Compare | |||||
Compare All Features Differing |
Side by Side Comparison of: PRO vs Dynarex vs Band-Aid vs ProAdvantage vs McKesson
Learn More | |||||
Learn More | |||||
Rating info | |||||
eComparisons Score | |||||
eComparisons ScoreThe "Comparison Score" Is calculated based on the average number of times this item was compared with other items in this category by our users | 8.8 | 7.6 | 9.4 | 6.6 | 0 |
User Rating (Amazon) | |||||
User Rating (Amazon) | |||||
Five Star Reviews: | 75% Great value. May 2, 2017 I will repurchase this. It is difficult to find bandages this large and of this quality. Great value. Convenient size and does not tear skin when removed. ... March 12, 2017 Convenient size and does not tear skin when removed. Large pad underneath that can span a very large cut up to an inch or slightly more in length. Latex Free! January 23, 2017 Latex Free! I actually haven't used these yet. I gave myself a two inch cut on my hand with a right angle grinder using a thinner cutoff blade. I needed to change out a larger pad band-aid several times daily until it healed. I am not allergic to latex but I actually stopped dressing the wound when I started to get a skin irritation from always being bandaged. If it happens again I'll have 50 fresh latex free bandages ready to help get me through. Either that or I can nick myself here or there several times and have a bigger band-aid ready to soak up the bleeding. Excellent Product, Price And Quality November 8, 2015 Good Product, Good Quality, Good Price For The Amount In Box. Excellent Over All Will Buy Again. Good price for good product February 9, 2015 These are great--tough, they stay on, and they don't leave a residue when it's time for them to come off. Buying them this way is a bargain compared to smaller boxes at the store. I would buy this again August 22, 2014 Good productPros:-- Easy to unwrap (sometimes bandages are a bear to get a tiny edge peeled away from the outer wrapper)-- Provides nice control while applying an ointment to the pad before applying the bandage-- Latex free-- Stays stuck very well but also easy to remove when you want to remove itCons:-- None | 57% Packaged well and price was good April 8, 2017 Exactly what I needed to add to the OCC Shoe Boxes. I put 10 bandages in a snack zip lock bag along with Q-tips to be sent to children around the world in need. I cannot give a review on how well they will stick, but I am sure they will be fine. The price was better than I could find any where else. Great Quality! March 27, 2017 Excellent quality! I'm using on fingers, they've stayed on thru 24 hours of handwashing and dishwashing, w/out sticking to wound and still coming off skin easily when time to change.Highly recommended. Better Than The Photo Shows May 25, 2015 I was a bit leery about purchasing these by just looking at the photo, but the price was right for a humanitarian project. I was pleasantly surprised when I received them because they are much better than I expected. They are nice and wide so the could be cut in two very easily for a smaller bandage. I have lots of "Grand Children" who love to go through the bandages. I will be purchasing these again for my own use Good deal. July 6, 2014 Good bandages at a good price. They stick well, have good flexibility, don't make me break out. I like the way the pad comes right up to the edge, so you can place several next to each other to cover a large cut. You can also cut them in half to cover little kids' fingers. They're just right, I will be buying more of these when this batch runs out. First Aid Stuff Where You Need It. September 13, 2012 These are quality fabric bandages. The bandage is one inch wide, like the package says. The absorbent pad is about 5/8" wide and 1" long. It is non-stick material. That's the right size for about the biggest wound for which an adhesive bandage is suitable.I bought these because I hate the "assortments" one gets at the grocery or drug store. A bandage that's a bit too big is usually fine. One that's too small is useless.The thing about first aid supplies is that they're never where you need them. Three hundred of these are enough to put some every place they might be needed: kitchen, garage, car, suitcase, etc. Very good bandages December 23, 2011 I suffer from eczema and my fingers are constantly cracking and bleeding. I use bandages at night to help. The problem I have with the primary name brand is the adhesive is so strong, it would pull a layer of already dry skin off my fingers when I removed the bandages, thus compounding the problem. The problem with store brands is the pad does not cover the entire width of the bandage. These bandages stay on all night, do not fray at the edges, do not pull skin off when removing, and the pad covers the entire width of the bandage. The packaging is also excellent. | 83% 1 inch wide Band-Aids, No Small Ones! March 9, 2017 My favorite! The others don't perform nearly as well as Band-Aids. Also, for me I always use the larger band aids and am left with a box is smaller assorted sizes. Now, I can just order the 1 inch wide size in a good quantity by itself without the assorted smaller sizes! I'm then able to supplement the assorted boxes with the ones I use the most. Nice to Buy Just the Size I Want March 4, 2017 It's hard where we live to find a box of Band-Aids that are all the same--the size everybody actually uses. All we can find are small pricey boxes or the large variety boxes. I hate the variety boxes. All that means is that you get a lot of bandaids you can't use because of their weird sizes and shapes. This is just what I wanted and I'll order again. Don't go cheap when it comes to band aids December 25, 2016 These are very high quality, pretty much what we expect from Johnson and Johnson. It will absorb any remaining blood from the cut, and will actually stay on for the full day. Do not get the band aids from the dollar store, and get these instead. It is well worth spending a few bucks more. This is still cheaper than what you would pay for these at the pharmacy. STRONG, DURABLE & "No Tears" SECURE November 9, 2016 These are my favorite Band-Aid. They have great coverage, wear comfortably, and adhere well with near-painless removal. I have been using the product, non-stop, for adult and grandchild injuries for nine years. The flexible fabric moves with your skin, and is strong. When there's a need to wear one a little bit longer than usual, the product holds up to the job. I truly think Johnson & Johnson has cornered the market, here. If your little ones still long for pirates and princesses, slap the flimsy, trendy ones over these flexible, fabric bandaids. You'll get the strength. And durability I've described along with the smiles kid bandages offer up! Proper Bandaids that hurt when you remove them. August 19, 2013 Let's be frank--Band Aids are supposed to hurt when you take them off. That's how you know they'll stay on. It also reminds you to wear shin guards next time. These are great bandaids that stay on for days, even after showering and exercise. If you're a man and you want a bandaid that sticks, here you go. Fabric bandages June 7, 2013 Given my way, I would rid the world of the pseudosticky plastic garbage band-aids and replace them all with fabric. The only problem would be putting all the cool designs on them. If you do not require artwork on your minor cuts, buy these fabric band-aids. | 50% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
Four Star Reviews: | 11% Purchased for School September 22, 2017 Rather expensive but this was only place I could find a box of 50 large latex free bandages. I will not be using firsthand but will ask our school office later in the year regarding their efficacy and quality. Kinda thin and cheap, but I wear two of ... July 15, 2017 Kinda thin and cheap, but I wear two of them daily and they stay on for about 12 hours . Perfect for your first-aid kits. June 2, 2015 Just restocking various first-aid kits. Quality bandages, of good size for many needs. | 11% Cheap and Easy May 9, 2017 For those of us that get cuts often it seems there aren't bandages around when you need them. I think I have found the solution. These bandages came in a 300 count. They are individually wrapped and stick well. the price was also very good. As a contractor I get a lot of cuts. Between me and my crew I'm sure these wont last long.I also have noticed that they do start to come unraveled a bit when being worn on your fingers and continuing to work. I cant say they are by any means heavy duty but for the price and amount I received I can change the bandage once or twice in a day if needed. Very Good and Economical Product May 7, 2016 This product works very well, at a fraction of the price of the major brands (and the store brands). I use them all the time. Good for the price August 29, 2015 These bandages are very good for the price. Sometimes they don't stick well if your skin is sweaty. They remove fairly easy and this is less painful for sensitive skin. They work fine. These work well but are lighter than the Band Aid ... August 9, 2014 These work well but are lighter than the Band Aid brand so show up on my skin (are more obvious) more than the Band Aid brand. Other than that they do the job. Good band aids at a great price December 22, 2013 Great band aids for a great price. I have ordered before and the reason for the 4 stars is due to them changing them and their not as sticky as before. | 10% Good price August 23, 2017 Package could of been better. Recieved the box with half of it smushed, which means half of the band-aids were bent/folded in certain areas. It even looked like some were missing, but were all there. Four Stars January 18, 2017 When I received my delivery the bandage box had been damages and there were bandages everywhere. Missing bandages January 17, 2017 They seem to be genuine band aid bandages. However the retailing packaging was beat up, and there were only 97 bandages so I'm taking off 1 star. Super sticky July 12, 2014 I work in a machine shop and people are always getting small cuts. These are the band aid of choice due to them being able to get wet and dry out without peeling off. I was told the last pack we got was so sticky that when the guy went to take the band aid off most of the adhesive stuck to his skin and didn't come off the on the band aid. The adhesive washed off with warm water. So these will stay stuck to you for a while. | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
Three Star Reviews: | 4% Adhesive could be stronger January 10, 2016 The shape of these bandages is perfect for my purposes, but the adhesive is not very strong. If you apply the bandage in an area that you don't move much, it will stay put. But if you apply it to an area which moves or stretches, the bandage will start to come up, and you can't re-adhere it. These are great bandages. However October 19, 2015 These are great bandages. However, I have no known allergies to anything and I do not have sensitive skin but I ended up with large red, itchy patches only where the bandage was adhered to my skin. So there must be a component of the adhesive on these bandages I am allergic/sensitive to. Other than that, the packaging is easy to manage, they don't fall off after 1 day even with it getting wet repeatedly. If it wasn't for the reaction to the adhesive I had I would have given these bandages 5 stars. | 10% Note these are 3" in length and 1" in width ... August 26, 2016 Note these are 3" in length and 1" in width. The "wound pad" itself is just 1"x1", with adhesive strips extending 1" to each side. Irritating but nice to have when you need a bandaid for a ... October 17, 2015 for the price their ok, but they really do not stick well. for a short period of time then starts to slowly fall off. Irritating but nice to have when you need a bandaid for a short period of time Not what I was looking for. September 29, 2015 I didn't like these band aids because they are too sheer. I was looking for something much heavier and more durable. I like the kind that are closer to skin color and a more stretchy fabric. These were plastic and very light in color. The company that supplied these to me was very understanding and refunded my money. Good customer service and prompt attention to my request. | 2% These got ordered by mistake through Alexa. At the ... August 24, 2017 These got ordered by mistake through Alexa. At the time I didn't know my Prime Account was connected to our Alexa. My 4 year old Grandsone, needed a bandaid and I guess she took him seriously. They showed up a few days later in the mail. Oh well, we can always use bandaids. Needless to say, I've disconnected this feature on Alexa now. I ordered to go with Piggy Paste, but noot ... July 12, 2017 I ordered to go with Piggy Paste, but noot worth the trouble of sending back. I could have picked these up locally. Pretty good stickem, but won't stand wetting. June 10, 2017 They are flexible and stick on clean dry skin, but wash right off in the shower. I'll keep these and order water proof ones in the future. Pack of 100? more like 92! April 16, 2017 What in the hell????I got the 100 count of band-aids, but I counted it as 92...??I was just curious to see if it was really 100 with no doubts in my head.. but come to find out, it was a pack of 92...I thought I had miscounted, but I counted for a good 4 times now...Please count yours if you buy this product! It may be that it is a 100 on average (some may get 102, some may get 93)Although I am ticked about the missing 8 bandages, it still works great Limited Usefulness-Not Good for areas exposed to wetness February 25, 2017 While they flex (slightly) and allow wound to breathe these bandaids have severe limitations. Not Waterproof or resistant.NOT RECOMMENDED for hands, fingers, thumbs or any body part that needs to be washed frequently. Ugly shiny gold color too! | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
Two Star Reviews: | 3% Proadvantage bandaides April 3, 2017 Bought them because I needed a larger bandaide. Didn't stick to skin if used with medications. States no Latex March 1, 2017 States no Latex..HA! These itch so bad after about an hour on my hand and arm..I had to remove them and tossed the whole box out, after 4 tries of using them.. sorry.. But they made my hand and arm itch like crazy!! Irritating. November 22, 2015 For something that's latex free and hypoallergenic, its adhesive sure gives me a skin rash.Just go to the local pharmacy. You'll be happier. | 8% Poor adhesive June 4, 2017 I tend to get ingrown toenails often enough to need a bunch of bandages in the house. I was using Bandaid brand tough strips, which are awesome but pricy. So, after some hunting on Amazon, i decided to try these. These are definitely inferior. Most of the time, they fall off my big toe within an hour of application. Tough strips literally stick on the same spot for days if i leave them. I suggest spending more and getting better quality bandages. Won't stick October 29, 2016 Poor adhesive, stays on my hand for 10 minutes. Returned them all. Won't buy again. Great amount for the Price October 24, 2016 Pro: Great amount for the Price. They stick well if you really press them down and then don't rub against them, get them wet, or pretty much do anything with them.Con: For all practical purposes, these are terrible. They hardly stick to you and they don't stick to themselves at all. If you have a cut on your finger, forget about trying to wrap these around it, you'll need a new one in 30 minutes. Adhesive fails quickly - don't stay on well August 31, 2016 I like to cover small cracks around my cuticles with fabric bandaids and hoped these 3" x 1" bandages would provide adequate protection, but unfortunately they don't stay on for more than an hour or two, before they loosen up and fall off. These bandaids also fall off if I get my hands wet, such as when I wash my hands. I don't plan to purchase them again, even though they were reasonably priced....it's worth it to me to pay more for a bandaid that stays on! These bandaids really don't stick. I have a rash ... July 8, 2016 These bandaids really don't stick. I have a rash I have to use bandaids on every night. I, literally, have to use medical tape OVER these bandaids to keep them on my finger. Sorry, not buying them again. Poor Quality September 16, 2015 I should have read and noted some of the negative reviews on this product...it is entirely possible that I got a bad batch, but the bandages I received are next to impossible to open as the paper shreds and sticks to the bandage as you are trying to remove it. Once the bandage is on, good luck getting it to say if there is any motion or even the slightest amount of moisture such as sweat. I would not recommend this product. | 2% Quality Is Lacking August 25, 2017 I ordered these because they are a "brand name" and the quality was great from the last box I used.Unfortunately, these are of poor quality. The cloth is much thinner that prior ones. The size is smaller. They don't adhere as well as before.They are also made in China. Outdated Technology and Poor Quality March 23, 2017 First time a J and J product has disappointed us. This fabric bandaid is not waterproof and often does not stick correctly. Not pliable enough for example to use on a finger or other awkward or angled area. Heavy looking. J and J makes so many varieties of this item...this is not the one for every day use in our family. We like the sheer or antibiotic bandaid. Thought we would try this type but big mistake. It is heavy duty in terms of the weight of the fabric. A disappointment. THESE HAVE LATEX IN THEM!! March 8, 2017 I am so disappointed in these bandaids. I purchased the fabric kind especially because I am allergic to latex. After using them I have broken out all over in welts and pain. In looking all over the box I finally found in small print on the side that there is latex in them. NOT GOOD!! Two Stars September 28, 2015 I was a little disappointed that the box of bandaids came opened and damn near ripped apart. No longer "Stuck on Ban-Aid brand". September 19, 2015 Maybe it's just me, but I really do not like these new "cloth like" band-aids. I grew up in the "I am stuck on Band-Aid, cuz Band-Aid's stuck on me" era where they were latex and they were amazing! These darn things fray all around the edges and God forbid they get even slightly damp! I bought them because we have our 5 grand children living with us and you can never have enough band-aids with that many kids, and because I have a nervous habit of picking at the skin all around my fingernails to the point of bleeding. I wanted to wear these around the tips of my fingers to stop me from picking, but they simply will NOT stay on! AND they fray so bad that I found myself pulling at every little string that was hanging off instead of picking at my fingers(which is better than ripping flesh off I guess) and I had to change every one of them out several times a day. The good old fashioned latex band-aids would have stayed on for at least a week. This is a case of "If it ain't broke, don't fix it." I understand that many people have a problem with latex, but do we ALL have to have no choice but to use "lesser quality" band-aids because of that??? Why can't they sell both types??? It's just incredibly aggravating. Adhesive needs improvement. March 28, 2015 I need to use cloth bandages due to an allergy to plastic bandages and adhesives. The cloth Band-Aids are okay except the adhesive won't stick to the cloth when wrapped around a finger for example. So then I have to wrap cloth tape around the bandage. At least the Band-Aids don't cause a rash! | 50% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
One Star Reviews: | 7% Almost useless August 2, 2017 These have very poor adhesive--they come off easily and will not re-stick. This is not the product they sent. I am ... March 19, 2017 This is not the product they sent. I am a medical professional and I would not buy again. These bandages stick very well, but are irritating to the skin. The ointment that I use comes through the bandage and unto my clothes. This ointment stains my clothes and does not come out. The pad comes loose, at times, from the bandage and is far too thin. I am searching for another product to buy. Low quality - cushion pad separated from adhesive strip March 1, 2017 Low quality - cushion pad separated from adhesive strip in under 4 hours use. Very disappointed! Don't buy from this Seller! January 30, 2017 Product not as originally advertised and I cannot use them. However, they do not accept returns. Terrible. adhesive does not stick to skin, starts coming off after just a few minutes. December 3, 2016 Looked like a good deal, but was not. The adhesive does not stick to skin, starts coming off after just a few minutes. I would not purchase again. | 14% not great, leaves a rash January 2, 2017 I didn't like these, they give my son rashes, and they leave weird residue on my skin. The price is tempting, but i'd rather spend more for something of higher quality. my whole family thought these were the worst bandages we ever used June 20, 2016 my whole family thought these were the worst bandages we ever used. No stick whatsoever - fell off seconds after you put them on. Would not buy again. Horrible. The paper that contains the bandaids are so ... September 8, 2015 Horrible. The paper that contains the bandaids are so thin that Im unable to open bandages by the tab, so the paper shreds. Then the paper that sticks to the adhesive is thin too, so it shreds making it almost impossible to for the bandage to stick to skin. Waste of money. Non-Sticky Bandages! November 26, 2014 You guys are crazy, five stars?! The bandages....DON'T STICK! You have two basic features to a bandage like this, the bandage area covering the injury/wound and the adhesive. Without one, the product becomes worthless, as this is. They don't stick.... | 3% Skin reaction July 6, 2017 After some repeated trials with this product, I found it causes reaction to my skin. A couple photos that show what happens during use and one day after the band aide was removed. These fabric band-aids have latex in them April 14, 2017 When someone purchases fabric bandages that is usually due to allergies to latex. It was not clear that these FABRIC band-Aids had latex in them which caused a horrible skin reaction on the arm where cancer had been removed. Uncool. Not Latex Free March 24, 2017 Caution: Even though this product comes up under an Amazon search for latex free bandages, these are NOT LATEX FREE! Package content is not the same quality that I have been buying many many times before February 20, 2016 Purchased these from seller "Medical Products Depot". Box and product look authentic but the band-aid edges start unraveling really fine fibers within minutes after being placed on fingers. I have been using this brand every winter, using new band-aids every day, to protect my finger tips, especially when folding laundry and doing other household tasks. Arizona indoor air is bone dry in winter and cracked finger tips are always a problem no matter what ointments/medications I have tried, so I have to cover my thumbs and index fingers.Picture has small flex fabric Band-Aid I bought from Walgreens (which work perfectly as usual). The large Band-Aid, bought from "Medical Products Depot", started fuzzing after folding one towel. I tried several but they all make a fuzzy mess which then catches on everything like microfiber. I have NEVER had a problem with these flex fabric bandages before and I was glad to find a good deal on them here but what I got instead is just garbage.I am sending samples to J&J with the lot number to have them investigate what is going on. What did I order? April 10, 2015 I will never order these bandages again ... not when I can get perfectly good, sticky, fabric bandages from family dollar that are much, much less expensive than these. actually, the description for these bandages is not clear at all. and the price? no way ... never again! :(to be fair, these bandages are a good size, but that's the only good point I can think of. i'll take the slightly smaller family dollar fabric bandages any day! I feel like I just lit a match to those extra dollars I spent on these. :( | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
Vote for Me | Vote for Me | Vote for Me | Vote for Me | Vote for Me | |
Pricing info | |||||
Old Price | |||||
Old Price | - | - | - | - | - |
Price | |||||
Price | $13.13updated: Mar 18, 2020 | $9.50updated: Mar 18, 2020 | $6.89updated: Mar 19, 2020 | $5.73updated: Mar 4, 2020 | $9.29updated: Mar 13, 2020 |
Features | |||||
Answered Questions | |||||
Answered Questions | - | - | - | - | |
Article Number | |||||
Article Number | 0812082807664 | 0616784361215 | 0381370044444 | - | 0647679163126 |
Binding | |||||
Binding | - | Health and Beauty | Misc. | - | - |
Brand | |||||
Brand | PRO | Dynarex | Band-Aid | ProAdvantage | McKesson |
Color | |||||
Color | - | - | Tan | - | - |
Currency | |||||
Currency | - | USD | USD | USD | USD |
Formatted Price | |||||
Formatted Price | - | $14.01 | $24.00 | - | - |
Height | |||||
Height | 110.2 in | 158.3 in | 153.5 in | 55.1 in | 158.3 in |
Label | |||||
Label | - | - | - | Pro Advantage | McKesson |
Length | |||||
Length | 196.8 in | 186.2 in | 70.9 in | 185.0 in | 393.7 in |
Manufacturer | |||||
Manufacturer | Pro | Dynarex | Band-Aid | Pro Advantage | McKesson |
Model | |||||
Model | - | - | 4444 | - | - |
MPN | |||||
MPN | TM80759 | 3612 | 4444 | P150120-BX | 4816 |
Number of Items | |||||
Number of Items | - | 3 | 1 | - | - |
Number of Parts | |||||
Number of Parts | TM80759 | 3612 | 4444 | P150120-BX | 4816 |
Product Group | |||||
Product Group | Health and Beauty | Health and Beauty | Health and Beauty | BISS | Health and Beauty |
Product Type | |||||
Product Type | PERSONAL_CARE_APPLIANCE | HEALTH_PERSONAL_CARE | HEALTH_PERSONAL_CARE | HEALTH_PERSONAL_CARE | HEALTH_PERSONAL_CARE |
PublicationDate | |||||
PublicationDate | - | 2011-09-15 | 2009-06-15 | - | - |
Publisher | |||||
Publisher | Pro | Dynarex | Band-Aid | Pro Advantage | McKesson |
Quantity | |||||
Quantity | - | 3 | 1 | 1 | 2 |
Release Date | |||||
Release Date | - | 2011-06-23 | - | - | - |
Reviews | |||||
Reviews | - | ||||
Score | |||||
Score | 9.4 | 8 | 9.4 | 6.6 | - |
Size | |||||
Size | - | 100 Count (Pack of 3) | 100 Count | - | - |
Studio | |||||
Studio | Pro | Dynarex | Band-Aid | Pro Advantage | McKesson |
Title | |||||
Title | - | - | - | PRO ADVANTAGE® FABRIC ADHESIVE BANDAGE - Adhesive Bandage, Strips, 1" x 3", 100/bx | McKesson 16-4816 Medi-Pak Adhesive Strip, Performance Fabric, 2" x 3" (2 boxes of 50) |
Warranty | |||||
Warranty | - | - | N | - | - |
Weight | |||||
Weight | 1.1 oz | 0.9 oz | 0.5 oz | 0.5 oz | 3.5 oz |
Width | |||||
Width | 118.1 in | 59.1 in | 236.2 in | 145.7 in | 158.3 in |
Feature | |||||
Feature | Ideally suited for areas where flexibility is important. Absorbent, breathable island pad cushions and protects wound. Long lasting adhesive stays secure even when wet. Latex free. | Non-stick pad is highly absorbent and helps to cushion wound. Latex free Economical | Provides extra flexibility Stretchable and comfortable fabric moves with you to fit better Flexible enough to move with you anywhere you go Ideal for bumps and scrapes Packaged for individual use and to replenish first aid stations and kits | This Listing Is For Adhesive Strip Qty : Box Of 50 Dimensions : 2 X 3 Inch , Color : Tan Material : Fabric , Shape : Rectangle , Sterility : Sterile Stretchable for added comfort. |
McKesson Performance Bandage...
Band-Aid Brand Adhesive...
Dynarex Adhesive Fabric Bandage,...
Johnson & Johnson Flexible...
Flexible LARGE Adhesive Bandages...
Band-Aid Adhesive Bandages,...
Coverlet Latex-Free Adhesive...
Performance Bandage Adhesive...
Band-Aid Brand Adhesive...
McKesson Performance Bandage...