjacket, I think they serve their purpose. I'll rate 3/5 stars and keep looking.But it'll be a little while since I have 4 rolls left to use! (As an afterthought, I realize that these are NOT the item thatis pictured. Others have said the same thing. They ARE Scotch BRITE, but NOT Scotch as the pic shows. They use SCOTCH BRAND ADHESIVE, and also, each roll says that they're perfed appropriately for an easy tear. That is NOT the case. Standing by my 3/5 stars.

Sure not all it was made out to be on the internet. If I wanted to yet my clothes and furniture I would have just used a sponge.

A decent brush. However, for $10 more, you could buy the Bissell Pet Hair Eraser Handheld Vacuum, Corded, 33A1 and get much better results.

I was hoping this would be the answer to the dog hair on the couch problem, but this brush really didn't seem to work for me. I ended up buying one of the red velvet looking brushes which works a lot. It might be that my dog has longer hair than what this is intended for, but it would only pick up a few strands and then just move the other hair around.

Not as good as they say. Takes a few brushes to remove the hair and does not work on all surfaces (clothes). We use for couches and it works for a quick fix. Easy to wash with the bristles instead of fabric. Not worth the price overall

Did not remove hair off of a microfiber couch as it said it would. No matter how much I tried, it would simply swipe the hair around in front of the bristles. Never stuck to the brush. In the trash it went. I have a yellow lab and 4 cats-- 1 siamese, 1 long haired siamese and 2 domestic short hairs...didn't work on any one's fur. :( Bummer!

Didn't work at all for me. The hair it did manage to remove, it didn't even pick up, but instead kind of brushed it on the floor. I tried on both my upholstered furniture and on my clothes to see if it would work better, but it didn't. I have two dogs- one with slick, short black hair and a German Shepard. I had high hopes and really wished this worked for me, but at least they will refund it! I guess I'll keep using lint brushes and my vacuum.

I really don't like these lint roller's. I don't think they do a great job of getting went up off of clothing. The paper seems very flimsy and isn't very effective. I regret buying such a large pack of them.

Good product but one of the roller was defective, it had somehow stuck to the roller and doesn't work.Better off buying in the store so you can check for defects. Didn't open it in time to return it.

I was looking for a roller that would be able to remove all of the hair from my seasonal shedding husky. I noticed this roller had some of the highest reviews and it was price a good price for a pack of 5. When it works, this thing does in fact have the stickiness to remove most hair. The big issue I have is when you are finished with a sheet and you start a new one you have to go REALLY slow. Otherwise, from one quick rollover the sheet will stick and will continue to pull out the rest of the sheets. I went through one full roll (95 sheets) and seriously probably wasted at least 30 of those sheets due to this issue.

Nice big rolls, nice and sticky thats why I gave them 2 stars not one. Really deserve the one star. First roll I opened was not perforated so you have to cut off the used part with scissors, giant pain in the neck. The newly cut end does not adhere to the roll properly so you have an unraveling roll while trying to get the pet hair or whatever off your clothing, It's just a giant mess and not worth the aggrevation

I honestly didn't like these. I bought it because it was a good price for the amount but the sticky pads don't tear well and all the pads seem to unravel. It's actually really annoying. I should have paid extra to get a better brand but I really had no idea. Scotch-Brite should stick to making tape. I actually ended up giving these away.

I've always used Evercare Lint Rollers. I have 3 long-haired cats and have used Evercare for at least 10 years. Decided to try these because they were a few cents cheaper. Never again. They don't have the stickiness that Evercare does and it takes more sheets and more time rolling over the same areas to pick up cat hairs and lint. Going back to what I know is a better product.

Doesn't work. Don't waste your money.

not the best hair removal brush on the market.

crap. couldnt find one surface that it picked up hair. I really cant understand the good reviews, which is why i bought it. would have returned it but forgot and now its too late. going to goodwill.

Not sure what kind of Dog or Cat was used to test this product, certainly not one with much fur. The brush will quickly pick up minimal amounts of fur, then you need to "pick" it off the bristles. I have 2 Devon Rex, they don't leave a lot of fur around; and this brush didn't do the trick.

Not even nearly as good as a simple hand vac. Bought primarily for cleaning my hatchback where my dog rides. Does not pick up anything!

Didn't work. Obviously nothing will work on all surfaces, but my Subaru has three diferrent textures in it, and when my dogs covered it in hair after a trip, I bought this thing. All it did was push the hair around. I have shorter haired dogs, a chihuahua and a pit mix. This thing did nothing to pick up hair. Going back to adhesive style lint rollers. What a waste of my time. I'd like to note that I did get it wet, shake it off, etc. No hair stuck to it, nothing magical about it.

I have two cats, one of which is an American Medium hair breed. Sheds quite a bit of hair. This product hardly did the job on my sheets. It could only remove part of the cat hair; and is more suited for picking up dust and lint from the sheets. I used probably 10% of one roller and then left the entire set as it is. Had to give it off for free to others.

Garbage!They do not roll half of the time!!The roll does not turn over easily when rolling and gets stuck in onw position..Also sometimes the sheets unroll when you are trying to roll them

When trying to roll it on your clothing it comes unraveled and 3-4 sheets are then useless. The sheets don't tear off when you get to the last third of the roll - you have to use scissors. Also MUCH cheaper to buy at Costco - the exact same thing is $8.89.

I'm super disappointed with these. I could post a video of me rolling the same section of my couch over and over with new sheets and you'd see the frustration. Or the roll sometimes slipping off the handle and it stops rolling. Which once isn't a big deal- but when you think of that happening the 500 times over the life of this purchase that annoyance builds up. Or finding and ripping the used sheets off- they rip poorly or fold over. All these little annoyances add up and tell me that scotch brite didn't think this one through at all. If you want to hire me to fix this product- give me a call. Or if you want to replace or refund it- let me know.

Awful! Sheets don't ever tear apart - not sure where the guarantee comes into play! Not nearly as effective as removing lint or pet hair as Evercare brand. Definitely won't buy this product again.

Like another reviewer stated the sheets do not stay on the roll! The label clearly states tears cleanly guarnateed, it will not let me upload photos to show what I mean. Terrible quality, super thin and not sticky. Going back to my Evercare super sticky lint roller!