Side by Side Comparison of: SOREL vs J. Fiallo

My husband loves these. He's on his second pair. His first pair, purchased three years ago, still has intact sole so these have been relegate to outdoor lazy Sundays.

Purchased these for my son, he is so picky about slippers and LOVES these! Thinking everyone else loves, too, because I have been trying to order another pair for my dad and can't find the same size 11 anywhere!

Got these for my dad for Christmas and he loves them! Wears them all the time. Great quality--durable and long-lasting, and incredibly comfortable. The inside is nice and plush which he enjoys.

This is my second pair. The first pair I bought just about a year ago, back in February 2016. I have worn them every single day--in the house and out. They are super comfortable and cozy. You and your feet will love them. Now, if you want to wear these slippers comfortably, order a 1 or 2 sizes larger than what you normally wear. I wear a size 11.5 shoe/boot but the slippers are size 13. You slip your feet in them and, as you use them, your feet will mold them up to gratuitous and unadulterated comfort!

I have been wearing these all weekend. I have always worn moccasin style slippers. These had an open heel. Right away I like the easy slip on. There is enough heel cup for full support and for walking naturally. They are very warm. I am in Texas, it is 30-40's right now, and I find myself sliding my feet out to cool.They fit well. I got an 11 and I normally wear 10 - 10.5. I like a relaxed fit in a slipper and these are great. My feet sit well in the footbed and my toes have room to spread out. The arch feels normal for a slipper, it is noticeable but not high.like the stitching, the color and the shape. They seem to be the quality one expects from Sorel. The rubber sole is great for walking out to the garage or to the car. I even wore them to a friends house the other evening. No one mentioned it. I was very comfortable.

I bought a pair at REI about 5 years ago, and asked for a new pair for Christmas this year. Unfortunately my wife bought the wrong size, and they were out of the right size, so I had to return them and order a pair from Amazon.I love these slippers; they are the best I have found. After 5 years the "fur" inside is all matted flat and the suede outside has spots from sloppy eating and normal wear, but the leather, stitching and soles are still sound. I love that I can slip them on without bending over, yet they don't fall off while I'm wearing them.Although people claim that they fit as expected, note that slippers are designed to be worn without socks, unlike shoes. So if you, like me, wear socks inside your slippers you might need a larger size. I normally can wear a size 10, but I need a size 11 wearing socks inside these.Update: I just received the new slippers from Amazon, and have to revise my comment on sizing. I have worn my old pair so long that the fur is all smashed down and the leather stretched, so they feel loose. But with the new pair that just arrive they are much tighter. I normally wear size 10, but even without socks the size 11 slippers are snug -- just about right. I certainly wouldn't want anything smaller.My only complaint (and I now remember feeling the same thing when my previous pair was new) is that the "Sorel" label sown into the sole is right under my heel and feels a little uncomfortable. Based on my experience with the previous pair, I know it won't be a problem for long.Update: After more than a year, the "fur" is all matted down again, and they are very loose on my feet. They were tight for a few months, but the fur mats down so quickly that they soon loosen up. In the summer, when I wear them without socks they are always falling off my feet. In the winter with socks on they fit OK.

I have wide feet, so I usually tend to have better luck with men's slippers. I wear a women's size 9W, so I decided to take a chance on the men's 10-11 and they fit very comfortably.The furry insides of the slippers keep my feet warm and cozy! I like the hard bottoms so I can run outside to check the mail in them, or even just go out on the deck if I have to, without having to change my shoes.I think at this price point, these slippers are a great buy and I would purchase them again.

These slippers were precisely what I was looking for. Nice looking but not too flashy, and also doable on a tight budget. I've worn these almost daily for the last three months, and they've held up rather well so far (especially for the price). They started out super soft and well-cushioned on the inside, but they've flattened out a bit over time. Still, they're comfortable to wear around the house even though the cushion isn't what it used to be, and they definitely keep my feet warm.For size reference, I have very small feet (men's size 6), and these are probably about a size or two too large for my feet. I like my slippers to be a bit big though, so I can wear them with thick socks in the winter if I need to step outside my apartment for a minute but won't be going far.

I bought myself these slippers along with a nice velvet bathrobe to spoil myself for my hard work. The size I chose was the approximate shoe size I wear (11 which falls under the 10-11 size) and was very pleased with how well the slippers fit despite other reviews suggesting to get a size higher. The interior of these slippers are luxurious to sat the least, with plush soles and lining as well as memory foam underneath the plush sole itself. I do not have hard wood floors, so I can't say for certain if the hard rubber bottoms of the slppers would scratch it or not. I will say that the rubber is rough to the touch and is pretty sturdy since I weigh over 220 pounds and the rubber doesn't even bend or recede with my full weight on them. Easily one of the best purchases I made recently and would highly recommend for anyone interested in them.

Feels like I am walking on a cloud. I bought these for a trip where it will be cold so they should do well for me. I couldn't believe how soft they felt slipping them on. Being a size 11 in women's shoes, I have a hard time finding slippers that fit and aren't obnoxious in color/pattern (I am not a frilly person). These are perfect for me. I can use them to take the dog out and not have my feet hanging out the back like women's slippers that don't ever fit right.

When I first tried these slippers on, I was not impressed at all. They were tighter than I wanted, the lip in the back bothered me by rubbing my heels, and the soles seemed like they would be a bit slippery on my tile floors. I figured I would end up returning them.I decided to give them a chance since they were so inexpensive. I'm happy that I did. After a couple of days of wearing them around my house, I love them.The slippers fit my feet better - they're looser, yet form to my feet. The lip on the back no longer brushes against my heel, therefore, they are not bothering me. I don't have any traction problems from the soles like I initially thought I would. The foam padding is very comfortable. The fur lining feels great against my skin and is very warm.These slippers are a great find. They are less expensive and more comfortable than similar slippers that I had purchased locally a month before that had already begun wearing out and had become completely uncomfortable. If you can deal with the minor annoyances in the beginning, they are worth giving them a couple of days trying them out, in my opinion.

Best slippers ever! Extremely comfortable and warm to the point where they make your feet sweat. I have to take them off every now and again if I am just lounging around with them on because they are that warm. The fur fabric the lines the inside is VERY plush and make you want to wear these things all day. When I first received them they fit a bit snug for my liking but after wearing them for a few weeks my feet have worked in the fur to make them fit perfectly(its not as fluffy, the fur has been matted down a little). The bottom rubber sole wraps around the sides just high enough so that if you go outside and its wet out the fur part doesn't get wet at all. I have been outside a lot with these and have yet to have any moisture or wetness soak into the fabric/fur, walking on grass/dirt/leaves/ect. I have the gray color and it goes with practically everything. The perfect slipper for a guy who wants to keep his feet warm and not look like a you know what. I highly recommend. Enjoy!

Bought these as a gift for my husband. They are very nice slippers, and he reports them as WARM.

Nice slipper, good quality. Got it for my husband. We just had to send it back for another size 1 time. He is 10.5 so we ended up having to go a size larger instead of this actual size.

Very comfortable. The sole is very sturdy and has great support when walking. These are a better value than uggs.

I highly recommend purchasing a pair of UGG Australia Men's Replacement Insoles Boot Inserts. The one that comes with are not as good and tend to fray and eventually ball up.great quality, have lasted me a long time, even though I wear them in my house all the time. The rubber soles are nice and thick, which feel great even if you wear them outside. Again, they'll feel way better when you have the UGG Australia Men's Replacement Insoles Boot Inserts.Here's a link to the insoles I purchased for mine: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B004AGVSNS?redirect=true&ref_=cm_cr_ryp_prd_ttl_sol_16

This would be definite 5 star material if offered in half-sizes. I am an 10.5 and thus this true-sized slipper is slightly too big. That particularly makes a difference with the back of the slipper being a "low rise." So a bit of slippage. A nice sole and sturdy stitching.Still, my slippers with leather ties, coming undone pretty much constantly, were driving me insane — so this constitutes a major overall upgrade.

I was looking for slippers that were a) good looking, b) comfortable and warm and c) could handle the occasional trip down the driveway to get the morning paper. I have been wearing these slippers for about a month now and I must say that they are one of the most comfortable and best pair of slippers I have ever owned.While I was a little concerned about some of the negative reviews having to do with proper fit and interior fleece coming off of the heel I decided to get them anyway, finding no good alternatives out there. I can confirm that the fleece coming off the heel is a problem - after a month of daily wearing there is some coming off (exposing the cloth foundation below), but I plan on gluing as much back into place as I can. As for the fit, I generally wear 10-1/2 to 11 so ordered the 11s and the fit is perfect. In the beginning they were tight, but as the fleece compacts and conforms to your foot over time they just keep getting more and more comfortable. The sole is perfect for the morning paper trip so no worries there.Bottom line - even though Sorrel needs to figure out the heel situation (I dinged them one star for this), the look, feel and function of these slippers is everything I hoped for and maybe a little bit more, especially for the price.

When these arrived, the right and left slipper are held together with one of those plastic tag tabs that has a flat tab on one end and a small cylinder tab on the other (with really thin plastic string in between)... Don't just pull them apart! Snip the tabs off from inside the slipper. I yanked them apart and the smaller tab got stuck in the slipper and I cannot get it out --- and I feel it when I wear them.OK - aside from the perma-plastic tab annoyance, these are really comfortable and they stay on when you walk. They are also durable. I've had mine for a couple months and they still look and feel great.

Comfy, warm, slips on and off easy- just got them so don't know how long they will lastUPDATE: warm, comfortable, but after a few weeks, it is clear that these were built for smaller, lighter people- I am 6'2"- 200lb.The side blew out of the shoes

Fit Well, Feel good on my feet, very warm, but WTF is with the copper rivet? "So stylish with a Classy button on the side. (Now avail in a copper color Button which adds so much to the look)" Yeah right, could do without the stupid rivet. Would have given 5 stars but had to knock off a star for the claim the rivet makes them stylish and classy.

Lowered a star because the slippers are a little small. I ordered a half size up as recommended and could have gone a bit larger. Also lost a star because the back lip that fits on the back of your foot doesn't do anything. The slippers flop like flip flops when you walk. Gains a star for how incredibly lush the inside material is. It's SOOOOO soft and the sole is super cushioned. Took me a bit to get used to how they feel and I love it.

So when i got them I instantly put them on and they were soooo soft and warm. They will provide you warmth with comfort all around your foot except the back part. These come with a very small back side so your foot will be cold towards the back and they fall off easier than if you would have included the backing. After a week I noticed that some of the sewing was coming undone. Nothing is ripped or damage yet but it does bother me that you can parts of the sewing that connect the bottom to the top to be coming off just hanging there. The string can easily be cut off to fix the problem, but it shouldn't come apart so quickly. So yes the slippers are warm all over the front and bottom of your foot, they will also make your foot sweat if you wear them when it's midday and a little more warmer, but the nonexistant backing isnt there to secure and warm that part of your foot. If you prefer the small backing that there is then this is the one for you.

These are great for lounging around the house in. They fit more like flip-flops so not a slipper you'd want to run out to get the mail in. I was looking for something that slips on and off easily and these fit the bill. I'm a EE width and these fit me nice so they do run a bit larger then the advertised D width.

these feel good I bought a size big and they are almost too small

They seemed great, but were definitely way too small for my husband.

Overall these seem like they are fairly well made, but for some reason the pair I received was so small that it left over 1 inch of my heel hanging out of the back of the slipper. It was labeled as size 10, but when I hold it up to any of my other shoes (all size 10), they are between 1 and 2 inches shorter in outside length. I would have expected them to be slightly longer due to the lining. Yes, I checked the box, they say men's, so unless the contents were switched they are not women's size 10.Never got a chance to test durability, as I tried to slide them on, then took them off and put them right back in the box and returned them. However, my sock was covered in loose chunks of "wool-blend" lining, to the point I wondered how they would even last.Made in Myanmar. Don't know if that is good or bad, but it's not China. Stitching seems good, exterior material seems rugged enough to last.

I usually wear size 11 dress shoes. Bought the 11s. Shoe runs small about 1/2 size. There's a raised lip along the back of the shoe to make your foot feel more fitted in the slipper. My heel kept rubbing the back of this lip when walking around. I did not like this feeling at all. Lightweight, well-made shoe that feels a bit "bloated" when worn. Not much arch support. Had to return these. Ended up buying Birkenstocks instead.

I wear 10.5 at a regular width in most shoes and boots. I've been wearing these slippers about 2 weeks now and they are still tight fitting. I expected they would loosen up some by now.

I bought it for my husband. I wish it was half size bigger, he can not fit his feet inside in full length. It's not exactly slipper as I expected. There is still small piece of shoe that needs to be pull up at the end. It is not a slipper nor a shoe.

These fit nice but the foam compacts quickly making the slipper hard and uncomfortable for daily use. I bought 3 pairs and alternate them each day allowing the foam to recover. I'm 180 lbs. and wear them inside my tiled floor home.

Is a bit small for my husband

The slippers are comfortable but the soles are so loud it's impossible not to wake my wife when I get up first. Another reviewer said they sounded like tap shoes on a wood floor and I totally agree. Also, I got low heeled slippers (for the first time) hoping to be able to slip them on but that was not the case -- still requires a hand.

These are great for staying in the house, but would likely fall apart after a few months walking the dog. I just wanted something to keep on my feet while in the house so I don't have to wear normal shoes. The sole is flexible man-made material and lightly padded. The fake fur is sufficiently warm, but feet sweat after a few hours; wearing socks solves that problem. Price is fair based on my expectations/use of product.

I'm between 2 and 3 stars here. The lining of the slipper is great. Very warm. My problem is with the sole of the slipper. It is too hard. My wife joked with me that it sounded like I was wearing heels on our hardwoods. Additionally, there is a raised logo on the bottom and it scratches my hardwoods if I slide my foot at all. I would not recommend this slipper unless your house is entirely carpet.

Good support but the back end slides over the plastic base and at times as you go to slip your feet in it hits the back lining...which provides for an uncomfortable feeling, like stepping on a toy or something. This is good for a short use during the day and cheap enough to buy for guests. I would look for something of higher quality like Mens Brandon Textured Velour Mule Slippers or other comparable items for personal use.

These have been comfortable slippers and are non-slip, but not non-skid. They're falling apart and have packed down tremendously within two months. I wear them at night and briefly in the morning- usually with socks, which is why it's strange why they've developed a foot odor too. While I love the comfort and the feel, I will not be purchasing these again, because they're cheaply made, stinky and they leave marks on the floor. They're built as well as some Wally-World knockoffs.

The width is not wide enough.

The slipper looks nicer in the photo. After opening the box, I also realized the inside layer was not soft but a coarse feeling wool. I have to return this slipper as the shoe appears to run small as well.We do still love Sorel, just not this slipper.

Was excited to receive the slippers but they just don't cut it. The inside lining is falling out. we are finding pieces of the faux lambswool all over the house. Was hoping and expecting more

A bit heavy and clumpy

I'm a size 10.5 usa and these were tight and hoping they stretch because my heels can't fit and hang over the back,, this is because the front is too tight the the slippers actually pop off my feet when i lounge, the size 10 to 11 mens I ordered are not true to fit.

The cushion in the slipper does not go all the way to the end of the toe box. This resulted in my big toe going over the cushion which was not at all comfortable. Returned!

After less than nine months, the outer soles have started coming unglued from the rest of the shoes. On one shoe, padding material that was under the sole has started to slide out to one side. To be fair, I wore these a lot around the house and a few times ventured into the yard with them on. And they were comfortable while they lasted.

Disappointed - if you plan to walk at all, even just down the hall, expect your heel to pull out and shift. The heel support of this slipper is way too short without proper elastic. I just walked from the bedroom down the hallway and my heel comes out of each slipper then falls back down onto the heel support of the shoe. Poor design.

I'll give these things some credit-- they sure live up to their name. These things are slippery!So as the owner of a 100+yr old house with hardwood floors in Wisconsin, I wear slippers a lot. A few years ago I decided I had no problem buying decent-but-inexpensive slippers every winter or so, and then throwing them out when they had run their course. $25 for slippers may not sound inexpensive to most, but when you wear them every single day and often all day on the weekends, that's a lot of wear and so I feel after five or six months of this, I've gotten my money's worth.This is the first time I've purchased these. They seem pretty comfortable and warm, but I have not even worn them much. Not because we've had unseasonably warm days here this fall, but because the sole of these slippers is incredibly slick. There is absolutely NO grip whatsoever to a hard surface. I am still trying to find a solution for this because it is inevitable I'd take a fall at some point because they are just that slick on hardwood floors. Until then.... I wear thick socks and/or slip-on shoes. And look for another suitable pair of slippers for the year.

Too narrow in width. They all seem to be that way. Should make a wide choice.

Love the appearance, but the arch support is so bad and the sole so thin, that I'm lucky if my feet aren't killing me after a hour or two. They're also a bit too wide so they flop around on my foot and I have to curl my toes to keep them on and I have size 11, the size below was too small. I've really been procrastinating on finding something more comfortable, I was thinking to try some regular shoe arch supports before I give up on them completely. I work at home and just wear them around the apartment. Really the only positive thing I like about them is the appearance.

Very small hurt myself because there's no traction on the soul slipped and fell and as I said they're very small I wear a size 12 and they're not even close to fitting I have a very narrow feet in these don't fit at all there still tight don't buy these I should sue the manufacture for my swollen knee right now

Inexpensive slippers in the bottom line. They are okay but not what I had hoped for from the photo. I took them to our mental hospital to put in the patient clothes donation bin since I am diabetic and need more protection from slamming my toes.

I wore these for the second day and the shoe is tearing apart. See photo.

Warm and comfy, but the stitching on the front of the slippers isn't lined up . The left slipper stitching is acuret but the right slipper stitching isn't accurate

I needed new house slippers because my dog keeps chewing them up. So I bought these thinking these would be a good fit for me. I got them yesterday and I was all excited to wear them. And I noticed something happening with my new slippers. I was leaving scuff marks all over my floors with these new house slippers. SCUFF MARKS THAT I HAVE TO SCRUB TO GET CLEAN. So these slippers get a 1 star for making a pair of house slippers that leaves black scuff marks all over my clean floors. Making my daily chores more of hassle because I have to get down on hands and knees to get my floors cleaned again. I WOULD HAVE NEVER BOUGHT THESE SLIPPERS IF I KNEW THEY LEFT BLACK SCUFF MARKS ALL OVER MY FLOORS. I AM TOO BUSY TO RETURN THESE SLIPPERS BACK TO AMAZON. TO RETURN THEM I WOULD HAVE TO TAKE TIME OFF WORK, RE-BOX THESE SLIPPERS, DRIVE TO UPS AND GET A RETURN AND THEN WAIT WEEKS FOR A REFUND.

Would rathet give .01 stars,but that rating isn't available. Cheap cushion. Delivered Jan 21, 2016. My husband told me today Feb 21, 2016 that the cushion is completely gone, flat!Seems I can't return it because the period for returns expired "yesterday ". I have purchased dear foams at Ross in the past and the cushion has taken anywhere front 6 to 9 months to collapse. The rest of the slipper is very nice, too bad! Could've been such a great review.