Side by Side Comparison of: BSD Treasure vs Amazon Collection vs Feramox

These took than the expected delivery date by 2-3 weeks. They are my go-to earrings and do not look cheap.

Very nice. Right size and very sparkly. I have for a week without any skin problems. I would definitely buy again I bought the 5 mm.

I absolutely love these. They sparkle and do not look cheap. If you are looking for an inexpensive pair of earrings to wear daily, travel with or wear on a special night, these are it!

Great purchase, just what I was looking for. They reflect colors not just flat glass looking. 8mm size needs a larger disc back to keep from flopping down. Fast shipment great seller!

I like the earrings so much. The shipping was fast and its exactly how i expect it yo be. Its so shiny. Im the type of person who takes a shower without removing off my earrings and im so surprise that it still looks the same, shiny. At first my ears got itchy but i did not worry because its normal for me when i change earrings. Eventually i got used to it and its not itching anymore.

These are amazing. Larger than expected. Sparkle even in the shade! Great for a gift or for yourself. Would buy again!

These look great. Understanding the sizing can be tricky. The cttw is for both earrings combined. I order 2cctw and each stud is 1ct. Because I already have some 1ct studs, these will now be a stocking stuffer for one of my daughters. I would order these again, but the size information could be clearer to save on returns.

I recommend this set of earrings. I got the 1cttw platinum-plate.

Just opened. A little big(7.5mm), a little expensive. Hope the pair will last.

They came very fast, nice packaging, good quality for price. My mother and I loved them! Perfect size for any piercing as well.

Love them. Just do it, they are stunning. PS- they are .5ct per earring!

This pair of earrings was bought as a gift for my sister and I also bought the princess-cut ones for myself. Comparing these two, the round-cut has more fire and brilliance than the princess-cut studs. At 5mm, they are the right size for casual or even dinner wear, and will fool anyone. Good buy!

The earrings are sparkly! They look amazing. I ordered the 6mm one and the size is good. Maybe, I could have ordered 5mm though. My earrings did not come in with any fancy bags. It came with a plastic pouch. I wish it came with a nice pouch though.

Earrings are a little bigger than I would like but they are exactly as advertised. The CZs have a lot of shine and the earrings are put together well.

Are beautiful. I like too much and are too shine.thanks

I love them! I also just am the slightest bit disappointed because they're black and not clear like it poses as.

It's been a month now and still as new.

They are okay for the price

Nice and shiny but the 2 carat is too big. The cut and shape on that size really does make the stone look fake. I liked the 1 carat size better.

Pretty earrings, but larger than i thought, have to wear 'helper' clutches 'cuz ones included didn't seem to be big enough not to cause ear droop. Seem to be well made otherwise.

These earrings are good for sensitive ears. Mine usually turn red and itch if I wear cheap earrings but these worked fine without any irritation. I bought the 3 cttw size. They are big enough to add some glitz to any outfit but not so big that they weigh down my ears. The post is located at the top of the stud. I would have preferred it to be located in the center but they still look nice. For less than $10 these are pretty great earrings!

Ugh! I read lots of reviews on these and determined that I would order the one cttw (deciding to follow the camp that said each earring would be one carat, contrary to the carat "total weight" in the description). Not sure if the seller figured out their mistake or what, but the one carat pair I got was definitely 0.5 ct each stud, when I wanted 1 ct each. My bad, I guess.That said, they are a very nice quality. Very shiny and appear to be well-constructed! The post is SUPER long but that doesn't tend to bother me as I don't sleep in earrings, anyway. They come very nicely packaged in a fantastic box.Wish the seller would have some consistency so you know what you're getting. Until then, four stars. I might be reordering the bigger pair soon.

They are very pretty. I think this size (5 cttw) is just a little too big. They weigh on my ears more than I like. I think they could fall off and a different back would be better, but I'll have to try them for a while and see. I might buy one size smaller and then they would be perfect.

I was super excited to get these after reading the other reviews. They are very pretty and sparkly, just like the picture and as other reviewers mentioned. I was actually super excited when I opened because the gift box they come in is GREAT (if you are giving as a gift, this is WAY better than a baggie and cheap looking silver or gold box)! It is a heavy duty, jewelry store quality black box inside another black box. But, I was so disappointed when I opened my box to find one earring with a bent post!! I was just going to carefully try to bend it back and it did bend back quite easily, so the posts are not the strongest! I was considering sending back when I first saw the bent post, but once I bent it back, and tried them on, I decided I really liked them and for the price, they are worth it! I'd buy more for gifts if I knew they would arrive in better condition. I knocked off one star for the bent post. If they were in perfect condition on arrival, I would have given 5 stars.

The stone in these is pretty. very very sparkly but the setting is super cheap looking. I'm not going to keep mine but for the price these are very very nice.

Not as big as I anticipated. Would have liked a larger size.

To small

Arrived today but unlike the other reviews my 2 sets of earrings arrived in a small and then larger plastic bags not in the nice velvet pouch the other reviews spoke about... They are pretty... Definitely not ready to give as gifts.

Meh. They're not as big as I wanted, and they protrude a lot more than I expected. But for the price they're very shiny... don't expect them to last forever

This studs are a cute little touch for anyone with an ear piercing. Now they aren't real and aren't the best quality but if you don't mind wearing fake jewelry then this is great! Like I said they are cute and add a nice little blingy touch!

They are decent quality. That said, the post is not in the middle so they often are off-center and look like one is lower than the other. The post is on the side almost.

Super beautiful earrings, but they're also really easy to bend. Out of curiosity, I slightly bent the back of the earring to see how solid it was and was surprised how easy it was to bend. I was able to bend it back into shape, but will have to be very careful so that they don't get misshapen.

The setting is really quite nice. The stones sparkle. Nice box. That said, they are very obviously CZ. That's the reason for the 3 star rating. I'm sorry I got this size, I should have gone smaller. I am a petite woman with smaller ears. I also have very short hair, so they are very much out there. I feel these are perhaps too large for me. IF they looked real, this would be less of a problem. In fact, I don't think it would be a problem at all. For the price, it's not worth a return. I don't know how much use they'll get.

I purchased these a couple of years ago. I have very sensitive ears and the platinum plating works to keep them from getting infected. After approx 2 years my ears are getting sensitive to the earrings as I imagine the platinum is wearing off - definitely a reasonable anand so I purchased them again. They look just as nice and real but the posts are thinner. The earring back twists sideways as a result of the skinny post and makes it uncomfortable. I purchased in both the 1 and 2 ct. I will use and hope that they will last a while but am nowhere near as happy with these as I was with the previous pair.

I didn't find the sparkle to be that great but for the price a great deal. I usually can't wear silver/gold/platinum tone due to allergic to such but so far they are not bothering my ears so impressed with this...the 1 karat is almost too big so I would suggest staying with 1 karat. These are a great deal and I am wearing everyday so I do recommend. The post is a bit long so I use different post caps at end which causes them to slope down but the post doesn't stick out and can't stick me. I keep these in and sleep in them so using the post ends that cap off the post at end of post prevents posts from sticking me. I use the gold filled post ends and since these don't touch my ears they don't bother my ears even though gold tone or gold filled..I do recommend for the price.

I carefully read the reviews and questions/answers before choosing which size to get. I was torn between the 1cttw and 2ct tw sizes. I had wanted to purchase these to wear for a while before deciding what size real diamond studs to buy.The 2cttw size seemed a little large in the photo but in the question/answer it appeared as if the seller answered the question of sizing to be 2 ct TOTAL WEIGHT (So 1 ct each stud) even though other buyers stated each stud was 2ct each. What confused me is that the description is 2 cttw, which stands for 2 carats total weight. So I decided to buy that size since I wanted to see how large 1 ct in each ear looked like.When I received these I was immediately impressed with the quality but knew the description was wrong. I should have listened to the other buyers and not the seller/description. The 2cttw earrings are most definitely 2 ct each stud. These are way to big to look real to me even though the quality is great. I also dislike that the posts are at the top of the earring so you cannot avoid having the earring droop beneath the lobe. So these are going back. I will purchase the 1cttw and update my review. I am hoping the sizing is consistent and those will be 1 ct each but only time will tell!

Back broke off and unable to repair.

Sparkly but small

The CZ itself is nice but I have only used it once. I have a sensitive skin and the earring from the front to the back it a thicker in an angle to the ear. I wish I see that in the picture. Matching with the small lock. It kind of dig in my skin, it make sit hard to wear all day.I like it better if the earring had a thinner metal. I am keeping it to give it to a family It might work for others but not for me.

Very cheap looking and flimsy.

I have real diamond earrings as well as a Cubic Zirconia set. These were a huge disappointment. The setting was VERY cheap and it was obvious. I returned them immediately.

The carat weight is total weight, the 1 carat was sooooooooo small. Did return.

Pretty earrings. But you get what you pay for. After a few wears the clip on the back of the earring seemed to start coming loose and sliding back. And I didn't take off my earrings everyday maybe 1 or 2 times a week. And I've only been wearing it for maybe a month.

Junk! Should have known Bent to thin

Earrings that came are way smaller than what they were advertised to be. I might send them back, actually.

I was very pleased when I received my earrings. The basket setting is my favorite, and the stones sparkled nicely however, the first time I wore my earrings I kept hearing a jiggle. I couldn't figure out where the jiggle was coming from for hours until I finally took the earrings off... and the jiggle stopped. One of the stones was extremely loose and thinking it would be a quick fix, I brought the earrings to a jewelry store - it cost me $10 to have the stone tightened so I ended up paying over $25 for these earrings. Not the bargin I thought I was getting.

I hate to rate these a 2 star because they are very pretty. For the money paid they should be a 4-5 star. What has me giving this rating is that one of the stones rattles in the prongs which tells me that it is loose. Also, the posts only have metal backs and I feel they should have the more comfortable rubber ones. I will wear these until the stone is lost...not worth spending money to repair it or take the time to send back. That is disappointing.

S*** broke in a week

These are very cheap looking

I was really happy about these earrings, they didn't irritate my sensitive ears. Unfortunately the backs fell off and these earrings were lost some where throughout my day so I did not get to enjoy them for long.

I sent them back as description said 2 karat .They looked like 1/2 karat for each ear . Maybe their 2 karat total weight meant they "weighed" more ?Most women look at karat as size !So disappointed when I received . The quality was just okay as the stones had a blue cast to them . As a former copy writer I would never use 2 karat total weight and mislead a customer .

The earrings are nice. But one of the earring's back piece was loose and I already lost it. Not sturdy at all. I'm really disappointed.

Lacks the sparkle and brilliance of even the cheapest cubic zirconia. It is a shame to waste sterling silver this way. Product was cheap and you get what you pay for. I wouldn't purchase again.

I received this product and the stem on one of the earrings was bent. I was able to fix the bend but the stem seemed super flimsy. Despite this I attempted to wear the item. At that point the backs would not remained fastened. Therefore I contacted Amazon to return the item. I was able to return with no issues.

Got these and thought they were beautiful and a great alternative to the real thing. Unfortunately however, these "platimnum plated sterling silver" earrings caused a HUGE allergic reaction and I have now had to spend a lot of money going to the Dr trying to clear up this reaction (literally both my ears swelled to near unrecognizable and spread all the way down my neck, jaw line, and all the way down my arms). I ONLY bought these earrings because it said "platinum plated sterling silver", of which I have SEVERAL pieces of jewelry that really are platinum plated sterling silver and have never once had a reaction to them...I am currently wearing a platinum plated sterling silver necklace that I haven't taken off in months and ZERO reaction. Extremely disappointed. Before the reaction I had told all my co-workers and friends they had to check these earrings out and buy some because of how pretty they were...I have since made sure that no one I know will ever order from you guys. Hope these never cause an anaphylactic reaction in someone!!