Side by Side Comparison of: McNeil Labs vs Trojan vs K-Y

I use this with a cryogenic hemorrhoid product and it is better than the lubricant that came with the product because it does not drip a lot. I have used this for years without any complaints.

A++++++++++!!!!!

I was on the fence about posting the following review, as it is a fairly private issue for which I purchased the KY; however, it helped me -- a lot. As such, I’m posting this, as the information might help others as well (with the understanding that I am not a physician, in conjunction with idea that you should always consult a physician -- preferably a specialist -- before trying anything). Please bear with the backstory, as it directly relates to the purchase as well as how, and how much, the KY helped me.I had a hemorrhoidectomy for two stage-four external hemorrhoids and one internal hemorrhoid in April of this year (2016). I originally went to an MD (not a colorectal specialist, as I should have to begin with -- live and learn). There were complications from the surgery. After every bowel movement I would experience a stinging sensation (a six or seven out of ten on the pain scale) for at least 30 minutes. The stinging occurred despite cleaning properly and taking pain medication. After three months of this -- still experiencing pain, despite trying all kinds of salves and home remedies, and after the original surgeon seemed to have no explanation for the fair amount of pain I was in other than, “this shouldn’t be happening at this point, keep doing what you’re doing and you should heal in time” -- I went for a second opinion from a specialist in colorectal surgery. The colorectal surgeon (who turned out to be a Godsend) told me, due to the original surgery, I had an deep, chronic anal fissure in the various stages of healing, tearing, and healing again... and, possibly, a fistula. This was based on visual inspection only. The pain was much too severe to allow an internal inspection. He noted that surgery is almost always a last resort (and should have been in the original situation), but both issues would likely need surgery to correct them. Still, he wanted to exhaust all possibilities before trying surgery again. So, in the hopes of allowing me to heal enough to be able to check things internally, he told me I needed to take Metamucil, increase my fiber intake, drink a lot more water, take sitz baths to promote healing, quit the salves and home remedies (as they tend to do more harm than good) and… place a dab of KY Jelly on the open wound before and after bowel movements. He told me the KY would protect the wound during bowel movements, make clean-up easier, and would keep the wound from being open to the air and other things that go along with that particular nether region. An older country doctor (but a sage in his own right), he told me this region is made to heal fairly well on its own, as long as it’s tended to properly. Surprisingly, not once in all my research over the past few months (and I did a lot of research), did I come across anything that said to use KY for this purpose. While, in the end, we both came to the conclusion that I needed surgery to correct the issue (really the best thing I ever did), the KY Jelly was a-ma-zing throughout the entire process (before and after the second surgery)! It helped with bowel movements in ways I couldn’t have imagined and allowed me to sit down after those movements. If you haven’t gone through this, you don’t understand just how sensitive the area is when it’s wounded and healing. If you have gone through it or are, I feel for you… truly. For me, the KY provided tremendous relief.Recommended Purchase?: I’m not a doctor. I’m in no position to offer medical advice. I only offered what I did based solely on what I experienced. Everyone is different. Your results might vary. Always consult a physician (preferably a specialist) before trying anything. However, for me, the KY worked as my colorectal surgeon said it would -- providing relief I didn’t think possible. For that, I thank both him and KY and have no problem recommending it for this purpose.

I use this as a lubricant for my menstrual cup and it helps a lot for insertion. Just a tiny bit goes a long way, though it will dry out pretty quickly. It doesn't have any scent which is good.

My advice is BUY TWO bottles, you're gonna need it. Shagalicious, Hooray!!!!!

Can't really say much other than it makes things slick! Keep a glass of water, nearby if it dries a little it gets sticky, but a drop or two of water and its super slick again! Arrived quickly, and discreetly.

Been using these for a while now, a whole box last long. Quality is great, last long and it doesn't breake easily. I do wish it could streach a bit more thou, im more of the thick 6.5" diameter or circunference in the middle so its a lil struggle to put it on and make it pass that part to fully unroll down to the base. Iv'e managed to make it work thou, not complaning, in fact I just reorder to restock.

She's still not pregnant, sooo....they work

I'm not a doctor and I don't play one on tv. After my wife complained that she wasn't feeling the full girth of my magic Johnson and several incidences of blowing the tip out of regular condoms, I decided to go with these. So far working well and no additional rug rats running around. That's an A+ in my book.

Well lubricated and high quality condom.. My 'thing' is also much more comfortable with Magnum than wearing regular sized condoms which I think are just too tight for me.You don't need to have a super long package to be able to put this on, you just need to have the girth... Will definitely order again.

bought these simply because they're so much cheaper on amazon but what can i say... no babies!!

Always used MAGNUM and never chose anything else. Had one break once but that was a rare occasion. If you need protection, look no further. Also the value pack is a PLUS! Get some!

PROS:Friction reducedCONS:Total pumps decreased

Works fantastically and with no irritation.

This KY is great, perfect composition and great price, especially for the size of tube.

No numbing or burning!

As advertised

Highly recommend

No review for this product it is what it is and functions as such

This stuff is all I use. For personal use or with a partner, it's great.

does what it is made to do...

I always love the feel of K-y jelly. I just wish it last longer.

Effective

so far soo good my wife love it! get straight to point #no4playneeded

Good fit, unlike so man other condoms that are too tight – just wish these didn't smell so chemically (rubber / latex / plastic).

No kinds yet, so I guess they work, and hell they're cheap.

As expected

Some of them were "wrapped" poorly. I'm not sure what term is used for that but some of them would not unravel very well compared to buying Trojans in smaller quantities.

Very Satistfied

Not bad but I have felt better.

Good, but water-based is better

Basic lube. Doesn't get sticky. Large volume & good price

Great product.

Received intact, no shipping or packing issues. Product is as expected, which is clear, almost odorless, safe, water based lube; not very long lasting

works well

good

I didn't realize this was the jelly cuz the pictures don't show the container, just the box. The jelly is very thick and can get kinda messy. Other than that it works well.

It is what it is.

Did not meet expectation

It's ok. The KY Ultragel is much more expensive, but much more natural feeling. This is much more jelly-like which is fine, but not as pleasant. This feels more like what they use at the OB/GYN's office (it probably is the same thing, actually). Not bad and would use again, but would consider getting the ultragel next time instead because it is much better.

great feel, great for toys, great lubricative power, but slightly messy/sticky after about ten minutes, slightly expensive.

Lube is expensive. It's unfortunate but true. Even budget lubes (and I include the standard K-Y in that category) are $4+ per tube. I managed to get this 6 pack of 4oz tubes (which are pretty large) for under $12. Great price, so no complaining there. This should keep the party going for quite a while.Quality wise, it's only okay. I find that the sensitive skin version actually works better though I have no explanation for why.The good:-A lot of people don't like jelly lubes, but I find them easy to measure, easy to apply and rarely spill on the sheets.-Easy to dispense, cap doesn't leak or anything-It's cheap-Water based lubes are easy to cleanThe not so good-It dries out fairly quickly. I don't have marathon sex sessions, so it's not really an issue most of the time, but after about 15 minutes, you probably need to reapply.-It doesn't smell great (which is true for most lubes)-Water based lubes do not work in wet situations like showers or pools. If this matters to you, you need to spend the money and get silicone based.-The last 15-20% of the tube is hard to get out. It gets trapped in the corners near the mouthBottom Line: If you need a lot of cheap lube and keep your lovemaking to a tight 10 minutes, this is a good affordable option. But if you have the means for something better, you can definitely do better.

Good product, but was too large for my guy

There wasnt much lubrication

Good not great. Fits but still snug. Classic condom..

They're fine. The best size and shape I have found for me so far, but not perfect. They can start to slip around on the end a little but do not give me the same death-grip type feeling that some other brands do.

While they provide a comfortable fit and great sensation due to the thin latex, they tend to tear at the base of the shaft during a good pounding session.

length fit ok, but the girth was not big enough. not trying to talk myself up, but when i remove the condom i have a ring at the base of my shaft. if you have girth be aware.

It serves its purpose.

Not so impressed, other lubricants work so much better. You need to keep adding more as you go

Dries out pretty quick so use a lot

product was ok but the box was open and damaged

ok

Great at first but after a while it gets very sticky, but overall it gets the job done.

It is not very effective in doing the work it supposed to do. I would not buy it again.

Sticky residue..

This was the wrong product for me both in the hand and in the "sleeve". Dries up rather quickly and tends to make a mess. You'll probably want to take a shower after using it. It can get the job done but there are much better products out there.

Tried it and then it just was sticky and now lays in the drawer not used.

It's water based, I should have read it closer, it's not what I like.

Lubes for like a minite. Then gets gummy and sticky. Not sure what that's about. Maybe it was a bad bottle? No one was impressed with this.

Package shipped well but, inside 3/12 had been cut/opened by some sort of box cutter or knife....

We stopped using these because of the synthetic lube irritating my skin :( We've gone to a totally natural lubricant and condom and find it much better!

I think someone got in the mood before delivering this to me because my box was totally damaged when it got here, no pun intended.

My man must just be too big. Everytime we use them, they break. But their ecstasy and bare skin work great for us.

A bit thick, poorly lubricated. Not larger than normal

Go with the skyn large, much thinner, much better.

Packaging did not match the photo.This stuff leaves a sticky residue behind and is a bear to wash off.

first time user not a fan personally did not make things better

Wasn't water based it was gel

We prefer the KY Liquid to the jelly.

was too sticky

Dries quickly

Gloppy and too thick. and you need lot. Don't buy this stuff.

Seems to dry up and get gummy rather quickly. I do not recommend it

I don't care for this product at all and threw it in the trash. The goop is too gooey and sticky. Pure vaseline or creamy vaseline works much better and is a lot cheaper.

Gell is not gentle and safety.. It getting dry very quick and getting burn. Brought it from walgreen or medical better than from third party

They keep breaking!

Length is fine but it's just not wide enough.

When looking at the details for this product it was unclear that it was 3 boxes at 14.47 each. It looks as if though there are 3 boxes of 12 for that price and having never bought them I would have no idea how much they are supposed to cost. Perhaps one should go in and fix that to make it a little more clear. There is no reason in the world that I would need all of these and I wondered why my bill was so much after it was shipped. Nothing thinking about it when I got the confirmation since I also got an expensive book and tee.So it may be a great product I have no idea, I am just upset about the description being so unclear.

One of them broke! Very inconvenient!

Omg! I bought these and idk what's wrong with them. Whether they're not Trojans or just old but I must have had 3 rip while I was in my ex. Not safe!

bad

Useless dries within seconds

This becomes thick and sticky during intercourse. Definitely not a solution for my Sjögren's syndrome!

Very bad irritation.

Wrong item used it to groom my hair

For the price, this PRODUCT SUCKS. Do not buy it.