Side by Side Comparison of: Roper vs Justin Boots

great boots

Husband loves these boots, light in weight but still durable.

I rated these as somewhat large but I intentionally bought a half size up for a reason as I have wide feet. These are so perfect. I love these. Almost no break in needed. I have had boots that are super stiff but these are great. Comfy, stylish, and will go with just about anything. Fantastic purchase. Shipping was wicked fast too.

great fit and comfy

These the the greatest boots I've ever owned! I get A LOT of compliments on them. They're my dress boots and my casual boots. Comfortable all day long and for long rides on the motorcycle. Get them, you won't be disappointed!

Awesome love my boots and the price was excellent you can't ask for more just very happy with my new boots

Love the boots, look even better than the picture, lots of character within the leather

Very good for the price, especially the Bent Rail which features a boot that has a weathered leather so it is going to be softer on the foot and not so hard to break ... the crease on boots is typically very hard on the top of your foot until they are broken in whereas a weathered leather tends to be easier on the foot where the natural boot crease occurs.

Very happy with these boots and even happier with the price ($95.00...ever since then the lowest I've seen is just under $200.00). Some have mentioned they seem to run wide. Seemed that way to me too at first, but I soon realized (1) All the rest of my boots that I have wore for the last 15 years are all now a size to small and are pointed, so they naturally felt tight, and (2) I wore these with a thin boot sock. After switching to a nice padded boot sock, they snug up fine. Great boot and a great shipper and super price. I'll be in the market for another if any of them once again dip below $100 in a size 15.

I'm not a cowboy, but I really wish i had purchased these boot many years ago. I love the way the feel and look. I constantly get compliments from people about how cool they look. The feel just like slippers and the worn texture makes me feel free to do anything without feel of scuffing or scratching these fine boots.I will say that I normally wear a size 10 or 10.5 in most shoes. I ordered the size 10 and they did fit with fairly thick socks for the first few weeks. After they stretched out some they are a bit loose. It's not a major problem but they do sometimes allow my foot to slide up and then I need to tap my heel to reseat the boot. I am planning on soaking the boots and wearing them wet for a day to allow them to tighten up. I hope this corrects the issue.

At first, I was a bit worried about how it would be after ordering. As soon as it arrived, all my concerns with the boots were gone. It's true to the picture, and fits well. The Leather, with first initial look, is a bit more polished then what the picture leads, but once worn some and broken in, that should be no problem.1. Fits well2. Looks great3. 100% Leather4. Comfortable5. No sign of damage through shippingAfter about 3 weeks of wear, I'll come back with an update to this review.Edit: The boots are great. Plain and simple, no wear/tear after breaking them in. Just overall a great quality pair of boots.

I have tried boots for YEARS and not have any fit as well as the Bent Rail brand from Justin! Comfortable the first time you put them on. No break in period. Amazon did a wonderful job of handling my order from beginning to end.

i like these boots but if you are looking for a boot with a more durable, harder leather, these aren't for you. they are very comfortable but kind of flimsy. all in all good boots but i question how long they will last

Bought for my son and he likes them.

Giving it a 4 star. One boot fit but the other was to tight, returned item.

Pretty good boots.. My shipment was delayed due to bad snow in my area i choose two shipping the second day i got the notification saying it had been delayed woke up the next day they was laying on my front pronch. Very nice boots!

Most comfortable boots I have owned. I recommend these boots especially because of the cost. The size was somewhat larger than expected.

My husband LOVED these boots. He liked that the top of the boot was flexible and did not rub against his leg. Would buy another pair of these Ropers.

There was a yellowish waxy substance on one of them. Not sure if it was just some excess coating that didn't get rubbed of or what, but they were a slightly different color due to this substance. Fit good and were pretty comfortable. Overall I liked them.

I have flat feet and boots aren't design for that. The boot itself is great and looks good. I get the wide size to allow for an arch support insole.

First got the boots and tried them on and only concern was the left one felt a lil bigger. Not a full or half size bigger but just a touch larger then the right boot did. Once I wore them out and around that concern went away because I barely noticed. I can tell u that the boots fit on the larger side so if ur a sz 9 shoe or work boot I would go with a sz 8.5. Great boots though love the look love the style can't wait to buy another pair!

These boots look good and get lots of positive compliments. That was surprising as I have nicer and more expensive boots that no one seems to pay any attention to. These are seriously like wearing comfortable slippers. I am not a big fan of the floppy shaft though. This is my first pair made that way and will be my last. They do also tend to widen out at the balls of my feet. Perhaps the leather is a bit thinner for comfort and pliability, which these have plenty of. The leather sole is wearing very well. These boots get worn at least 4 days per week.

I love the boots. There were only two issues I found. I wear a size 11D and often find the EE are too wide. With this boot the size 11D was somewhat narrow although over time I feel the leather will break in and stretch enough. The leather is very soft compared to a pair of Durango boots I wear daily. This boot is a little larger and rides up on my heel when walking. To fix this I inserted a Dr. Shouls insert and the boots fit much better. I am afraid a 10.5D would have been too small.

It always amazes me that people will buy western wear that is made in China! What do the Chinese know about western wear? My cowboy hats off to Justin for making at least some of their products in the USA! These boots are stylish and appear to be well made. Currently they are tight fitting but, I am hoping they will stretch as I wear them more. I recently purchased a pair of Tony Lama square toe boots and they are very tight fitting and have not stretched. All in all I am very satisfied with Justin's Bent Rail collection and recommend these boots to anyone looking for a stylish pair of boots at a reasonable price. Made in USA!

Fits perfect once you can get your foot in it.real tight trying to put it on

The barrel is too white!

Have another pair in a different color but same size, these fit small. the other pair fit loose.

They are ok boots. Definitely not Ariats or Justins. We will see how well they hold up.

Fits as expected. Looks as advertised.

Nice boots, light weight and very comfortable.. but a little skinnier than I'm used to.

Good boots, just too small

These boots seem to be slim for a square toe boot. Going to try and break them in more to see if they relax.This is an update as it has really been the first time I have been able to wear these.I noticed that these boots shipped without any insoles. I thought it was just me, and didn't notice until I was trying to remove the insole to put my race runner one, and realized there was nothing there. As I was going to replace it it isn't a big deal, I was just under the assumption these were brand new and that makes me think, they weren't as new as believed when ordered and arrived.

The fit is small.

Good boots, but wider than expected

Was going to retrun it, but I can work with it.....

the insoles need padding badly, and they aren't as shiny as the pics, but they are sturdy and good stuff.

The opening is too small, my feet can't seem to get in

Boots where on the large side but nice

Less than one month since I actually began wraring these and the upper is already seperating from the sole. I only wear these as casual shoes and would have expected them to hold up better than this. Very disappointed in this product. Gave it two stars because I think the boots look great, but are made poorly.

1 month and torn apart

Read my other review on Roper's boots

Cheap quality and fits way larger than most.

I purchased these boots as a gift for my husband for his birthday. The boots are beautiful and good quality but even though i purchased wide they were still too narrow for his foot.

These are Women's boots. The shopping page shows Mens boots, and if you don't pay close attention you will not see that the actual item description is womens boots

One shoe was smaller than the other. Sent back

They run big and the square toe is pretty large.

Not very sturdy or supportive

For the cost of these boots and to have the Justin brand I expected better quality. Just felt cheap at the way around and did not fit well at all. Not what I'm accustomed to with Justin boots.

These suck didn't even last me a month waste of money

Worst boots ever, I'm so disappointed

I bought these for my son. He wore them for 3 weeks and the sole ripped off of them.

Boots came apart at the toes where the leather attaches to the soul. Very disappointed. Have never had that problem before.

The right boot was prefect but the left boot was made so narrow that my foot wouldn't go in at all. My wife put both boots on and said that the left boot was made differently.

The quality sucks had them a month and there falling apart peeling horrible quality would never spend that money on Those again

Love the way the boots looked but they were like 1-1/2" too long and don't come in a smaller size. Love the width too, but too long. How can I return these for a shorter double wide short distressed leather boot?

Ok, I ordered a pair of Justin boots a year ago and loved them..With that said, I "tried" ordering this pair of boots a month ago.. 1st time I received them they had some kind of glue all over them.. So, sent them back to get another pair. 2nd time I get them and its like all the brown has been polished off! Terrible! So...Waiting on my refund..

Don't buy these unless you know the exact size that will fit. They were too big and I couldn't exchange them. They also do not come with insoles.

The boot itself is a short boot? they are nice but tend to have your pant leg catch on the shorter boot.

The boots were too big and dont fit right

will return these books - I wore them around the house for several hours 3 days in a row, and they just are not comfortable. Arch support is lacking.