Side by Side Comparison of: Justin Boots vs Shoes8teen

I received my boots one week ago and have been wearing them every chance I get. These boots have the authentic western cowboy boot appearance that I wanted. The stitching is pretty. The leather seems to be good quality. They have a slightly distressed look. But I like that. I ordered a half size smaller than my normal size and they are not snug at all. I may have been able to order a full size smaller. My foot is wide and I have a high instep. It took a good tug to get them on but they are super comfortable. They don't pinch or rub anywhere. The shaft of the boot is perfect. They are not snug on my calves. I wore them for hours right away and they are great! I received many compliments. Would love to have them in other colors. Love these boots!

They are a little larger sized than normal...but it works out well for me because I like to wear a thicker sock with my boots and they fit perfectly with the thicker sock. I can wear these boots all day and night and they have yet to cause any foot discomfort (I have other boots you can't wear for too long, or walk around in without hurting the foot!) They are gorgeous boots and I have received many compliments when I wear them! I bought the Tan Damiana color.

I really wanted to buy a pair of western boots, and I soon found out that this pair was a winner! This is my first "real" pair of western boots, so I did a little looking around online and in stores before I bought these to make sure my money was well spent on a quality pair that I would love. I learned that I would save over $30 on this pair by ordering through Amazon vs. in person at local stores and that I needed to order a half size smaller in boots since over time the leather will stretch and my typical shoe size left my foot slipping around too much in the boots. I wear a women's size 9 and the 8.5 fits me perfectly.A little while before I bought this Justin pair, I had bought a pair of 8.5 Ariat boots. I wore them all over the house hoping to start breaking them in, but unfortunately they rubbed terribly on my ankles even when I put a sock over the trouble areas. I returned them to the original store and tried on another pair of Ariats, which I thought they would not rub like the last pair since the stitching didn't overlap the ankle area. However, they also rubbed against my ankles leading me to believe that the Ariat brand was not going to be comfortable for me. This is when I slipped on the Justin boots and discovered how much more comfortable they were, how much more appealing I thought they looked on me, and later I learned that they don't need to be broke in hardly at all.These boots are absolutely fabulous and I highly recommend them to anyone looking for a new pair!

Love this boot it is beautiful and a bit worn looking like I wanted! I wear an 8.5 and stuck with my normal size even though other reviews said go down a size. I have worn them for two weeks and they are a perfect fit definitely do not go down a size, they would be way to tight! I danced in them for hours 2 nights in a row and they are comfortable but the leather rubbed against the top of my foot but this is my first pair of real cowgirl boots and I think they still deserve 5 stars! If you are just walking around you,can wear them all day and you can dance in them for a while too! Everyone loves them and asked where I got them! I love Amazon and order everything on here! Thanks!:)

These boots are beautiful. I usually wear an 8 to an 8 1/2. I ordered an 8 and am pleased. They are a tad big, but I think a 7 1/2 would have been too small. I absolutely love them!

I have very small and narrow feet and these boot fit like a glove. BY far the most comfortable boots I have ever had. This is the only brand I will ever buy again.

This was a gift for my niece and she loves them. They looked just like they did in the picture.

I actually love these boots and still wear them a year later! Great quality and amazing price! Really amazing price!

Out of all my pairs of shoes these are definitely my favorites. They fit comfortably and definitely scream country which I love because I love country fashion and definitely want to look like the country girl that I am and these actually do the trick especially if I wear them with my pink tank top and blue jeans.😊

I bought these boots for New Years Eve and they worked perfectly! They were comfortable enough to wear the whole evening. I would purchase another pair in a different color.

Great for Riding or Just wearing.Womens Cognac 6314 Tall Leather Western Cowboy Boots With Traditional EmbroideryThese boots were a requested gift. The recipient loves them and wears them everyday. They are beautiful & very durable. I purchased the Womens Cognac 6314 Tall Leather Western Cowboy Boots with Traditional Embroidery.Pro's*Very well made!*Great for riding or Just wearing.*True to size.Con's*NoneOverall this is a great set of boots they meet all of my expectations. I would recommend these Womens Cognac 6314 Tall Leather Western Cowboy Boots with Traditional Embroidery to anyone looking for a well made set of boots.

Love these boots!! They were shipped very quickly and they fit great!!

The shoes is beautiful. However I had to return it because the left shoe had almost like a bent,mushed by the ankle. Otherwise it's great quality. The color is beautiful. Well made. Worth the money for sure. True to size. I recommend it.

These boots are really nice looking & have that awesome leather smell ! Was excited to try them on. Sooo disappointed when I could barely get my heel thru the top of the boot. Finally got it in but I have wide calves & I'd never be able to wear them ! They'd never even be able to be stretched. I've read many reviews on Justin boots & most say they're not made for a wide calf. But in the reviews I read on Amazon, many people said they have large calves & these fit perfect. Sadly, I have to send them back. You're returns are easy but wish I didn't need to. Being made in Mexico is a big plus along with Amazon's very loose price. I gave 4 stars because they are beautiful & so well made.

Pretty boots that look just like the picture. I've only worn them a couple times so far, but my right boot rubs a bit on my right ankle, whereas the left one does not. This issue should become moot as I wear them more since they are leather and should soften over time.

After I wear them and see if they will stretch normally Justin's won'tOther than that I love them....The price was awesome as well

Well I had to get my hands on a pair, but mainly for fashion reasons. With that being written, I love my shoes and they hurt at times. Square toes are the way to go if you're wanting a more realistic shoe, but if you're a fake cowgirl like me... get them!! Also I have flat and wide feet soooo... smh

These boots are classic and very comfortable. My first time wearing them I walked three miles or so to attend an All Souls processional in downtown. I was a little concerned that my boots would require some breaking in but that was not the case. As recommended, I ordered a half size smaller than normal to accomodate thick socks. I could have gone down another half size and been fine. As they are slightly large it is a breeze pulling them off. The construction is height quality and the design the quintessential,cowboy boot. Go with one of the less traditional colors to make more of a fashion statement.

I love it! These are my first pair of cowboy boots and there everything I wanted. The only thing I'm concerned about is that the heel. You can see the gluing and I'm scared when I go to work in the pasture, it will come off. Other then that, it's great. No scratches, or marks on the boots. I would recommend this boots!

My only complaint is visible glue lines. I do like they are faux leather. The ones I received are pointed toes and have short heels which is great because I am 5'11" so I don't need a lot of added height. I will update later as far as wear and tear as I wear them more. They seem as they will hold for a little while at least.Update:They are still mostly holding together. The sole and show are separating on one but I do have a tendency of walking though puddles and not drying them after. Within the first two days the leather started peeling by the toe but I also was kneeling on carpet so that may have played a role in it

These boots are a little tough to get on the first few times. It has adjustable straps on the sides and you can wear them tight or loose. They have a good hard sole and made of a quality product. I have worn these with jeans or dress pants, it all depends on my mood for the day. I would recommend wearing them with thinner socks. I am a size 7 and have somewhat of a wide foot. I purchased a size 7 and they fit really well, apart from being tough to get one the first few times. I found it was easier to unbuckle each one, put them on and then re-buckle them. They are comfortable to wear and I was able to wear them for over 8 hours a day. These boots are ankle high as well

Not the color I had ordered. Lighter than expected, but fits well. I'm upset they weren't the darker color listed, but happy they fit & will have to learn to like the lighter color. These arrived 2 days after ordering, which was earlier than anticipated.

I thought this was a good basic boot for the cost. (I was buying for a costume, so I wasn't looking to spend a lot). I was pleased with the style however they were a little large so I returned them. The footbed may not be the most comfortable for long wear, but I didn't think it was anything a simple insole couldn't fix. I also received these incredibly fast, and my refund was processed quickly so I give a star rating to this seller as well.

Nice boots for the money, these were purchased for a country wedding and will look great!

The way the boot bends near the ankle when you walk hurts really bad. One shoe is worse than the other. Hoping they just need breaking in but can't wear them more than an hour before the pain is just unbearable.

The color shown has a green hue to it. That is the reason I purchased the boots. The boots are actually a Tannish brown not tannish green as shown. The description said Tan so expected the boots to definitely be a lighter shade than they actually are. Again I purchased them because the hue of green is what I needed

Color is a strange red & these fir small

Nice quality. However, they were a size or so too large. I ordered my regular size 8 1/2 and returning for a 7 1/2.

My foot has a very high arch...so I did have to have the boots stretched . The foot size is fine but the "neck" ? had to be widened so I could get my foot down into the boot. Other than that, all is fine.

Too large and they didn't look like the picture. The leather was lighter.

I really like them but they were to sma

The boots were okay. The sizing is not the best. I ordered a size 8 for my daughter, which is what size she wears. When they came they me, I wear a size 6. So you have to order 2 sizes up from what you normally wear. I reordered a size 10 for her and they fit.

Boots were exactly what I wanted only they were smaller than what I ordered.

Super cute. A little small so get a half size or next size up. Not the best quality but cute!!

Looks nothing like the picture. They're a couple shades lighter. And there is no heel. They don't look bad but they look like a cowboy boot and a riding boot had a baby. Kind of awkward looking. But hopefully I can't pull it off

Don't expect them to last forever, they are clearly a mass marketed item. But for what I spent, I'm pleased. Not fine quality like a handmade boot, but they are much better than expected.

I returned these. I have large calves - 15 3/4" and these were SO big on them. They were almost floppy looking. Not sure if I got a defective item or not.

Leather quite streaky and doesn't feel good enough quality for what I paid

I returned these because they run at least a full size bigger than expected.

Gorgeous red torino boots but I ordered the same size as the last 3 pairs of Justin boots I have owned and they are way too small. Dissapointed, as now I am stuck waiting on a return credit so I can order a bigger size.

I love Justin boots but was not thrilled with this purchase and have since returned. These are very well made but the color was much darker than I expected and I felt the sizing ran a little large. Otherwise, prompt delivery and great packaging but just didn't work for me.

I was looking for a plain black boot, and these fit that. However, I got the size I've worn in other Justin boots, but these were WAY too large! I even gave them to my daughter whose feet are a bit larger and wider than mine. They were even too big for her. Unfortunately, by then it was too late to return, so I'm stuck with them.

These boots look nothing like the picture, they were a rounded toe and the 9B was more like a size 8 or smaller. My size 9 foot barely fit. Smelled like plastic shoes, I guess you get what you pay for but in the end I returned them.

looked cuter online, not the boot I received, worn once.....

The boots look pointy in the picture but they are not. Their customer service is great.

These boots fit according to size. The width is a tad narrow, however I have a wide foot. The boot 'leather' quality isn't the best, if anything they definitely look like they came from K-Mart (That's what my friend said as I was putting them on, haha), but that's what you get for the price I guess. If you're looking for a fancy cowboy boot, this isn't the product for you. If you need something just for a quick look and afforable price, go for it. I am giving them 3 stars because the heel became unglued on the second day of wearing them, so it kinda defeated the pupose of even buying them. I would spend the few extra bucks and get a boot that won't break on me so soon, Thank goodness I only needed them for a weekend camping trip. Enjoy!

The material was made like a cheaper material not like the picture shown.It was thin soft and cheap almost plastic look and feel I paid 39.99 for them but i spent 24.99 at pay less years ago and the boot lasted many years with better material.It looked like a fake boot made from china.The color was a light color the boot above does not look like what I have.

These are not at all like the boot shown in the photo. The tops are nearly straight across, the toe area/top of the foot is strangely shaped, they have a lower heel, and the color is way off. The only positive is that they seem to fit true to size? Disappointed/returning.

Too big not a true size

We ordered size 6M , that was the size indicated on the box, but 9B was in the box!

Nice looking boots. But after the first time I wore them my toes were extremely sore.. 2days later, the nail on my big toe turned black and blue ..

I was so excited to get these boots! They fit perfect and after the second time wearing them they were super comfortable....after a week or so one night I took them off and my legs looked bright red, yes I had on socks. After about an hour the imprint of the boot was swollen and itchy. A couple of days later and one leg blistered and was super painful !! It has been weeks and I'm still fighting this reaction to them..had to go to the Doctor and get meds to help clear it up...no boot is worth such pain and misery!!! May look good but I wanna keep my legs looking good

Is probably a great pair of boots, but they are 1/2 size too small and cannot get in touch with the seller to exchange for a larger size. I hate that I purchased something expensive that only had a 30 day window and I am out of luck. Hopefully I will have better luck selling them to someone that they will fit.

I have a wide foot and a high arch. Battle to get my foot in so I can't wear them. They are none the less stunning boots. I'm trying to sell them now

Very small like there are for a small child

The boot looked like it was made for a child. It was very narrow and the toe was much rounder that in the photo. Had to return.

Very unhappy with this boot and when I returned it they refused the return. Now I'm stuck with these smelly boots. Yes, they smell like burnt plastic.

Ordered these hoping they would look like the picture. Instead the tips are round and even though I ordered my size, they're too small. Will end up giving them away. Won't be purchasing again.

I order this product and I got a different one. I needed the boots for a party for Saturday and now I am stuck with a totally different product.

shoes were not as pictured I normally read the reviews but I didn't with these and was VERY disappointed!!!!! AGAIN SHOE does NOT look like picture and they run small