Side by Side Comparison of: Dr. Scholl's

I've been wearing the Air-Pillo insoles for years and will continue wearing them...its just that good. This comment is about the BLUE and YELLOW packaging vs. the ALL-BLUE packaging that I received unknowingly with this order. I decided to try them out before sending them back. FYI: The packaging may be different, but the quality, the foot-feel and the sizing is THE SAME. I hope this helps incase there is confusion when receiving a different packaging as I did.

These were a perfect temporary solution to my problem. I have flat feet and I absolutely hate walking long distances so I like to bike everywhere. Due to the unexpected rain in California, I had to walk to classes instead. I attend a fairly large university, so for me, walking is just ridiculously annoying. I felt a huge difference once I bought the soles! I used them on my admittedly old and not-ideal-for-flat-feet, Converse hightops and felt a spring in my step that made the long walks hurt a lot less. I also did not want to invest in expensive insoles I would only use for two months, so these were ideal!

My family has used these inserts for a few years and they are so comfortable and last longer than others. I walk 3-4 miles, four times a week and couldn't do it without the inserts. The price for the four pack makes them very affordable and I can only find them on Amazon.

Whether these are perfect or not, they are the best that I've found. They have a stiff enough base that they don't bunch up inside the shoes.I've serious metatarsal (fat pad) problems with my feet, worn them down with 70 years of hiking. With these, I can now handle 6 mile hikes and going to try for 8-10 this summer.Absolutely worth the price.

So I have used their regular insoles before and decided to get the ones with extra foam this time and it's fabulous! I use them in a pair of shoes that are 1/2 a size too big (rain/snow boots) and they made it so I didn't have to wear super thick socks now.One note on the sizing of these: they say they are women's (up to) size 10. More like up to size 11. My boots are a size 10 and I had to cut it down a bit so you start with the size chart and then trim as you need to to get a good fit.I got the $3 for $12 (6/ea) which is a better deal than Walmart ($8/ea).

Amazing soft feels like walking on pillows. I placed some in most of my shoes and it's done wonders for fatigue. I walk everywhere, so there amazingly useful. These pads can easily be used in any closed shoes. I ordered a pair for 4 pairs and will likely order more. The cushion just helps so much with foot pain and fatigue. I live in a city where you can walk everywhere and I generally do, and this has done wonders on how my feet feel at the end of the day. These insoles are double foam padded and should make most pairs of shoes really great for walking. And the best part is they are so inexpensive if your goal is comfort these are the insoles you are looking for. I would definitely recommend this product.

Not as comfy as I would hoped. I had bought it to stick into a pair of flats, but they didn't match up. I ended up giving them to my mom.

I love these for slippers. Because of some neuropathy issues and some months in shoes more than normal, these are so helpful in making even slippers more comfortable.

They do what they are supposed to do, add a little padding into a shoe which has little padding of their own. Still the product it always was and does its job which is great. Saved a pair of boots which were getting to be a little too painful to wear due to their age. Local cobblers want a ton of money (and rightly so) to add a cushion layer into my boots, these save me money and do the job just fine which helps me out a great deal. The double air pillow inserts are not orthodics which I don't need and was not looking for. If you are on your feet all day like I am from time to time, these inserts do help out.

I don't believe these are to be used as the only insole or a full insole replacement but instead to be used as an insole topper. These are extremely thin and by themselves offer little comfort while standing for a long time however if placed over another good insole they provide a little extra cushion while walking.So, if you are looking to add just a little cushion these are great. If looking for insole replacements look elsewhere.

I've used the Dr. Scholl's Air Pillo Insoles for years and now found these new Air-Pillo Cushioning Insoles with Memory Foam. Anyway, they're about the same price but these are a little more cushion-y. These, too, are your basic cushioning insoles adding a nice soft feeling for your feet and, because they're perforated, they help keep your feet cool and dry.My old ones would last about a year or so with me walking about a mile or two a day. I've learned to get the longest use is to be sure you cut them properly to fit your shoes not allowing them to slip or move within your shoes.For a few dollars, these are a good choice for a more comfortable walking shoe.

the title says it all i have been using these for little over a month and they are falling apart already the gel insoles seem to feel the same but last much longer ill be going back to those

Seems to last about 6 months. On some shoes, I've used two pairs (doubled up), in order to fit my feet to the shoes better.

The description is deceiving. It made it sound like this could also be used in women's shoes, I guess you could trim them down but that would be a lot of waste. I gave them to my boyfriend who said they are very comfy.

Fit men's size 13 great & made old shoes feel new again, but they only last about a month

It says Memory Foam, but these are so thin I can barely tell the difference between the "regular" insoles vs. the "memory" ones. If you wear size 13, like me, you will find that these are barely large enough -- more like size 12 -- but can fit a size 13 shoe with a no major adjustment. No particular arch support which you will find with more expensive models yet those tend to be molded around the heal and toes and often do NOT fit a true size 13 shoe.

It was comfortable for a short while then the insoles started tearing

I ordered these hoping they would be exact the the memory foam insoles as in some of the shoes that are now being sold with memory foam insoles already inserted at point of sale; however, these insoles are not as soft or comfortable as I had hoped they would be... They are okay, but need to be a little more plush and soft with more memory foam cushioning.

Wore once and had to throw out, they create some extra comfort but are more of a one time use sort of thing.

The delivery was fine but these weren't wide enough for ee shoes and were smaller than I thought they were gonna be. Soft coution and thin, like a strip of foam one side smooth silky like and the other memory foam feel

I returned this product as it was ordered by mistake. The regular double Air Pillo insoles are betterthan the memory foam. I am waiting for credit from Medicals.

these things move around a lot inside your shoes, you'll need really really really really really really strong glue in order for these to be worth the trouble

These are extra thick air-pillow insoles... they are nothing like the memory foam insoles that are sold in some shoes. These would be good if your shoes are about a 1/2 size too big and you want to make them fit better. I put them in some old clogs and they work good. Just don't mistake them for 'real' memory foam. I have shoes that have memory foam (Skecher's memory foam) and I love those shoes.... I'd hoped these inserts would be more like that and I could use them in other shoes to get the same effect. But no they did not work like that.

The idea is that you trim these insoles to fit your shoe size. The package says they fit mens sizes 7-13. Not really. I got them to to replace the insoles in a pair of New Balance shoes, men's size 11.5W. These insoles are actually a tad shorter and noticeably narrower than the original insoles. I just pushed them in untrimmed and we'll see if they stay in place. The external packaging says they fit men's sizes 7-13 but the template inside only goes up to size 11.Update. The size turned out not to be an issue. The insoles stayed in place without sliding around. But after about 10-15 hours of exercise walking around town, the foam crumbled under the ball of the foot. It seems these are only suitable for very light duty.

this shoe pad does NOT stick to the shoe. after you wear it for a while, it gets loose and wrinkles inside the shoe.

Really thin and doesn't stay in one place in your shoes

Very tin soles u start to feel the inside of the shoe very quickly was not impressed by these memory foam if I could return them I would

This item was advertised as 3 pair of regular thickness but what I received was 1 pair of double thickness. I plan to return them. It is frustrating when items are not as advertised.

They started falling apart from the first day i started using them and hurt my heals. Would not buy them again.

It is a nice design, but slides around a little in the shoe (size 12 shoe), and wore out within a month or two. I ended up buying a new pair of the same shoes to get the stock insoles back.