Side by Side Comparison of: Charming Jewelers vs Rosenthal collection

My husband and I buy new wedding bands every year. This was this year purchase. Sizing was great and my husband and I are mechanics, the rings still look brand new.

Great looking ring at an awesome price. The fit was a tad large but not a huge issue for me as my fingers like to swell from time to time.

Where do I begin? I was nervous about ordering a ring on Amazon, but I've been exceedingly pleased with this purchase. The quality is great, color is a bit darker, but overall a great ring. I get nervous when it rubs against various surfaces, but I have yet to scratch it. I get lots of compliments on it, too.

Nice quality ring with absolutely no issues. I originally bought a size 12.5 since that was my previous ring size. This was far too large and it would regularly scratch against things. While this sounds pretty bad, it actually helped me verify this was in fact tungsten. The scratches would wipe right off and the ring has kept its original look.I eventually ended up getting a second ring sized at 10.5 that fits perfectly. Please keep that in mind when purchasing, the 'comfort fit' may actually cause you to buy a few ring sizes down.

Order a size smaller. I usually wear a 9 1/4 but had to send it back. I got an 8 1/2 and it fit a lot better. The ring's color is unique and i liked the inner blue as well. This is my favorite wedding ring so far and for the price I won't be bummed if I lose this one. I'll just buy another. I'd recommend it, thumbs up.

I love this ring. I originally purchased it as a replacement/ backup wedding ring. To wear while doing things around the house, not having to worry about losing or damaging my real one. It's super comfortable and looks great. I liked it so much that i wear it about as much as my real one. It lives up to the same quality as my previous backup ring by King will.

My husband broke his original wedding band and we needed a quick cheap replacement until we could go get another nice one. Let's just say we won't be getting another one. This ring is super nice. Well made. And looks really good. Size is true. We ordered the size he wears and it fit perfectly. He did say it's heavier than his other ring, but it doesn't bother him. I DEFINITELY RECOMMEND IT. For the look and price, can't beat it.

This ring by far exceeded my expectations. I bought it for my neighbor and she was getting it for her boyfriend and they were both blown away by it. Perfect size an fit well. I have never bought jewelry from Amazon before but this was perfect and I will more than like buy jewelry from Amazon again!

I ordered this ring for my husband and he loves it! I purchased it with the idea that if something happened to it, it wouldn't be a big deal since I didn't pay a lot for it. But the truth is, this ring has held up better than his expensive white gold ring. I would definitely recommend this to anyone searching for a durable, nice looking ring.

My fiancee is a mechanic and welder. This will hold up to his beatings as well as still be able to be shattered off if there's an emergency. Plus he wears a size 14 and that was hard to find. Good heavy weight as well. I like it.UPDATE: My husband works (manages) in a machine shop with lots of heavy equipment. His ring shattered today but his finger is fine.

Contrary to many reviews here, these ring sizes are true. I measured my ring size using several different sources and each one came back as 10.5. I ordered the 10.5 and it fits perfectly! Not too tight, not too loose. Anyone who says ring sizes are off obviously doesn't know how to measure their own finger. Has some good weight to it, but I like that about rings. It's very black, not gunmetal gray as the picture tends to show, but I was prepared for that. Overall it's exactly what I wanted and expected. Would buy again.

I bought this as a cheap replacement for a wedding ring I lost and it looks great. Tungsten is a heavy metal (not chemically - physically - it's heavier than lead) so it has a nice heft to it. I ordered the wrong size so I checked it with calipers and the size is very accurate. US size 8 should have an ID of 18.14mm. Measured on the calipers - wait for it - exactly 18.14mm. So they don't "run small", it's exactly right - people clearly just don't know what size to order (me included). Still - I couldn't believe a $10 ring was solid ceramic so rather than return it - I put it in the vice to see if it would smash or shatter. Well - it shattered - so at least on cursory inspection - this appears to be genuine solid tungsten carbide - not just a steel ring with a black coating. I'm buying another one in the correct size and plan to keep it - this is a sweet deal for a nice ceramic ring.

Looks good for the price. Sized a little large. Try getting a ring 1.5 sizes smaller than you normally would.

I will say it runs a little smaller, size fits but tight.

A bit big... very nice looking

As expected. Unique yet simple. The blue barely shows; subtle. However, if you are ordering this ring for a special date..forget it. From the time I placed the order until its delivery took over a month.

Everyone noticed the awesome blue color comparison against the gray. I love it. Heavy duty, sturdy. Exactly what I wanted. Oh, and customer service with this company has been superb!

Very nice. Pretty much as expected based upon other comments. Order 1/2 size smaller that you are and should fit well. Great value. Would definitely buy again. I like the blue on inside and sides.

Nice finish, I get lots of compliments. Unfortunately, the edges are a little rougher than I anticipated so it has marked up my leather steering wheel on my truck from turning.

My husband and I love this ring! Great quality and inexpensive. The only reason why I didn't give it a 5 is because the color is misleading. It looks like it has some silver to it but it's actually pitch black. We love it though.

The ring looks great right out of the box. The weight of the ring is neither too heavy or too light which adds to the appeal of this ring. It looks and feels like a quality ring without having to pay the high price tag. I had a traditional silver band for over 10 years so I wanted to try something different... modern, sleek not beefy, eye catching but not gaudy, professional yet casual... this ring fits the bill. I am very pleased with this purchase and if I need to get another one in the future I would do it in a heartbeat. Well worth the price.The only reason why I don't give it a perfect 5 stars is because I wish it had arrived in a fancier box. It's not a big deal but for such a good looking ring it would be nice to have received it in a better looking ring box.

I like the ring alot. It as what I was expecting EXCEPT for the fact I was not expecting black. I took off one star because the picture on Amazon is not accurate and I was expecting a dark gray/gun metal color. I realize the description says black, but it would help if the picture truly reflected what you get.

These rings are similar to tungsten rings seen at a jeweler for 1/5th the cost. Tungsten rings are great for those working around machinery or in any other conditions in which a ring may be crushed. They will shatter before being crushed around your finger.

This is pretty nice for the price, I mean you can't really beat that price. I think I lost it already though lol. I haven't seen it in a few days. I guess I'll just get another one. The finish does wear pretty easily, of course.

My fiancé was sized by a jeweler at an 11.5 and that's what I ordered. Was at least 1/2 size too small. Very pretty though

Returned as it was not the correct size.

The ring fit perfect. The black finish is not holding up though. My husband works hard for a living and after 1 week the finish is rubbing off. Nice ring for a desk job. Good quality for the price, he's wearing it daily.

The ring looks very nice but was to big for my husbands finger even though we ordered his size. Also it was much heavier than we thought it would be.

I bought this as a replacement rind for my hubs and was a little disappointed. The black started to rub off pretty quickly after he started wearing it. It is not too bad and he still wears the ring but that type of thing drives me crazy. Of course, you can't really beat that price so I would say that it is still a good buy overall.

This is a great band, but be aware that the black starts to wear off and show the plain silver underneath after prolonged wear and tear. It can look cool, so get this if you don't mind that. If you do, then I suggest getting this same product in silver Tungsten Carbide as there is no color to wear off.

I bought this for my wedding as neither my wife nor I wanted to spend money on an expensive, precious metal ring when I truly couldn't care less about wearing gold or gems or anything like that.PROS - This ring is HEAVY (which I love) and is very, very masculine. It fit perfectly, so while I didn't test the size by using a sizing tool, I had already determined my size with a fitting at a jeweler, so I think you can be pretty confident that if you will receive a ring of the correct size.CONS - The description says the ring is black. Please re-read that. THE RING DOES NOT LOOK LIKE THE ONE IN THE PICTURE. The ring in the picture is more of a dark grey, which is what I wanted. This ring is black. Blackety-black-black. Jet black.If you want a BLACK ring, this one is probably the way to go. If you want a ring that looks like the one in the picture, then don't get this one.

Ring is extremely heavy and bulky and is not comfortable. While I kept the ring because it was cheap, I purchased another ring that was smaller and weighed less.

Unfortunately my husband is allergic to this ring. I am hoping to exchange it for a silicone ring. Within 2 months his finger was turning really white underneath and the skin was flakeing off. So weird. After research, apparently tungsten rings are mixed with other metals and that's why he is allergic. Will post photos. Otherwise the ring is perfect for someone else.

It is very black. The picture makes it appear light black with some silver. It's all black. I would not buy it again.

I have it 2 stars bc it's not even close to gun metal grey or what the photo portrays. It's straight up black. Literally. Black! I think the seller should take a photo until it shows the ACTUAL color.

My husband lost his wedding band years ago, so we decided to finally replace it with this ring. Although we love the look of the ring, and it is well made, the fit was wrong. We visited our local jewelry store to have my husband's finger sized because it's been years since we purchased a ring and wanted to make sure we ordered the correct size. He even tried on a few size 16 rings in the store to be sure the size was right since he has really large fingers. We ordered a size 16, and the fit was majorly wrong. The ring was way too big, so I had to return it.

Nice heavy ring. I had an expensive wedding band that is constantly scratched and dulled down. Hopefully, this ring will give me the durability of my daily life. The ring feels comfortable and looks good. I will update later on the durability. Update, 2 days after some of theblack coating is starting to come off. The ring may be durable but the black coating is not

Waste of money.

For some reason I never received the ring. Had to buy a stand-in for the ceremony. Not sure where it went. Wish it was present.

The ring isn't sized properly. At least .5-1.0 too large. Al

Do not recommended

Ugh. Carefully sized my finger and this thing is huge. Evidently the size of these rings is not accurate to the ring size standards. Probably need a 12.5.

I pulled the ring out of the box and the surface had 3 or 4 spots where the black was chipped off.

It looks silver on the image but this ring is solid black and rather cheap looking. I will be returning this item and do not recommend it to buyers. It looks 10,000 times better in the picture

I love the ring style and weight. But I can't vouche for the sizing. So far, disappointed in the sizing. As per measurement I should be a 14..I have purchased 3 rings so far...14, 13 and 12.5 and they still are loose and don't fit appropriately. Kind of disappointed. Until this is resolved, 1 star it is. Will try once more...

Finish was scratched off when it arrived. I'm disappointed in this item. The ring arrived today, and new right out of the packaging the black color was already scratched off. Waste of money.

My husband and I have only been married 2 weeks and this ring is already scratched terribly and the black finish is chipping off! Very poor quality. Looks nice at first, but terrible ring.