2 items
Compare
Compare
All Features
Differing
BellemainSee Similar
Bellemain 4 Piece Airtight Acrylic Canister Set , Food Storage Container - Bellemain
RubbermaidSee Similar
Rubbermaid 1857418 20-Piece Premier Food Storage Container Set, Red - Rubbermaid

Side by Side Comparison of: Bellemain vs Rubbermaid

Learn More
All Features
Differing
Learn More
Add to Whishlist
See Similar
Bellemain http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/511N0AD-xnL._SL160_.jpg
Bellemain 4 Piece Airtight Acrylic Canister Set , Food Storage Container - Bellemain
Add to Whishlist
See Similar
Rubbermaid http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51HO3nov%2ByL._SL160_.jpg
Rubbermaid 1857418 20-Piece Premier Food Storage Container Set, Red - Rubbermaid
Rating info
eComparisons Score
eComparisons ScoreThe "Comparison Score" Is calculated based on the average number of times this item was compared with other items in this category by our users
9.2
9.2
User Rating (Amazon)
User Rating (Amazon)

Five Star Reviews:

77%
Great for freshness
August 16, 2017
I bought these after we had ants and a moth problem, and so far, after almost a year, even after dropping one, they are doing great keeping the cereals fresh!
Great product
July 28, 2017
Purchased in order to clean up my pantry and it really makes a huge visual difference. They are easy to open but leak proof. Also very easy to clean. I wish the set came with another large canister.
Versatile canister set
June 9, 2017
These containers are great! The plastic canisters are lightweight and fit easily on my kitchen shelves. The range of sizes means I have one appropriate for just about everything. The hinged top and silicon gasket assures a tight fitting closure. Thanks for a great product!
I love these. I had previously bought some individual ones ...
April 12, 2017
I love these. I had previously bought some individual ones at bed, bath and beyond but this set is much cheaper. I stood in front of my pantry trying to decide what to put in them.
works great, fast shipping
March 30, 2017
These are very nice quality and look great in the cabinet. They seem to be completely airtight. Did have to wash because the initial smell was intense. Overall very happy and will probably get some more
Good solid product
March 4, 2017
These canisters are made of tough material and the seal is really good. It's nice to see my pantry organized and with such nice looking canisters and with a psycho cat who knocks everything over, there is n fear of breakage. A++++
78%
Great quality, great size.
May 20, 2016
I LOVE these. I bought this one to go with the full set and they are wonderful. The quality is great, I have microwaved, dishwasher-ed and stored spaghetti sauce in them. So far they have not stained, puckered, bubbled or warped. I also have dropped one or two and no cracks or spills have occurred. I really love these Rubbermaid's! Bonus the color is beautiful too!
... added these to my already preexisting set because I like them so much
October 22, 2015
I added these to my already preexisting set because I like them so much. I like how they always look clean, never the water marks or discoloration that happens with other tupperware sets I have owned. The lid always seals tight and they interlock when being stored. Most things that I put in them rinse out without any scraping or scrubbing, even stuff that seems cooked on comes off easily. I used them daily and have had my last set for 2 years with out any cracks, warping or leaks. The originals all still are holding up great, I just wanted more of them!With this particular 20 piece set, the containers are clear and not with the swirl pattern if that matters to you. Some of the other options from Amazon show the pattern, but this one does not.
Five Stars
March 4, 2015
I love these.
Well worth it, love them.
August 12, 2014
Summary: I love it. They are durable and work as described.Price: I would say the price of these is reasonable for what you get. The smaller containers won't be getting much use, but based on the quality as explained later in the review, the price is decent.Quality: These are built to last. They are very very hard plastic that is much more durable than I expected. The seal is great and I have had no issues with these.Functionality: My girlfriend and I cook fairly often. She doesn't like left-overs but I don't mind it. Before I got these I had a hard time eating left-overs because wrapping them in foil or plastic seemed wasteful and a big pain. These containers solved all of that. I admit I was hesitant to get these because I hate the discoloration that they all seem to get over time, and when they stain they look constantly dirty which ruins my appetite. I am happy to report that as of 7-8 uses I haven't noticed any stains or discoloration. I usually microwave the food in the containers and they clean up very easy.Design: These looks great on the shelf in our pantry. Typical rubbermaid color: red. They look nice in the fridge as well and keep things organized. I hated having a plate wrapped in foil in the fridge. With these I can stack them neatly and they take up very little space.Overall impression: Worth the money if you want to save left-overs, or store things neatly and nicely. This is my first set of storage containers and I am very happy with the quality and price. The smaller containers probably won't get much use, but they are nice to have around just in case (plus they don't take up much space).
Great containers. I have used them for about a ...
August 8, 2014
Great containers. I have used them for about a couple of months now and I haven't saw a single stain even after storing left over spaghetti and other red saucy foods that normally stain. The seals are great to help keep foods fresh.
Rubbermaid premere tint food storage set, 18 pieces
August 1, 2013
I had this previously and I loved it so much I bought another set. I also bought an additional set that is blue I believe its 30 pieces. I also bought the fruit saver which is wonderful keeps food for a long time. I've taken things from the freezer to the microwave to the table and don't have to use any other containers.

Four Star Reviews:

16%
Good So Far
August 1, 2017
I wanted see-through containers and a wide-mouth opening for fitting measuring cups in, so I appreciate those features of these canisters. The acrylic plastic is a bit thin so hopefully they'll remain sturdy and not crack if dropped/banged.
Great looking!
May 8, 2017
The only reason I didn't give them 5 stars is because the largest one doesn't hold a full 5lb of flour. I'm using them for the basic flour, sugar, brown sugar and coconut.
Great for cheap
April 12, 2017
These work great. They are on the light side (acrylic) and feel easily breakable. I haven't had any problems, but then again I don't use these every day. Next time I would buy glass.
Better than I thought.
April 1, 2017
My feelings about this product were mixed because I was looking for glass containers. But I'm glad I ordered them anyway. I like them. They're well made and aren't as heavy as glass so with full content, they're still easy to pick up.
Good for the price
March 15, 2017
These are lightweight ad the seal is ok. I don't know if these are actually airtight, but they are great for storage. I use them for bulk foods that don't have packaging otherwise.
Seems like a nice canister set
January 13, 2016
My first impressions are good: Nice wide diameter canisters, silicone gaskets seem to seal well. Time will tell as to whether the chrome stands up or rusts in a few months. Made in Taiwan, but seems to be of decent quality. Will update this in a few months if any problems occur.
12%
These bowls are a very hard plastic that does not ...
December 5, 2016
These bowls are a very hard plastic that does not stain or discolor at all from use and won't melt in the microwave even when heating greasy items. However, I have experienced problems when attempting to freeze items using the bowls. Because they are already a very hard plastic they can become brittle when freezing and are then prone to cracking.
Best ever Rubbermaid
November 23, 2016
These are my favorite storage containers by far. They have a dual plastic cover, so you can see inside, but still get a good seal. The base is a hard plastic. The downside is that it can break if dropped, but the upside is that it is very stain resistant, unlike previous Rubbermaid containers, and very clear and easy to see through. Overall, I think this is a big improvement, especially since it eliminates the plasticizers used in many containers.
NICE!!!
June 3, 2016
These are very nice and I like them a lot. I got them in the mail very fast, about two days. The colors are nice and they seal great, reducing spills. I have been using them for about three months now and I have dropped them several times and they have not cracked. I also put them in my dish washer and they come out great. I also notice that food does not stain them. Compared to other containers, I have used in the past these are the best. I give for stars and not five because the lids have a groove in them that make it difficult to dry completely. This is awful. You have to really get into that groove with a towel to dry them . Other than that these are great
Great quality, but a few too many crevices
November 19, 2015
My favorite food storage line. Solid build, no microwave burning, stacks well. My only issue is that there's probably more crevices and grooves than needed, so cleaning and drying can be a little more work. This size is probably a bit pricier than I'd prefer, but it's a unique color and sold as a single set. I really dislike the red lids that are usually on sale, silly I know but I'm like a bull with red lol.
Solid alternative to glass
November 17, 2015
Bought these to replace glass ones from Costco that have the rubber seal around the edge. That seal gets moldy over time even with replacing so we wanted to go a different direct. Found these but was slightly skeptical as they are not glass. But after using them for a while now I can safely say these work just as well as glass and don't weight as much. The plastic doesn't retain any odor or color and they snap into each other for easy storage (we live in a small apartment so this is really important to us). The only con we have found, as other reviewers state, is that after washing them and letting them sit to dry, water gets trapped in the lids no matter which way you have it drying. Not a huge deal but you just have to shake it out before you put it away.
I love the Product Line but Premier Purple lid Stain Resistant?... NOT!
September 22, 2014
I love the product and since I wanted to be different, I wanted the Purple. I saw The Premier briefly in Red at a large local retailer and then it disappeared. I did not know who made it or the name of the product, so I was surprised to stumble upon it. The product is supposed to be stain resistant, etc. but they must mean everything except the lid because after one use, storing Spaghetti and Sauce, the purple part of the lid underneath, is stained red, so they don't get a 5. I like the clarity and design on the bottom and hope the durability holds up. The lids stacks easy but does dip down quite a bit which seems to take up some of the storage area. So go large! You can find the Red Premier sets and separate pieces around. They seem to be discontinuing the Purple. The Premier product line is superior to their other regular Flex Seal product found retail but Rubbermaid's, marketing (or lack of marketing of this line) amazes me!I returned their regular (unused) Red Flex and Seal to the place of purchase. I have called Rubbermaid on several occasions trying to find reasonably priced, additional Purple 9 and 14 cup pieces and their customer service department, is totally useless. They don't know what they are doing. I have found the product at other large local retailers in Red and Purple, that Rubbermaid does not even know carry it.

Three Star Reviews:

3%
Three Stars
July 5, 2017
quality is not as good as before, the containers got thinner
Three Stars
April 24, 2017
Fell apart first time I washed them
Good sizes but the plastic seal continues to fall off ...
April 19, 2017
Good sizes but the plastic seal continues to fall off of them therefore not keeping my goods fresh. Cheaper plastic feel then I would have liked. Will not go with this grand next time I need containers for food.
They are not as thick walled as I was expecting and the locking hinges are not as sturdy as I would like
March 10, 2017
I needed to replace a similar container for my coffee and ordered this as you can always find something to put in them. They are not as thick walled as I was expecting and the locking hinges are not as sturdy as I would like. I hand washed them and the 2 smaller ones had the rubber seal cone off-1 of which will not stay in place. I am using those for puppy treats due to a question on the air sealing. These will work for the time being but I anticipate having to replace the coffee one soon.
Decent
December 15, 2016
These work for their intended purpose of storing things, the lining flops off the lids from time to time but it's relatively easy to pop it back on. They're inexpensive and keep bugs out, so they do what I got them to do.
Three Stars
February 10, 2016
Cheaply made at opening buckle.
4%
Rubbermaid 1857418 20 Piece set
November 28, 2016
Not satisfied. Plastic and They leak. Not for liquids. I have the glass ones and they work greatKaren from Kansas
Did not receive the "Premier" set as pictured and described ...
December 7, 2015
Did not receive the "Premier" set as pictured and described. Not a real big deal, but I only got this to match my existing items.
Worth it if bought at a discount.
October 18, 2015
Decent. Don't really have a use for half of the containers. Who needs 3 or 4 teeny tiny containers and only one leftover size container? Kind of a rip off.
good quality not worth the price
February 19, 2015
Looked to be good quality but I definitely didnt believe them to be worth tge price. I bought them for tgeir color as my kitch is purple and zebra however I returned them without using since I felt they were not worth the money.
Eh, they're ok.
February 8, 2015
I bought these so that I could batch cook and store for work lunches. Basically, they're ok.1. The purple lids are weird. They stain with tomato sauce, which one would think would not be a 'feature' of this particular set. Also, the lids don't fit nicely under the containers (say, if you microwaved them and tried to put the lid under the bowl part to walk back to your desk).2. The plastic in the lids will mar if you use them in the microwave (just a normal wattage microwave, for 2.5 minutes). They get bubbles in the plastic.3. They get really hot in the microwave.4. I think that the size selection is odd. I've had these for about a month, and I've used all the small ones numerous times. I have used the larger ones maybe once.5. The shape of the whole set (the lips on the bottoms) means that if you are going to run them through the dishwasher, they'll hold water, so they never really dry.
Colors Don't Match, But Product Works
December 2, 2014
The colors are bizarre. The box shows a lovely purple lid on a handsome purple bowl. Inside, however, you will find lovely purple bowls with blue lids. These are not even periwinkle...the lids are RUBBERMAID BLUE. Is this a mis-packaged item? Other reviews state the same issue, so it must be the intended package.Otherwise, the product design is fine and works as advertised. The lids nest conveniently.UPDATE: I went to a grocery store and saw these bowls for sale. That store sold bowls with PURPLE lids. These lids are BLUE. This product should be labeled as FACTORY SECONDS.UPDATE #2: I changed the rating to 3-stars. They product really works well. The color doesn't make sense.

Two Star Reviews:

1%
okay, but they feel flimsy
May 8, 2017
I ordered these to fix the storage problem in my kitchen but I didn't realize they weren't glass which is what I was originally looking for. Rather than the hassle of sending back, I decided to use the smallest one to store hair accessories for my kids which always get lost. and the others I'll probably use for pasta or extra rice storage. The clasps seem pretty flimsy and cheap, so I don't expect them to last long and the the seal isn't exactly tight.
Two Stars
March 18, 2017
Not that happy. Rubber liners keep falling off so have to keep adjusting them to get the suction.
Gaskets fall off; water gets trapped inside the lid - do not wash
March 8, 2017
Water gets trapped inside the lid and there is no way to rinse away the soap or get the water out. Water gets trapped because the gaskets fall off and the lid is apparently hollow! (I know, the lid does not look hollow.) If you can avoid getting the lid wet, the body of the canister is washable.
Glad I got them
November 30, 2016
Provides more space on my counter than my old canisters. Counter looks more spacious.Glad I got them!
Unfortunately, I AM DISAPPOINTED IN THE "AIRTIGHT" SEALS
September 1, 2016
I bought these for our RV trips, because food storage is important for long trips. Unfortunately, I am disappointed. The tallest one does not seem to close tightly, and the medium size canister definitely does not close. I can see where the white seal is loose and when I snap it shut, the seal bends. I would not recommend these.
2%
Two Stars
August 19, 2017
Covers do not always fit snug and one of the bottoms cracked!
Breaks easily
June 28, 2017
Atypical Rubbermaid containers. I thought these were supposed to be better than the average Rubbermaid containers, but alas, not the case. Dropped one on the floor and it broke. Not good.
Two Stars
November 21, 2015
lids take some playing around with to fit
No wonder they are on sale!
October 18, 2015
Both sets are incomplete
I'm extremely disappointed, one of the medium bowls has a crack ...
December 26, 2014
I'm extremely disappointed, one of the medium bowls has a crack at the bottom after the first time that I used in the freezer

One Star Reviews:

3%
One Star
July 12, 2017
Cheap plastic. Not air tight. The rubber lining fell out immediately.
very disappointed. Food went stale very quickly
July 7, 2017
Not air tight, very disappointed. Food went stale very quickly.
One Star
May 4, 2017
One of the canister seals was damaged when I received it so it doesn't seal properly
One Star
April 19, 2017
The product is much lesser quality than I expected. I will be returning the item.
So disappointed. Returning immediately
April 17, 2017
NOT air tight at all. Cheaply made plastic that will most certainly crack with constant applied pressure (from closing and opening lid). So disappointed. Returning immediately.
canisters,ha ha.
December 4, 2015
Dont waste money,cheaply made.So called gaskets I probably can pull apart with my hands.Look ok, though,Let the buyer beware,as the saying goes.
4%
false advertising - not microwave safe for more than 30 seconds.
March 14, 2017
So, if you use it for storage only, they are great. They are NOT microwave safe. I contacted consumer support and they said you can only microwave for 30 seconds. So, it also says they are dishwasher safe on the upper rack - I wonder if you can only do that for 30 seconds also! FALSE ADVERTISING. Not that microwaving plastic is a good idea, but don't say it's ok to do if it is not. I have 68 pieces of Rubbermaid that have been microwaved and are bubbled and peeling.
Does not last, started cracking,
January 15, 2017
I have the full set of these. LOVED them,,, but they have started cracking. I checked the Rubbermaid site. There are several reviews saying the same thing. I don't put them in the dishwasher.
Not Happy
September 10, 2016
The advertising said more than one, and I only received one. Misleading advertisement
What exactly does Shatter Proof mean?
May 10, 2016
Severely disappointed in this product. Purchased in Oct 2015, in less than 6 months containers began to crack down the corners from mouth to base. Shatter proof? Well, it doesn't shatter, but they certainly fracture and crack and become pretty much useless as food storage. More than half of the containers have cracked as of this writing. Buyer beware.
Melts in microwave
October 21, 2015
It melted in the microwave the first time I used it!
i was short of some of the bottles and the ...
April 2, 2015
i was short of some of the bottles and the additions and mixing of the sizes were all messed up
Vote for Me
Vote for Me
Pricing info
Old Price
Old Price
$39.95
Price
Price
$26.00updated: Mar 16, 2020
$78.00updated: Mar 4, 2020
Features
Answered Questions
Answered Questions
-
Article Number
Article Number
0731882416411
0071691469292
Binding
Binding
-
Kitchen
Brand
Brand
Bellemain
Rubbermaid
Color
Color
Clear
Red
Currency
Currency
USD
USD
Formatted Price
Formatted Price
$42.95
$29.99
Height
Height
216.5 in
265.7 in
Length
Length
523.6 in
576.0 in
Manufacturer
Manufacturer
Epica Products
Rubbermaid
Model
Model
-
1857418
MPN
MPN
-
1857418
Number of Parts
Number of Parts
-
1857418
Product Group
Product Group
Kitchen
Kitchen
Product Type
Product Type
KITCHEN
KITCHEN
Publisher
Publisher
Epica Products
Rubbermaid
Quantity
Quantity
1
1
Reviews
Reviews
Score
Score
10
9.2
Size
Size
-
20-Piece
Studio
Studio
Epica Products
Rubbermaid
Warranty
Warranty
-
1-year limited warranty
Weight
Weight
12.9 oz
13.8 oz
Width
Width
440.9 in
295.3 in
Feature
Feature

Seals air & insects out, freshness in

Clear acrylic lets you see what's inside

Lightweight, yet strong and break resistant

Locking lid with silicone gasket

Includes 1 each: 65 oz., 51 oz., 26 oz. & 22 oz.

Bases are made with Tritan plastic that resists stains and odors. Flex & Seal lids lock in freshness and are easy to seal & remove.

With the easy-find lids system, lids snap to the bottom of the container and to each other.

Containers stack smartly and fit efficiently side by side to save space.

Microwave, dishwasher, and freezer safe. BPA-free. NSF Certified.

Made in the USA. 1-year limited warranty.

Sorry, there's no review at this time. Try changing the filter or leaving one.
Share your opinion
User Rating
Post Review
Please enter captcha code
captcha
Send