Side by Side Comparison of: Wilton vs Cake Boss
Learn More | ||
Learn More | ||
Rating info | ||
eComparisons Score | ||
eComparisons ScoreThe "Comparison Score" Is calculated based on the average number of times this item was compared with other items in this category by our users | 9.4 | 9.4 |
User Rating (Amazon) | ||
User Rating (Amazon) | ||
Five Star Reviews: | 84% definitely recommend September 25, 2017 These are perfect for making tiered cakes. The cake did stick to the bottom so they aren't nonstick. They can be stored inside each other. There was some confusion as to if the sides of the pan were straight up and down or slanted, they are slanted slightly, but it is so minimal you don't need to cut the sides of the came in order to have it stack properly. I plan on using these for a long time as well as planning on buying more so I can make a rainbow cake for my nieces birthday. Five Stars December 21, 2016 These were perfect for making my first non-sheet birthday cake! They baked evenly and held up well. Nice product. Great Cake Pans! June 11, 2015 Light colored (not Teflon), so you don't have to adjust the heat level. Great cooking pans for cakes, and especially for home baked rolls! Very slight taper from inside bottom to inside top. Pans have lips on two sides for assistance in removing from oven. Rimmed all around top edge for strength. Baked items slide right out of non-stick pans. Highly recommended! You get two pans for about the price of one. Good company and good product April 23, 2015 I had a pair of old Faberware round pans that needed to be replaced. I already had new cookie sheets from Wilton so I had an idea of what I was buying beforehand. They're so nice, it seems like I don't even need to coat them in cooking spray before use. I also have cookie sheets from Wilton so I knew the quality beforehand. When looking at other round pans on Amazon, one thing you may want to note is that these have handles and some others do not. Great cake pans November 17, 2014 I used these pans to make my first ever 3-layer cake and it turned out wonderfully. These pans are non-stick and easy to clean, and the cakes came out perfect and ready to stack and ice! I bought them because it was cheaper than buying two separate ones but I can't imagine more expensive ones being any better. Great pans October 8, 2014 Cakes bake perfectly, I can take one out and let it cool, then frost the top of it, and THEN take the other layer out of the pan and put it on top. Other pan sets I've owned don't work that way, the cake will stick to the pan if left in too long. | 83% Good quality September 23, 2017 I purchase these pans for my cake business and the first time I use them my cakes came out a little darker than I wanted them to, but I know just to check them a little bit earlier. Other than that they're really nice quality pans. Awesome pans! July 24, 2017 Love these pans. You don't need to spray them at all. I made cinnamon rolls for a 3 tiered cinnamon roll cake for a wedding shower and they cam out of the pan perfectly. The pans are heavy and easy to clean. Love these. June 12, 2017 Heavy duty and solid. Love these...can't wait to bake my granddaughter's 2nd birthday cake this weekend. They are hand wash only which is a bit of a bummer but maybe that's why all my other ones don't last very long. Would of liked them a bit higher maybe 3" or 4" but they came as described. like some other pans June 5, 2017 I'm considering buying a second set! I'm an avid at home baker. I've never had an issue with a cake sticking to these - I don't even need to use parchment paper. Cakes bake evenly through, with little 'crust' on the outside, like some other pans. Something else I've noticed is that cakes bake very level in these pans. The pans are heavy and would be very hard to dent. Hold up well in dishwasher as well, but hand washing them is super easy. Definitely recommend! In love May 4, 2017 Pans cook evenly, hold up to dishwasher, if another style I don't have become a available I'll get those too. It's Cake Boss April 3, 2017 ...So your expectations should be high. And they will be well-met with a brilliantly thick coat of nonstick, a charmingly quilted base mold, heavy duty walls cut at nice, sharp angles... they feel out-of-placedly professional among my other tools. Look no further. This will make great bakes.*Deep cleaning may require toothpicks* |
Four Star Reviews: | 8% ... more shallow than I expected but they did a good job. The cake did not stick and I ... March 13, 2017 These pans were a bit more shallow than I expected but they did a good job. The cake did not stick and I was very pleased with the results. Great pans. March 13, 2017 Great pans. . .easy to remove the cakes once they come out of the oven. Any baker would love to add these to their supplies. Good Quality but hard to get cake out June 22, 2016 Great pans, but it's a bit hard to get the cakes out. I mostly make box-cakes, not homemade. Make sure you coat the pan really well! Otherwise, they are very easy to clean. To help the cake come out, I just warmed up the pans on my stove. Good for the Price August 9, 2015 I ordered these pans to bake a layered cake. Although they didn't stick and it was did help speeding up the baking process (both cakes were ready in 15 minutes), the pans stained after the first use. I know this shouldn't be an issue, but I was expecting that to happen after several uses. Great deal May 14, 2014 These pans are a great deal -- two for about ten dollars, it can't be beat. I have two already but want to make a three-layer cake next week, so, ordered another set.I don't know if this is a function of the pans or me just getting something stuck, but ever since I made cinnamon rolls in one of these pans, I can't get the marks left behind off. I mean, they're still usable, and they were only $10, so it's a minor quibble.Overall, I like these cake pans a lot and get good results. | 9% This is a great little pan set August 27, 2017 This is a great little pan set. The non-stick coating is good quality, it washes well, it heats well and cooks evenly. I gave it four stars because the logo in then bottom of the pan transfers to the cake. I know most people aren't inspecting the bottom of my cakes, but if they did, I don't necessarily want to be a walking advertisement for the Cake Boss (I prefer to have a choice in these matters). All in all, it's a decent set. Good pans! Good price! December 9, 2016 Great pans! Definitely non stick and easy to wash. Cake released from the pans no problem. The bottom of the pan is honeycomb but icing will cover the pattern. I didn't expect them to be so heavy but they are thick and heavy. Unfortunately not as deep as I would like it, so I would recommend making two of ... February 26, 2016 Pans are heavy duty! Unfortunately not as deep as I would like it, so I would recommend making two of the same size and stacking it, in order to make a nice, presentable cake. But other than that, the material definitely feels like it's for serious bakers (not that I am one, but it makes me feel like one). Good quality, but does NOT have completely straight sides. February 11, 2016 Pans are good heavy quality. Definitely better made than the Wilton pans. However, I was thinking the sides of the pan were true straight sides, but thats not the case. They top does flare out a big which makes it hard to stack up the cakes and have them even. Any cake baker knows, this is not good! I really like these pans December 10, 2014 I really like these pans. My only issue (which is not a big issue at all) is that the pattern on the pans makes marks on whatever you make. I don't have a big problem with this because I just iced the cake and it was perfectly fine. |
Three Star Reviews: | 3% Well-made but pans don't stack exactly on top of each other. July 31, 2017 Decent pans. They're well-made and I've baked cakes in these many times. No chipping and truly non-stick. The 3-star is because the pans aren't straight, they're slanted so when you're stacking and icing these, you have to do a lot of decorating to make it look straight. There are better pans out there that actually stack exactly on top of each other. Why would one make cake pans curved? It's not a huge deal but I would have purchased a different set if I had known. Seem very sturdy and good quality March 27, 2017 Seem very sturdy and good quality, but I hate that the edges are slanted. Cake pan edges should be straight :/ Three Stars April 14, 2016 like the pans for their non-stick use. Not deep enough. Cake comes to far to the top. a little small on the inside diameter, not quite 8 inches December 31, 2015 not quite 8 inches on the interior diameter, so if you are using precut pan liners made for 8 inch pans it won't work. Not great if you yse baking strips February 23, 2015 These are fine. Really. They clean well. The non-stick is good. The only reason I don't like them is because the sides are slightly angled. I've been toying with the baking strips (you wet them and place them around the sides of the pan with a velcro fastener). The strips don't stay on these pans because of the angle. I finally purchased new pans that are not angled. Other than that, these pans are very good. Sides are not straight February 7, 2015 After reading many reviews, it seemed that most reviews specified that the sides of these pans were good for layering cakes and some said the sides were graduated. The pans that I received did in fact have graduated sides, which will not suit my purpose and I will therefore return them. However, not having baked with them, they did appear to be of okay quality for the price. | 4% Started out great but.... May 24, 2017 First time using the pan every cake came out perfectly. Did what the instructions said about cleaning them. Use them a second time, every single cake stuck to the bottom of the pans. You can get better pans for less April 21, 2015 It's okay. You can get better pans for less. Pros: Bakes evenly, is heavy and does not warp. Cons: The sides are not straight, the pan has his logo in the bottom so it may be imprinted on delicate cakes. All in all, not a bad buy but not for professional bakers who need straight sides. (Ignore the branding "Professional Nonstick", though it is pretty good in the non-stick department. |
Two Star Reviews: | 2% Should be considered disposable March 19, 2017 Like most non-stick coated pans they immediately scratch and then rust after a single use.If you're planning to use these for a single cake and then throw them away they might be fine, but if you're planning to use them more than once, don't buy them.The non-stick coating will come off during use and you'll be eating rust and non-stick coating.My personal opinion: Cookware should not be made of any material that rusts and should not be coated with any material that can come off in your food. good but SLANTED July 10, 2016 The product arrived quickly. Has good quality and I did not experienced the issues other customers had with the cake sticking to the pan. to the contrary - I barely had to use a non-stick spray or something of that nature. HOWEVER, they ARE slanted: the top is 9in but the bottom is only 8.25 in. If you bought them for laying cakes like I did be prepared to be frustrated. you can still use it and fix the gap with icing, but that's pretty annoying. NOT 9 inches across June 3, 2014 I know this because I also bought the 9" parchment paper rounds to use with these pans and they overlap by about half an inch all the way around. Very annoying. 9" should mean 9" at the bottom and at the top. These are not ideal for making layer cakes because the cakes do not come out even. They are quite nonstick, however. Quality okay July 7, 2013 I didn't realize the pans were not 'straight' but graduated. The graduation was too much to be usable for cake decorating so they sit unused while I purchased other pans with straight sides. The quality was okay. If you are not decorating your cakes, it will serve your purpose fine. If you are a cake decorator - look for straight, not graduated sides.. | 1% Kind of a one time use, after that? March 12, 2017 Kind of a one time use, after that? No amount of flower going to keep this cake pan from sticking These pans are a good weight and don't buckle while baking November 14, 2016 These pans are a good weight and don't buckle while baking. However, I noticed despite the greasing and flouring, batter stuck to them and they have a strange grid in the center. Make sure you use parchment paper. Also, they are very, very difficult to clean. The seams in the corners trap batter and you have to use a toothpick to get them clean.I wouldn't recommend them. These are high quality pans, however, do NOT ... July 9, 2014 These are high quality pans, however, do NOT believe that they cook your cake evenly and make it cook more leveled. I cooked one 8" cake in this pan and one 8" cake in a "cheapie" pan, side by side, and they looked and were cooked IDENTICAL. |
One Star Reviews: | 3% Slanted sides May 7, 2017 Returning because the sides are slanted. Posted a pic next to my other 6 inch cake pans to compare. I do not think these will work to stack cake layers without shaving the sides. Non stick surprise February 29, 2016 I haven't baked in thr pans yet. My only disappointment now is 4hat theu ate non-stick pans and i didnt want that. I dont remember that being stated in their discrption. Not true 9 inch round pans. June 17, 2015 Not really 9 in, I have 9 in pans that are 9 in. It's fine, nothing wrong with the pans, but if you need true 9 in pans as I did, bottom measures 8 1/4, top measures 9 in. So when you stack layers, just an fyi, not quite 9 in. Wilton not 9 inch p[ans October 2, 2013 the pans i got were 8 inch pans not the 9 inch pans i bought and paid forBEWARE this seller I HATE THESE PANS AND THREW THEM AWAY! June 22, 2013 I bake a lot - for both my family, and church potlucks (fund raisers, etc.) I got these pans to replace a set I'd used for 15 years (or longer).The first time I used my new pans, they were terrific! I hand washed and dried, then stored them with a paper towel in between to prevent damage.The SECOND time, the entire bottom of the cake stuck and had to be soaked off. .The THIRD time, I added EXTRA oil and flour to the bottom and sides of the pans. The cake STILL STUCK! This time, my donation to a fundraiser had to quickly be swapped out for store bought cupcakes.I thought 'Wilton' was a reputable brand - it's been around a long time. Unfortunately for me, it does not live up to what I'd expected from "professional grade" baking pans. | 3% These are NOT SQUARE! June 30, 2017 Was looking for a SQUARE pan set for a wedding cake. These are not SQUARE so I really feel this item is mislabeled. I am not a professional baker but, when advertised as SQUARE I do expect SQUARE. Sides are tapered and cakes burn easily April 29, 2016 If I could give a zero I would. I do not like these pans at all. Was looking for a straight sided square pan when I purchased these. The photos looked promising but when they arrived they were tapered just like all the others. My question is: why would you make a square pan with tapered edges? It is impossible to create a double layer without trimming each side which gives me more labor when I'm pricing my cakes plus unnecessary waste. Please someone come up with a reasonable solution!Also the pans burn if you aren't super careful. I had to adjust all of my bake temperatures and times just to bake in these pans. Would not recommend them to anyone and wish I hadn't used them and kept the packaging so I could send them back. Worst purchase ever. Crooked Cakes July 3, 2015 These pans are not good if you are making a stacked cake. The side are slanted so your cake will be crooked on the sides. I do not recommend these pans. These are not for professional bakers looking to make tiered ... January 22, 2015 These are not for professional bakers looking to make tiered cakes. The sides are sloped and it is only about 1.5" tall...maybe 2". You would have to make 3 cakes of each tier in order to stack and even then it would be difficult to crumb coat because of the slopes. Returning these ASAP. sides are sloped August 11, 2014 The sides of these cake pans are not straight. They are sloped. They are not for professional bakers. |
Vote for Me | Vote for Me | |
Pricing info | ||
Old Price | ||
Old Price | - | - |
Price | ||
Price | $12.49updated: Mar 18, 2020 | $47.36updated: Mar 18, 2020 |
Features | ||
Answered Questions | ||
Answered Questions | ||
Article Number | ||
Article Number | 0070896590855 | 0051153594267 |
Binding | ||
Binding | Kitchen | Kitchen |
Brand | ||
Brand | Wilton | Cake Boss |
Color | ||
Color | As Shown | Silver |
Currency | ||
Currency | USD | USD |
Formatted Price | ||
Formatted Price | $9.99 | $80.00 |
Height | ||
Height | 59.1 in | 80.7 in |
Length | ||
Length | 423.2 in | 416.5 in |
Manufacturer | ||
Manufacturer | Wilton | Meyer |
Model | ||
Model | 2105-985 | 59426 |
MPN | ||
MPN | 2105-985 | WIR-168 |
Name | ||
Name | English | - |
Number of Items | ||
Number of Items | - | 1 |
Number of Parts | ||
Number of Parts | 2105-985 | WIR-168 |
Product Group | ||
Product Group | Kitchen | Kitchen |
Product Type | ||
Product Type | KITCHEN | KITCHEN |
Publisher | ||
Publisher | Wilton | Meyer |
Quantity | ||
Quantity | 1 | 1 |
Reviews | ||
Reviews | ||
Score | ||
Score | 9.4 | 9.2 |
Size | ||
Size | 9 Inch Pack of 2 | Round |
Studio | ||
Studio | Wilton | Meyer |
Warranty | ||
Warranty | 5 year warranty | - |
Weight | ||
Weight | - | 11.1 oz |
Width | ||
Width | 393.7 in | 416.5 in |
Feature | ||
Feature | 2 pieces, each 9 inch round Heavy-gauge construction provides even-heating performance Pan dimensions embossed on handles Easy to clean Won't stick | Set includes: 6, 8 and 10-Inch Round Cake Pans The round cake pan set features durable, folded aluminized steel construction and wire-reinforced rolled rims to provide strength and stability The round cake pans' quilted surfaces resist wear and promote even heat distribution and beautiful browning Nonstick interior releases baked goods with ease and makes cleanup quick; oven safe to 450 degrees Fahrenheit Cake Boss Professional Bakeware works great with other items from all the Cake Boss collections |
Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware Set,...
OvenStuff Non-Stick 9 Inch Round...
Cake Boss Professional Nonstick...
Wilton Recipe Right 2 Piece 9...
Wilton 2105-2174 Mini Springform...
Wilton Performance Cake Pans...
Wilton 2105-0112 Easy Layers!...
Wilton 409-7716 Angled Icing...
Wilton Recipe Right 13 x 9...
Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware Set,...