Side by Side Comparison of: Beadaholique vs Bottle Cap Co. vs ALIN vs Fiskars

If you're here because these were a "recommended buy" when buying homebrew gear, turn around and try again.These are (as advertised) arts & crafts materials. They are 100% metal, contain no rubber seal, and will not seal a bottle airtight.I am rating them 5 stars as my wife is working on a Fallout cosplay, and she was thrilled when I said I didn't need these anymore.

This Pack of 100 Silver Chrome Bottle Caps Bottle caps Cap by Beadaholique are perfect for any bottle cap jewelry or hair bow making crafts. I purchased these 1 inch crown style bottle caps to use with my homemade bottle cap necklaces and homemade hair bows. I use the Euro punch tool to easily punch a hole for my necklaces without leaving rough edges and I use 6mm or 8mm open jump rings with these when making necklaces but the 6mm are my favorite and work well with these bottle caps. These lightweight but very sturdy shiny silver aluminum bottle caps are new, unused, and unlined. I am sensitive to nickel and have been wearing them for a while now without any redness, irritation, or tarnishing. The bottle caps are quite nice and are perfect for use with 3D epoxy stickers or resin. I prefer to use them with the epoxy stickers and they really stay put and keep the images clear and bubble free. Also they do not have sharp edges which are important since the necklaces I make are mostly purchased for children and subject to routine handling. I have found other brands to have sharp edges but I haven’t had any issues with these at all. The bottle caps have a beautiful shine and are much nicer than others that I have purchased previously and they look very nice with ether ball chains or ribbon cord necklaces in stainless steel or sterling silver. I highly recommend these bottle caps as they are high quality and very reasonably priced and I will definitely be buying these again!

Great product for bottle cap crafting. I used a hole punch to make a small hole, then added a ring to it, designed my insert, glued it in, then added the epoxy dot. Perfect for this scripture bookmark. These bottle caps also make good necklaces or you can add a magnet and put it on the fridge.

I am happy with these caps and their quality. I started out collecting bottle caps and trying to remove the rubber lining but found with the price of these caps it just wasn't worth the effort. I do find these seem a hair larger than regular bottle caps but certainly work much better and are more open. I have been creating all kinds of projects for gifts and to sell and will certainly purchase these again.

I am very please with this transaction. My bottle caps arrived on the projected delivery date and they are true to description. They are really cute when used for magnets or on the hairbows that I make and the size is perfect. These can also be used for jewelry and other crafts. They are much better priced than the ones you can find in the craft stores. I highly recommend these!

I bought these to use in crafts and all came in promised condition and the quality is good. Best of all, they arrived VERY quickly, a full week ahead of what was expected. Overall, I am very pleased with the purchase and if I need more, I will order form here again.

I bought these to use as lacquer color identifiers. I store my lacquers in a travel case, and only the tops of the bottle are visible. I stuck one of these on each of the bottles after I painted 2 coats of lacquer on (and let it dry). Now I can see which color I'm picking up without having to pull every single bottle of lacquer out of my case.Note: I used these on Jamberry lacquer bottles and they fit perfectly! If you're wanting to use them with other brands, check the size first.

These Epoxy stickers are great! They fit nicely in the bottle caps. I received them on time and the packaging was neat. The adhesive on the stickers holds well. I posted a picture of the sticker on my finger but that ended up leaving a fingerprint. Luckily, it wasn't noticeable in my paper craft project. They're so fun to use, I can't wait to experiment what else I can use them on.

Item arrived on time and worked perfectly for the project we were completing.

Used these in a project for a family reunion, very easy to use and looks great.

These stickers are just as good as the big name brand and they don't fall off like some do. Great value for a popular craft item.I've bought these a couple of times already.

I bought these to make bottlecap necklaces. These went over the 1 inch round labels that I used to print on and make the center. These are very cute. It definitely does not make them waterproof although that was never my intention. If you're looking for something to make it waterproof and actually protect the label I don't think there is anything that's possible. Please just make it look finished and will protect the label from normal wear. I love these!

This is one of the best little tools in my tool stash! I love it!

Very good. I even open holes in my watches

great quality

Very Pleased

Before buying this My Mother In Law was hammering in holes by hand & said it was so hard & she would ruin some of them & her hand would hurt… So, when she said that this was something she'd like to purchase someday… My young daughter & I knew this would be great!She is so happy! & Says this makes it sooooo easy!A great buy!

I wanted to make something for my sons birthday party. I was going to have my husband drill holes in the bottle caps then as I was looking at something else I saw this tool. I'm so glad I did. It works great. It is very easy and super fast to use. Now I want to make bottle caps for everything and everyone!!!!

They look nice and work well but are VERY lightweight which cheapens them when using as a keychain. This might be the standard for weight though and not supplier specific. I may do some magnets with them and that will eliminate the weight issue.

Do not buy these for home brewing! They are for arts and crafts! The product is as described it was my mistake on the ordering it!

Using it for Girl Scout Swaps, would have liked it more if they had a hole in the edge.

I paint these and make buttons out of them. They are very sturdy and get the job done.

a couple came damaged but other than that they hold up well and came quickly

Good price for how many you are getting. The picture is self explanatory. What you see is what you are getting.

Makes my apple watch work with my wrist tattoos! Totally the intended purpose, right?

They didn't quite cover the entire image, which was a bit disappointing. But other than that they worked as expected.

These were clean (no dirt underneath) and were protected with a clear sheet on top of each page of 25. They were a perfect fit to the Martha Stewart 1" punch I have.My only disappointment was that they are a soft and very flexible epoxy sticker, versus some of the other brands I have bought in the past that are firm and not pliable at all.Overall, they met my needs, and were a good price - but I will search for a firmer one next time.Arrived very quickly and in excellent condition.

great stickers but some of mine had some sort of streaks and weren't clear so they got tossed

This is a great bargin. Good quality products. These are fun for card making, scrapbooking, bottle cap projects. They are crystal clear. I have found that once you start making these, you just want to keep going, so it's good to have a large quantity on hand. The only thing I would like better is if they were not flexable. They are not hard, there is just a little flexability to them. Not a big deal though. Still well worth the price.

I've used these before, but for some reason this batch was a little too hard. Most of the stickers were really hard and not easy to press onto the images I used. Usually epoxy stickers are rather flexible, at least the ones I've purchased on Amazon and at craft stores. There were maybe 10 flexible stickers in this pack. The harder epoxy stickers also appeared to have lines in them that didn't buff out. Not sure if this batch was affected by the extreme heat here in Texas during its transit to my mail box or if it was just a manufacturing fluke. I will continue to order them because the price is good, but I hope the next batch is more flexible.

Good made product

Before using this bottle cap hole puncher, I did not think it would be all that easy. I actually thought that it would prove to be a challenge to punch a hole into the cap especially with my pre-arthritic hands. I was proven very wrong. I had purchased it to punch the holes for some bottle cap necklace charms that some kindergarteners and I would be crafting. I had to punch over 25 holes and the first punch was as easy as the last. My hand did not cramp up once while using it.

Hope they work haven't received my bottle caps yet!

This product is one of the better bottlecap punchers that I have used. Others I have used did not remove the metal completely and so a piece of sharp metal was stuck to it. This puncher took it completely off, so I would recommend this product that anyone that needs to punch metal.

I bought these for my sister-in-law who collects bottle caps. She is a huge Fallout fan and collects different bottle caps, so I thought it'd be nice to buy her a lot to help her collection. If you're using these as actual bottle caps I wouldn't recommend them, but they'd probably be good for scrapbooking.

Bought these caps to bottle beer with only to discover that they lack the pressure sealing plastic inside that helps seal the bottles.

As my first bottle cap purchase, I was pleased to get these. Sadly, once I had something to compare them to, they didn't hold up so well. They look great at first, but sometimes you'll get some caps that have some film on the inside of them that just wont come off. I've also noticed over time that they seem to yellow a little bit. When I accidentally used one of these caps in a set of themed necklaces, I could clearly tell the yellowed cap stood out against the silver ones. I don't know why they do this, but it really makes it hard to tell my customers they are silver colored when they turn a yellowish tint by the time they get the product.If you're not so worried about the color, these caps are durable and they don't dent easily.

I'm a little disappointed with the blurriness that the glue adds to the image. I was expecting some distortion from the shape, but not the smudginess from the sticky bit.

Used these in a project and they looked great...but two days later the stickers were lifting up and peeling away already. Thankfully they peeled off cleanly so I could go in another direction with my project, but not what I was hoping for.

These stick well, but they are not as clear/see through as the picture shows. They have somewhat of a yellow tint to them. Pretty disappointed with that.

The stickers are ok. Some of them have markings on them which means I can't use them. If you put them on the image you can see a line or a smuge. Out of 100 i can prob only use about 60 of them.

These are very expensive if you don't mind the shipping time. Initially I was very pleased, however, after about 9 months, they yellow.

Just getting into the bottle cap hobby and this is the second purchase of epoxy domes I've made but the first from Beadaholique. I found these epoxy stickers to be very thin. Not much of a dome effect. Also, in comparison to the others I've bought, I find them to have a slight tinge of yellowing, not crystal clear.

This product came quickly and was easy to use, but did not meet my needs. It very clearly is made for standard bottle caps and not the flattened type in craft jewelry supply, which I prefer. Perhaps the ad should make this caveat? I still need to use drill or buy caps with jump ring already attached.

I don't know if is the material I'm working with, but, they make a perfect clean hole, leave the piece of the metal hanging out the hole. Hope is just the king of metal and not the pliers.

If you are actually using these to cap bottles, beware. While it could have been user error, I've capped plenty of bottles without leaking troubles previously. About 80% of bottles I capped with these went flat on me. I will be throwing the rest out and trying a different brand for my next batch.

Nice look, good price, but the bottles did not seal once capped. Sealed a 5 gallon batch with the same bottle, same capper, but half with these, and half with a second brand. Every single bottle with this cap was not carbonated. Every single bottle with the other caps were carbonated.

Just what I wanted

Wish I had listened to the other reviews ! These had a yellow tint, were slightly smaller than 1" and somewhat brittle. I've ordered these from another seller but they were out of stock so I was desperate ! Never again...

Horrible bubbly residue on the "sticker" side. You can see it even on very light images/white background.

Did not fit properly into 1" pendant trays, slightly too big. Very thin,low dome with no magnifying effect.

These don' t stay stuck on the top of bottle caps - they are not pliable enough and lift-up on the edges after a short time. I didn't see earlier mention of this issue. I'll try someone's suggestion to apply to image and add glue on t he back of image. These are only good for use on flat sufaces - not good for bottle caps with slight rounded edges. Disappointed.

The 40 that worked were good; however, 60 (that's more than half) went cloudy and obscured the picture underneath in the area I glued them to the bottle cap. Would not recommend these for use with E6000 glue. I ordered some more, but will probably return them.

Although they stick well, they are very, very yellow. I've been looking for the perfect epoxy domes and I am disappointed with these. If they were only clear!!! Sad.

Product states the hole can be punched to make necklaces and keychains, etc. The hole is not large enough even for a small split ring to use as a keyring. If you get the keyring on it cannot be turned because the hole will not accommodate more than one thickness of the splitting, so where the split ring overlaps - which is almost the entire ring - the bottle cap cannot move or slide. Narrow cording, not even ribbon, would have to be used to make a necklace unless you use a jump ring. Again you are limited by the size of the hole. DON'T BE FOOLED !!!!!

Bottle caps don't seal on the bottles. Tried several different ones with no luck, still loose after using a bottle capper.

Cheap, cheap cheap! Thin, no seal on the under side of the cap, all metal! My whole went flat!

I hate this because the seller didn't described it well so I spent my money on it and couldn't return it....

These are craft caps, not home brewing caps! There is no rubber seal. What ticks me off is that's not stated anywhere, and Amazon recommended them while buying other brewing stuff. Can never have too many caps...so I threw them in my cart.They went into stock until it was time to bottle a beer, and by then it was past the return policy deadline.

Description NEEDS to specify these are not intended for capping beverages (sodas and beer). I made the mistake of ordering these beautiful caps for this very purpose. The name of the company is "The Bottle Cap Company" so you naturally assume they're for capping bottles. Not so (at least not bottles with liquid). Now it's too late to return!

Caps are awful. About half my batch was capped with these and they all must have failed to seal properly because I have a fair amount of flat beer on my hands. The ones capped with a different cap are all carbonated and fine.

These are NOT clear as pictured. They are all yellow and hard. They are either extremely old or made with poor quality materials. If I put them on anything with white in it, it turns the white to yellow. TERRIBLE!

All the Epoxy stickers were yellow as if they were old and scratched up. This product is also not eligible for returns! I am not happy with this product and seller.

Very disappointed in the quality of this product. They are not clear. They are a yellowish color and more than 1/2 of them came scratched up. Definitely a waste of money since I can't use them for what I intended.

I am extremely disappointed with this product! I am not sure if it is just a poor product or that the problem was that it arrived hot from heat in the UPS truck which may have caused this defect. More than half of the Epoxy stickers are unusable. They have smudges and bubble marks which show through when placed over images.

I doubt these are from beadaholique. They shipped from Hong Kong and had brown yellow stuff all over almost like pee. Had a horrible smell to them. I watch the tutorials beadaholique has a YouTube and they look nothin like the ones they use in the vids. I don't know about the sticky ness most are saying they don't stick so we shall see but ima be very careful when I buy again

I purchased some awesome epoxy bottle cap circles at hobby lobby. They were a self sticking hard circle. I was excited to see what I thought was a huge batch of them on amazon. These arrived gummy and bendable. I would have NEVER ordered these. Order with caution.I like to stick two back to back with a picture of some sort between, drill a very small hole, slide a small ring through and make custom necklaces for my daughter. You can NOT drill through this because of the gummy, NOSOLID consistency.

i had returned it. price to high for this small piece

i needed holes in the middle of my bottle caps & this is too short so im using a nail & hammer to get it right