Side by Side Comparison of: UTG vs Umarex
Learn More | |||
Learn More | |||
Rating info | |||
eComparisons Score | |||
eComparisons ScoreThe "Comparison Score" Is calculated based on the average number of times this item was compared with other items in this category by our users | 9 | 0 | 0 |
User Rating (Amazon) | |||
User Rating (Amazon) | |||
Five Star Reviews: | 70% great holster, fits my sdve 9 perfect love that ... February 24, 2017 great holster, fits my sdve 9 perfect love that its got the pouch for the extra mag as well. i like the buckle and really like the quick release snap, i looked at holsters for a while and this one was half the price of anything equivalent. the only down side is that i put a flashlight on the gun and it doesn't fit in the holster with the light on... kind of a drag but not a deal breaker by any means Great quality, simple, affordable! April 25, 2016 I ordered 2 of these. One for my .22 and the other for my husbands 9 MM.Both of our guns fit well in these belt holsters, and they velcro strap keeps it in place really well so it is not moving around in the holster and you do not have to worry about your gun falling out of it.The strap is adjustable, and will adjust to longer gun if need be.I love that there is a place on it for an extra clip, me and my husband always carry 2 clips.The velcro straps that connect the holster to your belt have a really strong hold on them, so we do not have to worry about the velcro coming lose and falling off.This holster was a great price and is really great quality.I highly recommend this belt holster if you are looking for something simple that is not expensive!Pros:-Holds different sized hand guns-Velcro strap to go over gun to hold it in place-Pocket for extra clip-Strong holding velcro to attach holster to belt-Great quality-Great priceCons:-Me and my husband are very happy with this product, We dont have any complaints on it and have been using them daily for almost 2 months. Nice holster November 28, 2015 Really nice holster for the money. I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of and construction of this product. This fit my Sig Sauer P320 compact .45 caliber almost perfectly. Just a note this is not holster for concealed carry, this goes on your belt and makes a pretty bulky rig. Very comfortable to wear but like I said it's very noticeable and not made for concealment. GOOD HOLSTER February 3, 2015 This holster is a perfect fit for a Makarov 9 X 18 pistol! The spare magazine also is a perfect fit.Unusual quality for being China made. Seems like good materials and good workmanship.Lots of Velcro, maybe a little too much, BUT you will NOT lose your weapon if it's in this holster!Looks nice as a set too. I carry left and draw right. The QR buckle is easy to open with my left hand and the draw is smooth. After a few drills I did not notice the pistol hanging on anything. If you are into quick draw look for something else as this procedure takes some time.If you need a good protective holster for for your Mak you have found it. Nice November 26, 2013 I love it for the price I paid, less then ten bucks! Looking at it, as a friend did for example, you would expect at least twenty bucks or more. It fits my SW 40 MP Shield perfectly. The spare clip pouch is a perfect fit for the clip as well. I like how the clip pouch is on the front edge of the holster this seems to make for less bulk. This holster is not a full conceal holster. I can hid it under a heavy jacket in the winter but I did not buy it for that purpose. I use this holster for the purpose of hiking and fishing in the mountains. It keeps the gun out of my way and up tight against my waist. | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
Four Star Reviews: | 18% Good for storage in a range bag March 8, 2017 Decent holster. Not the fastest draw but a sound sheath for your weapon. Good for storage in a range bag. I have a a GAMO PT85 (AIRGUN) and it fits nice. Full size gun. Study construction and added PELLET magazine holder is cool. The button in on the side actually snaps off but the strap seemed to get in the way of any fast drawing. I've worked on using the latch. Seems faster too me. the Velcro strap system is really good. Good buy. Not bad for the price April 26, 2016 I got this for a sccy cpx-1. The holster is well built but what I didn't like about it was it is really hard to get a magazine in the spare mag holder. It did fit, but I had to give it a good push to get it in there, but if you have a single stack mag (mine are double stack), it should go in without a problem. Also, the strap that holds it onto your belt is shewn on the top and then has velcro down the back and a retention strap at the bottom. I was not expecting that and thought it was weird, but I think it will work just fine. Considering the price, I am happy with it. pleased overall, nice holster December 5, 2015 Not a bad holster at all. Can be put on without taking off one's belt; feels secure, material is sturdy. The retention strap is a "buckle" style (which I like, requires two fingers to unsnap and is likely more secure than a button), though there is a button on the bottom that can be unbuttoned (for better or worse) if one wishes (I actually sowed the material around the button to the holster itself, for maximum retention). The extra mag holster is nice, though snug for double stack mags (definitely fine for single stack 1911 mags). Fits all of my compact pistols very well. I am very pleased overall. Very well made for the price April 21, 2015 Very well made for the price. As far as size. i tried it with all of my pistols. sig P238, holster is too large. M&P Shield 9MM it will work with about an inch of extra barrel length left in the holster. Ruger SR9C is a perfect fit, as well as the SR22. Magazine holder is also suitable for a double stack more than a single stack but would secure either. I would use this for a range holster or if i wanted to carry my SR9C with a jacket on, its just a bit on the bulky side for summer time carry. And my impression is that this is not designed for a quick draw or anything due to the nature of the strap and clip. I would use this for instance if i was camping out and about in the woods if there was a possibility of coyote or something that i wanted to have a larger sized or caliber gun on me. But i think for my summer time carry I'd still go with an IWB for the P238 or Shield 9MM or a much smaller OWB that allowed for a quicker unholstering of the gun Great Quality, but mag pouch too tight. October 24, 2014 Great quality. After smooshing it around getting out the stiffness, it fit a Glock 26 (ultra compact semiauto 9mm) and a Chiappa 200DS snubby compact .357 revolver nicely, but snugly.Bad news is, the spare magazine pouch on top will not fit the G26 mag. It looks like it would tightly fit the WIDTH of the mag - the left to right dimension of the mag as you hold the firearm with the mag in it - if it could get in there; but it is too tight to fit the front-to-back dimension of the mag. If your familiar with these types of holsters with the spare mag pouch on top, you'll know what I'm talking about.The mag pouch also tapers to tightly so I don't know how far into the pouch it would go even if it did fit it.I got two of these and the story is the same with both.So because of the front/back dimension of mags being related to the cartridge length, it wouldn't fit a .22LR or .380 mag since they're on par with the 9mm length.At least that's my assumption.So great quality, but bad on the spare mag pouch. UTG Deluxe Commando Belt Holster - Good for Open Carry December 2, 2011 Great light-weight holster with mag pouch.Bought this originally for a Smith & Wesson M&P BB Pistol Black Finish Semi-Auto CO2 Md: 2255050 and a Crosman Under The Barrel Laser Sight fits 1? Weaver® rails.. The Magazine Pouch will hold two Crosman 2 Pk Spare Clips for C11, C21 and C31 BB Air Pistols. Fully adjustable strap with snap and quick release buckle. Will fit any belt width with hook & loop system.Found out it will also hold a full-size M&P .40 with an extra mag. For awhile I had mounted a Tactical Pistol Red Laser Sight w/Rail. Eventually, I ended up with a different holster and no laser, because the weight started to stress the double stitched seam. Besides, the laser just wasn't what I expected either.Bottom Line - This is great for Airsoft, Pellet or BB, but not as a permanent solution to a full-size handgun. Can't beat the price. | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
Three Star Reviews: | 8% ... grand sons BB gun fit in it so all good there. August 3, 2017 my grand sons BB gun fit in it so all good there. Gun fits good, but the magazine would not fit in a ... October 18, 2016 Got it for a full sized 9mm Smith and Wesson. Gun fits good, but the magazine would not fit in a million years. Might be good to put a few latex gloves in. Practical and functional. February 10, 2015 Very sturdy and lightweight.It.s a little big for my Beretta 380 but I can still get the pistol in and out easily enough.I would never want to be caught in a true need for rapid action.The hold down strap is not east to unlatch or unsnap .Maybe with more use it would work easier but I also feel secure that the gun isn't go to jump out of the holster if I was running..It is a good holster for the money. Airsoft quality, but depends on what youre using it for September 2, 2014 I do not own this, I bought it for my father in law that just wanted something really cheap to keep his 1911 in in the closet. he likes it because it holds the gun amd a mag just fine. I wouldn't use this in any REAL use, other than maybe just wearing it at a shooting range, or keeping a gun in it in the closet. It is a very airsoft-like quality holster, but for 10 bucks? heck ya. works well October 21, 2013 I like the holster but for a few things....the velcro strap that you pass your belt through is hard to get your belt through! You have to completely pull the velcro apart to place the holster onto your belt. However once on your belt its secure! Another problem is the velcro rubs against the belt damaging the finish. A problem if you wear it on a leather belt. Lastly the adjustable strap that holds the weapon in the holster slips. All these are easy fixes. Otherwise it would be 5 stars. OK general medium duty holster February 14, 2012 Not suitable for conceal-carry, at least not for a bigger gun. I'm using a .45 compact Colt Officers and like all belt holsters it's too bulky of a package to conceal. Maybe a smaller version is more concealable. Furthermore, I'm finding a separate belt is needed as this one pulls down too hard on my pants belt. So for me, this holster will be used on the gun range and for open carry around my property. My gun sits rather deep in this holster just as the picture of it shows. This makes it a very secure hold. On the positive side it is lightweight yet stays open without the gun. The retention clip releases easily and the draw is smooth. Carrying a SA 'cocked & locked' works fine. It has a nice pouch for one magazine and the price is good. On the negative side, two things: The retention strap is attached inside the holster which prevents returning the gun with one hand (pushes the strap down inside with the gun). Also the plastic clip on the retention strap cannot be closed easily with one hand making this a two-handed holster in the return functionality. | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
Two Star Reviews: | 2% Too small September 4, 2017 Very small, Barely holds a sig 2202 9mm and the clip compartment will not close with 9mm clips. Won't hold Glock or Springfield 40s. Nice but not for me January 5, 2016 this just didnt work for me. not saying it wouldnt work for anyone else but in searching for just the right holster, this one just wasnt comfy. i returned it with no hassles. i did like the spare mag holder in the front but the rest of it was just not comfy. Retention strap is crap. Difficult to undo plastic clip in a hurry September 22, 2015 Retention strap is crap. Difficult to undo plastic clip in a hurry. It also has a snap that would be faster but it doesn't have a pull tab to grab onto. Also, the the other end of the retention retention strap is attached to the INSIDE of the holster and gets in the way of the draw and re-holster. Could get caught in the trigger. BAD! Another thing is the belt "loop". It is a large velcro strap that must be completely opened to put onto belt. It's secure but a hassle. Finally the mag holder is way too small for double stack mags. It's tight on my single stack mags. OK as range holster and will fit a my Ruger SR9 as well as MY CZ 75B and some others but I tuck the retention strap into the mag pouch to keep it out of the way. Would not buy again. build quality is pool, not much ergonomic features built ... February 13, 2015 build quality is pool, not much ergonomic features built into it.My CZ can fit ok, but there is no way I can quickly unbutton it in an emergency situation. Not very well made October 15, 2014 The holster itself seemed ok, but the belt clip is Velcro'd on and the Velcro is sewn into the holster so not 45 min into wearing it the clip ripped off. Since that is the whole point of having a belt holster, it didn't really do it's job. Fortunatly I'm a pretty good imaginer, and was able to make my own plastic belt clip that is made into the holster. I probably wouldn't recoomend this to anyone just because it tore up so quickly and easily. OK but not for quick release November 28, 2011 The holster is a bit clumsy to use, hard to extract weapon and tentative in it's carry security. However, it does contain, protect and present the pistol and with patient adjustment and fit you'll make it work. Really presents a case for taking your pistol to a gun shop and trying the holsters up close and personal. | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
One Star Reviews: | 2% Don't waste your time or money June 11, 2017 Don't waste your money, even if it is only 9 bucks. The belt that holds the gun in position will not stay secure in the belt holder that it loops around, not the clasp itself. You can snap it in, then push the belt completely loose with your finger. Also, the magazine holder does not even hold a small single cartridge. Button broke first time using September 16, 2016 Got this today, put my pistol in it for the first time, went to tighten the strap and the button broke. Disappointing. Not recommended!!! Produced visible scratches on new Glock 43! January 21, 2016 Not recommended!!! There is an exposed metal rivet inside the holster that holds on the belt loop. I did not notice the exposed rivet until I noticed scratches on the slide of the brand new pistol, after holstering. I supposed the rivet could be covered in some way to protect the finish, but knowing that beforehand would have saved me from dealing with the scratches. One Star September 19, 2014 Deployed to Afghanistan with this. It started to unravel within a week. Not worth the money. Useless Gun holster November 8, 2013 As soon as i put this holster on my belt is was a failure from the start. It dropped by gun on the ground, i failed the pull test, the Velcro failed after two days of used. This holster is a complete waste of time and money. DONT BUY IT. | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
Vote for Me | Vote for Me | Vote for Me | |
Pricing info | |||
Old Price | |||
Old Price | - | - | - |
Price | |||
Price | $9.00updated: Mar 18, 2020 | $12.95updated: Mar 18, 2020 | $15.99updated: Mar 17, 2020 |
Features | |||
Answered Questions | |||
Answered Questions | - | - | |
Article Number | |||
Article Number | 4712274521841 | 4712274521964 | 0723364535178 |
Binding | |||
Binding | Sports | - | - |
Brand | |||
Brand | UTG | UTG | Umarex |
Color | |||
Color | Black | Black | - |
Currency | |||
Currency | USD | USD | USD |
Department | |||
Department | 211 | unisex-adult | - |
Formatted Price | |||
Formatted Price | $10.65 | - | - |
Height | |||
Height | 39.4 in | 61.8 in | 315.0 in |
Label | |||
Label | - | UTG | Umarex |
Length | |||
Length | 255.9 in | 433.9 in | 19.7 in |
Manufacturer | |||
Manufacturer | UTG | UTG | Umarex |
Model | |||
Model | PVC-H270B | PVC-H288B | 2253517 |
MPN | |||
MPN | PVC-H270B | PVC-H288B | 2253517 |
Number of Items | |||
Number of Items | 1 | - | - |
Number of Parts | |||
Number of Parts | PVC-H270B | PVC-H288B | 2253517 |
Product Group | |||
Product Group | Sports | Sports | Sports |
Product Type | |||
Product Type | SPORTING_GOODS | SPORTING_GOODS | SPORTING_GOODS |
Publisher | |||
Publisher | UTG | UTG | Umarex |
Quantity | |||
Quantity | 1 | 1 | 1 |
Release Date | |||
Release Date | 2009-10-14 | 2009-10-14 | - |
Reviews | |||
Reviews | - | - | |
Score | |||
Score | 9 | - | - |
SKU | |||
SKU | PY-A-637 | - | 62619 |
Studio | |||
Studio | UTG | UTG | Umarex |
Title | |||
Title | - | UTG LE Grade Ambidextrous Belt Holster, Black | Beretta Elite II, S&W M&P & Crosman C11 BB Mag, 19-Shot Stick, 2/Pack |
Weight | |||
Weight | 0.9 oz | 0.2 oz | 1.4 oz |
Width | |||
Width | 157.5 in | 232.7 in | 157.5 in |
Feature | |||
Feature | TACTICAL GEAR, HOLSTERS, MAGAZINE POUCHES | Premium Synthetic Material, Law Enforcement Quality Velcro and Snap-on Systems Great Padding to Secure and Protect Pistols, Fully Adjustable Double Secured Thumb Break with Rust-proof and Wear-proof Snap Clever Double Sided Adjustable Belt Loops and Reversible Thumb Break Systems for Ambidextrous Use Offers Excellent Security As Well As Unobstructed Quick-draw and Re-holster of Pistol Extra Spare Magazine Pouch with Velcro Retaining Strap, Universal Design to Fit Most Pistols | MAGAZINES, CLIPS & RELOADERS |
UTG Deluxe Commando Belt Holster
Uncle Mike's Nylon Open Top...
AlphaHolster Belly Band Hand Gun...
UTG Concealed Belt Holster (Black)
Fobus Standard Holster RH Paddle...
BLACKHAWK! Serpa CQC Carbon...
Generic Tactical Cross Draw...
UTG Elite Tactical Leg...
UTG Deluxe Universal Horizontal...
Condor Tornado Tactical Leg...