Side by Side Comparison of: Panacea vs Woodland Imports vs Deco 79 vs Great Deal Furniture

This is great and especially fir the price. I love it.

I really like this set. It is sturdy and functional. I like the bronze finish. It was well packaged. I swore a few times trying to get the ties to cut but it arrived undamaged.

Just received the tool set and was so pleasantly surprised. It looked beautiful in the picture, but it's even better in person. We have a lot of wrought iron in our home (fixtures, railings, chandeliers, etc.) and wanted something somewhat heavy and iron. I actually realized this tool set had a bronzed finish after I purchased it...so I was nervous about how it would look. I thought it was all black. I pulled it out of the box and wow, it's perfect. The bronzing is randomly brushed, so it's not uniform, which I love. It looks custom and appears handmade. I absolutely love the detail of the curled edges on the stand, the ornate top, and even on the handle of each tool. There is one negative, which is minor in my case, but I have seen others comment on. The brush was not protected, so I see how it could get bent. Mine isn't 100% perfect, but it's fine and I'm not going to return it. I'm sure it will straighten out, it's not bad. But I see how others could be more bent...this would be my only recommendation to the seller as an improvement. Perhaps a band of cardboard around the brush bristles would be beneficial. The set comes with the 4 standard fireplace tools - the poker, brush, shovel and tongs. All of which are heavy duty and will do a wonderful job. Again, you have to see this in person to truly appreciate the detail...or zoom in to the handles of the tools. They are so well made but also beautiful. I am a huge fan of iron, so this is exactly what I was looking for. Fireplace tools aren't typically a centerpiece of your decor, but these at least are more than simply utilitarian...they are also attractive. I highly recommend this tool set. You will love them more in person!

Great product ,Very sturdy and actually stands up even when taking 1 of the 4 options off to use , unlike others that tip over because they can not even hold the weight they are supposed to hold !! Bought this set along with the 3 pannell fire place screen for our living room and looks great,added bonus it does not look cheap and think the price is really fair for the quality ! Would buy again !!

Great tool kit. I've built more than a few fires and used these tools successfully with the fires. They look nice, they are sturdy and seem to be the perfect fit for my fireplace. Great price too. I'm very happy with this purchase.

This set is perfect. We ordered it for ourselves and loved it so much we bought it for my sister and her husband. It's heavy duty while still being decorative. I'd recommend it to anyone looking for new fireplace tools.

So elegant. Really dresses up my fireplace.

This looks great on my fireplace. Nicely disguises or at least distracts from the ugly 80's brass fireplace. This was a little bigger than I was expecting which was a bit of a disappointment for me since now I don't have room to set anything on my hearth in front of this, but that's probably for the best. Seems high quality. I've gotten compliments on it. Definitely dressed up my living room and the price can't be beat.

Just as described. Very nice!

Exquisite!! My friends rave about it..it is elegant..It was delivered in 2 days.I am an amazon girl for life...make me a thirty anazon!

Shipped quickly and fits perfectly with our outdoor fireplace. While it is a gorgeous piece, we bought it to really keep our dogs from going in to fireplace and digging! It's definitely a sturdy enough deterrent for our two Labs.

I love this fireplace screen! I looked everywhere...including Garden Ridge and Home Depot! The other screens I found didn't compare to this one and especially for the price. I was a little leary of ordering because of some of the reviews and when I received mine it did have a couple of defects in the screen...looked like where the screen had overlapped and pressed but the company gave me an adjustment and I couldn't be happier with my purchase! And I am very ticky...ridiculously so! Perfect size and weight! And looks gorgeous! Thanks Amazon!

Really easy to put together and it is really sturdy. I like the design, simple but classy. I wanted to use it outside by our fire pit so I sprayed it with a clear outdoor spray paint. Very happy with my purchase.

Easy to assemble. I just piled 3 Cords of wood on it and it's holding up very well! Very nice color and scroll work. Looks exactly like in the picture.

It holds about a dozen medium logs stacked a little over the top. There are a couple of keys to successful assembly. Put the 4 bolts into the non-slotted holes first, then place the 4 into the slotted holes. (If necessary you can twist the frame slightly as below to make the holes line up).Then tighten all. Then, if the rack does not sit flat on the floor (i.e. it wobbles), lay it on its side with the opening facing you and look across the long bottom rails to see if they line up (i.e. are parallel). Kneel on the bottom rail on the floor and twist the side frames until they are parallel (pull the top of one panel toward you, while you push the other side down). It takes a little muscle, so get Ahhnold ("I'll be back") next door to help if necessary. Twist until it sits flat and then enjoy! I like this rack so much I just ordered a second one for the other side of the fireplace to hold kindling.

We really are impressed with this item. It was very easy to assemble upon arrival and looks great in the house whether it is full of wood or empty. We have received numerous compliments already. Great item and a great price, I definitely recommend it!

Fatwood fits on this log bin perfectly. I fit a large amount in front of the wood box. I hate those dainty little fatwood holders. You're always filling them up. Fill this bad boy up and forget about it. Looks good filled up and holds a ton of those little sticks. Looks great sitting by the fireplace. Really i think its too small for firewood, unless you're sticking decorative logs in it for just looks. But, that's just my opinion. Maybe, 4 small logs will fit in this little rack if your lucky of ash or maple to look decorative. So I use it to fill my fatwood logs to the brim.

I had no issues assembling this log bin. Eight screws and an Allen wrench were included. Although there was an instruction sheet, assembly was intuitive and all of the holes lined up. The bin holds an evening worth of wood and has a nice bronze appearance.

Very nice fireplace tools. My previous set from a different manufacturer had a problem of breaking where the handle screws into the rod. This set does not have that problem since they are all one pice, no screw in to the rod. Recommend these tools

The product is great. Packaging was horrible. It did not ship in an additional box, just the product packaging. The box was opened and torn upon arrival. Thankfully the product was not damaged and all pieces were accounted for. Tool set looks great and has all the essential tools needed for fires.

The fireplace set was delivered in a timely manner and the set is very nice for the price. My only real issue with them is that the stand isn't quite stable. One foot does not touch the ground and it therefore rocks a bit, but not too much. The other issue I have is that the color isn't as black as I had hoped from seeing the picture. It's more gold than I would like, but that's my personal preference.

Good product. The only reason I didn't give it 5 stars is that the color isn't what I imagined... Instead of brushed bronze, it looks more like a copper color that has been painted over with black brush strokes. Not ideal, but still it was a good alternative to buying a black iron set. Our living room has more browns than blacks, so this was a good compromise. We've only used it a few times, but it has worked great. No assembly required - the tips and handles are all one piece so you don't have to worry about screwing them on, and then having them fall off in the fire!

I really like this set. Shipping was on time and it arrived in tact. To my big surprise I opened the box to find it was fully assembled. Yay! It's pretty rare to purchase anything these days that you don't have to assemble yourself. With that being said my set is sturdy and the legs are even. The only negative is the color. I did what another reviewer mentioned and spray painted the set black. It turned out perfect. If I could have ordered it in black I would have given it 5 stars. Still happy with the purchase though.

This sturdy fireplace tool set is well made of all-welded solid wrought iron bar stock and is of very high quality. No flimsy screwed-on base plate to get loose and wobbly. And, no assembly required. The four legs are set wide enough to provide a very stable platform, and the hooks are deep enough to hold the four wrought iron tools securely. The dark bronze finish has a pleasing patina with subtle accents of lighter antique bronze color. The scroll work is uniformly well done, and closely matches the scrolls on our fireplace screen, even though the screen is made by another manufacturer.The only negative is that I would rather have tongs with a top hinge, but that is just my preference and does not mean that the tongs are not of good quality. In reality, strong well made top-hinged tongs are very hard to find, and most tool sets have the kind of tongs supplied with this set. So, it's not really a big deal.All-in-all, a very handsome and well-made fireplace tool set at a great price.

Great for keeping my grandchildren away from the fireplace.

It's beautiful and we really like how light it is. It's great.

Came in on time and just as nice as I expected worked perfect for fireplace

Looks really nice, lightweight without being flimsy (wont topple easily nor would it squash a child or pet if it did... well maybe a cat or small dog). packaged securely. The only blemish on the item is a patch on one of the side panels to cover a hole in the screen, the patch is about 3/4 inch square and covers a 3/8 inch hole. Fortunately the location behind the scroll work makes it hardly noticeable, but I wouldn't have bought it full price that way in a store.Overall I like the product and would get it again, or for someone else.

This screen is beautiful! No question regarding that. I was looking for a new screen and this was advertised as "handmade" (per the description) and the price was very reasonable based on the actual list price.However, as lovely as it is...it IS NOT handmade. The tag attached to it (like an item tag in a store) and even the box it came in said "made in China". I am disappointed it was not handmade as advertised, but it is quite nice. The "list price" is overly inflated, but it is a nice screen and the shipping was fast with Prime.

This was very pretty to look at if you are looking for the color black, it was a little too light in weight for a large open fireplace for me. But like I mentioned it nice to look at and it doesn't clog the view of the fire.

Very nice. Not solid but it's definitely ver nice for the price.

This is a great log holder. We were in an apartment when we used this product.We primarily were looking for something that looked nice, and would hold all our duralogs rather than keeping them in the box.This product really does the job. It is great quality, and looks really nice.Keep in mind that it isn't large, so will hold enough logs for convenience.I recommend this log holder if you are looking for a nice looking, good quality product that will hold several logs for convenience.

So, it's true, this item has some quirky assembly issues. Mine arrived with no nuts for the bolts. All the bolts and holes lined up just fine (it looks like they've elongated the top set of holes to accommodate manufacturing slippage). The rack is "square" once put together, and it looks just as I expected it would. Very nice. It is small, but that's what I bought it for -- to hold smaller pieces of wood for my chiminea. Anyway, because of the missing bolts, Amazon gave me the choice of replacing the item or giving me a 20% refund. I opted for the $8.55 refund, drove to the local hardware store and bought 8 bolts (and washers) for less than $2. It's now put together and I'm pleased with the final result.

When I first took it out of the box we said uh oh...it's too small like the reviews said. Then I put it together, it literally to 5 minutes if that, and we said hmmm maybe not too small. Long story short we think it's great. It could stand to be a few inches taller but as you'll see in the pictures it holds 12 normal size logs pretty easily and I'll probably pile on 2 more next trip to the log rack.. We bought a half cord at the beginning of winter and these are 12 random logs from that cord. We also took a few pictures because we find that helps us a lot. We put a fairly large patio chair from Target behind it for a few shots to help with the size.

We purchased this wood holder for our breezeway. We have a fireplace we use mostly for atmosphere in our living room and needed a place to store some wood to keep it dry until we needed it. Running outside to the wood pile all winter was not an option nor was piling wood in the corner of the room.This item was priced right and VERY easy to assemble. It fits the planned space perfectly. One note. Please look at the dimensions of the product before ordering. This is a SMALL wood bin. We burn pieces of wood no more then 2-3" round, NOT "logs". If you were to stack logs in this unit you may get 6-8 into it before it's full. That's all it will hold of full size logs. However, that is not what we use it for so it was great for us.

Product arrived as advertised. Assembly was easy, took me about 15 minutes. Assembly involves installing 8 Allen screws to attach the sides to the base.. All of the holes lined up perfectly. Some reviewers had issues with screw alignment. You need to leave all of the screws a bit loose until you have them all started on each side, then snug them up. I can't wonder if some people who had problems were tightening each screw as they installed it, leaving no "wiggle room" to get the other screws started. The brushed Bronze finish looks nice, but I'm temped to spray paint it flat black to match my wood stove, I'll wait awhile before I change anything. This log bin is sturdy, sits flat with no wobble, and holds approximately 12 split logs. I think the picture makes it look wider that it actually is. It is 18" wide by 16" tall. It is made in China.

These tools are well made, but the finish described as "brushed bronze" is really a tacky gold with some splotchy black paint, it looks really fake. I bought some high heat, flat black paint at the big box store and painted the tools, they look a lot better now. Too much effort and cost to ship them back.

Pros: Heavy duty, nice finish, good tools, extra hooks so we could also hang our bellows Cons: legs uneven and metal is too hard to bend to even them out. I may have to glue something to the shortest leg if the rocking bothers us too much.

I love the look, but the stand wobbles. Had it for a few months now and it just doesn't balance properly. Good enough for its purpose, the pieces are all sturdy quality tools, but I wish I had spent a little more money for a better quality stand

Not what I expected for the price.

THIS FIRPLACE TOOL SET WAS ORDERED JUST FOR "LOOKS"....WE HAD A FAKE FIREPLACE BUILT IN! THE SET LOOKS GREAT, HOWEVER, THE LEGS ARE UNEVEN SO IT WOBBLES IF TOUCHED. DON'T KNOW WHAT TO SAY ABOUT UTITILY OF THE UNIT......VALUE IS GOOD AND APPEARANCE SATISFACTORY.GOD BLESS AMERICA

It's nice as the pictures show - but it arrived in undamaged packaging yet had a dent in it. It's hard to see the dent because we also have black marble around our fireplace, so probably not bother returning this.

Quality was ok, not high end like I expected. Screen is beautiful and had only one small flaw.

I'm torn on this because I really love the screen, but I have had to return it twice. The first one had a blemish about the size of a quarter on it. The second was really bent on the top and there were numerous holes in the screen. I'm just debating on if I want to try this one one more time, or if I should move along!

The build itself is nice quality for the money but I was under the impression the background screen would be lighter it's all black, still looks nice but not what I thought.

Would have been better but it had scratches all over and you can see where someone tried to cover it up with spray paint and did not do a good job. Noe that I cleaned it up and got it all same color it looks good.

The pictures look like it's a bronze color, but it's not. It's black. All the products came in bronze, but this one arrived and looks out of place.

Easy to assemble and it works well for small amounts of wood.It was clean this item had been repackaged. The plastic ties that held everything in place had already been cut and some pieces were already out of the plastic covers.

I was very disappointed with the finish on the panacea 15919. The base is black, and then a yucky gold paint is swiped over it with a large brush - tacky and not as pictured. However, I assembled the log rack and sprayed it with one coat of Rustoleum all-in-one in Oil Rubbed Bronze (about $7 from Home Depot) and it looks great now. No drips, no smears - the Rustoleum stuff is great.

I guess the only way to describe the appearance of this item is "crude." The finish looks like it was painted gold, then "antiqued" with brown paint. I'll probably take it outside and spray some dark bronze paint on it when the weather gets nicer. The construction is also crude; the welds are not only visible, they're obvious. Of course, I have a critical eye, and my guests probably won't be inspecting my log rack closely.I did not have the problem with alignment of parts and holes that others reported. I did have a bit of trouble getting the screws started in the threaded holes without cross-threading them. The screws have allen heads; there's an allen wrench included, but the position of the screws means you get less than 3/4 turn with each swing of the wrench. That made assembly a fiddly operation.The rack is both big enough and strong enough to hold an evening's firewood. The legs have plastic feet of just the right hardness to be used on hardwood floors.I've had some critical things to say, but this cost $40 or so, and I looked log racks costing $300-400, so I think I got my money's worth! (However, the price went down a buck and a half the day mine came. Gripe, grumble...)

This Chinese product, like many, WAS NOT made to good tolerances, so the holes don't line up correctly. After attaching the threaded bolts to one side of either end's railing, the other side screws (bolts) holes DO NOT line up with the threaded inserts that are welded into the metal. I had to devise an appropraite length sliding stretcher to wedege in place so as to get the holes to line up to screw the bolts in. Then I had to get one of my own allen keys when their cheap one started slipping. Then on the other end, I had to file one of the holes a bit so the bolt would even go through the hole. In other words, like many Chinese products, the quality control SUCKS! After assembly, I like the unit and it seems like it is strong and should last decently, if none of the Chinese spot welds break from the additional pressure they are under from being stretched so as to line up the holes. I could have also taken one of my drills with a much larger drill bit and possibly made the holes on one side of each end rail larger (quite a bit larger) so that the bolts could be made to line up, but that would have meant a whole lot of metal drill dust that I did not feel like cleaing up afterwards. The 3 stars are for the final product. The rating for quality control and therefore ease of assebly would have been ZERO

The assembled product is nice and sturdy, but wow - was it a pain to assemble! There are just eight bolts to screw in, but the frame & tray are a bit warped so it was an awkward two-person job to hold the thing with holes aligned and get the bolt threaded in straight. Making it worse, the allen wrench that comes with it doesn't really fit well up in the little corner where the bolts are.Once it's assembled, it looks OK, but the finish is rather cheap-looking and the joints look very roughly spot-welded. When it's filled with wood and you see it across the room, it looks nice. Close-up - not so much.It's still a decent value and does the job.

This is a good product for the price. It is considerably cheaper than other comparable products. This one doesn't come with the fireplace tools, which I already had, so that might contribute to it being cheaper. Assembly was quick but the parts did not align well. I even had to leave one screw out because I could not force an alignment of the holes. It didn't matter, still works well and will be sturdy enough to hold as much wood as you could stack on it, without the wood falling off.

The dimentions of all the tools are small compared to a higher quality set.

My stand is very sturdy and the look is nice. I am not really happy with the color. It has a lot more bronze then I would like. The photo makes it look darker. I also own the Panacea brand log bin in the same brushed bronze and they don't really match. My log bin has a lot less bronze and is darker (which I like) I saw a cheaper one I liked at lowes. should of just bought that one.

Would not recomend this product. While it looks nice, the four scroll legs on the stand are all different lengths. As a result the stand is always leaning so much that it looks like someone bent it.

Quality bad ..

This fireplace screen is really beautiful. The reason I give it only two stars is because the screen that I got is damaged. It has several holes in it.

Pretty screen but very poorly made. We bought for 65 and noticed a recent increase in the price. Definitely not worth more than that. It came damaged and I had to return it. Hoping for something better in quality.

This is a pretty fireplace screen, don't get me wrong, but it is cheaply made. I should have gone with my gut feeling after reading previous reviews. It is not worth the money I paid for it. It's very light weight and easily bends. We had bought one at Target that was much better quality and better weight for less that we were replacing for this one only because it was taller. I would suggest you keep looking if you don't want to be disappointment.

Pull out the log bin out of the package and it looks easy to put together. I screwing one side in and go do the other side and there are no wholes. I measure and make my own holes on one side. This was very inconvenient!!! I have a drill, but I had to go buy a different bit to drill the proper size of the hole. I normally have good experiences with buying things online and have not really had any problems. I also ABSOLUTELY hate dealing with the hassle of sending things back so I try to make it work. This was ridiculous buying something that is expected to have predrilled holes and it did not.

So small!!!

I was disappointed to find that this log bin had to be assembled with bolts which makes me wonder about how well it will hold up with constant dumping of wood into it. I expected it to be already set to go with perhaps the parts welded together as it looks like iron in the picture shown. I also find the color of this log bin to be different than the one depicted. My rack is not almost black as portrayed, but is rather a dark grey tone with almost slipshod goldish color streaking all over especially on the curved base plate. I am considering returning this item but don't know if a different one would be any better. Perhaps they all have this terrible streaking. I would not buy another one, that is for certain. As for the strength and integrity of this log bin.....that is to be determined.

This appears to be a lovely option for a log bin; however, it required huge effort due to poor quality of parts. could not assemble properly.

Screw alignment seems to be the prevailing complaint in these reviews. Three corners align properly leaving the alignment for the screws on the fourth corner off by almost a full inch, they had welded the mounting plate on upside down. (The slotted hole should be at the upper part of the mounting, one of mine was at the bottom). Had to drill and shape new holes before it could be assembled. If the unit had not otherwise been as nice as it is we would have returned it.

This item looked great and had some great reviews. I received it and it does look nice. However, rather smaller than I expected. I doubt it will hold much of good size logs. Maybe two would have done the job.The assembly on this item is beyond annoying. It was hard to line the things up and the little tool made it a tedious job to get the screws in. I am not sure why they didn't use a regular phillips screw driver top. I would rather pay more money to get one that is already assembled than deal with this one again.I assembled a large medicine cabinet quicker than these little screws to put the ends on it.Not bad item for price but I'd shop around next time.

For starters, the finish on this set is not bronze. It has this yellowish finish on it, not sure how to describe it. But the major disappointment was the product tag that said made with a chemical known to cause cancer. Returned immediately!

This set was supposed to be bronze,but it was actually black with a spattering of gold paint.

Broom Broke after two weeks.

They claimed it matched the scroll fireplace screen I got and it didn't. I sent it back.

The feet of the stand are unstable - only 3 of the 4 feet are balanced on the ground. I am disappointed, as this is a Christmas gift for my boyfriend. I'm hoping they'll replace the stand ASAP.

I received a severely beat up box with a broken stand and two missing tools. I contacted customer service on 11/5 and I am STILL waiting for a return shipping label and refund. I looked and this item is only available for return until 11/27 so it seems they are dragging feet for a reason. Completely unacceptable.The set itself is very pretty ans would go wonderful with my decor but I would NOT purchase from this particular store.

Did not meet my expectations, product is poorly made, flimsy metal is thin

The screen has three very obvious holes in it, one of which is front and center, which has a horribly apparent patch job. I don't know know if this is what was meant by their description of "handmade...blemishes", but the item is being returned. Also, the screen is black. It looks more bronze in the picture. Lastly, does not stand evenly. No thanks. You get what you pay for.

The fireplace screen is flimsy with a capital "F", and is poorly finished. If your screen is going to be in a lighted area, save yourself time and trouble because this is a piece of junk. Please look at pictures supplied. The metal surrounding the screen is poorly soldered and painted. The screen has areas where the solder fills in the holes in the screen. If your screen will be in an area with a lot of light, you will NOT be happy with this screen. As I was cleaning the screen I noticed there are areas where they burned holes thru the screen, but attached it to frame anyway. This must have been done by child laborers. Pathetic workmanship.Regardless, I am keeping this screen because I mainly wanted a black screen. I will spend the hour or so it will probably take me, inserting a pin into the solder covering every little hole in sections of the screen plus I will spray paint it to improve the look. My fireplace is in a poorly lighted situation or I'd be sending this piece of junk back. If you look at it from a distance, it looks ok.

As soon as the box arrived I was quite surprised as the description nor one single customer review stated that the middle panel curved inward at the top towards the fireplace opening. This may seem like a safety feature for a fireplace screen, to curve towards the flames to keep sparks inside the fireplace, however this prevents the side panels from being able to lay flush against the opening thus leaving a 3 inch gap between the screen and fireplace. Sparks can easily escape through these two gaps. Because we never leave a fire unattended and make sure the fire is completely extinguished before going to bed or leaving the house, you all should do the same by the way, we were not going to send the screen back.The screen looks very nice in front of a lit fireplace and the construction appears to be fairly solid. However, after just 3 weeks of ownership, and about 4 uses of this screen the left side panel fell completely off while I added another log to the fire. I went to reattach the panel only to notice that the part the pin that joins the panels broke completely off. This part was welded and it literally just fell off. There is no way to repair this except to weld it once again. I am not a welder nor do I have access to a welder. I could have returned this product but return postage would have cost at least $40 which is a bit expensive. For now we will just MacGyver it by wiring the panel back on until we find another screen that is actually large enough for our extra large fireplace opening.Overall, the screen cost approximately $90 but was supposedly originally a $400 screen. I am sorry, but there is no way this screen could ever be worth $400 unless it could add logs to the fire for you. I am hard-pressed to say that this screen is even worth the $90 price tag. If it had not broke after 3 weeks then the price would have been worth it.

This screen looks nice when set up but it came with a defect. Looks like the manufacturer tore the metal mesh screen and tried to patch it. It also started to rust after a few days.

This product came in with a hole in the screen, but beside that, it is way too light to safely put in front of a fire.

Poor quality cheap and flimsy build. Attractive look.

Ridiculous Price for this very tiny firewood stand. waste of space and time

I received my firewood bin two days ago and it had no hardware to put it together. It was supposed to come with 8 screws and 8 nuts and came with none! I am very frustrated. Do not buy this product.

No screws. No way to put it together!Looks like it's been partially used as one of the zip ties that holds it together has been cut.

Defective- metal holes not punched all the way through the metal, so no way to put screws through and attach. Amazon very good about accepting a return and giving a refund.

The welds were substandard to the point that is fell apart in the mail.