4 items
Compare
Compare
All Features
Differing
JW PetSee Similar
JW Pet Company Mini Hol-ee Roller Dog Toy, Colors Vary - JW Pet
KONG
KONG Puppy Kong Toy, Small, Assorted Pink/Blue - KONG
Nylabone
Nylabone Just For Puppies Ring Bone Puppy Dog Teething Chew Toy - Nylabone
Petstages
Dog Toy Pet Stages Cool Teething Stick - Petstages

Side by Side Comparison of: JW Pet vs KONG vs Nylabone vs Petstages

Learn More
All Features
Differing
Learn More
JW Pet http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51tp7H41O%2BL._SL160_.jpg
JW Pet Company Mini Hol-ee Roller Dog Toy, Colors Vary - JW Pet
Add to Whishlist
KONG https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/51ipC-8PB-L._SL160_.jpg
KONG Puppy Kong Toy, Small, Assorted Pink/Blue - KONG
Add to Whishlist
Nylabone https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/51SLXncx9nL._SL160_.jpg
Nylabone Just For Puppies Ring Bone Puppy Dog Teething Chew Toy - Nylabone
Add to Whishlist
Petstages https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/41V5VBSiamL._SL160_.jpg
Dog Toy Pet Stages Cool Teething Stick - Petstages
Rating info
eComparisons Score
eComparisons ScoreThe "Comparison Score" Is calculated based on the average number of times this item was compared with other items in this category by our users
7.8
8.6
0
0
User Rating (Amazon)
User Rating (Amazon)

Five Star Reviews:

56%
ONE OF THE BEST TOYS FOR STUFFING AND FREEZING.
May 23, 2017
I have a mini and a small. At first, it seemed like the smalls were a bust - the puppy just wasn't very excited about them. At least I could fill the mini with wet dog food and freeze it, which would keep him busy for a while. But now I've realized that the smalls are REALLY GREAT for stuffing. I soak my dry kibble in water for a few minutes, drain the water, add a dollop of yogurt and some shredded cheese. I put the hol-ee roller in the bottom of a tupperware container and then stuff the kibble mix in through the holes. Yes, this is not an enclosed object, so some stuff will dribble out the sides/bottoms. But since there isn't too much liquid, most of the mix stays in place inside the ball. My puppy does better with this than with other objects where the food is frozen inside a closed cylinder. I haven't bought any large kongs yet, but I've used something similar from target. With the stuffed cylindrical toys, he can only lick at the stuff at the end, then he has to wait for it to defrost enough to knock the food out. With the hol-ee roller, he can access the frozen stash of food from multiple angles. This definitely keeps him engaged right from the get go. For reference, the puppy is about thirty pounds. The material seems to be holding up well, but I don't think the puppy is the heaviest of chewers.
Great toy! Versitile in design. EVERY dog should have one.
March 5, 2017
Acquired a "Medium" ball from a friend who has 2 medium sized young dogs. My 6 mo old 50lb Collie / Cattle Dog is a chewer. He loved it so I bought the large ball (this ad). I don't let him play 'Tug' with either ball (that's what the ropes are for) but he chews and chews and throws them in the air then shakes them and chews some more. I've had the medium ball about 4 mos now and the large ball for about 3 weeks. Both are holding up. Note: He has other toys and I rotate them throughout the day... usually depending on activities in the house.Let me say too, that I supervise much of his free playtime and am teaching him how to treat his toys... which ones he can play Tug with (ropes), which ones are for chewing (balls and bones), and which ones are for 'playing nice' with (stuffed and squeaky). So far, he's only torn up a few 'play nice' toys... but he's getting better. I never leave him alone with a toy that could hurt him if he did tear it into pieces. So far, he's not chewed on anything in the house EXCEPT for his toys. I think having balls to chase and chew, bones to chomp on, Kongs for stress relief, and stuffed toys for gentle and quiet playtime... and teaching him the difference, have really made a difference in the preservation of the toys. Oh... and we've named just about ALL of the toys...Kong, Red Bone, Pigley, Bacon Bone, Tug, Snort, Baby Bear, Hairy Ball, Bumble, Krinkles, etc... He's getting it.Back to THIS toy... the Waffle Ball, as I call it... it's good to have a ball that isn't 'hard' for the dog to play with and chew on. It's a ball, but it's also a 'nice' toy. The dog can expel energy chasing it while learning control too because it's not a hard chew toy like his bones. It's somewhat of a puzzle too... as he isn't quite sure if it's a ball or a toy. It rolls but it bends. It's got holes in it, but he can't quite get through to the other side. It's an activity ball! I think this is a great toy and every dog should have one.Hope this helps.
Easily my dog's favorite toy
October 31, 2016
So, my puppy goes absolutely crazy for this. We have two now (one for "Grandma's" house and one for home. Even without anything in it, she loves chasing it. She can flatten it with her paws, pick it up at all sorts of angles (She likes using her molars - teething - to pick it up with the side of her mouth. Guess it feels good maybe?), play fetch and even tug of war. I was skeptical she'd play with it, since she showed very little interest in any rubber toys at the store, but her trainer swore by it and you know what, she was right.The trainer's recommendation was to stuff it full of fabric scraps, twisting up treats inside the fabric as you did so. That way she's got to pull out the scraps of fabric to get the treats and nothing you love gets destroyed in the process. So far we've done that once and it occupied her for a good twenty minutes or so. I'll be packing it tighter next time.That said, the one con is that I recommend closely watching your dog with it. My pup is a 4 month old Rottweiler (small for her age, she's about 25 lbs) and she can get her bottom jaw wedged into the holes pretty good. It has yet to hurt her or even scare her, and each time she has managed to get it off on her own before I could intervene, but I can only imagine what could happen if I weren't there. So this is a strict "while playing with Mom only" toy. But she loves it.
Perfect for small dogs!
May 10, 2016
At first I was disappointed. My friends Pit Mix gnaws on this thing like a beast. I got the littlest thinking my lil guy would like to chew it. I was disappointed because it seemed small and flimsy for the $4... Wrong! My lil one gnaws and crushes it and it bounces back. She loves chasing it and crushing it in her tiny jaws. I'm always fishing it out from under the couch. She loves it, and that's worth it🐾
Tennis ball obsessed doodle loves this ball even more!
December 12, 2015
Our dog went crazy over this when I gave it to her. Has a nice bounce to it and is lightweight that she can easily Carry it around in her mouth. So far have only used it indoors, but the material is easily cleanable so would be great for both indoor/outdoor use.My dog: mini goldendoodles 22 lbs, 1 yr old
Perfect for our bunnies
March 12, 2015
This is the perfect size for our dwarf rabbits. Easy for them to pick up and fling. The ball is soft enough that if they accidentally (?) fling it at the other one no one gets hurt. Note these come in several sizes so please order the proper size for your pet. The "mini" is 2 in. internal diameter, 2.5 in. external diameter, and 5 in. external circumference - slightly larger than a golf ball and smaller than a tennis ball.
64%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

Four Star Reviews:

11%
Not a chew toy! Great for treats and play
April 7, 2017
I used this as a treat ball, sticking a long piece of chicken jerky through the holes and let my Aussie figure it out. Took her 15mins to get the 2 pieces out. It works great when used like this! However, she also managed to chew it up pretty good before I was able to take it away from her. This looks like a chew toy, but it's not. I bought two and used to second for my pitbulls. They would toss it around and play tug with it, and it's held up great, oddly enough. If your dog is a chewer, don't leave it out for them to gnaw on, it'll get destroyed and becomes a choking hazard. Fetch and tug are great! Would buy again, but maybe a bigger size.
bought the largest size and its perfect for a lab puppy
March 31, 2017
Dog loves this ball, we place other things inside to give her some additional activity to do. sometimes we use a tennis ball or treats and she loves chasing it. bought the largest size and its perfect for a lab puppy.Update - After a month our dog has been able to tear the ball, figured it to be a bit more durable, however i still would buy again, much rather have the dog chew on this and tear it up rather than the furniture, she does still love chasing this.
Brain fun for dogs
March 14, 2017
My dog (a standard schnauzer) is smart and gets bored easily during the winter months when the weather is bad and he doesn't feel like staying outside all day. He generally finds bad things to occupy his time (barking at passers-by or finding a shoe to run around with). The JW Pet Hol-ee Roller ball is one of the tools I use to help keep him busy doing good things so he doesn't turn to the bad ones. This ball is great for caging other toys or treats so he has to work hard and use his brain to get to what he wants. Whimzees has made their dental treats to fit snugly inside of the Hol-ee Roller ball so it becomes an awesome puzzle for food motivated dogs like mine. Other toys like smallish balls also fit in the rubber with a little elbow grease so they can't come back out and entertain for awhile. When I intervene and make sure my dog doesn't get to the treat too soon, this toy will entertain him for an hour at a time. However, my dog is a moderate chewer and has destroyed on of these when I wasn't paying attention to him playing with it without a toy or treat in it, so be cautious of that.
Smaller than I thought it would be but pretty sure it says the size in the description
November 5, 2016
Smaller than I thought it would be but pretty sure it says the size in the description. Maybe a little bigger than a golf ball. So it didn't work for what I wanted to use it for. Not real sturdy my black lab got ahold of it and bit threw parts of it. It it was intended for my morkie who doesn't chew things up or tear them up like my black lab. Over all pretty good toy for a small dog.
bouncy small dog toy
March 4, 2015
My dog loves this little ball. I expected it to be the size of a tennis ball but it's a good bit smaller.
Put tshirt scraps inside!
May 29, 2014
I bought this product and our dog is not as entertained with it as my friend's dog is. I saw on Pinterest that you can cut up old tshirts into strips and cram them into this ball, then give it to your dog. Our dog LOVES this! She gets the satisfaction of tearing something apart (pulling tshirts out of ball) without destroying anything. When she's all done, we just put the tshirts back in and she can play all over again. Much cheaper/easier than buying stuffed animals, watching her tear out the stuffing, and then throwing it away/re-sewing it back up.
14%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

Three Star Reviews:

9%
Holes TOO big, Treats fall out immediately.
September 8, 2017
It's an ok item. Looks durable. I have the size smaller (Medium?, Red) which is awesome, but was thinking when my lab puppy gets bigger, she'll need a bigger more durable chew toy. I like the ability to hold treats and bounce around. My dog likes to swat it, pounce on it, and hold it down and attach it, especially when there's a treat inside. It takes her awhile to figure out how to get the treat. The size below is perfect for a large milk bone, or the Costco Kirkland milkbone, and works great. This larger size, has HUGE holes. See pic. The tag says "Holds Treats", but what kind of treat would you put in here that wouldn't fall out? A rotisserie chicken? or a porterhouse, maybe? I might return it. Without a treat, it's still a decent chew toy.
Dogs love this ball, but not for aggressive chewers
June 6, 2017
My terrier plays with a lab who adores this ball....the only problem is that she chewed this ball to pieces, then began to eat the pieces! That's why I bought this, as a replacement for the poor lab's destroyed ball! Beware not tough enough for aggressive chewers, and apparently tasty.
Hol-ee toy
May 31, 2017
This is fun to put cookies in and let the dog work on it. He did figure it out after a little though. Would like the holes a bit smaller to challenge him more.The quality of the rubber is very good though.
Sturdy material but if your dog is a heavy chewer ...
March 31, 2017
Sturdy material but if your dog is a heavy chewer I wouldn't leave them alone with this. My dog enjoys chasing it around and playing tug with it.Update: after 3 times playing with it, one of the connections broke already
I have a large breed puppy and this ball size was perfect. I was actually afraid it might be a ...
October 25, 2016
My puppy loves it. He carries it around, drops it and it rolls and he chases it. He absolutely loves to play with this thing. I have a large breed puppy and this ball size was perfect. I was actually afraid it might be a little small when I first ordered it. I was happily surprised at it's size. (That's what she said!)Update: I still really like the ball, but don't let them use it unsupervised. My pups destroyed this thing one day into a bunch of little pieces, I'm still not sure if one of them swallowed any of it.
Great toy - BUT can be destroyed by a tough chewer
November 19, 2015
This is a great, fun toy - but with a big caveat. It can be chewed to pieces. It is easy to toss, and easy for a dog to pick up. Also easier for you to get from the dog's mouth than a ball. BUT - and this is the caveat - it is easily torn apart by a "tough chewer". We've had all kinds of chewers - once had a Labradoodle who could destroy black Kongs. Our latest puppy has turned out to be both. Originally she was only a "modest" chewer, and we let her play alone with this. Then one day I noticed she had bitten through a couple of the sides. She must have swallowed the pieces with no ill effects. Our older dog will play with this without damaging it - she even bounces it down the stairs and fetches for herself. I now see that this company has a tougher version which has gotten very high marks on its durability from some people. Some say they see no teeth marks after months of use. I have ordered two but will monitor for signs of damage carefully.
11%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

Two Star Reviews:

8%
Usually a great toy
August 26, 2017
This brand toy is ok. The last ball/toy I had was great. I'm a Labrador retriever kinda guy (specifically black labs) and I've gotten one for every lab I've had. I always stretch out a hole just big enough to put a tennis ball in for extra fun. Was just about to give this product 5 stars but as I'm writing this review my pooch is tearing it to pieces and got her tennis ball out. She had it 5 minutes and her tennis ball it out. My last lab had her tennis ball in it for years my current lab less than five minutes.
2 inches ... description is deceptive.
July 17, 2017
This is a cute little toy but the "mini" is very small. It would be ok for a small breed puppy ( Pomeranian, Yorkie ...etc) but I question the safety for my large breed puppy. The picture shown in the listing is not how this ball actually looks. The description gave me the idea that the ball is 2.5", but it is only 2" ( listing says 2.5" x 5.2" x 2"). It's a ball, for pete sake, it doesn't have 3 sides, lol. I will have to get a bigger one.
It seemed to be a fun toy, so I gave it 2 stars and ...
June 7, 2017
My hard chewer...30 pounds...not a huge dog...got through it in about 10 minutes. It seemed to be a fun toy, so I gave it 2 stars and maybe if your dog's don't chew a lot it might be really good. For me, it is in the closet. I bought 2 but sending them back was too complex at the time, maybe if she loses her teeth when she gets old she will get it back
Our 100 lbs German Shepherd loved it. After about 2 months he managed to ...
April 1, 2016
We had another ball by this company. Our 100 lbs German Shepherd loved it. After about 2 months he managed to start destroying it and I hopped on Amazon to replace it. Well the new one came. I am giving this two stars because he absolutely loved the thing. It would have had a much higher rating though if it would have lasted more than 12 minutes. It was completely destroyed in 12 minutes. Every single link in the ball was ripped apart. The last one we had was green and we bought it from TJmaxx or something for like $3.00. This one was definitely not worth $9.00 and I won't be buying it again.TL;DR Dog destroyed it immediately out of the box.
Very disappointed in the description as 'large'.
December 18, 2015
When they advertise this unit, they should be very specific about what they consider large. This ball is only 5" across (though my seller called it 6.5") and to me, that is not 'large'. We have a 70 pound dog, large but not giant and a 5" version is just too small, he prefers the 8" which is considered oversize or jumbo by these standards.If you're buying over the internet, then the seller really should specify the actual size of the ball by measurement and not leave it up the imagination of the buyer to guess how big or small 'large' actually is.Besides this, the quality of this dog toy is excellent and I would highly recommend buying one for your dog; just be careful to get the size you really want.
Different from earlier versions and not as good.
September 24, 2014
The problem with a toy like this (and the related reviews) is that, for many, it will be fine. It's a nice toy and, if you're dog is not a strong chewer, it may very well last. But, if your dog has strong jaws... this toy probably won't last. I bought one for my daughter's 6-month old Weimardoodle and he had sections of it broken loose in under 15 minutes.The reason I bought this is that my daughter has an earlier version of the toy that HAS lasted... and I thought I'd get another. But there is definitely a difference between the first and second toy. The earlier one has a logo stamped on it and seems to be a bit thicker and of a different (sturdier) makeup. So, even if you're had an earlier version you were happy with... you can't assume the new one will last as well.It's hard to find good chew toys for strong-jawed dogs. This isn't one.
4%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

One Star Reviews:

16%
Smells terrible
April 11, 2017
The rubber smell was so strong with this product that neither of my dogs would have anything to do with it. They were slightly interested and when they sniffed it, they literally ran away from it and wouldn't get near it again.
The first one we ever got was amazing but it got lost
August 24, 2016
We've purchased this toy several times on Amazon. The first time was in 2012. So when I ordered replacements twice in 2016 I was surprised they broke apart so quickly. We don't leave this out and it's for monitored play and throw only. The first one we ever got was amazing but it got lost. These last two just didn't make it and I'm certain the quality had changed. I recall this not being an issue at all from our first one. We love this toy but I'll look elsewhere because this becomes a waste of money. I'd be willing to pay more for something that lasts long.
Size is misleading. Do not buy!
May 10, 2016
I ordered the 5 inch holy roller toy for my pup. The item I received is indeed labled 5 - inches, but is barely two! I absolutely cannot use this for my pup. It's a choking hazard.
From other reviews apparently these used to be good..
April 8, 2016
My dog is not a strong chewer...after 3 uses (put a treat I it) it is falling apart.Seems to be a substandard rubber that is falling apart. From other reviews apparently these used to be good...but now many complain of not lasting (falling apart). I assume these are made in China and of an inferior material than they used to be. I would not recommend at all unless reports of better material. If like the one I got they are a waste of time and money.UPDATE (6/2017): It was complete junk. You can see in photo (was taken when new) that material was failing when brand new. It appears they change formulation and no longer good like old ones were. If yours is like this contact Amazon for a refund. Hopefully that will force a change. NOTE: I did not contact Amazon for a refund (I just ate the cost) and at this point it is too long. However, please contact ASAP if yours is crappy like this to help force vendor to change or fix this issue.
My dogs love this ball - but the new ones STINK ...
December 7, 2014
My dogs love this ball - the little guy (17 lbs) has no problem carrying it around; and it has withstood countless games of tug 'o war between the 2 dogs. I LOVE this ball, because even when thrown forcefully by a grandchild - it has no hard impact with whatever it hits, it just collapses, then springs back into shape. I'm ordering 2 more balls to take along when we camp.(Update) And now that I have the 2 new balls - there's a drastic difference between the original and now. I've changed my 5 star rating to one star. I expect a slight rubbery odor to a dog toy - but these balls made my whole house smell like rubber/latex (my husband remarked on it, too); and after tossing one for a while, it was like I could TASTE that smell. So last night, I washed both; and let them sit to air out. Tonight, all I did was pick one up, and I can "taste" that nasty taste again. Figuring if it smells (tastes?) that bad - my dogs can keep playing with the old (good) ball.As another reviewer had pointed out - the old ball has a solid panel with "JW" stamped on it - the new ones do not. Hopefully, Amazon will refund my money - if not, I'll throw them out.
Much flimsier now than it used to be
February 18, 2013
I bought one of these last year at a pet store and it was amazingly sturdy. It survived hundreds of hours of intense chewing by my terrier. Finally he destroyed it, and we immediately bought this replacement on Amazon. But *it wasn't the same thing*. It was the same shape and color and brand name, but much much flimsier. Just looking at it, we could see how the rubber was thinner and stretchier. And indeed, our terrier tore it apart easily, within 10 minutes.Investigating further, I went to a pet store and saw on the rack both the hardy and the flimsy kind of ball, with exactly the same price and SKU. My guess is that the company has just recently switched to a cheaper manufacturer that makes the flimsy balls, and I was seeing the last of the old hardy balls.Here's a trick: With the hardy kind, one of the hexagons is not a hole but filled-in, with "jw" written on it. With the flimsy kind, all the hexagons are cut out the same.Anyway, if you see that the reviews seem to be "love-it-or-hate-it", this is why: Some customers got a totally different product than others did. Mine was the flimsy kind. The customer reviews lead me to believe that everybody is getting the flimsy kind these days.
7%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

Vote for Me
Vote for Me
Vote for Me
Vote for Me
Pricing info
Old Price
Old Price
Price
Price
$4.95updated: Mar 15, 2020
$6.99updated: Mar 9, 2020
$6.49updated: Mar 7, 2020
$2.39updated: Mar 7, 2020
Features
Answered Questions
Answered Questions
-
-
-
Article Number
Article Number
0617407644630
0035585131313
5147841394006
0885348679527
Binding
Binding
Misc.
-
-
-
Brand
Brand
JW Pet
KONG
Nylabone
Petstages
Color
Color
Assorted
black
Yellow
Multicolor
Currency
Currency
USD
USD
USD
USD
Department
Department
-
Racks/Futons
-
Pet Supplies
Formatted Price
Formatted Price
$3.62
-
-
-
Height
Height
78.7 in
68.9 in
118.1 in
334.6 in
Label
Label
-
KONG
Nylabone
Petstages, Inc
Legal Disclaimer
Legal Disclaimer
Our pet products and supplies are provided as is without any guarantees or warranty. In association with the product, PVGold, LLC makes no warranties of any kind, either express or implied, including but not limited to warranties of merchantability, fitne
FINAL SALE
-
-
Length
Length
98.4 in
118.1 in
236.2 in
216.5 in
Manufacturer
Manufacturer
JW Pet Company
KONG
Nylabone
Petstages, Inc
Maximum Age
Maximum Age
-
-
15
-
Minimum Age
Minimum Age
-
-
1
-
Model
Model
43109
KP3
N600P
126
MPN
MPN
43109
KON-124
N600P
0126
Name
Name
-
Spanish
-
English
Number of Items
Number of Items
1
-
-
-
Number of Parts
Number of Parts
43109
KON-124
N600P
0126
Product Group
Product Group
Pet Products
Pet Products
Pet Products
Pet Products
Product Type
Product Type
PET_SUPPLIES
PET_SUPPLIES
PET_SUPPLIES
PET_SUPPLIES
ProductTypeSubcategory
ProductTypeSubcategory
-
19900501
19900501
-
Publisher
Publisher
JW Pet Company
KONG
Nylabone
Petstages, Inc
Quantity
Quantity
1
1
1
1
Reviews
Reviews
-
-
Score
Score
7.4
8.4
-
-
Size
Size
Mini
Small
6 inches x 2.9 inches x 3 inches
Regular
SKU
SKU
DJW43109
-
-
-
Studio
Studio
JW Pet Company
KONG
Nylabone
Petstages, Inc
Title
Title
-
KONG Puppy Kong Toy, Small, Assorted Pink/Blue
Nylabone Just For Puppies Ring Bone Puppy Dog Teething Chew Toy
Dog Toy Pet Stages Cool Teething Stick
Warranty
Warranty
-
Your pet will love it or we'll buy it back! Simply return the toy along with the sales receipt within 30 days of purchase for a full refund.
-
-
Weight
Weight
0.0 oz
0.4 oz
0.7 oz
0.1 oz
Width
Width
206.7 in
68.9 in
113.4 in
59.1 in
Feature
Feature

Tug and treat ball

Durable natural rubber

Certified non-toxic

Flexible

Suitable for small and toy dog breeds

Teaches appropriate chewing behavior while offering mental enrichment

Soft puppy KONG rubber formula is customized for puppy teeth and gums

Unpredictable bounce for games of fetch

Great for stuffing with KONG Puppy Easy Treat, Snacks or Ziggies

Recommended by veterinarians and trainers worldwide

Made with our exclusive teething rubber formula

Recommended worldwide by Veterinarians, Trainers and behavior experts

Perfect for stuffing with KONG Puppy Easy Treat, Snacks or Ziggies

Aids in crate training, decreases separation anxiety, promotes proper chewing behavior and deters misbehavior

Unpredictable bounce for games of fetch

Made in the USA

Nylabone Puppy Chew toys encourage nondestructive chewing habits while satisfying the natural urge to chew

Designed for teething and actively chewing puppies

Bristles raised during chewing help clean teeth and prevent tartar buildup

Entertaining colors and textures keep your puppy busy

Great for powerfully chewing puppies

Outer shell freezes to provide soothing relief for tender gums

Crunchy when frozen, helps satisfy your dog's urge to chew

Measures 6" L x 1.5" W x 1.5" H

Sorry, there's no review at this time. Try changing the filter or leaving one.
Share your opinion
User Rating
Post Review
Please enter captcha code
captcha
Send