Side by Side Comparison of: Penny Loves Kenny vs Forever

I haven't worn them out yet, but I did try them on and walk around a bit. I LOVE LOVE LOVE the way they fit!!! Even thought it is a pretty high heel, you can still walk in them (if you're usually a heel person). I usually have a hard time finding over the knee/knee high boots that will fit my calves, but surprisingly these fit PERFECT! I usually order a 7.5 in shoes so I went ahead and did the same with these boots and they fit as expected. Probably can wear these with normal trouser sock but not those super thick winter kind. It's still warm here so I will have to wait until it gets a bit cooler to wear them out comfortably. I'm 5'2 and these come up maybe a little less than an inch above my knee cap and the back sits comfortably at the crease of my knee and isn't rough or annoying. Will probably order them in the gray color as well! DEFINITELY a must have and great deal fort the price!

I didn't have high expectations and was pleasantly surprised when got these boots, these looks pretty good, a little on the larger side, I usually wear 7.5 but always buy size 8 if it's a pointed toe, no need to go half size up here, fits perfect, wore these to a mall, walked for a few hours and was fine.

Nice boots. My wife is 5'2", 120 lbs, size 5+. These were size 6 and they fit with room enough to wear socks or leggings.

Really cute over the knee boots! I wanted the grey one but I was unsure cause the photo doesn't really look grey but once you receive the boots and see it in person, it is. I'm 5'0" and these boots were the right height I was looking for! I somewhat have thunder thighs but it didn't look weird at all. I think these boots are sexy and would definitely recommend it.

This boot is amazing. For the price this boot has an extremely high quality look to it. If I saw somenone out with these boots on I would have never guess that they are so reasonably priced. I was hesistant to order them because of the heel; however that was the least of my concerns as if you are an avid 4 and above girl like myself, you should have no problem navigating in these bad boys. I am strongly considering ordering the black ones as this boot is just to amazing to not have both colors. The only thing that is stopping me is that I own one pair of thigh high and one pair of knee length black suede boots and don't want to be greedy. All I can say is get this boot, you will not be disapointed.

very lovely boots, i love them.

in my personal opinion i love "peny loves kenny" shoes, and these boots are not the exeption, they are so so so beautiful, elegant, and super affortable, but the reason what i givethem 4 stars is because i choose my usual size, and it fits really tight, and so painful, after a couple times wearing them, the fabric fall apart in one side, but i fix it and, now are my fav

I wear a size 8 in women's shoe but I can never get it right with the heel sizing ! Anyway I got an 8.5 and in glad I did ! If I would have got the 8 then I wouldn't be comfortable in them and they would be too snug . They're just fitted .. I think a 9 would have been fine too , like perfect . Anyway they're fine ! It's not I comfy but if I had room then it'll be even better ! If you have narrow feet you may be ok but still order a HALF size up . The shoe itself is cute and well made for the most part . The heel is the perfect height . I HOPE THIS HELPS .

So tight on the calf I couldn't get them on. But I am giving 4 stars because they are BEAUTIFUL and sexy looking boots. If I had smaller calves I would've loved them. My calves are not huge though. So these will really only work for women with very small calves.

Price was great for these boots. I needed a cute over the knee boot to wear out for Girls night out. They are taller than what I usually wear but I need them for the look and not for comfort hehe. I wear 81/2 but bought a 9 so I could wear a thick sock or insole inside the boot.

For the price, the quality is good enough to wear for a few seasons if you take care of them. The style is very trendy and fits true to size. I wish the boots came above my knees (but I guess I'd need to then get "thigh highs") but they fit right at my knees and look great, providing a slender look to my shape/legs.The material is acceptable (suede-like) and fit the calves perfectly. My calves aren't small but aren't big either.The heel height is perfect and arch as well.They hurt after a couple of hours but they're high heels so it's not a big deal.Overall, a great buy.

The boots look good but the fit is a little off. The cut of the shoe seems more narrow than normal. I have muscular calves and can't wear these with pants or thick leggings.

Very cute boots, however I wore out the heel cap on the first wear. I will be repairing them and wearing them again because they look great!

nothing special. good for smaller feet

Boots are beautiful and come above my knees and I am 5'3. I wear a size 6 and order 6.5 and they fit a tad tight. I tried them on and I couldn't walk without my feet feeling uncomfortable especially in my arch. If I placed an arch support insole maybe that would've helped but I didn't try it. I returned them that same day.

Boots are really cute, but they dont fit. I bought my usual 6.5 and they are a big snug. Also the side zippers are hard to zip up. I dont have big calfs but the boots were tight around that area. I had them on for about 5 mins and my feet started to hurt.

I'm so bummed about these boots! They are adorable but I ordered my size and when they came, while they did fit my foot, it was tight and pinched in the toes and that was without socks. More importantly though I couldn't get these much higher than my knee despite being marked as a 16" circumference for the calves. Unless you have petite or thin legs, or you don't mind a slouchy/bunched look, I'd keep searching, I know I am!

These heels are hot as hell!! but they are not the most comfortable. The arch is very high, so I can only wear this for just a few hours. also, the bottom of the shoe is not made for smooth surfaces, they can be very slippery. Be careful!

Stiff

Very uncomfortable. The toe points up instead of sitting flat, which knocks of your balance. The ankles are uncomfortable as well. I am 5'5 and weigh 138 so I'm not a big person.

I just received this and it is made very poorly. I can see the glue on the seam and the base looks as flimsy as construction paper. Granted for the price I didnt expect great quality, but this is just ridiculous. Shipping out to return tomorrow!!!! DO NOT BUY

Not comfortable

Yes, it's true. They look nice, however, at the front of the boots down where the ankle is, it sticks out so it had a cheap make up and look to it. I didn't like way it looked at all so I returned them.

Terrible quality. I wore them twice and the heel tips broke off. Not worth the money

I didn't even wear these once. The sole was really, really, really thin, and I'm not sure they would have held up to outside wear. Also, the glue to between the upper part and the sole was applied very messily. The glue at the seams was smeared onto the upper as high as half an inch. Also, the heel tip, the plastic part that you walk on was really, really cheap and absolutely NOT durable enough for more than one or two wears.

These boots are super cute and were very comfy but I wore them one time and the heel looks horrible. The fabric started coming off and the tip on both heels busted.

Too small and uncomfortable. They are pretty steep, walked in the house from one room to next and they hurt. Only barely covered knee and im only 5'1. Also ordered 6 1/2 and were way to small. And I'm normally a 6 or 6 1/2. Returning.

They are like stiff pointy blocks. I have 30+ pairs of heels and boots of all different heights shapes and materials. These are awful. My first complaint is that if you look at my picture I can back up my claim that you can't walk comfortably in these because they are so stiff and the tips are so pointy and DONT EVEN TOUCH THE FLOOR WHILE MY FEET ARE FLAT. When shoes are like this with the toe off the floor, it's what makes a heel impossible to walk in. Unless you lift your knees up high abc march like a soldier. There's no give in the entire foot area it's like bricks on my feet with a high uncomfortable heel.The first pair I tried ordering never arrived but it said delivered on my account for 3 days. Amazon did resend a new pair immediately replacing them but I wish I had just gotten a refund. These are witch boots and as an avid heel lover, these are the worst kind. And the most pointy shoes I've ever seen in my life.Also If you live up North where it rains a lot or snows a lot you better not even try these. Look at my other picture of the bottom of the sole. It's a felt tear drop shape. That's what they call "tread".. Haha I couldn't walk across my bathroom floor without almost slipping. I've never been more disappointed in anything I've ever bought online in my life. And u buy A LOT. You can see most of my reviews are very good.

Disappointed ..especially from all the good ratings loose where the ankle section and calves and I got 8th 1 size smaller also . Will be returning it I also for both colors thinking it'll be what I expected..