Compare | |||
Compare All Features Differing |
Side by Side Comparison of: Band-Aid vs New-Skin vs Steri-Strip
Learn More | |||
Learn More | |||
Rating info | |||
eComparisons Score | |||
eComparisons ScoreThe "Comparison Score" Is calculated based on the average number of times this item was compared with other items in this category by our users | 9.4 | 7.4 | 0 |
User Rating (Amazon) | |||
User Rating (Amazon) | |||
Five Star Reviews: | 83% 1 inch wide Band-Aids, No Small Ones! March 9, 2017 My favorite! The others don't perform nearly as well as Band-Aids. Also, for me I always use the larger band aids and am left with a box is smaller assorted sizes. Now, I can just order the 1 inch wide size in a good quantity by itself without the assorted smaller sizes! I'm then able to supplement the assorted boxes with the ones I use the most. Nice to Buy Just the Size I Want March 4, 2017 It's hard where we live to find a box of Band-Aids that are all the same--the size everybody actually uses. All we can find are small pricey boxes or the large variety boxes. I hate the variety boxes. All that means is that you get a lot of bandaids you can't use because of their weird sizes and shapes. This is just what I wanted and I'll order again. Don't go cheap when it comes to band aids December 25, 2016 These are very high quality, pretty much what we expect from Johnson and Johnson. It will absorb any remaining blood from the cut, and will actually stay on for the full day. Do not get the band aids from the dollar store, and get these instead. It is well worth spending a few bucks more. This is still cheaper than what you would pay for these at the pharmacy. STRONG, DURABLE & "No Tears" SECURE November 9, 2016 These are my favorite Band-Aid. They have great coverage, wear comfortably, and adhere well with near-painless removal. I have been using the product, non-stop, for adult and grandchild injuries for nine years. The flexible fabric moves with your skin, and is strong. When there's a need to wear one a little bit longer than usual, the product holds up to the job. I truly think Johnson & Johnson has cornered the market, here. If your little ones still long for pirates and princesses, slap the flimsy, trendy ones over these flexible, fabric bandaids. You'll get the strength. And durability I've described along with the smiles kid bandages offer up! Proper Bandaids that hurt when you remove them. August 19, 2013 Let's be frank--Band Aids are supposed to hurt when you take them off. That's how you know they'll stay on. It also reminds you to wear shin guards next time. These are great bandaids that stay on for days, even after showering and exercise. If you're a man and you want a bandaid that sticks, here you go. Fabric bandages June 7, 2013 Given my way, I would rid the world of the pseudosticky plastic garbage band-aids and replace them all with fabric. The only problem would be putting all the cool designs on them. If you do not require artwork on your minor cuts, buy these fabric band-aids. | 51% | 0% There are no reviews yet |
Four Star Reviews: | 10% Good price August 23, 2017 Package could of been better. Recieved the box with half of it smushed, which means half of the band-aids were bent/folded in certain areas. It even looked like some were missing, but were all there. Four Stars January 18, 2017 When I received my delivery the bandage box had been damages and there were bandages everywhere. Missing bandages January 17, 2017 They seem to be genuine band aid bandages. However the retailing packaging was beat up, and there were only 97 bandages so I'm taking off 1 star. Super sticky July 12, 2014 I work in a machine shop and people are always getting small cuts. These are the band aid of choice due to them being able to get wet and dry out without peeling off. I was told the last pack we got was so sticky that when the guy went to take the band aid off most of the adhesive stuck to his skin and didn't come off the on the band aid. The adhesive washed off with warm water. So these will stay stuck to you for a while. | 12% A medicine cabinet must have June 17, 2017 When a bandage strip just won't work, this will keep a wound clean and covered. It works well witj my flats. I still yet ... May 10, 2017 It works well witj my flats. I still yet to try it with my heels. I thinks it may work well but I hopefully will try it for heels soon . Good product for certain uses May 3, 2015 Loud but effective for places where a bandaid is difficult to use, i.e., hand, wrist. The smell might bother some. Good product. | 0% There are no reviews yet |
Three Star Reviews: | 2% These got ordered by mistake through Alexa. At the ... August 24, 2017 These got ordered by mistake through Alexa. At the time I didn't know my Prime Account was connected to our Alexa. My 4 year old Grandsone, needed a bandaid and I guess she took him seriously. They showed up a few days later in the mail. Oh well, we can always use bandaids. Needless to say, I've disconnected this feature on Alexa now. I ordered to go with Piggy Paste, but noot ... July 12, 2017 I ordered to go with Piggy Paste, but noot worth the trouble of sending back. I could have picked these up locally. Pretty good stickem, but won't stand wetting. June 10, 2017 They are flexible and stick on clean dry skin, but wash right off in the shower. I'll keep these and order water proof ones in the future. Pack of 100? more like 92! April 16, 2017 What in the hell????I got the 100 count of band-aids, but I counted it as 92...??I was just curious to see if it was really 100 with no doubts in my head.. but come to find out, it was a pack of 92...I thought I had miscounted, but I counted for a good 4 times now...Please count yours if you buy this product! It may be that it is a 100 on average (some may get 102, some may get 93)Although I am ticked about the missing 8 bandages, it still works great Limited Usefulness-Not Good for areas exposed to wetness February 25, 2017 While they flex (slightly) and allow wound to breathe these bandaids have severe limitations. Not Waterproof or resistant.NOT RECOMMENDED for hands, fingers, thumbs or any body part that needs to be washed frequently. Ugly shiny gold color too! | 10% Good product, but its brush-on version is superior July 16, 2016 I bought the spray=on version of New Skin to compare against the older, brush-on style. Here are my findings:PROS:+ Like the brush-on New Skin, this product is great for quickly sealing and protecting cuts on pars of your body where traditional band-aids don't work well -- joints, especially fingers and hands.+ The product dries in about 3 minutes into a mostly-clear, somewhat flexible synthetic "scab."+ Because it is a spray, there is little or no risk of cross-contamination between users, in contrast to pathogens that might conceivably be communicated between users sharing the brush-on model. However, the antiseptic properties of New Skin itself make it unlikely any pathogen would survive that contamination route.+ In contrast to Band-aids, you can shower or wash a cut protected by New Skin, and it won't get soggy or wash away.CONS:- Hard to aim the spray in exactly the right place.- Often squirts on more New Skin than you really want. requiring extended drying times.- After a day or so, New Skin tends to crack and flake, requiring trimming (I use nail scissors) or re-sealing with more New Skin.CONCLUSIONS:New skin is far superior to Band-aids for cuts on your hands, elbows, knees, or feet. However, the spray-on version of New Skin is inferior to its brush-on version because it does not provide sufficient control over where and how much New Skin is applied.This product is good, but the brush-on version is better.. Not a breakthrough July 26, 2014 If you're expecting a liquid skin that deals with the mess of protecting cuts and bruises from elements - yes , it can do an OK job.Ber in mind in can be washed off, tears easily once cure and flakes in the process. Cannot say if any cuts I took were faster to close. Oh well. | 0% There are no reviews yet |
Two Star Reviews: | 2% Quality Is Lacking August 25, 2017 I ordered these because they are a "brand name" and the quality was great from the last box I used.Unfortunately, these are of poor quality. The cloth is much thinner that prior ones. The size is smaller. They don't adhere as well as before.They are also made in China. Outdated Technology and Poor Quality March 23, 2017 First time a J and J product has disappointed us. This fabric bandaid is not waterproof and often does not stick correctly. Not pliable enough for example to use on a finger or other awkward or angled area. Heavy looking. J and J makes so many varieties of this item...this is not the one for every day use in our family. We like the sheer or antibiotic bandaid. Thought we would try this type but big mistake. It is heavy duty in terms of the weight of the fabric. A disappointment. THESE HAVE LATEX IN THEM!! March 8, 2017 I am so disappointed in these bandaids. I purchased the fabric kind especially because I am allergic to latex. After using them I have broken out all over in welts and pain. In looking all over the box I finally found in small print on the side that there is latex in them. NOT GOOD!! Two Stars September 28, 2015 I was a little disappointed that the box of bandaids came opened and damn near ripped apart. No longer "Stuck on Ban-Aid brand". September 19, 2015 Maybe it's just me, but I really do not like these new "cloth like" band-aids. I grew up in the "I am stuck on Band-Aid, cuz Band-Aid's stuck on me" era where they were latex and they were amazing! These darn things fray all around the edges and God forbid they get even slightly damp! I bought them because we have our 5 grand children living with us and you can never have enough band-aids with that many kids, and because I have a nervous habit of picking at the skin all around my fingernails to the point of bleeding. I wanted to wear these around the tips of my fingers to stop me from picking, but they simply will NOT stay on! AND they fray so bad that I found myself pulling at every little string that was hanging off instead of picking at my fingers(which is better than ripping flesh off I guess) and I had to change every one of them out several times a day. The good old fashioned latex band-aids would have stayed on for at least a week. This is a case of "If it ain't broke, don't fix it." I understand that many people have a problem with latex, but do we ALL have to have no choice but to use "lesser quality" band-aids because of that??? Why can't they sell both types??? It's just incredibly aggravating. Adhesive needs improvement. March 28, 2015 I need to use cloth bandages due to an allergy to plastic bandages and adhesives. The cloth Band-Aids are okay except the adhesive won't stick to the cloth when wrapped around a finger for example. So then I have to wrap cloth tape around the bandage. At least the Band-Aids don't cause a rash! | 5% Burns a bit. September 13, 2017 Prevents infection, but I'm glad I used it on myself before applying to cuts and scrapes on my grandkids. Reminds me of the iodine we used when I was a kid. | 0% There are no reviews yet |
One Star Reviews: | 3% Skin reaction July 6, 2017 After some repeated trials with this product, I found it causes reaction to my skin. A couple photos that show what happens during use and one day after the band aide was removed. These fabric band-aids have latex in them April 14, 2017 When someone purchases fabric bandages that is usually due to allergies to latex. It was not clear that these FABRIC band-Aids had latex in them which caused a horrible skin reaction on the arm where cancer had been removed. Uncool. Not Latex Free March 24, 2017 Caution: Even though this product comes up under an Amazon search for latex free bandages, these are NOT LATEX FREE! Package content is not the same quality that I have been buying many many times before February 20, 2016 Purchased these from seller "Medical Products Depot". Box and product look authentic but the band-aid edges start unraveling really fine fibers within minutes after being placed on fingers. I have been using this brand every winter, using new band-aids every day, to protect my finger tips, especially when folding laundry and doing other household tasks. Arizona indoor air is bone dry in winter and cracked finger tips are always a problem no matter what ointments/medications I have tried, so I have to cover my thumbs and index fingers.Picture has small flex fabric Band-Aid I bought from Walgreens (which work perfectly as usual). The large Band-Aid, bought from "Medical Products Depot", started fuzzing after folding one towel. I tried several but they all make a fuzzy mess which then catches on everything like microfiber. I have NEVER had a problem with these flex fabric bandages before and I was glad to find a good deal on them here but what I got instead is just garbage.I am sending samples to J&J with the lot number to have them investigate what is going on. What did I order? April 10, 2015 I will never order these bandages again ... not when I can get perfectly good, sticky, fabric bandages from family dollar that are much, much less expensive than these. actually, the description for these bandages is not clear at all. and the price? no way ... never again! :(to be fair, these bandages are a good size, but that's the only good point I can think of. i'll take the slightly smaller family dollar fabric bandages any day! I feel like I just lit a match to those extra dollars I spent on these. :( | 22% Comes out of the nozzle way too fast if you have a small cut October 26, 2017 It comes out of the nozzle too fast. I purchased this at CVS because I needed immediately and they did not have the one with the brush. I only recommend using this when you have a larger cut and you can use the hand that you use every day for things to put your finger on the nozzle. Otherwise it comes out way too fast. When you use the one with the brush like I just ordered and it just came in yesterday you have full and total control of how much you put on it doesn’t go all over the place. I have diabetes and I cut my finger a lot more than I should for some unknown reason so I wash my hands frequently as most people do I have to continuously change a band aid. Now eventually I got it down where I could spray it kind of without going all over the place you have to put on multiple coats and yes it does work and yes it becomes waterproof. But here’s what happened to me after only having it for three days all the air pressure went out of the can and I have a half used can that I paid almost $11 for that I have to throw in the garbage. I have a picture down below above. This stuff works great if you have a large cut I recommend the new skin with the brush for any small cuts because you don’t have to have it go all over the place so i have to order that thing seperately and im disappointed that i cant even use it without that October 1, 2017 0.it doesnt even have a clipper i thought when i bought it it has that thing included but i was wrong it doesnt have it.so i have to order that thing seperately and im disappointed that i cant even use it without that.and that is also much expensive than the tag remover. burns and leaves scars March 3, 2017 Terrible. Only worked for 1 day and then the sprayer stopped spraying. You can hear the product in the can but it is not coming out. Burns like hell and left a scar on my hand where I used it. When I contacted the company on their facebook page and emailed them about the broken product they ignored me, so I'm certain they know they are selling a faulty product. I used to be pretty loyal to New Skin products, after this I'm never using them again. Did a great job of coating my irregular wound April 16, 2016 The odor was so strong, I can't subject everyone else to it. Did a great job of coating my irregular wound, but I can't take this outside. Shame the product is being wasted. When I was young, the brush on version was easier to tolerate. | 0% There are no reviews yet |
Vote for Me | Vote for Me | Vote for Me | |
Pricing info | |||
Old Price | |||
Old Price | - | - | - |
Price | |||
Price | $6.89updated: Mar 19, 2020 | $6.10updated: Mar 18, 2020 | $6.08updated: Feb 28, 2020 |
Features | |||
Answered Questions | |||
Answered Questions | - | - | |
Article Number | |||
Article Number | 0381370044444 | 8732508728415 | 7174117238267 |
Binding | |||
Binding | Misc. | - | - |
Brand | |||
Brand | Band-Aid | New-Skin | Steri-Strip |
Color | |||
Color | Tan | - | Off-white Reinforced Sterile Strips |
Currency | |||
Currency | USD | USD | USD |
Formatted Price | |||
Formatted Price | $24.00 | - | - |
Height | |||
Height | 153.5 in | 19.7 in | 1.2 in |
Label | |||
Label | - | New-Skin | 3M |
Length | |||
Length | 70.9 in | 78.7 in | 157.5 in |
Manufacturer | |||
Manufacturer | Band-Aid | New-Skin | 3M |
Model | |||
Model | 4444 | - | R1547 |
MPN | |||
MPN | 4444 | 10032515 | R1547 |
Number of Items | |||
Number of Items | 1 | - | - |
Number of Parts | |||
Number of Parts | 4444 | 10032515 | R1547 |
Product Group | |||
Product Group | Health and Beauty | Health and Beauty | Health and Beauty |
Product Type | |||
Product Type | HEALTH_PERSONAL_CARE | HEALTH_PERSONAL_CARE | HEALTH_PERSONAL_CARE |
PublicationDate | |||
PublicationDate | 2009-06-15 | - | - |
Publisher | |||
Publisher | Band-Aid | New-Skin | 3M |
Quantity | |||
Quantity | 1 | 1 | 10 |
Reviews | |||
Reviews | - | ||
Score | |||
Score | 9.4 | - | - |
Size | |||
Size | 100 Count | 1 | 10 Pack |
Studio | |||
Studio | Band-Aid | New-Skin | 3M |
Title | |||
Title | - | New-Skin Liquid Bandage Spray Antiseptic -- 1 fl oz | 3M Steri-Strip reinforced Skin Closures - 1/2" x 4" - 10 pack of 6 strip envelope (60 strips) |
Warranty | |||
Warranty | N | - | - |
Weight | |||
Weight | 0.5 oz | 0.7 oz | 0.4 oz |
Width | |||
Width | 236.2 in | 78.7 in | 19.7 in |
Feature | |||
Feature | Provides extra flexibility Stretchable and comfortable fabric moves with you to fit better Flexible enough to move with you anywhere you go Ideal for bumps and scrapes Packaged for individual use and to replenish first aid stations and kits | Helps to reduce bacterial contamination in minor cuts and scrapes. | •Provides wound support and increases the tensile strength of the wound compared to sutures 10 Pack of 6 Strips Sterile, breathable and comfortable to wear 1/2" x 4" Hypoallergenic adhesive |
McKesson Performance Bandage...
Band-Aid Brand Adhesive...
Dynarex Adhesive Fabric Bandage,...
Johnson & Johnson Flexible...
Flexible LARGE Adhesive Bandages...
Band-Aid Adhesive Bandages,...
Coverlet Latex-Free Adhesive...
Performance Bandage Adhesive...
Band-Aid Brand Adhesive...
McKesson Performance Bandage...