Side by Side Comparison of: Schutt vs Riddell

Nice helmet, had to get smaller cheek pads though; it was too snug.

good quality.

Premium helmet!

Great helmet for my son. Fast shipping, and my son loves it.

Fits perfectly and excellent quality. I will definitely purchase again if my 14 yr old grows out of it.

Great helmet, size was surprising though. Went from a recruit hybrid to this one, medium to a large and that was a big jump. Probably should have went with a youth medium in the vengence. Aside from that we are extremely happy with this helmet. We can use his visor because of the attachment at the top, but we will figure that part out. Great helmet at a great price.

These helmets are awesome and totally worth the $20 Amazon is selling them for! The helmets are slightly larger than the $0.25 gumball machine helmets and are much higher quality. The displays are cardboard but still pretty cool. A cool way to display the NFC & AFC standings in your office or man cave as each display is separated by division and the helmets can clearly be seen. A very nice gift for the NFL fan in your life.

I got this for my son and grandson for Christmas. They had fun with it.

The photo shown is pre-2015 set & I wanted the 2015 set (with new Browns shown in picture). Definitely got the 2015 set & came by earliest it was expected. Would recommend buying from this seller.

These are great for kids who love football and like to play around with helmets. My two year old loves these, and my 11 year old plays with his imagination about scores and games, and has superbowls with these. Lots of fun.

Good quality. These aren't those mini helmets you get out of the gumball machine with the cheap stickers that fall or peel off easily. These mini helmets are pretty good quality and some look painted and clear coated. Nice addition to my football-crazy 7 year old's room.

This is one of the main things my 7 year old asked for this year for Christmas. Certainly did not disappoint! He is a football fanatic and loves these helmets! He's not gotten too much in the playoff tracker yet, but I'd say next football season he will. Great product!

Good solid helmet and at a good price. Goes well with this face mask.----> Schutt Sports Youth VROPO DW YF Carbon Steel...

bigger then expected

This helmet is advertised as WITHOUT faceguard, so I ordered a separate faceguard. The hjelmet arrived WITH a faceguard.

Well made quality.

Great just wish it came with a face mask

The helmets are great! The playoff tracker... Not so much. I will be either building my own display or purchasing one. I was disappointed in the tracker as I am sure many others have been too, but if you are getting this solely for the helmets you will be happy. The helmets are well made and look great!

The helmets are great. Very detailed and good quality. Taking one star off because of tracker.

My boys love playing with these. They aren't anything special in how they are made - literally small plastic helmets - but they find hours of fun in lining them up, arranging them in different playoff possibilities, and a variety of other things! They arrived on time as promised and seem fairly priced to what I saw in stores in town.

My sons loves this set.

Pretty much what I expected for the price. I may have spent a bit more to get a set with a better display than the cardboard. But, you get what you pay for and I have no complaints.

Gave this gift to a number of friend's kids and they loved them. They can pick their favorite teams and/or try out the match ups for playoffs and see how they do.

Although the Schutt helmets are great quality the sizing always seems to be a little off. We purchased a large. My son's measurements say he should wear a large, and his medium Schutt is really tight. They need to have an over lap of size or something, we had this same problem from small to medium. Just wish it fit. :(

Not the same size as the classic Riddell brand/type. About 75% as big as Riddell brand mini-helmets. Overall they are of good quality. The colors are off just a bit (I actually didn't think the Brown's helmet could get any uglier; it can). One comment stated that the logos were only on one side of the helmets. Mine came with logos on both sides.My 9 year old is happy with them and I think they will hold up, but he already has some college helmets that are the Riddell brand and a display case for them. These just look a little "off" in the case next to those.

This product does get the job done. it's pretty much minimally produced; the team logos are only on one side of the helmets, and the materials are clearly cheap. However, for tracking the NFL regular season and playoffs, it is perfectly functional.

I knew I wasn't getting anything great with the tracker and my main purpose was just getting the helmets. But, the cardboard tracker will probably be ruined before next season... Again, we really ordered this just for the helmets, so I'm still pleased..

The tracking boards are made out of cardboard and we have already had to tape it to keep helmets secure. Would it really have made much price difference to manufacturer to make this out cheap plastic instead? On the positive side arrived quickly from third party distributor.

Didn't come with a face mask like it is pictured. Very dissapointing

I JUST had delivery of this item and I'm not sure I'll keep it. It has scuff marks all over (inside and out), and some green marker or something on the top. The inside padding is bright orange, and white with blue backing so it's not as pictured or expected. At the moment I'm feeling misled and seriously considering a return even though that will make someone's Christmas less bright. Has anyone else experienced this? It's my first time buying a helmet - are they always like this?

Sizing is terrible. The helmet appears to be good quality, but the difference between the Medium and Large is HUGE. The size chart indicated my son should wear a Large, but it was WAY too big. I then bought the Medium, which was was way too small. Had to return both and buy a totally different helmet. What a pain.

Nice helmet. .my son loved it..it is soft inside and fits like a glove on his head..

The helmets are great but the "standings boards" are cheap and flimsy. It's almost impossible to get all 16 helmets on the board without some falling off.

I had two helmets the same, and writing/signatures on others.

We received the helmet today and it only had ONE jaw pad. Really irritated! Not sure how it's possible to NOT notice that the item your're putting in the box is missing padding on one side.

Missing jaw pad

I am selling this helmet hardly used for 70$ with faceguard and chin strap.

Helmet in the image looks like it has a high gloss finish. The one I received was dull, had to paint and polish.

I bought this item for the new logos like the Dolphins, Jaguars, Buccaneers, and Browns. They came with the old logos and not as pictured. Very dissapointed.

For $20, I would expect a bit more. The helmets are decent, but the boards (that you're meant to hang the helmets from) is super flimsy and doesn't hold the helmets at all. As soon as you touch one helmet, all of the others fall down -- and isn't that the point of this in the first place... To be able to shuffle the helmets to various locations throughout the season? I probably should have returned it, but I had disposed of the packaging and didn't feel like going through the hassle. Don't bother.

The product was misrepresented and did not receive all the pieces