Side by Side Comparison of: American Trading Company vs Whitmor vs Great Deal Furniture

Well made!

Well made perfect for patio.

Easy to put together and looks great.

The table was everything I expected. It seems very well built and the color and style is almost an exact match to chairs I bought at Macy's for my bigger table.

Heavyweight sturdy table, perfect size for my patio.

I was very impressed with the workmanship on this table. We live in the mountains and get a lot of strong winds down in the holler. We ordered this to go under our pergola beside the pool and absolutely love it. Very heavy and well made. The bronze is gorgeous and goes really well with our dark brown chairs from Better Homes and Gardens. Absolutely would buy another one and love the different size options. We got the biggest one but are considering getting the 24x24 for our back porch area. The fact that it is Solid Iron makes a huge difference in the value!**I also must mention that our table came in with a hole in the top for an umbrella, so that was a nice surprise! All the way around worth the money!LOVE!!!!

Arrived on time, as described, fully assembled, packaged well, and undamaged. It has quality design and manufacturing, and will serve its purpose well in our designated guest bedroom.

strong and sturdy and holds heavy luggage. Don't have to bend when unpacking. I have a bad back and this is a life saver. Also great for when I have visitors. Don't like to put luggage on my beds.

Review #110. I bought two of these racks for our guestroom and to use when I'm packing for a trip. Initially, I wanted to buy the nice wood racks, but I'm on a budget and my house is nice but it isn't fancy. These racks come already assembled. They look nice and I'm happy with my choice. I live in a coastal area, so I'm hoping they don't rust.I think they're sturdy enough for a bag up to 26 or 28 inches, but I wouldn't use just one for a super large, packed bag. Those are usually easier to manage on the floor or on two racks. Overall I'm please with my purchase and glad that my in-laws don't have to stoop to go through their luggage.

Well constructed. I believe I will get many years of use from this product. It will be helpful to our guests when they visit, as their luggage will be sitting up higher which will not require them to squat down to the floor.

We have lots of house guests that come for just a weekend and this is a great addition to the bedrooms to keep suitcases from exploding on the floor! Also helps when we pack for trips. Sturdy and a great price.

I run several airbnb's and these racks are surprisingly high end for the price! Very classy and holding up well even as my properties are near the beach and the salt air corrodes many things, even indoors. Sturdy and fits many decors.

My guests laugh when they see this, but really appreciate a place to rest their suitcase or duffle bag! Lightweight, but sturdy and strong, this rack helps welcome guests and saves their backs.

Good quality, okay price

Nice product, but NOTE: the product picture is misleading. the rack does not come with rubber tips on legs. The tips are hard plastic, which in my experience can scratch wood floor. We bought our own rubber tips.

As an AirBnB super host, my mom suggested I get one of these. I'm glad I did. It works and the price was fair. It's utilitarian, but who needs decoration inside a closet. It helps keep things off the floor.

A luggage rack can be a great convenience if you have overnight guests who do not stay long enough to warrant unpacking their suitcase.Practical, light, and (compared to a similar item I bought elsewhere)it is good quality. The slight bend to the legs make it look quite nice. I like these metal versions (as opposed to wood) because they look better in a modern setting. This one can be closed and put away in the back of a closet (much like the wooden counterpart). However, the one I had gotten earlier (at "Improvements.com") even though not as good quality, was modular (the legs snap off) so that as to occupy even less space when put away.

It is always nice when you visit someplace that you don't need to put your suitcase on the floor. This luggage rack is the second one we have purchased so that both guests have a place to place their suitcase. We had a wooden one that broke under the weight of a suitcase and we needed a replacement.The service was quick. The rack is sturdy. we will enjoy for many years. I didn't give it a 5-star because after I had purchased it, I did find it for a bit less but I don't regret the purchase!

Have to admit I agree with the comment that the instructions were very unspecific but I got it together. My only drawback is the legs aren't far enough apart to slide my patio chairs in so I really didn't gain any space from downsizing to 32" from 48". Table is attractive and well made but I'll probably be looking for something else that my chairs fit under. Sorry I gave away my round table before this was setup.

Those reviews telling us how easy it was to assemble are a little misleading. First of all the instructions are not specific. To attach the legs they say to use the headless screws but don't tell you they only go in one way, one end has been slotted to accept a screwdriver. One of the holes on table had not been tapped i.e. No threads to screw headless screws into. Holes in connecting ring drilled to close together to accept screws in one leg. If you have no mechanical skills and lack some tools, the table I received could never have been put together. Once together it's great!

Some of the finish was scraped off in the shipping, but not too bad. I see a small can of spray paint in my future. :-)The top of the table seems to be of good quality, but the legs seem awfully light. The jury's still out on this one

Quality seems to be good but these are smaller than the ones you see in hotel rooms. Therefore I have to be more careful when loading and unloading my suitcase so that it doesn't fall off the rack.

The item pictured is different than the one I received: in the picture it appears to have black plastic around the legs, but in the one I got there is no plastic: the chrome goes straight to the floor, meaning it may mark up woods. It also makes the rack look cheaper. The rack works, so I'll keep it for me and hide it in the closet - but will have to keep searching for one suitable for guests.

Nothing too special, thought I was getting a bargain, but was grossly mistaken. Would give more stars if it were cheaper price

Good for guest visitors at the home. Priced right.

We have a vacation rental and bought two of these luggage racks for guests. They're super lightweight, which may be an advantage for some, and they work fine. In retrospect, I wish we'd opted for something a little sturdier.

It does what it's supposed to do. No construction needed. It came on time to accommodate my house guest's luggage. I'm happy with it so far.

Right leg was bent when we received it. Still works, just looks lopsided on the right.

One of the legs has no foot protection. Will contact Whitmor's customer service for part. If they don't send immediately it will be faster for me to return and buy another one prime. The stand came with no protection in box. The box was dented. Fortunately, the stand is not damaged.

not i needed.