Compare | |||||
Compare All Features Differing |
Side by Side Comparison of: MBI by MCS Industries vs Pioneer Photo Albums vs MCS
Learn More | |||||
Learn More | |||||
Rating info | |||||
eComparisons Score | |||||
eComparisons ScoreThe "Comparison Score" Is calculated based on the average number of times this item was compared with other items in this category by our users | 8.6 | 9 | 9.4 | 7.2 | 8.6 |
User Rating (Amazon) | |||||
User Rating (Amazon) | |||||
Five Star Reviews: | 65% pages were just as I thought. July 29, 2017 pages were just as I thought. I made the mistake of buying from wrong brand but I made them fit (holes didn't line up) Five Stars May 11, 2017 I loved that it came with those tiny pieces to also expand the spine, so the whole book grows. Great way to keep adding to my scrapbook. February 13, 2017 Adding to my scrapbook is easier with the refill pages. I order the 3 pack and it saves me time and some money. Will buy more in about 2 months. Best version of this product I have ever bought September 12, 2016 Best version of this product I have ever bought. Pages are extremely clear, and there is the perfect amount of space for attaching them to the binder, so that the sleeve itself isn't bent at all. Will continue to buy! | 70% Good quality for the price July 28, 2017 As described. Please note that it has 10 clear page protectors with 2 pieces of paper in each, totaling 20 pages. That can be confusing. Otherwise, good quality for the price. the packaging was good & it was honestly bigger than I thought it ... January 15, 2017 It arrived on time, it was shipped with other items I ordered, the packaging was good & it was honestly bigger than I thought it would be. It's more like the size of a photo album than a scrapbook, so keep that in mind. However, I love it! I ordered this one because of the page protectors & the binding. It looks exactly as advertised and it's working perfectly for the scrapbook I wanted to make for my sisters birthday. I love it! Perfect July 4, 2013 This is exactly what I wanted. My kids do a lot with their music and in school. I wanted something to keep their certificates, programs, announcements & pics. This is exactly what I was looking for. I bought one in black and one in purple. The covers are very nice, the pages are sturdy with a white background sheet, and there are extra page inserts avlb for purchase when I need them. This is something they can keep forever. | 79% Liked them. August 18, 2017 Made scrap books for myself and siblings after Mom passed with old picks of both parents and were well received by all. able to add or subtract pages depending your desire. Really good size, too August 17, 2017 So so so cute! Really good size, too. It's one foot by one foot - I can fit several pictures on each page. Very sturdy and thick covers keep it protected. Amazing price for a really good product. I've never scrapbooked before and this was one of the cheapest ones I found that was actually still super adorable. I haven't tried to add more pages - some people's reviews say it's hard to do, but my boyfriend looked at it and said it should be pretty easy with the help of a little screwdriver maybe. Fingers crossed! Beautiful. Great size May 21, 2017 Beautiful. Great size. Scrapbooking my grandparents in this one. They had tons of trees in their backyard. I have lots of birds in mine. The cover says it all :) Great beautiful scrapbook May 7, 2017 Great item, beautiful, bride and groom loved it, used for photo booth business and it was a total hit, thanks Beautiful well made scrapbook March 12, 2017 My father-in-law was a photographer in WWII. He passed in February and I got this scrapbook to organize his photographs. Is very well made and is perfect. I love it. Nice and durable December 13, 2014 The book was very durable, and was exactly what I was expecting! It held up very nicely, and held everything I needed it to. | 49% There are no reviews yet | 67% There are no reviews yet |
Four Star Reviews: | 22% Better than others. September 8, 2017 Work great for adding pages, especially since each pack comes with extender pieces. You do have to separate them slowly as they come stuck together where the holes were punched. The holes are slightly too far apart as well, however it still works. Will still be getting more. Not bad! October 27, 2014 The standard 12" x 12" pages that fit with most scrapbooks. They aren't the most durable as one page in my scrapbook has already ripped at the holes, and I am just in the "putting it together" stages, so it is not as if I've done anything rough with it or transported it somewhere that would make that happen more easily.It was worth the price though! I'm fairly happy with them June 1, 2014 These came quick and no tears etc. However I have 12 inch scrap book and they stick out about a quarter of an inch past page. That didn't bother me to much but if you were going to load a ton in the scrap book it might be annoying for some people. I can say they aren't as good quality as Creative Memories pages, but they'll do fine for your project. Scrapbook Pages January 31, 2012 This comes with the plastic sheet covers as well as paper inserts - it is really 6 physical pages but they say 12 because you can use front and back. I was hoping there actually were 12 so I could use the extras for something else but c'est la vie. Ok pages December 20, 2011 I have been creating a massive scrap book for my almost 5 month old baby. I purchased the Monkey Scrapbook and these refills fit the book by the same company. I agree with the previous review. The pages arn't the best and to separate the pages, you have to be careful not to tear the hole punches. However, they are economical and appear to hold up to my scrapped pages. Each comes with additional pegs and cardboard reinforcers for the pages, which I will be useing. I am fairly happy with them. | 17% Great album November 28, 2015 Comes with 10 sheets already (plain white) that are in plastic sleeves/paper protector. You are able to add more sheets, however, you need a screw to undo the screws on the "hole punched" bar that keeps the sheets in. It is for 12 by 12 scrapbook paper so the album is a little big but most scrapbooking albums are this size. The writing design is shiny as pictured MORE ROOM April 26, 2015 Just perfect for bigger items than pics. I have many booklets of our trip to Key West. Photos won't stick to the back of the pages. Beautiful but... April 17, 2014 This scrapbook is beautiful, I LOVE the feel of it & the bungee strap to hold it closed is a plus. My only issue is the color looks nothing like the color in the picture! I ordered the purple scrapbook but I received one that looks more pink than purple. I would've given this five stars but the color is a disappointment for me. If I wanted a pink scrapbook then I would've ordered one! Great but not expandable as it says.... November 20, 2013 My scrapbook arrived two days after purchase which was incredibly important to me. The gloss, color, and pages are very nice. For being so cheap, it was nice to know that it was fairly sturdy. The only reason I gave the product four stars instead of five is the fact that it says it's expandable. As far as I can tell, it is not. I cannot figure out how to add more pages. It does not come with instructions on how to open the centerfold and I've done quite a bit of digging around the web to try and figure it out. As far as I'm concerned, it is not expandable or they need to send me some instructions because I cannot figure it out. Other than that, it is a great piece for the price. great for scrapbooking March 4, 2013 This is just as pictured and it worked well for my scrapbooking needs. Only complaint is it says it's expandable but I haven't figured out how to add more pages if you even can. Oh well it's 10 pages double sided for a total of 20 pages. For the price it's great. | 14% Purchased this for my wife and so far she loves ... January 23, 2017 Purchased this for my wife and so far she loves it but It said you can add pages to it and we haven't figured out how to do it yet if we figure that out I'll change this to a 5 star Really like the book March 15, 2016 Really like the book. Only issue is when refilling with more pages the back paper holder ripped. Had to repair it. Nice cover overall March 5, 2016 Nice cover overall. I gave it 4 stars because it could have been a little more sturdy & the plastic sheets could've been thicker. I like that I was able to put in pictures in the cover slots As expected. July 2, 2015 This is an inexpensive scrapbook. I knew this when I purchased it. You basically get what you paid for. It is attractive but the texture feels cheap. If you are expecting an average product, this will work fine. | 12% There are no reviews yet | 14% There are no reviews yet |
Three Star Reviews: | 5% Just ok September 12, 2017 Quality isn't the greatest. I would say they are just ok. I don't expect these will last a long time and we will be replacing them. not the greatest quality. Paper inserts VERY thin November 16, 2016 OK, as mentioned by a few others, not the greatest quality. Paper inserts VERY thin. All the other pages look great though. October 29, 2015 I think the pages will certainly do the job they were intended for. The only complaint that I have, and it's not due to product construction by any means, but when you have to remove the metal spacers from the plastic wrap, there is an issue. The metal spacers are attached to the actual pages with an adhesive they leaves a pencil eraser sized defect on each page where they were attached. There is no way to remove it since it damages the page slightly, so you have to be very careful about what picture you choose so that you can try and hide the spot created. All the other pages look great though. Good value June 30, 2014 Good value. It is difficult to add these pages to any photo book (you have to take the book apart) - it's doable, just a little tricky! Ok pages! February 7, 2009 For the price, it's not bad. They are a bit flimsy though. If you are on a budget, these will do. Otherwise, it's worth spending a couple more dollars on firmer pages. | 7% Good for the Price... April 21, 2016 For the price, I can't complain too much. These albums are very cute. I had no condition issues with the pages or album upon receipt. However, they are super hard to get apart and put back together to add pages. And I wish they came with a plastic cover like some of other brands do. I'm a little unsure how well these will hold up over time with no cover. Disappointed. October 26, 2015 When the scrapbook arrived, part of the binding was ripped... I was VERY disappointed. The scrapbook itself seems alright. like there were way too many September 8, 2015 I had an extremely hard time getting the screws out of the book to add more pages. It took 2 people and 2 screw drivers to get them out. Once we got the additional pages in the book, the pages just seemed too bunchy in there, like there were way too many, but I only added 5. Nothing special but good for the price July 30, 2014 The outside is a bit tacky in person and too glossy. If it were more matte, I think it would be extra stylish. I didn't like how the plastic page sheets inside were crumpled, which in turn made the paper in them look wavy. I'd have to purchase sheets separately to replace it. I probably won't purchase again but it works for now. One Screw Fastener Defective May 7, 2014 The bottom screw peg would not come apart. I had to run to a crafting store to get a new set of pegs and replace after I used pliers to finally release the third peg, The thread were not right, Got it all together and it looks ok but instructions of some sort might be nice especially for the other reviewer who wasn't sure it could have extra pages added. | 5% Nice and Large December 30, 2016 Not bad for the price, it appears as it looks on screen. its rather large to other scrap books. Look forward to putting in new memories. There are no instructions explaining how and I've tried but stopped because I'm afraid I will break it as it isn't very sturdy. April 6, 2016 This is a cute scrapbook but it isn't expandable as advertised. There are no instructions explaining how and I've tried but stopped because I'm afraid I will break it as it isn't very sturdy. I am unable to put more inserts in this scrapbook ... July 28, 2015 I am unable to put more inserts in this scrapbook. I bought the inserts, but am, so far, unable to use them. | 12% There are no reviews yet | 13% There are no reviews yet |
Two Star Reviews: | 3% sticks together and rips easily especially around the holes May 1, 2016 Really cheaply made; sticks together and rips easily especially around the holes; some holes also do not line up with regular posts. Only a few were usable in the pack I received. At a price of nearly a $1. 00 per ... November 28, 2015 At a price of nearly a $1.00 per sheet, I think it would be much more of an artistic impact to just use dollar bills as pages, or invest in a 3-hole hole punch (for about the same price as only 6 sheets of this product) and consider using alternative materials. 2 out of 6 pages came with torn holes February 16, 2015 Bought this 6 pack of extra pages, but 2 of them came with torn holes so I was unable to use them. The vertical strip with the 3 holes punched was torn. Giving it 2 stars since the items came damaged and may be susceptible to tearing, but I like the top loading page style. Misleading Ad August 24, 2014 The description here is really misleading. You will receive 6 (six) sheets and covers. | 4% Damaged! July 9, 2017 We really hoping this wouldn't be my experience, but my album came damned too!The disassembly and assembly of the book is difficult if you are looking to add more pages.The spine of the album is terribly cheap! It's merely a detached piece of paper.Very disappointing, but still functional. I didn't quite like the page count June 8, 2016 I didn't quite like the page count. Says there are 20 pages, but for me... it felt like 10 pages. It only said it was 20 pages because they count the front and back of each sheet as a page. A bit disappointed, but I love the product itself. Not what I wanted July 25, 2014 Returned it. Had to hold that book at different angles to see the words. I thought they would be more visible. Liked the color. A present! May 4, 2014 My hubby bought this for Valentines Day! Super cute, but made kinda cheap! Front cover even tore a little when I carried it to a friends house! He paid too much...kinda cheesy make.. Skip this one | 1% | 11% There are no reviews yet | 2% There are no reviews yet |
One Star Reviews: | 5% Awful replacement sheets August 27, 2017 These are the worst scrapbook replacement pages EVER. The plastic is SO cheap, it tears with the slightest tug. Which was impossible to avoid as the pages were stuck together by the punch holes. Then, the size is completely non-standard! They didn't fit any scrapbooks I have, so I had to cut them and it looks like a total hack. Will never buy again. Lastly, this is probably my fault for not reading closely enough, but when I see 12 pages, I expect 12 sheets, not 6. Pages came very dirty/dusty, even on the inside of ... February 12, 2017 Pages came very dirty/dusty, even on the inside of the page protectors. Also, many of the binder ring holes were defective. Clearly these are some sort of second rate knock off or seconds from the real company. Poor quality!!! February 18, 2016 Horrible quality!!! I bought a bunch of these, filled my album with them and had to dissemble the entire thing because I noticed all the ripples in the plastic. Do not buy these!!!! | 2% Not what I wanted. I wanted a scrap. ... June 8, 2015 Not what I wanted. I wanted a scrap. Book with paper leaf to clue on my pictures and cute emblems. This one has plastic photo pockets to hold photos. not good if you want to add pages November 10, 2014 This item looked so nice was looking forward to starting my scapbooking, however when I took off the little screws to add the extra sheets I had bought, the screws wouldnt hold the extra pages, and this was while the pages were still empty, I imagine had the pages been full it would hv been even more impossible to close, sent both items back and got a refund. Scrapbook March 10, 2014 The scrapbook is poorly made. I bought three books and when I opened them and all the plastic pages on two of them tore right out.Didn't open them until after the return date and now I am stuck with garbage. Got This With The Clear Pockets Wrinkled Up~~~ February 7, 2013 I was really sadden about this... all the clear pages was wrinkled up & it looked good on the outside but UGLY in the inside...I hope they would send me unwrinkled pages... or I will NEVER buy these again.... I LOVE the Black Scrapbook I got.. but this was was BAD!!!!!!!!!!!! | 1% what a cheap piece of crap. I'm not even going to bother trying to ... April 9, 2017 Tried forever to unscrew this scrapbook to add more pages and could NOT get the screws to come apart, ending up accidentally tearing the book trying to get the screws out, what a cheap piece of crap. I'm not even going to bother trying to order another scrapbook online I'd rather go to a store to check the quality myself. An absolute WASTE of money, save yourself the frustration and go somewhere else. Cute but not well made. October 2, 2015 Super cute cover but the binding cover piece was made out of a paper material and broke as soon as I attempted to add pages and spacers. Great if you only want the number of pages it comes with. | 16% There are no reviews yet | 4% There are no reviews yet |
Vote for Me | Vote for Me | Vote for Me | Vote for Me | Vote for Me | |
Pricing info | |||||
Old Price | |||||
Old Price | - | - | - | - | - |
Price | |||||
Price | $6.94updated: Mar 17, 2020 | $14.99updated: Mar 17, 2020 | $14.02updated: Mar 17, 2020 | $5.24updated: Mar 18, 2020 | $14.55updated: Feb 24, 2020 |
Features | |||||
Answered Questions | |||||
Answered Questions | - | - | |||
Article Number | |||||
Article Number | 0469097200142 | 0046909481212 | 0046909601078 | 0739420567618 | 0046909025119 |
Binding | |||||
Binding | Kitchen | Kitchen | Misc. | - | - |
Brand | |||||
Brand | MBI by MCS Industries | MBI by MCS Industries | MBI by MCS Industries | Pioneer Photo Albums | MCS |
Color | |||||
Color | Top Loading | Black | White | - | Blue |
Currency | |||||
Currency | USD | USD | USD | USD | USD |
Formatted Price | |||||
Formatted Price | $2.99 | $26.52 | $15.49 | - | - |
Height | |||||
Height | 472.4 in | 521.7 in | 531.5 in | 211.8 in | 531.5 in |
Label | |||||
Label | - | - | - | Pioneer Photo Albums,Inc | MCS |
Length | |||||
Length | 472.4 in | 492.1 in | 496.1 in | 29.5 in | 492.1 in |
Manufacturer | |||||
Manufacturer | MBI by MCS Industries | MBI by MCS Industries | MCS Industries | Pioneer Photo Albums,Inc | MCS |
Minimum Age | |||||
Minimum Age | - | - | - | 120 | 120 |
Model | |||||
Model | 899676 | 848121 | 860107 | AM-350 | 802511 |
MPN | |||||
MPN | 899676 | 848121 | 860107 | AM-350 | 802511 |
Number of Items | |||||
Number of Items | 1 | 1 | - | - | - |
Number of Parts | |||||
Number of Parts | 899676 | 848121 | 860107 | AM-350 | 802511 |
Product Group | |||||
Product Group | Art and Craft Supply | Art and Craft Supply | Art and Craft Supply | Art and Craft Supply | Art and Craft Supply |
Product Type | |||||
Product Type | HOME | HOME | HOME | HOME | HOME |
ProductTypeSubcategory | |||||
ProductTypeSubcategory | - | - | - | professional-photo-albums | - |
Publisher | |||||
Publisher | MBI by MCS Industries | MBI by MCS Industries | MCS Industries | Pioneer Photo Albums,Inc | MCS |
Quantity | |||||
Quantity | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 |
Release Date | |||||
Release Date | - | - | - | - | 2013-07-28 |
Reviews | |||||
Reviews | |||||
Score | |||||
Score | 8.6 | 9 | 9 | - | 8.8 |
Size | |||||
Size | 12 by 12 | 12 by 12 | - | 1 Pack | 12 by 12 |
Studio | |||||
Studio | MBI by MCS Industries | MBI by MCS Industries | MCS Industries | Pioneer Photo Albums,Inc | MCS |
Title | |||||
Title | - | - | - | Pioneer Auto Mounts Permanent Mounting Squares Roller 350/Pkg, Permanent | MBI by MCS Fashion Fabric 12-Inch by 12-Inch Page Top Load Scrapbook with Photo Opening, Blue, 12.5 x 13.5 inches Overall |
Warranty | |||||
Warranty | 1-Year guarantee against manufacturer defects | 1-Year guarantee against manufacturer defects | - | Lifetime. | 1-year guarantee against manufacturer defects. |
Weight | |||||
Weight | 0.4 oz | 7.3 oz | 0.0 oz | 0.2 oz | 0.1 oz |
Width | |||||
Width | 9.8 in | 39.4 in | 39.4 in | 137.8 in | 39.4 in |
Feature | |||||
Feature | Acid free, top loading Vinyl pages Easy to install Extra set of binding posts included Crystal clear pages Comes with 6 sheets of paper to create 12 scrapbook pages | Top quality 12x12 scrapbook 10 Acid free, top load pages Post bound page-binding system for easy expansions Elastic album closure Page Refill #899676 | 13.5 x 12.6 Album with 2 Openings to customize album 10- White Acid Free 12x12 sheets (use both sides) Padded Heavy Duty Recycled Clipboard Cover Post bound page binding construction for easy expansion Page Refill #899676 | Auto mounts dispenser for scrapbooking and other paper craft projects! Features 350 permanent photo squares Simply press down on a photo or piece of paper where you want adhesive and turn back a touch with your wrist | Top quality 12.5"x13.5" scrapbook |fabric cover Ten 12 by 12in top-loading vinyl page protectors with 10 white, acid free cardstock inserts Post bound page binding construction for easy expansion Page Refill #899676 Dust jacket |
SiCoHome Scrapbook Vintage Photo...
DCWV Once Upon A Time Postbound...
MBI by MCS 12-Inch by 12-Inch...
Pioneer 12 Inch by 12 Inch...
Pioneer Post Bound Jumbo Album,...
Our Adventure Book,Movie Pixar...
MBI by MCS Industries 860107...
Expressions Collection Family...
MBI by MCS Embossed Gloss...
Pioneer 12-by-12-Inch...