Side by Side Comparison of: Tough 1 vs Diamond Plate

Bought as a gift, seems OK

Perfect for over the saddle horn. And big enough to fit do much in it. Love the color! Fabric very durable.

GREAT POMMEL BAG

This is a pretty nice horn back. While it says "insulated" I am not sure about how cold it might keep drinks. I really bought it for a place to stick my cell phone, a trail saw and pocket hoof pick. It's nice and it came as advertised. I think I'll order some various colors soon! :)

Bought this bag for a 2 week camping /trail ride trip. The hole for the horn is smalll and keeps the bag from coming off when you move at a faster pace. Pockets have lots of room and the smaller pockets are very handy for cell phone and camera. Easy to get into pockets when you are on the move.

I LOVE this horn bag. I ride a lot of long, hard trail rides, through water and mountains. This little bag stays in place, you don't even notice it is there. It sits perfect on any saddle (I've used it on three different ones) and it is big enough to hold up to four bottles of water plus other items. I love the outer side pockets, i put my keys and cell phone in them. I have a larger cell phone and it fits just fine. I would highly recommend this horn bag, great product and great price!!

A little smaller than I expected. The smaller pockets are to small for a larger cell phone. It's well built and serves it's purpose other than if you have a bigger phone.

Perfect size and pockets for what I wanted: phone, keys, hand cleanser, snack bar, riding gloves, hoofpick, general tool: the usual trail ride accroutrements! Ranch friend got the same product, the same week, and loves his, too. I've not had this too long, but my only complaint is that one of the back things for attaching to my saddle just disintegrated. Not sure how, there'd been no pressure on it, other than the jostling of trotting and running, but I found it shredded yesterday and almost lost my clip <sigh>. Will fix, but now hope the other side doesn't disintegrate, too.

OK I didn't order it for a horse,but for a motorcycle.

Not exactly insulated but works perfect for what I need!! Able to fit water. Phone. Camera etc all in there.

I bought this one for my husband, and he loves it. It works great for all the electronic gadgets he takes on the trails, plus holds his water bottles fine. I bough the same exact horn bag earlier from a seller on eBay. The only difference was mine was tan and brown. About the third time I put the bags on my horse, with two pop cans in each side, my horse shook while tied to the trailer, and both bags flew off and hit the ground, leaving the connecting piece on the horn. Apparently the stitching was defective. We checked the stitching on this one, and it's fine. In the end, all turned out great. I have a nice set of tooled leather saddle bags, and I simply put my drinks and whatever in each of the now single horn bags, and place one in each of my saddle bags. So all is well that ends well.

Good horn bag, but weak stitching. The stitching started unraveling on our first long trail ride. However, it's an easy spot to fix and for the price, I'm not completely surprised. The fabric is very nice and durable though.

little pocket not big enough for my cell phone

Works just fine.

bought middle up July. two months later and the entire right side bag has ripped off. :-(

Bags don't have a plastic inside of them so if you put a little ice inside of them be prepared for your legs and horse to get wet...

It say they are insulated, BUT the only part that is insulated is that small little pocket in the front...lol the big pocket is just nylon. Not bad serves its purpose, but insulated.

Price is low but this product isn't what I would call insulated. I didn't purchase I to carry cold stuff in so it's no big deal to me. It works fine for my purposes. If you want it to carry cold items in, I think you would be disappointed.

Not insulated as states. So far has held up and not come apart.

This seemed really nice for the money. Until I just used it for the first time riding last week. On the 3rd day of riding, the threads totally tore apart, leaving it in 2 pieces. Luckily one piece was still usable to hold my phone and water bottle.

Worked for one ride then ripped. Pretty disappointed.

On my second outing, the zipper broke on one of the bags. I had bought one of these years ago and it worked well. This one was a major disappointment.

I really like the size of this bag so I was excited to use it. The first trip out one of the D buckles tore off the bag. The bag wasn't overfilled, tied tightly or pulled on so there was no reason for it to tear. I've managed to resew the D on so I can keep using the bag but I was disappointed that it was required.

Seams split after second use had to reinforce the seams cost 10$ cheaper than shipping😕

Bought two and zipper on both broke the first time used

The stitching for the reinforcement around the horn hole was done incorrectly such that the material was already partially unattached. It would have become completely unattached during the first ride. So? I'm sending it back. What a shame. It was intended as a gift for someone who I ride with frequently as a way to say "thank you." I guess I'll go buy some treats for the horses instead!

Only the small pockets are insulated! Not a very good buy!!

I took this out for a full day ride and by the end of the day w/ multiple on and offs of the horse, the bag separated into 3 parts - right bag, left bag, and horn strap. Not what I expected out of something called Tough 1!

Do not buy!!! Stitching came apart after 15 minutes of use. Not like I had a lot in it. Water bottles, (3) sandwich, and cell phone. I will be sending this back!!!!!

poorly made, cheap material and weak stiching. fell apart out of the box never even used.