3 items
Compare
Compare
All Features
Differing
SimmonsSee Similar
Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers Ultra Deluxe 2 n 1 Crib and Toddler Mattress, Neutral - Simmons
American Baby Company
American Baby Company White Waterproof Fitted Crib and Toddler Protective Pad - American Baby Company
Summer Infant
Summer Infant Contoured Changing Pad - Summer Infant

Side by Side Comparison of: Simmons vs American Baby Company vs Summer Infant

Learn More
All Features
Differing
Learn More
Simmons http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/31nijYExy5L._SL160_.jpg
Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers Ultra Deluxe 2 n 1 Crib and Toddler Mattress, Neutral - Simmons
American Baby Company http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/31SDjbg6OEL._SL160_.jpg
American Baby Company White Waterproof Fitted Crib and Toddler Protective Pad - American Baby Company
Add to Whishlist
Summer Infant http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/31fx5WTzQaL._SL160_.jpg
Summer Infant Contoured Changing Pad - Summer Infant
Rating info
eComparisons Score
eComparisons ScoreThe "Comparison Score" Is calculated based on the average number of times this item was compared with other items in this category by our users
7.8
8.6
9
User Rating (Amazon)
User Rating (Amazon)

Five Star Reviews:

65%
I really love this well-made robust mattress
March 3, 2016
I really love this well-made robust mattress, after failing with Sealy. First I bought Sealy mattress for my baby girl, but it wasn't firm at all. It was way too soft, my daughter couldn't even turn her body when she was 3-4 months old. (even though I used the infant side, not the toddler side). That mattress was just too plush for a baby. So, I changed the mattress to this one (Simmons), and she finally could turn successfully, since there is much more support in the mattress! Much firmer, much more support, much heavier. I feel a lot more secure with this one. I regret I didn't buy this one from the beginning. This is my second purchase for my next little one.
This mattress saved my sanity
January 25, 2015
It might be a coincidence, but our baby is finally taking naps and almost sleeping through the night now that we've swapped out her brother's hand-me-down mattress for this one. She isn't waking herself up when she moves in her sleep, and she settles into bed without a screaming fit when we first lay her down. I inspected the mattress thoroughly before putting it in her crib and found none of the tears mentioned in other reviews. Also, there is not a chemical new mattress odor. I am most happy that the mattress fits snugly in her crib and is soft to the touch, but firm under pressure. I highly recommend this crib mattress!
Absolutely the greatest Mattress
June 2, 2014
This is a great mattress and I was so impressed with how it looks and feels. Quite heavy, not like the cheaper mattresses they had when I had my babies, 30 years ago and I wondered why my babies didn't won't to sleep at night in their crib.LOL! Our grand baby is not here yet but this mattress I know is going to be so comfortable he will not have trouble sleeping. On one side this mattress is a little harder for newborns so they don't get their little nose pressed down in the mattress and suffocate and its a little softer on the other side so it is comfortable for a growing toddler. Love it!
Fantastic Quality!
June 2, 2014
This baby mattress may be the best mattress in our house! The quality is far superior to that of others we have shopped for and even the one we had for our first son which we thought was decent (at about 25 lbs/18 months it started to fail). I foresee this mattress lasting longer without sagging as it is very well made. One side is slightly firmer which is what you want for your growing youngster especially if you plan to use or convert into a toddler bed using this mattress. We are very pleased with this purchase!
Excellent mattress
April 28, 2014
I originally ordered an organic mattress from Sears and was very unhappy with it, to the extent that I returned it. The first night my baby slept on it, there was an indent from his body - not what you want! I then ordered this mattress and was very pleased with it. It has a high coil count so there's no body indentation. My baby can roll around on it comfortably and I don't need to worry about him suffocating if he's on his tummy. I haven't tried out the toddler side yet but it seems softer to the touch. I also love the cloth covering. I dislike the plastic covered mattresses because they seem to crack quickly but this one offers the flexibility of fabric with some protection against moisture. Lastly, this was on sale so the value is excellent. All in all, both my son and I are happy with this mattress!
Buy buy buy
March 6, 2013
I did research for over a week for the right mattress... The wife wasn't happy because the crib sat empty for a week, but I was happy because of my purchase.We have only had it a couple weeks. But here is why the 5 stars:Smell: No chemical smell. This was very important to me. I have a sensitive nose, and I also hate chemicals. So my nose was the first thing to touch the mattress - creepy but true.Firmness/weight/durability: very well constructed and heavy. Not cheap and very firm... I didn't notice a huge difference at all between the 2sides. If you want a memory foam mattress then go buy one, but this is not it.Material: I originally was going to buy an organic mattress but I heard they smell like pure chemicals, so after much research this is the BEST available nonorganic mattress when looking for few chemicals. I obviously chose this over an organic mattress because I listened to the reviews and I'm glad I did.Best bang for the buck right here!****UPDATE: between 4-6 weeks of use, the edge of one seam started to give way. There is now a tear 5 inches in length because of poor craftsmanship - I will be contacting the manufacturer today and will update this comment accordingly.****UPDATE: I wrote an email to customer service. I requested an RA, took very detailed images of the defective mattress, showed proof of purchase, and requested a new mattress per Simmons defect guarantee/warranty. I received a response email within 2 days with the gentleman's direct contact info (customer service contact info is on the Simmons card included with the mattress - don't bother looking online as you may get confused). I had a new mattress at my door within 5-6 days of the response email. I carefully looked over the new mattress. There are 2 air vents on each of the long sides of the mattress. 1 of the 4 vents had the material starting to come out around the vent, but I took a think object and slid it back underneath. The edging - where the original mattress came apart - is not the best! But for the price, you cant beat it - so I am leaving the 5 stars and would definitely recommend this to everyone (the edge stitching looks to be single thread - another go around with the stitch and I think this mattress is perfect).Great customer service! Turned a seemingly poor experience into a very pleasant one[sorry for the length]
72%
So far I really like these. I bought this double pack so I ...
May 12, 2017
So far I really like these. I bought this double pack so I could double up sheets in case there is an accident and I can just rip the first layer off and put the baby back down asap. They fit the crib mattress wonderfully and they aren't so thick that the second layer was hard to put on. So far, so good. Can't wait to see how they hold up after first accident.
Great Mattress Cover
March 25, 2017
When our large dog had a leg injury and could jump up on the couch, I purchased a baby mattress so he'd have something comfortable to lay on, on the floor. My smaller dog likes to pee in the house sometimes and the mattress was a huge temptation. I purchased this waterproof cover and it has saved the mattress on several occasions. Very durable, waterproof and cleans up well !
Good purchase!
January 13, 2017
Soft and durable. Previously, we weren't using a crib pad under the sheet in the crib and boy, am I glad we purchased this. I have peace of mind knowing that it fits snugly around the mattress, makes the crib more comfortable for baby, and also protects against and overnight leaks.
Skeptic at First True Believer later
March 24, 2016
Love it, I was skeptical at first because I have never heard of this company, but it works well and holds up pretty good after numerous and numerous of washes. Its a nice fit as well-- its snug and tight but not too tight.
it still looked nice. The fabric was nice and fit perfectly over ...
February 24, 2016
My 3 month old son vomit all the milk that he had drank on his mattress but luckily, i had this waterproof fitted sheet over the mattress. The milk did not get to the mattress. it was machine washable. after the wash, it still looked nice. The fabric was nice and fit perfectly over the crib mattress. I would buy it again once it has worn out.
Does the job!
November 20, 2015
I bought two of these so I would always have one for the crib if one was in the wash. I layer them (mattress+cover+sheet+cover+sheet) in case of middle of the night accidents, just take off the top sheet and cover and you still have bedding for the rest of the night without having to remake the bed or wash immediately.
74%
It fits great on top of our changing table (Dream on Me ...
July 8, 2017
Came quickly and exactly as described! It fits great on top of our changing table (Dream on Me - Emily). We haven't used with it baby yet, he still won't be here for 5.5 weeks. It seems to be good quality and will last a while. The bottom (where baby lays) doesn't feel that thick and padded, but I am a first time mother and honestly don't know how other changing pads are in comparison or if the extra padding is necessary. The changing table came with a 1 inch pad, so I have that under it for a little more cushion, just in case for now.Update: Been using it for five weeks now. Works great. Super easy to clean as we have a boy that likes to pee everywhere during diaper changes. Would purchase again. Additional padding not needed, baby does fine.
Highly recommend!
November 28, 2016
I really hesitated between this changing pad and a few pricier ones on the market. As a new mom, I'm guilty of always wanting to buy the BEST everything for my baby--even if that sometimes means spending over 100 dollars on a changing pad my daughter will lay on for less than 5 minutes at a time to get her butt wiped (yes, I'm thinking of the Keekaroo Peanut Diaper Changer). But most times I listen to that voice in my head laughing hysterically at me for falling prey to marketing. I then searched around a little more and saw that this changing pad was incredibly affordable and had good reviews, so I decided to go for it. And, honestly, I couldn't be happier. It's safe, comfortable, fits perfectly on top of our $60 Ikea changing table, and there are PLENTY of adorable, affordable diaper covers that fit out there (I recommend getting at least two covers, so when one's in the wash, the other's on the pad.) Zero complaints. Get it.
Great buy
November 17, 2016
I couldn't believe the cost of some changing pads, of course I want my baby to be comfortable but it doesn't need to be as high of quality or price as the crib mattress! We purchased this one after a lot of recommendations & research and are very happy. Fits our changing table and covers perfectly. Love that it comes with straps because we are using a dresser as a changing table. Highly recommend.
I can tell this product has great quality, and seems very comfortable
August 3, 2016
I have not used this yet, as my baby is due soon :)However I did open it up to set up the nursery. I can tell this product has great quality, and seems very comfortable. I like the idea of having a strap to hold the baby in place, my first child's changing pad did not have that! I installed a pad cover, and it really looks great!I got a little OCDish, and tested the waterproofness of this changing pad. I simply dropped some water in the middle and watched it just hang out above the pad. It did not go through at all, which is great considering what fluids it is going to see very shortly :)Overall a great buy, at under $20 it was also cheaper than what I have seen at the typical baby stores.
Great pad! Horrible delivery!
August 21, 2015
The PRODUCT itself is nice, and is exactly as pictured. It is not hard, but firm to the touch which is good for newborns. When you put weight on it it conforms, I can feel the styrofoam like memory foam when I put weight on it. So it should be comfortable for my son.I am however very irritated with the packaging and shipping. I don't know if it was Amazon or FedEx, but I am NOT very happy about the giant tear and dents in the box! Amazon told me this would be here today and FedEx told me it was supposed to be here tomorrow. So I was already irritated about that. Then I get it today, finally, and it's a damaged package thrown on my door step?! I am very OCD and everytime I look at the changing pad my eyes are automatically drawn to the scratch that lifted and bubbled the plastic cover (not sure what it's called, it's like when you scrap a garbage bag on something and the plastic deforms and bubbles). The item wouldn't have been damaged if the box hadn't been damaged. I'm not happy that I wasted my gift card on something that showed up late (or on time, who knows?!) and damaged!I give the 5 stars to the actual changing pad, NOT anything else.Photos of the pad are attached, excuse my pregnant belly!
Recieved a different model this time
April 17, 2015
I've had this changing pad for 3 years now, It is amazing! My three year old still fits on it for diaper changes. Even if you don't have a changing table you can store it under your crib and pull it out as needed. No rips or tears 3 yrs later! Its so convenient to have a pad to change messy diapers on. It didn't have any smell when I received it and it still doesn't now. We put two covers over each other and just take the top on off if it gets dirty. All standard covers fit well. I will be ordering another one for new babys room as wellUPDATE:The new one that came in is not the same model # and has slightly shorter contoured sides. The sides don't come up to a point/look triangly instead it is a squared top. Not sure if this is an update or a whoops but summer brand who I called has not heard of this pad with this model #, yes that is kind of scary how the company hasn't heard of a product that I received from their brand/their tags are on it. This ones model # is 92870z and not the 92000z as listed

Four Star Reviews:

15%
This is a good bed. I had purchased a different bed that ...
September 29, 2017
This is a good bed. I had purchased a different bed that was $20 cheaper first, when that bed needed replaced i got this one. The quality of this bed is astounding. They used good materials and constructed it well
Definitely firm, even on the 'soft' side of the mattress
August 10, 2017
Bought for my 3 year old, but it was too firm for him, so I traded it with our 1 year old's mattress and they both seem happy. :) Definitely ok for the little guy, but our 3 year old found it too firm, even on the 'softer' side. Was hoping it would help him sleep better/stay in bed...no luck :) Seems to be good quality, especially for the price.
Good for the price.
June 4, 2017
Reasonably priced. Good quality. Reversible to a toddler mattress. Read the description for the best information.
Love these mattresses
March 6, 2017
The baby isn't here yet so I am not 100% sure about it. I bought a BeautyRest for my son when he was a baby and it had the side vents as well so when I seen this one, I figured it was the same or updated version. I was kind of taken aback when I opened it and it felt more like fabric covering it than your waterproof plastic type covering. I am a little nervous about the waterproof ability of this. Hoping it holds up in that aspect. Besides that, the mattress seems just as comfortable as my sons did. There are two sides, the firmer side meant for babies (it is recommended that they don't sleep on anything really soft) and then the reverse toddler side that is softer. It's a big mattress, which is what I remember about my sons as well. It still fit our standard sized Graco Benton crib that we bought. I haven't put sheets on it yet but I would recommend looking for toddler sheets instead of just sheets that state for the crib. While there is not much difference in size, past experience has shown that the ones that include the label "toddler" are so much easier to put on. Whatever mattress you choose, go with the most or higher coil count. This makes so much more of a difference than you could know. I had a crib that came with a mattress and my son hated it. I looked it up and it had maybe 75 coils in it. It literally folded itself in half when we stood it up outside of the mattress.
What a genius mattress!
August 19, 2015
This is a very nice crib/toddler mattress. The infant side is very firm, which is recommended for safety reasons. Other crib mattresses my babies have used always bowed where the baby slept, I had my youngest son lay down on the mattress and it did not. I think it's genius to make a mattress that will extend the use. When my baby gets big enough I will be able to just flip it over for a much softer feel. I recommend a mattress protector since the material seems like it would easily absorb fluids..
Good deal, very firm
November 15, 2013
Good deal, similar to a mattress sold at TRU but significantly cheaper. The mattress if very firm, on both sides even though one side is slightly softer for toddler use. I stomped on it a bit to make it a little softer as this is being used for a toddler who is not in danger of suffocating himself in the mattress.
14%
I'm not sure I would be happy with the quality if I was planning to use ...
October 27, 2017
I got these as back ups for when I am washing another that I received as a baby shower gift. I think these are ok quality, but I can't speak to how they will hold up. I'm not sure I would be happy with the quality if I was planning to use as a primary, but good enough as a back up.
Good enough
September 16, 2017
The price was right. It is a good enough mattress for as often as my grandbabies are here. But if I were a new parent I would probably get in that is not foam.
it arrived in excellent condition and I believe it would have worked out ...
August 7, 2017
I returned this item so I can't give an in-depth review. However, it arrived in excellent condition and I believe it would have worked out well if I had kept it. I
Fits well, soft
January 18, 2017
Fits snug which is great for infants. No issues fitting a sheet over top of it. So far it's soft and I don't have any concerns! Will update if we have issues.
Great fitted crib sheet that should fit almost any crib ...
August 30, 2016
Great fitted crib sheet that should fit almost any crib mattress. Love that it is waterproof and Amazon had a great price for it. Fits our crib mattress perfectly and tight without much extra slack. Highly recommend
This has a bit of a smell coming out of ...
August 20, 2016
This has a bit of a smell coming out of the bag, but nothing that was concerning since I wash everything. I wish the padding was a little more thicker but it still works well.
14%
Good for a changing table or to convert a dresser
November 23, 2016
We bought this as a thicker, more comfortable changing pad than the thin one that came with our changing table. It fits that bill very well, and fits right on the table with a little bit of extra room around the sides. The straps are stitched directly to the back of this pad, so I ended up simply replacing the ones that came attached to the table, and it seems to be working so far. A standard size pad cover fit on this just fine even with the extra height (presumably why it's a little narrower than the other one). All in all, does just what we needed, and would work very well for someone setting up a normal dresser or table as a changing station.
good contour pad
August 21, 2016
I have to say it is so convenient to have this changing pad and it is really great for diaper changing and powdering for my baby.The contoured sides and a set of straps with buckle to make sure your child in securely while on the table, that give me great confident of protecting my baby from rolling off. And the straps can attach the pad to the dresser or table. So the total thing is secure.
Considering so many changing pads are pretty darn expensive
June 26, 2016
Considering so many changing pads are pretty darn expensive, I love that this one is super affordable and I can't really tell the difference from the other more expensive versions on the market. The fabric is kinda plastic-y feeling, so it doesn't absorb any grossness that might occur during diaper changes and it wipes clean. I like the safety strap feature for extra peace of mind when dealing with a wiggly baby. Mine didn't have a weird chemical smell at all, so not sure what the other reviewers are talking about there....maybe I just got lucky or they changed materials since then. Overall, I think it's a great value.
Good Value, Works Well
November 30, 2015
After seeing the prices the big box stores wanted for a changing table pad, we ran to Amazon. We picked this up for about 50% of the big box cost.So far we've gone through two of these pads and have been pleased. With both, we have only noticed a slight plastic smell that many other reviewers mentioned. Nothing overwhelming. We've found this pad works perfectly well and does seem to fit all standard covers.To answer some common questions:- The pad measures 31 1/2" long by 16" wide (see photos)- There is a set of straps to securely buckle your child in while on the table, and a third strap for securing (with a screw) the pad to the dresser or table. There are no "grips" on the bottom of the pad. Because of its plastic outside, it's actually quite slick when placed on a hard surface.- We've had no problems fitting several different standard covers, from different makers, to this padBe aware that, while the plastic itself is waterproof, the "quilted" perforations in the cover appear to let liquid soak in. I happened to be changing my son while our covers were being washed and he had a blowout. I cleaned up the poo immediately and expected it to wash away. But as you can see (photos attached), some of it seems to have gotten through and permanently stained the pad. Obviously a perfect storm of events for that to happen, but wanted to point it out.Overall a good purchase, especially for the price.
Must Have Changing Pad for a Great Price
June 14, 2015
This changing pad is great for the price and quality. It fits nicely on top of a changing table or dresser and the contoured sides help give peace of mind that baby can't just roll oven the edge (but this doesn't mean you should leave your baby unattended!). Easy to clean material of you have an accident that soaks through the changing pad cover.Any standard sized changing pad cover will fit over this. I've purchased summer infant brand covers, as well as other brands of changing pad covers and they all fit well.I took away one star because of how slippery this pad is. With or without a cover, it can easily slide all over the top of the dresser that we have it placed on. It would be nice if there was some sort of rubber strip or spot on the bottom, in the middle, so that it is non-slip.Besides the above reasoning, I still think this is a great purchase for anyone in need of a changing pad. It's a great price and I would recommend to any new parent looking for an affordable and nice quality changing pad.
Nice, but stinky initially
June 19, 2013
Yes, some of them do have a residual smell and it does stink if you put your nose to it. I let it air out and it's fine now. It's a nice pad. I think it's the right 'plushness' as it's not too soft that you can't do anything with it but not too hard that the poor child is freaking out.I sewed my own cover for it by just tracing it on extra fabric I had. Any spills and I just wash the cover and wipe that sucker off, I appreciate how easy it is to clean. Fits well in my changing table and I like the contoured sides. Good price for it being new.Update:After using this for 4 months, here's what I've noticed-It gets much softer after being used for a while, but still keeps its shape-If you don't have a cover and use it, be careful of getting anything from the diaper on it. The texturing has a design of tiny circles that are depressed and baby messes easily get in them and will dry without you knowing. They're small enough to where you can't get it clean with a wet wash cloth unless you really scrub. It's a little irritating because I don't see it being dirty initially and then I have to spend about 10 minutes cleaning it up.But, it still is great to have, it fits nicely on the changing table and gives my baby enough comfort during changings.

Three Star Reviews:

4%
But my daughter doesn't really like it. It's also very heavy
May 5, 2017
The mattress is ok. But my daughter doesn't really like it. It's also very heavy, so it's really hard to change bed sheets. It is a pretty firm crib mattress compare to the other ones in the market. I would say it's just ok.
Was happy until....
November 3, 2016
I bought this for my infant grand daughter and after changing the sheets for the second time we noticed the side seam had split like mentioned in the reviews.
Not impressed
April 12, 2015
Bought this mattress planning to just use the toddler side. It is VERY firm. Was quite surprised. At first I thought I might have it on the wrong side, but nope. We have only had it a week and no complaints so far from the peanut gallery, but it won't shock me if we do. The craftsmanship also doesn't seem that great. Can't imagine buying this mattress for more as indicated by other reviews. There are loose strings hanging everywhere and if you pull them they do undo at the seams. I will be cutting them off. Time will tell if the seams stay put.
Firm is good for a baby
January 29, 2015
It's very firm. Firm is good for a baby, but this is very, very firm. My toddler uses it, but we got her a pillow and a cushier mattress pad to make it more comfy. After that she slept fine in it. We have her baby mattress to our new little one.
Horrible chemical smell
September 30, 2014
This mattress is almost a year old now. its holding up ok, except for the horrible chemical smell.
Strange smell
November 9, 2013
I was very pleased when I first received this mattress. It was firm without being too hard; construction seemed good and I liked the fabric (not PUL or similar material) cover. Also, there was no chemically smell such as some mattresses have.However, after a day of the mattress being unpacked, I noticed an odd smell, similar to cocoa butter or old coffee. After another day, I realized it was coming from the mattress! I am returning it.I couldn't sleep with it in the same room and figure if it bothers me, I am not going to risk the baby feeling the same way (we hadn't put it in the crib yet). Maybe I got an odd mattress but mention it in case it is not an isolated problem.
5%
Does the job
August 7, 2017
Frayed out after first wash and it's not smooth anymore. I put another cotton smooth fitted sheet on top of it.However; it's a very good water-proof sheet and it does the job.
Not worth the money
August 2, 2017
When the pad arrived 2 days ago I was excited for it. However a couple things convinced me this was only worth 3 stars. First, the elastic around the edge is not very strong. I mean both in how tightly it wraps the pad around the mattress and the quality of the elastic. Honestly, the elastic doesn't look like it will last the 2 years we need it to. Secondly, I put it in the washer and dryer when it arrived and it came out looking kinda gross. It seemed it had caught every loose strand of hair and lint in the load and velcroed it to the top layer. Also, the top layered had "pilled" quite a bit and looked raggedy. I will probably return it and buy a better quality one.
The water proof portion works great, but they don't wash well
September 27, 2016
I purchased two of these to use on crib mattresses my dogs sleep on. I have two bull-mastiffs. The water proof portion works great, but they don't wash well. They fuzz up the first wash. Not a huge concern with me since I also use a normal crib sheet over top of these.
After one wash...
July 18, 2016
The fabric gets fuzzy after one wash. You don't see it once you put a mattress cover over it but I was hoping a little bit better quality...
Satisfactory
June 28, 2016
I personally see it as adding more cushion than anything. It is nice yo hsbecthat extra barrier between the sheets and the bed but it is not 100%
For cover it is ok, for more comfort not so much
September 29, 2015
Just as cover it is ok. What I really needed was something to make the mattress more comfortable for the baby and this does not add much, I still will need to find foam to put under the pad.
6%
Looks like a great changing pad
June 22, 2017
I compared the size of this product to the one I already own, and it appeared they should be the same size, 16x32, so I was assuming all of my changing pad covers would work on this. Not the case, it seems to be a couple inches longer and my PB changing pad covers do not fit this thing, when they are designed for a 16x32 pad... I haven't pulled a tape measure out to see which one lies about the size, but I'm guessing it's this one since it is the odd one out. Looks like a great changing pad, but disappointed about the size discrepancy.
About as expected for the price.
July 30, 2016
This is about what I expected. This was one of the least expensive contoured changing pads available and if I were to purchase another one, I would consider going up to something a little better. The outer fabric doesn't seems to stand a little above the inner pad around the contoured sides. The bottom, which they say is non skid doesn't seem to be non skid at all and it freely slides on top of the dresser I have it on. It does have a connector for attaching to a table or dresser but requires a screw to be attached to the back of the dresser. This will keep the pad from falling off the dresser but it will still slide back and forth on the dresser (how much depends on exactly how it was attached). This would be so much better if the bottom was more non skid. I may look into some type of velcro attachments to fix it to one spot better.
Holes in the side
June 27, 2016
I ordered this as a 'package already opened'. When I received this there were holes in the side of the changing pad, I ordered this knowing the package would be opened however I was not aware there were holes in the product. The product itself seems like its good quality and it fits in our changing table. I'd give it a better review if it came with no holes.
Too big for 2 out of 2 changing tables
May 18, 2016
Sad that this is advertised as fitting most changing tables... it is about 2 inches longer than the average changing table is. We have 2 different changing tables in the house and this is too big for both of them. Worst part is that it is a great changing pad. Water proof/resistant material and the wings on the side hold baby in well. I wanted to give this 5 stars but it's lucky to get what it is getting. I don't like when companies advertise so shady. It makes for bad customer experiences.
Great changing pad with the exception of the straps
December 17, 2015
This changing pad is decently padded and easy to clean. I gave it 3 stars just because of the straps. I know they are there for safety's sake but we never leave the baby on the changing table anyway. We just had the pad on the top of our babies dresser and the straps ended up really doing a number on the wood.We tried putting a blanket over the dresser to prevent any more damage and this just led to the changing table sliding all over the place. There is no where to put the straps away when not in use. I ended up ripping the straps off of ours and would recommend anyone buying this do the same.
Thick changing pad but beware - it slides around
October 14, 2013
We are having our third child in a few weeks and I purchased this changing pad as a replacement for a worn out one I bought 5 years ago.The old one had two straps (one on each end) that would secure it to our changing table, and I expected this Summer Infant one to be the same. Unfortunately, it has just one strap in the middle of the pad that secures it with a screw to the changing table. It slides all over the place and does not feel secure at all. I worry that with a wiggly baby it won't stay in place.It is a nice cushy changing pad, however, I was disappointed that there is only one strap to secure it, rather than the two my old one had.One the bright side, it was fairly easy to secure to the table, and it seems to be nice and cushy for the baby. I purchased a few changing pad covers for it and I think it will work.

Two Star Reviews:

5%
Great mattress except for weak seams
December 18, 2016
Love the mattress, but durability is a problem because of seams that rip easily. This mattress is a great fit in the crib and my daughter seems to have found it comfortable to sleep on, but we experienced the same issue as others whereby the seam ripped with only normal use. Clearly there is a systemic manufacturing issue here. Very disappointing since we like everything else about it, especially that it didn't smell or off-gas at all.
Does Not Last
October 27, 2016
When this mattress first arrived I was very pleased with the condition and there was no weird smell. However, within the first nine months of using it in my son's crib it tore at the seam near one of the corners, by 1.5yrs of use it was torn at 2 corners.
If you like rips
August 20, 2016
This is the second time we have purchase this mattress. While they sent us a new one after the first one we bought tore on the seam (I thought it was a fluke). I has happened again with the second one, I am disappointed and very annoyed at this happening again.
Great If Stored/Shipped Correctly
August 13, 2016
Seems like a great mattress, but....It arrived in an opened box (mashed a bit on that end so likely a result of transport rather than tampering).Has a crease across it's width due apparently to being stored upright.We would return in hops of getting better quality, but that doesn't seem detestable.
Two Stars
March 10, 2016
Ripped at seams after 10 months! I sent an email via Simmons warranty so hoping they replace it!
disappointed on this purchase
January 10, 2015
Not sure why everyone is rating so high, disappointed on this purchase, mattress is hard and the coils can be felt and heard through the mattress. The other crib mattress we have is much better quality.
3%
Plastic feeling and not as soft as the organic kind
September 29, 2017
A stomach bug hit our house and I realized I didn’t have enough mattress covers. I needed several more in a hurry, and I wrongly assumed that this product was the same as our other ones (American Baby Company Waterproof Quilted Crib Size Fitted Mattress Cover made with Organic Cotton, Natural Color), except not made with organic cotton, so cheaper. That was not true - these are thinner and feel very plastic-y, where the others are soft and more cushioned. They have several layers and are more breathable. It seems like these would protect your mattress fine, but I’ll be returning them because they seem uncomfortable.
Very soft BUT....
July 19, 2017
Started pilling the very first time I washed it. The material it's covered with is basically too soft and each time I wash it it looks messier and messier. If I don't brush it with my pill- remover every single time it creates an uneven sleeping surface under my baby's crib sheets. I just ordered a different mattress pad and plan on tucking this one in the back of the drawer for emergencies only.
Waterproofing only, not at all padding
April 28, 2017
I bought this hoping it was a little more padded than it actually is. Its more like a felt material with a waterproof backing. As I was really looking for a combination of padding for baby and waterproofing, this won't work...it just doesn't add any padding.
Massive amounts of pilling on first wash.
April 20, 2017
Washed this on warm when I first got it. Hung it to dry. Pilled terribly. It pilled so bad it's virtually unusable.
Did not like the material but washed it to see if it ...
January 23, 2017
Did not like the material but washed it to see if it got better as a friend suggested. Wish I hadn't so I could return this. Very bad material.
Ok - not great
January 17, 2017
Not sure how long these will hold up, the sides are a really light fabric.I think we will just use these as backups - rather than in the rotation as we planned
3%
Poor quality and twisted shinny noisy covering. Sending this thin cushion back.
October 19, 2016
Very disappointed in the quality. The padding is too thin. The covering is twisted and will not stay flat against the cushion, straps are too chuncky. I will not go by the number of great reviews. This is a big waste of my time and now I need to hurry and find a replacement. The reviews are stacked perhaps from a free giveaway.
Soft and fits changing pad. As other reviewers have ...
March 18, 2016
Soft and fits changing pad. As other reviewers have made mention, there is a stain where there is a hole in the bag. There is a round hole that exposes part of it so you can touch it and feel how soft it is. This circle or hole exposes it enough so it gets a blackish stain in that area, which happens to be right in the middle of it. Does not come out with washing. I'll keep it for the price but would not order again.
Tiny holes means this changing pad DOES NOT WIPE CLEAN
March 6, 2016
Tiny holes in the quilted plastic are impossible to clean! If baby pees or poops while being changed, it gets into the tiny holes and DOES NOT WIPE CLEAN easily. This sort of defeats the purpose of a changing pad. Look for a changing pad without tiny holes!
Not holding my breath...
January 7, 2016
Upon opening the package, I found it already had a rip the size of a quarter in the white cover. The stuffing is not immediately falling out, but gentle use may change that. I suspect this is due to the cheapness of the material.Otherwise, it is just OK. Hopefully it lasts at least a year - but given it already had a hole in it, I am not holding my breath.
Cheap and light
January 29, 2015
Kind of cheap and light. I had one of these for my son a few years back and it held up so well that I bought another for my new baby. The quality seems to be less. It is so light that unless you bolt it to the dresser (Who wants a hole drilled in your nice furniture??) it just slips and slides right off, especially with a kicking and active baby. I have had it for six months and was just changing the cover on it and noticed the pad has turned yellow all over (this is not dirt, we have had no accidents on it!). I would recommend going with something a little sturdier and heavier.
not great
September 1, 2014
i never thought i'd have an opinion on a changing pad but this one is hard to clean and the outer plastic layer does not fully protect water from soaking the inner cushion looking for reviews for a better one to replace mine.

One Star Reviews:

11%
Unsafe
December 19, 2016
Mattress seems very small. Sheets, which are normally a 2 person job to put on a crib mattress since it is suppose to be tight fitting!, are extremely baggy on this mattress. I can shove my hand easily between mattress and crib rails. My 6 mo old is always losing a limb between the crib and mattress. It is so excessive, I feel like it might be defective...
Saggy end- return pending
September 5, 2016
One end is sagging and not consistent upon receipt. I am returning it and buying another brand. Very disappointed
Falling apart
August 20, 2016
The seams are ripping after one year of normal use. We did love this mattress for the first year of use, but it is ridiculous that it is falling apart already.
Tears apart
July 22, 2016
What recourse do we have amazon? My kid is sleeping on a defective mattress. I want my money back. Don't buy this mattress because it will will tear along the edges. So upset with this purchase and will look into any available recourse through the manufacturer.
Mattress Ripping
February 27, 2016
Very disappointed with this mattress. After only a year in a half, the mattress is ripping in two spots. The inside of the mattress is coming out. This can't be safe to sleep on anymore. I was hoping to use this with our second child. Now we have to buy a new one. Expected more from a Simmons product.
VERY DISAPPOINTED
September 24, 2015
I loved the mattress until it completely ripped like others have mentioned when pulling the fitted sheet off of the mattress after only 2 years of proper use in a crib and a couple months converted to the toddler bed. I am very disappointed and was hoping to use the mattress for our second child. I could not find enough information to use the warranty and not sure I want to waste my time considering what others have said about warranty and it most likely will rip again!
6%
poor quality - pilling after 1 wash
August 31, 2017
prewashed it in preparation for baby (gentle cycle with other crib bedding, then low heat in the dryer) - the mattress pad looks horrible, and is already pilling. Looks like it's been heavily used, not brand new. Not worth the money...
Not good for infants
July 28, 2017
This is nowhere near firm. Not good for infants. Would not buy this again.
My husband tried to convince me to wash it to see if the smell goes away but if it smells bad now, it can't be good long-term ev
March 12, 2017
As soon as I opened the package, there was a strong chemical smell. My husband tried to convince me to wash it to see if the smell goes away but if it smells bad now, it can't be good long-term even. I don't want to expose my baby to bad stuff when he's so vulnerable. Returning it.
This is the 2nd mattress protector I purchased for my ...
March 8, 2017
This is the 2nd mattress protector I purchased for my 2nd child. After washing and drying it once the material disinigrated. Apparently the manufacturer has downgraded
Not recommended.
January 29, 2017
Just after the first wash, it left black particles all over the sheet. Not sure if that was a bad product or I got the bad version. Will not recommend.
Not the best
January 9, 2017
Poorly made and returned it immediately
3%
Not Waterproof - Pee is absorbed into the quilting
January 8, 2017
NOT Waterproof! The pee will NOT stay on the surface of the pad, rather it will sink INTO the quilting holes. Impossible to clean the stains as the pee is stuck underneath the surface in the foam.
Horrible smell! & Too big.
November 26, 2016
The chemical smell that hit me when I opened the box (the pad was still in a plastic wrapper) gave me a headache that lasted for hours. Called to return it immediately. Too big for my changing table anyway.
Did not like!
November 20, 2016
I felt the plastic made a funny noise and separated from the base. I recommend the colgate changing pad over this one! Not a fan.
This has little holes it it and gets moldy if ...
August 31, 2016
This has little holes it it and gets moldy if little one has an accident on it!!!!! The holes are not a defect! This is just the way it's manufactured! Do not buy. Even if you clean the accident immediately, liquid leaks in and you cannot get it out. Thus...the mold.
Horrible
February 10, 2016
Read all the great reviews and figured this would be perfect for what I needed. I was wrong. Its too big to fit onto my average size changing table, the straps on it won't snap together so it doesn't move and my cover won't even go on it because of the size. I haven't even had a chance to use it and the price I paid isn't worth sending it back for a refund for a new one.
Four Stars
May 6, 2015
After using it for about 5 months, with maybe a few peeing/pooping accidents that made it to the pad, i had to throw it away due to the fact that the pad was reeking of urine, no matter how much cleaning i did. DEFINITELY NOT 100 PERCENT WATER PROOF!
Vote for Me
Vote for Me
Vote for Me
Pricing info
Old Price
Old Price
Price
Price
$131.23updated: Mar 18, 2020
$17.00updated: Mar 18, 2020
$19.88updated: Mar 19, 2020
Features
Answered Questions
Answered Questions
Article Number
Article Number
7661459693637
0656173286330
0012914920008
Binding
Binding
Baby Product
Baby Product
Baby Product
Brand
Brand
Simmons
American Baby Company
Summer Infant
Currency
Currency
USD
USD
USD
Formatted Price
Formatted Price
$174.00
$12.99
$28.95
Height
Height
2047.2 in
354.3 in
157.5 in
Length
Length
1082.7 in
2047.2 in
1279.5 in
Manufacturer
Manufacturer
Simmons Kids
American Baby Company
Summer Infant, Inc.
Maximum Age
Maximum Age
48
24
12
Model
Model
M55984-3146
2863-white
92000Z
MPN
MPN
GOTD-274411042
2863-white
45216
Number of Parts
Number of Parts
GOTD-274411042
2863-white
45216
Product Group
Product Group
Baby Product
Baby Product
Baby Product
Product Type
Product Type
BABY_PRODUCT
BABY_PRODUCT
BABY_PRODUCT
Publisher
Publisher
Simmons Kids
American Baby Company
Summer Infant, Inc.
Quantity
Quantity
1
1
1
Reviews
Reviews
Score
Score
8.4
9
9.2
Studio
Studio
Simmons Kids
American Baby Company
Summer Infant, Inc.
Weight
Weight
0.9 oz
2.5 oz
7.4 oz
Width
Width
236.2 in
1102.4 in
649.6 in
Feature
Feature

231 luxury Pocketed Coil Springs for even support; Reinforced border protection and Innofoam corner protectors provide stability

Natural cotton fire protection wrap has no chemicals, is non-toxic and meets or exceeds all federal flammability standards; Superior woven fabric cover features a medical grade waterproof barrier

Woven cover is water and stain resistant; 2-n-1 Design: one side provides ideal firmness for newborns and the flip side offers a layer of convoluted comfort for toddlers

GREENGUARD GOLD & CertiPUR-US certified for a healthier indoor environment; Limited lifetime warranty

Dimensions: 52 x 27.5 x

Measures 28 inch x 52 inch x 9 inch

Fits up to 6 inch thick standard crib mattresses

Waterproof for extra protection

Deep reinforced corners with elastic all around the bottom,Machine washable and dryable

Durable quilted vinyl is 100% waterproof material that can be wiped clean with a damp cloth

Contoured walls and quick release safety belt keep baby comfortably and securely on pad

Security strap underneath keeps pad attached to furniture

Fits most changing pad tables

Non skid bottom

Sorry, there's no review at this time. Try changing the filter or leaving one.
Share your opinion
Please enter captcha code
captcha
Send