Side by Side Comparison of: Madden Girl vs Rhode Island Novelty vs MG

I get a lot of compliments on these, and I wear them a lot because they're so comfortable. Wish they came in black!

Bought this cow girl boots for my sister in law country themed wedding. I got 7 and a half and it fits me perfectly the color is gorgeous just like in the picture and the details was so adorable. I love wearing it! Wore it again when we went for a Grand Canyon trip with family and we did a lot of walking haha! the boots is comfortable had no problem wearing it, it's not heavy just like everyone said "boots are made for walking" well this one is truly made for walking. Love the looks great buy. I recommend Maden Girl boots to those who's looking for a nice but not too expensive cow girl boots this is def worth your money.

Beautiful boots fit perfect I normally wear 7 I ordered 6.5 in these and they are great love them

Had to buy these for a wedding. I haaaaaate ordering shoes on line because I'm very picky about shoes, and my shoe size varies from a 7 to an 8. I was skeptical about buying this but went for a bigger size, figuring I could always wear thick socks if need be. I'm not sure if boots are supposed to be roomy, but I for sure had wiggle room in these but overall they fit great. As for comfort, same as before I'm very picky, but I wore these from 10am until midnight and my feet were fine. They weren't worn in so my feet were a tad bit sore, but nothing a few more wears couldn't break it.Overall, I was completely satisfied with this item and would recommend these to anyone.

These boots are very cute and really comfy, but run about 1/2 size too large. I still love them though!

I ordered these boots, and they came within a week, Extremely fast shipping as always with Amazon.com. I first have to say that I have very fat feet, They were a little tight to get on, which is normal for me, But they stretched out wearing them around the house. I wanted a boot that was very cowboyish with the point toe and the whole 9. I am getting married in these boots in 2 weeks, and they couldn't be more than perfect. They are NOT "plastic" like another review said. They are very comfortable, and very pretty!!! We got our engagement pics done in them, and Ive wanted to wear them since, but I need to keep them perfect until after the big day!! All my bridesmaids got these boots as well, No complaints from any of them either! Am buying another pair I love them so much!!

Love these boots! A bit more pointy than I thought they would be but I don't often where cowgirl boots so maybe it's just me. Hubby thinks they look good!

These are really good looking boots! The only reason they didn't get 5 stars is because I have knock-kneed really thin legs so I won't be able to wear them with a skirt or shorts. I'm sure I'll be happy with them in jeans. :)

Really happy with these boots! I haven't worn them out for too long yet, but they're super cute! I have somewhat chubby calves and they're still loose on me! There's wiggle room, but I'm not complaining bc it's better than them being super tight.Only downside is, you can tell that they are not the best quality. Because there is a heel on the boot, I thought it would make the "heel sound" when you're walking or taking any steps but ... nope. Silence. Almost as if you're wearing regular shoes/flats.I'm a 7.5/8 but majority of the other reviews that I read said to size down because they run big. I originally got the size 7 but it was too tight at the toes (was not able to stand or walk without feeling pressure) so I exchanged them for a 7.5 and they fit me like an 8.5.For the price, I can't complain! They look SO good with blue jeans!

These boots are a decent replacement for authentic cowboy boots. They fit comfortably through the night without any blisters or sore heels; even on the first night of wearing them. They are just a tad bit big after you wear them in. I usually wear between a 6 and 6.5, and my size 6.5 that I ended up ordering fit more like a 7 or so. I recommend getting a slightly smaller size than you would normally wear, just like with all boots because they will begin to stretch out a bit as you continue wearing them. Or just wear super thick socks if that's your thing :)

For the price, this was a fun investment in costuming...needed the boots to be a full-on cowgirl and these were priced right and kind of plain enough to go with virtually anything. The leather is kind of 'shiny' so, no, it doesn't appear genuine. The stitching detail is nice. The heel height just right. They fit like cowboy boots for women - so a bit narrow, a bit pinched at toe - and hard heel. Meaning don't wear them out dancing and then complain later of how sore your feet are. Ordered 1/2 size up to allow for that narrow/pinched feeling and that was a good choice.

These boots are really great! They are truly the most comfortable boots I've ever worn!I bought a size 8 (wear 7.5 or 8.0 most of the time) and they fit perfect - even have room to wear thicker socks. Even though - they are lined so they keep your toes quite warm. They are SO comfortable! I wore them for about 12 hours the very first time and I was standing a fair amount of time, and I experienced no discomfort at all!The color of them is perfect - I bought the Brown Multi - you can wear brown or black with them as they have both colors in the boot - its dark. They looks very stylish and I will wear them under jeans or with a skirt. I recieved many compliments and especially when I told friends the price! I think a few of my friends will go buy them!The only downside is that they are not leather uppers. I wasn't sure if they were or weren't based on the description - even on the Madden Girl website - but they definitely are not. However, they are for style so its not a major downside for me.Overall - extremely comfortable, stylish boots at a very affordable price point - definitely recommend!Madden Girl Women's Sanguine Boot

leather tore quicker than expected, but the general quality is fine and they look great on.

These boots are cute but they are a little tight at the toes and I don't feel like I'll be able to wear them for long periods of time. I'm a true 9 and even with very thin socks they didn't work out. I will be returning them.

These ran quite small, were very narrow and not a lot of room in the toes. They were also very uncomfortable, so I returned them. Maybe they would fit someone who wore a size 9 better than a size 10 and if the person has a very narrow foot.

These boots are super comfortable but look cheap up close. They look more "plastic-ally" than I hoped for. I am still searching for exactly what I'm looking for- comfort - which this boot has- in a real leather cow girl boot- which this is not. The finish wore off the toe within 2 months & reminds me of my faux-leather love seat that is now peeling. And I wasn't even rough with these boots at all! If you just need a pair of comfy boots that look ok from a distance these boots may be what you are looking for but as for me, I'm still searching....

they were super cute! loved them but get at least a half size smaller. the color and design is super cute. will just reorder them in a smaller size.. I am normally a ten but will get them in 9.5

This boot is cute (by no means an "authentic cowboy boot", but I totally knew that going in, so it's OK), but does not look quite like the picture. It is much darker with a solid brown, not the pretty "rubbed" effort I was hoping for. It also is NOT nearly as tall as the description says, which was the main reason I bought this one over the one at Target. They are 100% the same, minus the name (do a search for "Mossimo Kaci boot at Target... THEIR photo is accurate to the real boot style/ color for the brown). Overall, it's alright. I knew quality would be low, but this isn't for daily, and pure look so that is less upsetting than the low height (darn near an ankle boot, actually) and no variation in "rubbed" color. The fit IS small despite the super pointy toe, so definitely listen to everyone advising 1 to 1 1/2 size smaller. I think the price is a bit high for quality, but otherwise it's not a total cheap boot...just much much less than expected from photo and description. If it is still available, buy the Kaci boot. it might not look as pretty in it's photo online, but that's because THEIR photo is correct to the item. This one even has identical stitching patterns and Target's is about $10 less.

I have thin calfs and these boots looked really big on my legs. I will probably return. Also they have a fake look and not a real authentic leather look like I wanted. .

I got an 8.5 as suggested by others. The boot was very wide and fit more like a 10 in length. I don't mind it being wide around the calf in a cowboy boot, but wide around my foot (even with my 2 thickest pairs of socks on) is just a recipe for blisters. Because the shoes didn't fit me right they didn't supply arch support.

I bought these for my cousin and she said they're a good fit but they wore out after a month... not a good quality if you're a real country girl. Might be perfect if you're wearing them for dress up.

Very cheap quality, if you are looking for a boot to go out in and wear around the town these could do the trick as long as you don't scuff them. If you are looking for a riding boot not the way to go. They are also shorter than I had hoped for.

I bought these boots, and paid more than other very similar and less expensive items because of the weathered color shown in the image. These boots arrived basic dark brown (not at all the color in the image) and cheap looking, no different than any of the $30 to $40 versions out there that don't carry the name brand. AND they weren't that comfortable. I've owned more comfortable boots from Payless and Target. I wish I hadn't spent the money. Only get them over others if you need to be able to stay they are by Steve Madden. Otherwise, save yourself the money and buy the other cowboy boot knock offs, as they will look EXACTLY the same.IF you want to know what the boots you order will look like, see this item and you will see how different they look. http://www.amazon.com/Madden-Girl-Womens-Sangunwm-Western/dp/B00JOYMDM6/ref=sr_1_5?s=apparel&ie=UTF8&qid=1416508598&sr=1-5

The picture is very deceiving. The boots appeared to be matte and a little bit weathered in the picture, however, they are very shiny like plastic.... they look very fake. I bought them and made sure they were returnable... but with my busy life I ran out of time... they were purchased July 10 but I did not receive them until July 25... and I only had two weeks to return them apparently... so now i am down forty dollars. These might be appropriate for a little girl, but definitely not for a woman. Buyers beware.

Ordered a size 10 and it was not anywhere close to that. Way too small.

Too big, I ordered a 10 should've got a 9 I'd say. They are nothing like a real cowboy boot but that's what makes them comfy I guess. Real boots are real leather & no give. The toes are really pointy & with them being too big made me look like I have elf shoes on or something.. Looked weird.overall I'd say not worth the money!

My wife wanted these as a Christmas gift, so that she could wear them at the Stagecoach festival in California. Her second time wearing them resulted in the entire heel splitting apart and left unusable. We are very unhappy with this purchase, and will not be buying Steve Madden cowboy boots again......

i thought the picture looked pretty nice and authentic, but incredibly synthetic looking and feeling...almost like plastic. i put them i my halloween box - would never actually wear them for real (and i am not pretentious, but they are just that cheap). disappointing.

First of all I love dealing with Amazon. I have never returned anything I purchased until now. These boots look very cheap. I am really surprised "Madden" has their name associated with the quality of these boots. I have purchased boots from this company prior and was very happy with the product. Amazon was wonderful on their return process and I will continue to use them for future purchases.

I ordered these wanting a pair of cowboy boots...These are made of cheap plastic and look ridiculous. They have started tp seperate at the seams. I tried to return but was told to contact the manufacturer. Really I have had them for 3 weeks!!!! These are cheap don't waste your money! I buy alot from amazon but will never buy from this seller again.