2 items
Compare
Compare
All Features
Differing
Coconuts by MatisseSee Similar
Coconuts By Matisse Women's Gaucho Boot,Tan,8 M US - Coconuts by Matisse
Madden GirlSee Similar
Madden Girl Women's Sanguine Boot,Brown Paris,8 M US - Madden Girl

Side by Side Comparison of: Coconuts by Matisse vs Madden Girl

Learn More
All Features
Differing
Learn More
Add to Whishlist
See Similar
Coconuts by Matisse http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41HPd4DBaGL._SL160_.jpg
Coconuts By Matisse Women's Gaucho Boot,Tan,8 M US - Coconuts by Matisse
Add to Whishlist
See Similar
Madden Girl http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41fnFcKo8IL._SL160_.jpg
Madden Girl Women's Sanguine Boot,Brown Paris,8 M US - Madden Girl
Rating info
eComparisons Score
eComparisons ScoreThe "Comparison Score" Is calculated based on the average number of times this item was compared with other items in this category by our users
8.2
8.4
User Rating (Amazon)
User Rating (Amazon)

Five Star Reviews:

54%
A must buy!
September 28, 2017
I have to say that these are truly the most comfortable boots I've ever worn!! If you love cowboy boots, these are for you!! They are super cute with knee length denim dresses, or flowy skirts (and skinny jeans tucked into boots). If you are looking at these, BUY NOW!
Beauty and comfort together
June 5, 2017
I love this set of boots, not only are they beautiful but comfortable too
I love these boots
May 4, 2017
I love these boots!!! I got them just before a 3 day festival where I wore them everyday and walked a TON! Not only were they super comfortable but totally adorable as well. Couldn't be happier! :)
Five Stars
April 8, 2017
Absolutely love these boots. Soooo comfortable. I wore them all night at rodeo dancing.
Nice but order smaller
April 7, 2017
Very nice looking boots but they run a lot bigger than other Matisse boots I've tried.
Very good boot, especially for the price.
December 13, 2015
Love the boots but wish they came in half sizes. I'm a 7 1/2 and ordered them in a 7. Could not even get my foot in them. Returned them & got a size 8 which is just slightly large but are certainly wearable. Very comfortable and have had many compliments.
57%
Comfortable and pretty
March 24, 2017
I get a lot of compliments on these, and I wear them a lot because they're so comfortable. Wish they came in black!
I got 7 and a half and it fits me perfectly the color is gorgeous just like in the picture and the details was so adorable
November 28, 2016
Bought this cow girl boots for my sister in law country themed wedding. I got 7 and a half and it fits me perfectly the color is gorgeous just like in the picture and the details was so adorable. I love wearing it! Wore it again when we went for a Grand Canyon trip with family and we did a lot of walking haha! the boots is comfortable had no problem wearing it, it's not heavy just like everyone said "boots are made for walking" well this one is truly made for walking. Love the looks great buy. I recommend Maden Girl boots to those who's looking for a nice but not too expensive cow girl boots this is def worth your money.
but I for sure had wiggle room in these but overall they fit great. As for comfort
November 6, 2015
Had to buy these for a wedding. I haaaaaate ordering shoes on line because I'm very picky about shoes, and my shoe size varies from a 7 to an 8. I was skeptical about buying this but went for a bigger size, figuring I could always wear thick socks if need be. I'm not sure if boots are supposed to be roomy, but I for sure had wiggle room in these but overall they fit great. As for comfort, same as before I'm very picky, but I wore these from 10am until midnight and my feet were fine. They weren't worn in so my feet were a tad bit sore, but nothing a few more wears couldn't break it.
Overall, I was completely satisfied with this item and would recommend these to anyone.
Comfy
February 2, 2014
These boots are very cute and really comfy, but run about 1/2 size too large. I still love them though!
AMAZING BOOT!!
May 12, 2012
I ordered these boots, and they came within a week, Extremely fast shipping as always with Amazon.com. I first have to say that I have very fat feet, They were a little tight to get on, which is normal for me, But they stretched out wearing them around the house. I wanted a boot that was very cowboyish with the point toe and the whole 9. I am getting married in these boots in 2 weeks, and they couldn't be more than perfect. They are NOT "plastic" like another review said. They are very comfortable, and very pretty!!! We got our engagement pics done in them, and Ive wanted to wear them since, but I need to keep them perfect until after the big day!! All my bridesmaids got these boots as well, No complaints from any of them either! Am buying another pair I love them so much!!

Four Star Reviews:

23%
Love these boots
June 14, 2017
Love these boots! Really cute. I got a size 7 and they fit okay but putting my foot in is the hard part but once they are in they feel great.
Super cute, a little big
May 30, 2017
I ordered an 8, and I'm usually an 8.5. They were a tad large on me. If I could order them again I would go a full size down to an 7.5! Otherwise, they're super cute, and pretty comfortable!
Four Stars
April 4, 2017
These boots were very cute and were well-made but the toe is just too narrow--I had to return them.
Very cute boots
January 2, 2017
Great boots for my first pair of cowboy boots. Saw them locally in a store and they were the last pair in my size and scuffed. Found on Amazon prime for 3 dollars more and had in 2 days. Fit just as expected and my size 8.5 feet don't even look big in these like most cowboy boots. They are imitation leather, but the price reflects that and they still have a nice distressed look.
Great Price, Good boot!
October 3, 2014
I agree with some of the posts here that they look somewhat cheap, but I am giving a good review because I think it's obvious that if you're paying this price for a boot, it's not going to be a high quality boot. I expected them to look cheap. I wanted some boots and didn't want to spend a lot of money so I didn't expect high quality and that was fine with me. They actually look a lot better than I expected and fit perfect (true to size)! They do look a bit darker in the picture here than they actually are. That is my only complaint.
Lightweight and comfortable
November 27, 2010
I rarely buy footwear online as I usually need to try them on but I took a chance because I had a gift card to redeem. I wear a size 8 boot and hoped these boots were true to size. I was happy that they fit perfectly. It took only two wears to break them in. They are lightweight and comfortable and easy to put on and take off. I ordered them in burgundy which is a nice color for boots. You can't tell they're not real leather unless you get real close or touch them. The workmanship is very good.
22%
Texas Ho!
July 7, 2016
Love these boots! A bit more pointy than I thought they would be but I don't often where cowgirl boots so maybe it's just me. Hubby thinks they look good!
LOVE THESE!
April 22, 2016
These are really good looking boots! The only reason they didn't get 5 stars is because I have knock-kneed really thin legs so I won't be able to wear them with a skirt or shorts. I'm sure I'll be happy with them in jeans. :)
If you think you want these, get them!
December 30, 2015
Really happy with these boots! I haven't worn them out for too long yet, but they're super cute! I have somewhat chubby calves and they're still loose on me! There's wiggle room, but I'm not complaining bc it's better than them being super tight.

Only downside is, you can tell that they are not the best quality. Because there is a heel on the boot, I thought it would make the "heel sound" when you're walking or taking any steps but ... nope. Silence. Almost as if you're wearing regular shoes/flats.

I'm a 7.5/8 but majority of the other reviews that I read said to size down because they run big. I originally got the size 7 but it was too tight at the toes (was not able to stand or walk without feeling pressure) so I exchanged them for a 7.5 and they fit me like an 8.5.

For the price, I can't complain! They look SO good with blue jeans!
Don't Wear Them Dancing and then complaining how sore your feet are....
April 14, 2015
For the price, this was a fun investment in costuming...needed the boots to be a full-on cowgirl and these were priced right and kind of plain enough to go with virtually anything. The leather is kind of 'shiny' so, no, it doesn't appear genuine. The stitching detail is nice. The heel height just right. They fit like cowboy boots for women - so a bit narrow, a bit pinched at toe - and hard heel. Meaning don't wear them out dancing and then complain later of how sore your feet are. Ordered 1/2 size up to allow for that narrow/pinched feeling and that was a good choice.
Great Boots!
November 6, 2012
These boots are really great! They are truly the most comfortable boots I've ever worn!I bought a size 8 (wear 7.5 or 8.0 most of the time) and they fit perfect - even have room to wear thicker socks. Even though - they are lined so they keep your toes quite warm. They are SO comfortable! I wore them for about 12 hours the very first time and I was standing a fair amount of time, and I experienced no discomfort at all!The color of them is perfect - I bought the Brown Multi - you can wear brown or black with them as they have both colors in the boot - its dark. They looks very stylish and I will wear them under jeans or with a skirt. I recieved many compliments and especially when I told friends the price! I think a few of my friends will go buy them!The only downside is that they are not leather uppers. I wasn't sure if they were or weren't based on the description - even on the Madden Girl website - but they definitely are not. However, they are for style so its not a major downside for me.Overall - extremely comfortable, stylish boots at a very affordable price point - definitely recommend!Madden Girl Women's Sanguine Boot

Three Star Reviews:

10%
Okay boot for the price you pay
October 1, 2017
I needed a pair of brown cowgirl boots for a wedding. These are a nice color and I like the design. They are somewhat large but nothing that can't be fixed by wearing a little thicker socks. The material of the boot is soft but does seem somewhat cheap (the price you pay) so I'm not sure how long they would actually last. But for my needs of the wedding, they will do!
BE CAREFUL IF YOU BUY THE TAN
September 14, 2017
BE CAREFUL IF YOU BUY THE TAN colored boots because there is NOT free return shipping. For the price, I really liked the fit and look of the boot, but it's such a terrible color. It's more yellow when I was looking for a true tan color and the color looks even worse against my olive skin tone. I wanted to return for a different color, but now I am debating because I don't want to pay the $20 in shipping back to Florida.
Look good, aren't so comfortable
April 17, 2017
The boots are a bit tight on the foot, but he seam cuts a bit so they aren't as comfortable as most boots once bought by this brand. They look good though!
COULD NOT GET THEM ON MY FEET BECAUSE THE LEATHER IS TOO SOFT.
October 16, 2016
I really like these boots, but the back around where your heel goes in is so soft that I couldn't even get the boots on my feet, not even with a shoe horn. They are made with quality soft leather and they look really nice. My only complaint is that I can't figure out how to get them on my feet with the leather being as soft as it is.
... boots as another review stated they looked a lot like genuine boots
September 8, 2016
I had purchased these boots as another review stated they looked a lot like genuine boots. Upon receipt they do not look like genuine boots, they have a wrinkle or give in the material that you can tell they are not genuine boots. They are cute, with nice color & I do wear them with my bootcut jeans as the jean covers most of it.
The boots are very cute and a great price. However
July 1, 2015
The boots are very cute and a great price. However, the right boot is smaller than the left, and I had a hard time getting my foot inside it. I've never had problems with any shoes in the past, indicating that my feet might be different sizes, so I really think it's just a quality control issue. The heel of the boot is made of rubber, which makes it very comfortable (at least the left boot since it fits). The main sole quickly gets scuffed, and then you can see fibers showing through. I guess you get what you pay for... they are for looks more than anything. If the right boot fit my foot like the left, I would wear them all the time.
9%
but the general quality is fine and they look great on
June 22, 2017
leather tore quicker than expected, but the general quality is fine and they look great on.
... little tight at the toes and I don't feel like I'll be able to wear them for long periods ...
October 12, 2016
These boots are cute but they are a little tight at the toes and I don't feel like I'll be able to wear them for long periods of time. I'm a true 9 and even with very thin socks they didn't work out. I will be returning them.
Runs small and narrow - be sure to check your size!
February 6, 2016
These ran quite small, were very narrow and not a lot of room in the toes. They were also very uncomfortable, so I returned them. Maybe they would fit someone who wore a size 9 better than a size 10 and if the person has a very narrow foot.
Comfy but cheap looking
January 2, 2014
These boots are super comfortable but look cheap up close. They look more "plastic-ally" than I hoped for. I am still searching for exactly what I'm looking for- comfort - which this boot has- in a real leather cow girl boot- which this is not. The finish wore off the toe within 2 months & reminds me of my faux-leather love seat that is now peeling. And I wasn't even rough with these boots at all! If you just need a pair of comfy boots that look ok from a distance these boots may be what you are looking for but as for me, I'm still searching....
Identical to "Kaci" boot at Target for less...
February 13, 2013
This boot is cute (by no means an "authentic cowboy boot", but I totally knew that going in, so it's OK), but does not look quite like the picture. It is much darker with a solid brown, not the pretty "rubbed" effort I was hoping for. It also is NOT nearly as tall as the description says, which was the main reason I bought this one over the one at Target. They are 100% the same, minus the name (do a search for "Mossimo Kaci boot at Target... THEIR photo is accurate to the real boot style/ color for the brown). Overall, it's alright. I knew quality would be low, but this isn't for daily, and pure look so that is less upsetting than the low height (darn near an ankle boot, actually) and no variation in "rubbed" color. The fit IS small despite the super pointy toe, so definitely listen to everyone advising 1 to 1 1/2 size smaller. I think the price is a bit high for quality, but otherwise it's not a total cheap boot...just much much less than expected from photo and description. If it is still available, buy the Kaci boot. it might not look as pretty in it's photo online, but that's because THEIR photo is correct to the item. This one even has identical stitching patterns and Target's is about $10 less.

Two Star Reviews:

7%
Two Stars
July 7, 2017
Cheaply made. Received the wrong color.
The run a little on the small side. Even ...
April 19, 2017
The run a little on the small side. Even the calf area is small for a cowboy boot and I have small calves. Cute boot though.
Easy return and refund after I had to pay $15 ...
August 26, 2015
Cheap quality. The sides of the boot would not stand up. And I normally wear a 7.5 and these 7.5 were too small. Easy return and refund after I had to pay $15 to ship them back.
Super cute order half size up...runs small
July 10, 2015
Very cute however even though this item was sent to me a half size too small from what I ordered I could tell I would have needed a half size bigger than what I normally wear. Super cute boot.
Not What I Expected
December 29, 2014
The boots look better online than they do in person. They run small apparently because I ordered them 1/2 size bigger than my daughter normall wears and they are too small. They are also only mid calf, which we thought they were taller. Not very happy.
Adorable boot; LOUSY sizing...
February 16, 2013
This is the 2nd "go-round" I've had with this boot. I am VERY frustrated (despite an excellent seller). Reviews with regard to size are not detailed, so allow me. The boot does NOT "run large". I am a size 7- 7.5 in all shoes. Overall, the boot is simply ODDLY sized! The length and especially the WIDTH are enormous. However, the breadth at the neck to get the boot ON is tiny and will not "bend" to form. I followed size opinions here an went 6.5. I returned it since I could not even insert my foot at all. I then had to go 7.5 since there is no size 7 (there REALLY should be...). I can barely squeeze my foot in (and I have high arches on a very narrow foot), but once in, my foot SWIMS. I am about an inch or more from the toe and the sides gape. I seriously hope these do NOT stretch with wear because they will then fall off. I should probably return them and give up, but the boot is just so darn cute. I adore the height and honey-blonde colour! It is adorable, and since I won't wear them much, I guess I will just have to hope my feet don't look enormous when I wear them. Truthfully, while the boot has to be too large to get into, they are very true-to-size in the majority. The company hopefully can fix the sizing issues, because it's a great boot. The material is soft and the rubbing is awesome. The heel looks kind of cheap (not real wood), but generally, I like it. I am just annoyed I cannot seem to locate these anywhere in a size 7.
5%
Not for me
August 31, 2016
I have thin calfs and these boots looked really big on my legs. I will probably return. Also they have a fake look and not a real authentic leather look like I wanted. .
The boot was very wide and fit more like a 10 in length
August 27, 2016
I got an 8.5 as suggested by others. The boot was very wide and fit more like a 10 in length. I don't mind it being wide around the calf in a cowboy boot, but wide around my foot (even with my 2 thickest pairs of socks on) is just a recipe for blisters. Because the shoes didn't fit me right they didn't supply arch support.
unsatisfactory
January 16, 2016
I bought these for my cousin and she said they're a good fit but they wore out after a month... not a good quality if you're a real country girl. Might be perfect if you're wearing them for dress up.
DON'T BELIEVE COLOR
November 20, 2014
I bought these boots, and paid more than other very similar and less expensive items because of the weathered color shown in the image. These boots arrived basic dark brown (not at all the color in the image) and cheap looking, no different than any of the $30 to $40 versions out there that don't carry the name brand. AND they weren't that comfortable. I've owned more comfortable boots from Payless and Target. I wish I hadn't spent the money. Only get them over others if you need to be able to stay they are by Steve Madden. Otherwise, save yourself the money and buy the other cowboy boot knock offs, as they will look EXACTLY the same.

IF you want to know what the boots you order will look like, see this item and you will see how different they look. http://www.amazon.com/Madden-Girl-Womens-Sangunwm-Western/dp/B00JOYMDM6/ref=sr_1_5?s=apparel&ie=UTF8&qid=1416508598&sr=1-5
disappointed
September 18, 2014
The picture is very deceiving. The boots appeared to be matte and a little bit weathered in the picture, however, they are very shiny like plastic.... they look very fake. I bought them and made sure they were returnable... but with my busy life I ran out of time... they were purchased July 10 but I did not receive them until July 25... and I only had two weeks to return them apparently... so now i am down forty dollars. These might be appropriate for a little girl, but definitely not for a woman. Buyers beware.

One Star Reviews:

6%
DO NOT BUY THESE WHATSOEVER
August 28, 2017
I'm extremely disappointed... I received these today and immediately opened them. When I opened them they looked awful, the complete opposite of what is described. DO NOT BUY THESE. Also, they gave me the wrong color and size. Save yourself 70 dollars and get a different pair of boots. If I could, I would leave 0 stars.
I ordered this boot once and it was nothing like the picture
August 10, 2017
I ordered this boot once and it was nothing like the picture. They were not distressed, the heel was black and the color was more of an orange brown. I then spoke with customer service and was told that they were sorry and that if I returned and ordered another pair that I would get the correct pair. The second pair came in the exact same. NOTHING like the picture. I needed these for a wedding and was very disappointed in the product.
I received this today and had bought a 6 and ...
April 30, 2017
I received this today and had bought a 6 and 6.5 unsure of what size I'd need. I need a 6 but UNFORTUNATELY, the size 6 were both left foot! And, one looks worn!
One Star
April 14, 2017
Order a size smaller
Do Not Purchase....Does Not Last
April 9, 2017
The shoe is absolutely beautiful, but it has maybe only been 2 weeks and it does not last at all!!!!!!! The shoe is already falling apart at the seems, and is not worth the $50 purchase. I am definitely upset with how badly the shoe was put together.
One boot too small
June 23, 2016
I ordered a size 6. One boot slides on perfectly and the other boot is extremely small. My heel can only go halfway down before getting stuck. It's as if the boots are two different sizes. My feet are exactly the same size and I have never had a problem like this before with other shoes. Very bizarre. Returned immediately.
7%
too big
May 7, 2015
Too big, I ordered a 10 should've got a 9 I'd say. They are nothing like a real cowboy boot but that's what makes them comfy I guess. Real boots are real leather & no give. The toes are really pointy & with them being too big made me look like I have elf shoes on or something.. Looked weird.overall I'd say not worth the money!
Heel broke in the second use!
December 13, 2014
My wife wanted these as a Christmas gift, so that she could wear them at the Stagecoach festival in California. Her second time wearing them resulted in the entire heel splitting apart and left unusable. We are very unhappy with this purchase, and will not be buying Steve Madden cowboy boots again......
SOOO cheap looking and feeling!
November 23, 2014
i thought the picture looked pretty nice and authentic, but incredibly synthetic looking and feeling...almost like plastic. i put them i my halloween box - would never actually wear them for real (and i am not pretentious, but they are just that cheap). disappointing.
Poor quality, looks cheap
December 4, 2012
First of all I love dealing with Amazon. I have never returned anything I purchased until now. These boots look very cheap. I am really surprised "Madden" has their name associated with the quality of these boots. I have purchased boots from this company prior and was very happy with the product. Amazon was wonderful on their return process and I will continue to use them for future purchases.
Cheasp boots
September 27, 2012
I ordered these wanting a pair of cowboy boots...These are made of cheap plastic and look ridiculous. They have started tp seperate at the seams. I tried to return but was told to contact the manufacturer. Really I have had them for 3 weeks!!!! These are cheap don't waste your money! I buy alot from amazon but will never buy from this seller again.
Vote for Me
Vote for Me
Pricing info
Old Price
Old Price
Price
Price
$52.24updated: Mar 11, 2020
$69.95updated: Mar 13, 2020
Features
Article Number
Article Number
0803906819420
0882946411177
Binding
Binding
Apparel
Apparel
Brand
Brand
Coconuts by Matisse
Madden Girl
ClothingSize
ClothingSize
8 B(M) US
8 B(M) US
Color
Color
Tan
Brown Paris
Currency
Currency
USD
USD
Department
Department
womens
womens
Formatted Price
Formatted Price
$88.95
$69.95
Height
Height
173.2 in
169.3 in
Length
Length
547.2 in
582.7 in
Manufacturer
Manufacturer
Coconuts by Matisse
Madden Girl Footwear
Model
Model
GAUCHO
Sanguine
MPN
MPN
GAUCHO-TAN-8-M
SANGUINE-204
Number of Items
Number of Items
1
-
Number of Parts
Number of Parts
GAUCHO-TAN-8-M
SANGUINE-204
Product Group
Product Group
Shoes
Shoes
Product Type
Product Type
SHOES
SHOES
Publisher
Publisher
Coconuts by Matisse
Madden Girl Footwear
Quantity
Quantity
1
1
Reviews
Reviews
Score
Score
8.4
8.4
Size
Size
8 B(M) US
8 B(M) US
SKU
SKU
EC1229075-080-05
-
Studio
Studio
Coconuts by Matisse
Madden Girl Footwear
Weight
Weight
9.0 oz
3.3 oz
Width
Width
484.3 in
496.1 in
Feature
Feature

Made in USA or Imported

Sorry, there's no review at this time. Try changing the filter or leaving one.
Share your opinion
User Rating
Post Review
Please enter captcha code
captcha
Send