5 items
Compare
Compare
All Features
Differing
SimplicitySee Similar
Simplicity Breastfeeding Baby Nursing Cover, Grey - Simplicity
Philips AVENT
Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier, Pink/Purple, 0-3 Months, 2 Count - Philips AVENT
Lansinoh
Lansinoh Breastfeeding Salve - HPA Lanolin, 1.41 oz - Lansinoh
My Brest Friend
My Brest Friend Pillow, Petal - My Brest Friend
iLoveSIA
iLoveSIA 3pack Nursing Bra Nude+Black+Light Pink Size L Fit 36BC 34C 32D 30DD 38A 40A 30DDD - iLoveSIA

Side by Side Comparison of: Simplicity vs Philips AVENT vs Lansinoh vs My Brest Friend vs iLoveSIA

Learn More
All Features
Differing
Learn More
Simplicity http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51aricB-XML._SL160_.jpg
Simplicity Breastfeeding Baby Nursing Cover, Grey - Simplicity
Add to Whishlist
Philips AVENT http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51yGbAZlNFL._SL160_.jpg
Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier, Pink/Purple, 0-3 Months, 2 Count - Philips AVENT
Add to Whishlist
Lansinoh https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/51BaXDXPLOL._SL160_.jpg
Lansinoh Breastfeeding Salve - HPA Lanolin, 1.41 oz - Lansinoh
Add to Whishlist
My Brest Friend https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/41wtRIQ2CuL._SL160_.jpg
My Brest Friend Pillow, Petal - My Brest Friend
Add to Whishlist
iLoveSIA https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/51EhaD5ug5L._SL160_.jpg
iLoveSIA 3pack Nursing Bra Nude+Black+Light Pink Size L Fit 36BC 34C 32D 30DD 38A 40A 30DDD - iLoveSIA
Rating info
eComparisons Score
eComparisons ScoreThe "Comparison Score" Is calculated based on the average number of times this item was compared with other items in this category by our users
8
9
9.2
0
0
User Rating (Amazon)
User Rating (Amazon)

Five Star Reviews:

58%
Large, high quality nursing cover
May 18, 2016
My favorite nursing cover. I'm a plus sized Mom who was very modest and uncomfortable nursing because my previous nursing cover didn't cover me completely and would flap open. This one restored my faith in nursing covers. It covered all of me and I love the neck tie so you can see you little one and the back strap to keep the cover in place and not flapping. By far the best nursing cover!!
A must-have for breastfeeding mum's - but start using it from Day 1!!
March 9, 2016
My only regret with this product is not having used it from the start. I got it to use on a trip I was going to take with my 4 month old baby and she didn't take well to being covered up to feed, even though the material is light and the design is roomy. Nowadays she'll let me use it when she's really hungry and only for a short while... but I'm sure if I'd used it before she would have gotten used to it no problem. Personally I think it's great, it covers you up very well so you don't have to worry while breastfeeding even if baby unlatches or needs to burp suddenly, you can handle all that under the cover without risk. I definitely recommend it!
Necessity for breastfeeding moms on the go!
October 29, 2015
I bought this cover because I'm a little on the larger size and it seemed to be a good size for me. It is, it covers me well. Definitely and improvement over trying to cover myself with a towel or blanket. If you want to have cover while feeding in public one of these covers is a necessity. Definitely recommended.
... 3 different nursing covers and this one is my favorite. It's light so if you have a baby ...
October 27, 2015
I've had 3 different nursing covers and this one is my favorite. It's light so if you have a baby who is normally warm it's not so hot in there that they pull it off (in public). The coverage is great too in case you have a baby who moves their legs sometimes while they nurse.
Awesom product! perfect for hiding your racki in public
April 3, 2015
This is great nursing cover, it is generous in size and covers everything, This light cotton fabric with perfect floral has been really nice for summer, it folds up small enough so it doesn't take up too much room in an already full diaper bag, it is small so we can easily take it anywhere. This one is thin so me and my baby don't sweat during the summer months.The strap around the neck is great too so we can see what baby are doing buy others can't. L LOVE IT!!!!!!! I have used it in restaurants, at parties at a friend's house, i've even walked around feeding him while wearing this.I highly suggest this as a must have item tucked into your diaper bag or hiking backpackpack!!! A breastfeeding mom's best friend!
So glad to have found this cover
March 24, 2015
So glad to have found this cover. Great reasonable price and great company to deal with. This cover is perfect for breastfeeding in public or when guests are over. Provides ample coverage so there is feeling of being exposed and yet I can still check in on baby while feeding and see him. Also helps to block outside distractions from him so he eats better. Overall great item and love the fabric and pattern.
76%
They work.
September 17, 2017
These are the newborn pacifiers so they are a bit softer than the ones meant for older babies. I like to attach them to something because when they get dropped(or thrown) you'll be surprised and aggravated at the distance these things get when they roll-wow!!!! So many of them lost, maybe I should switch to the square ones lol
Favorite Pacifer
August 7, 2017
Best pacifier for a newborn! It is the right shape for an infants mouth. I got some cheapo ones that were totally the wrong shape that I was actually afraid to put in my baby's mouth. I tried the NUK ones as well, but they taught my baby to make a clicking sound with his tongue, so I threw those away. These have been perfect the whole time. Highly recommend!
my newborn likes them
August 1, 2017
I don't really know how to rate this since it was for my new born but since he didn't reject it i am giving them 5 stars because apparently my kid loves it. i bought this because they are like the ones they give you at the hospital and my kid didn't like the other shaped ones. this are great, nice texture and are one solid piece so there is no worrying about choking hazards.
These are great for tiny babies
June 12, 2017
These are great for tiny babies. My baby was only 4lbs 11oz. She could not fit regular pacifiers in her mouth because they hit her nose! She won't always take a pacifier, but when she does, she enjoys it. I particularly like that it is all made of the same material, because now that she pulls them out of her mouth, she doesn't always get them back in, but she doesn't care because she can still chomp down on it!
Great for babies!
May 25, 2016
Really love this pacifier. I bought this with my son when he was born,he'll be turning two this year, and they worked great! I continued to use soothie pacifiers until I took pacifiers away completely,they have pacifiers for ages 6 months and up also ! Another great thing is that my son didn't get hooked on these pacifiers, when it was time to ween him off of them it was a simple process, he didn't look for it or anything. It might've just been my child, but I'm planning on using these for my daughter, in pink, when she arrives this June !
Great pacifiers - my baby loves them
April 27, 2016
My son started on these pacifiers in the NICU, and since coming home, has refused any other pacifier we've given him. We've tried Mam and Dr. Browns, and he only wants the Avent. I particularly love that these are yellow. Very durable and wash up easily. They do not stay in at all when he sucks vigorously. That gets annoying. But the Mam fell out too when he sucked hard.
0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

Four Star Reviews:

21%
... thread that comes along the side but it works fine. i love it
June 21, 2017
not sure how to strap the black thread that comes along the side but it works fine. i love it.
Good product but ...
September 29, 2016
This is great for covering up while breastfeeding. The black string that's in the back made it a little bit difficult for me to maneuver with a wiggly child so I had to cut it off. Also the fabric is really thick and didn't seem to be that breathable. If you're pumping outside and it's breezy or kinda nipply, then this would be good to use, but when you use it during Spring/Summer like I had too, you over heat quickly and have to accommodate how you cover your child to make sure he/she can breath comfortably.
Off color, but still a good cover
July 28, 2016
Since baby isn't here I haven't actually gotten to use this yet but the material seems very breathable and it comes will a cute little bag to carry the cover around in. My only complaint is the material is much darker than I originally expected or maybe I received a different color. Overall I'm still satisfied with the purchase.
Perfect
March 10, 2016
Great coverage and fit. Love how the top has a thin plastic strip sewn in so you can see inside at what you're doing. Would have given it 5 stets but the fabric is a little rougher than I would like but other than that is perfect and a great price. No need to spend a ton on a bigger name version.
great large cover! but was broken.
July 30, 2015
Would of been 5 stars BUT the back black clasp to tighten the cord was broken! I'm leaving for a family trip and don't have time to exchange it. So I tied a knot in the black cord to keep it tight around me. Very large, great cover. My baby always pulls off my "udder cover" since its smaller and reveals "side boob". This one she can't!
This is a great cover! Beautiful color and very reasonably priced
July 7, 2015
This is a great cover! Beautiful color and very reasonably priced! The only issue I had with the product is that the tie string that came on the little pouch fell apart within seconds! This didn't affect the overall quality of the cover itself but it was still disappointing.
10%
I know lots of people who's kids love these. I was trying to find a "bottle ...
September 1, 2017
This has nothing to do with the product itself. I know lots of people who's kids love these. I was trying to find a "bottle like pacifier" to transition my kid off bottles for comfort at night in the crib and I got these because they were most like Madella nipples. Sadly they were rejected outright. Nothing wrong with the product, my kid is just ornery and they didn't work for us.
Get even if they don't take a binki.
August 21, 2017
THESE are great. Our LO won't take a pacifier but loves to play with these. You can stick your finger in them so they chew on your finger when they are fussy. Easy to clean and no place to get gross stuff stuck. They can chew on the entire thing. Will be nice when she starts teething.
Good product but not for us
July 30, 2017
These soothies arrived on time, in great condition, and after about a month of use they are still in great condition. They are excellent quality, but unfortunately we are switching to a different pacifier because my son has trouble keeping these in his mouth. I think that's just a matter of preference for every baby, which is why I still gave these four stars.
Our Infant's Favorite
January 10, 2016
These are great, the hospital gave us a couple of these and all the other ones our daughter just doesn't really care for. I also like how you can see through the center, so you can see how the child is biting/sucking. The only complaint I have is these were about 4 days late... and at this point, I have another item in my order list that is a couple days late as well. Starting to become a trend, and starting to regret Amazon Prime.
Does what the name says...Soothie
September 7, 2015
One of my daughters really liked this pacifier. It's the one she got originally from the hospital, and continued to prefer, even though her twin sister moved on to others. We got a bunch of these bundled together with other baby products so we always had a lot, but always had to buy more.one downside to this pacifier is that once our daughter started teething, these often developed holes. There are a range of different types (softer for younger, more rigid for older).
I think my kid was addicted to these. :p
April 30, 2014
EDIT: Looks like they updated the picture from the bright neon green to the proper color. Leaving the review as-is though just in case it changes later.Aside from the color lies on the listing, these pacifiers are the only thing my kid will take, and to that effect they're pretty great. They've been very durable. We've yet to need to replace any of them for the last year due to damage or anything.Pretty disappointed in the pictures shown on Amazon making them look like they're neon green (ie. easy to see) because I've bought the 'green' ones at Walmart before and they're more of a muted blue-green. That's what these ones are too. They're very hard to track down when my kid throws his binky somewhere because of the muted color.Get the bright yellow ones for better sight.
0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

Three Star Reviews:

11%
Great cover for the price
May 12, 2017
Great cover for the price, does what it needs too, however the metal that pops the top open so you can see you child doesn't work right on both of the covers I purchased, so I still have to lift up the top to see down to my baby while she is nursing.
Lovely fabric
December 10, 2016
The fabric is amazingly soft. The metal could be stiffer for a better view of the baby.
Color not as pictured
May 31, 2016
Color is more of a grey than the sky blue pictured. On the back there's a string in which is used to tighten around you...I feel this is totally useless and actually quite annoying moving around. Rather it be a tie string.
Bulky and uncomfortable.
December 27, 2015
This thing is way too big! I guess better for it to be too big versus too small, but it's pretty embarrassing how much of my body this covers.The neck part is really annoying too. It's bent and won't go into a normal, curved shape.I've stopped using this, and instead I now use either a ring sling or an infinity scarf for coverage.
It works for what it is.
December 13, 2015
This is sufficient. I'm plus sized and it's definitely not a "poncho" like effect on me but it does cover what I need it to cover. Because it doesn't cover all the way around the black adjustable string usually just gets in the way. The wire on mine also doesn't stay firm so I can't always see my son when he's feeding.
Delivered With a Broken Rope
July 28, 2015
It came with broken rope on the bag. So I don't have high hopes for the string in the back either. Disappointing. I bought it specifically for my upcoming trip. I am yet to see how long it lasts. It is compact and fabric is good quality though. I wish they made strings better quality as one can't use it if back string breaks.
6%
Not my child's favorite
September 23, 2017
They come highly recommended but I haven't had great success with them. They are stiff and fall out a lot for me. Granted could be my children, but that's the experience I have had with them.
These are fine. They do the job
November 29, 2015
These are fine. They do the job. They're BPA free, cheap, and it's cute to watch the little "hole" in the middle while your baby sucks on the pacifier. My boy was constantly spitting this out, and he could never find it or figure out how to get it back in his mouth. Cue the least fun game of "fetch" ever; I was the fetcher, he was the dropper.These were good in a pinch, but we learned quickly and replaced them with a Wubbanub in month one.
watch out for defects
October 17, 2015
These are my daughter's favorite pacifiers. My problem is that 2 of the 4 packages I ordered, 1 or more of the pacifiers had a hole on the end so she wouldn't take it. Having just had a newborn returning them was the last thing I was thinking about and I ended up losing them, or threw them away. I would test them as soon as they arrive!
The only one my baby would take, but...
January 12, 2014
When my fourth was born and would not take any of the pacifiers I had on hand, I went to the store and bought one of every kind of pacifier I could find. I gave them to her one by one, hoping that she would take ONE of them, leaving Soothie for last, even after the knock-off gum drops or whatever they're called. I don't care for the way they look or the weird nub looking thing on the backside of them, meant for a pacifier clip or something I suppose.As a last resort, I gave her the Soothie brand. She didn't take to it right away, but she didn't immediately spit it out like she had many of the others. Eventually she grew to like it and accept it and for that I am grateful. However it appears to be a magnet for every piece of hair, fur, and lint that comes it's way. I am forever washing the dang thing off, far more often than would be necessary for basic sanitation were it not a fuzz magnet. I have used various other brands and types with my previous children, and none of them had this issue. Of course there was a stray hair here and there that would make it's way, especially if it was freshly spit out and promptly dropped on the floor, but not to the extent that these do. If your child is willing to accept a different brand and there are no concerns with breastfeeding, then try a different brand.
Great newborn paci only
February 21, 2013
This pacifier was given to us at the hospital and it was great while she was a newborn, although she need lots of assistance keeping it in her mouth. At a little before 2 months old I noticed her losing interest in it and needing even extra assistance keeping it in her mouth so I switched her to Avent pacifiers and she is much happier. I am happy for the use I got out of it for the first 2 months but it was def. time to switch, plus these are not good for teeth developement at all.
Baby likes it but they fall out really easily
February 2, 2012
I got these because my baby just would not take the flat teat style ones that are so common nowadays. I live in Singapore and it took a while for the package to reach me and in the interim managed to find a more traditional style pacifier from Pidgeon but with an olive shaped teat.It's possible I would think more highly of the soothie if I had not tried the Pigeon pacifier first. My baby will take the soothie but does not prefer it over the pigeon one. The problem with the Soothie is that it falls out of his mouth really easy. If he lets up sucking for a moment it falls out of his mouth. If it happens to roll out of his cot (which seems to happen more frequently than a regular pacifier) it always lands teat side down (regular pacifiers are more likely to land teat side up). Additionally there is no cover for the soothie and it is more difficult to teather to a stroller or car seat so it is not a great pacifier to travel with.In short: I will use the soothies as back-ups as baby will take them but will not be buying more as a regular pacifier with an olive shaped teat is better
0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

Two Star Reviews:

6%
Two Stars
November 5, 2016
I don't know exactly was wrong but it didn't work for me
I bought this while I was pregnant and quickly sent ...
October 2, 2016
I bought this while I was pregnant and quickly sent it back--there's funky wiring that's supposed to help with feeding, but it made it more uncomfortable when I tried to wear it. The product just did not seem well-made.
This it very pretty pattern but i dont like how its not breathable ...
July 14, 2016
This it very pretty pattern but i dont like how its not breathable so this summer i havnt been able to use it with my LO cause she gets to fussy cause its to hot
Two Stars
November 13, 2015
The material is too heavy for the use. Should have ordered a gauze one. Lesson Learned!
Not the best
November 6, 2015
Not as much coverage as the others I've purchased, it's not as wide. It is pretty though. I recommend hooter hiders or udder covers.
Great idea, poor execution
August 20, 2015
Great idea, poor execution. It's a pain to put on in public due to the drawstring in the back. The wire rim that's supposed to allow you to peek at your baby to assist with latching and so on collapses onto itself, so I spent more time trying to readjust it so I could make sure he's latched all while my son is flailing trying to get this thing off his face. I just ended up using the muslin blankets I was using prior to this purchase.The material is wonderfully breathable, I'm very sad that it didn't work for us.
3%
Don't Have the Time for These
July 14, 2017
It's cute/amusing to see their little mouths sucking on the "soother" through the plastic. Work fine when we have the time to hold it in baby's mouth, but when you need to walk away... it will fall out very easily. Worthless if using in the car when you can't be there to hold it in. We prefer the mam pacifiers bc they do not fall out as easily.
Arrived open
January 28, 2017
Arrived in an open package, yuckI kept meaning to send them back but with a new baby I just forgot and got new ones to replace these at Walmart for less $ anyway.Lesson learned
No miracle for baby that doesn't like pacis
November 15, 2015
I could never get either of my kids to take a pacifier, but I heard these were the best so I bought them for baby #2. He won't suck on them, unless maybe someone has their finger inside it, but will occasionally chew. I think he's confused by any nipple that is not my own.I should note that the two we got had a little pin hole at the tip of the nipple, which would let air through. This doesn't seem like a great design.
Product can be dangerous
September 26, 2015
Pacifiers can be hit or miss. It really depends on what your child prefers and you won't know until they get here and you try different products.These pacifiers were once our go-to brand and the vanilla scent is nice. However, during our hospital stay, a nurse informed us that this product should not be used unsupervised because some babies have gotten their fingers stuck in the hole in the middle while sucking causing loss of circulation. That made us discontinue the use of this product entirely and we switched to a different brand.
... pacifiers we got from the hospital and my son loved those from the beginning
July 8, 2015
We have the green 0-3 month pacifiers we got from the hospital and my son loved those from the beginning. Then I bought some 0-6 month blue ones and they were so hard (not as flexible as the 0-3 month ones) and he would not suck on those. So I found these blue 0-3 month ones, thinking they would be identical to the green ones he had - same brand and everything. They weren't - there were open holes in each of the nipples so when he sucked on them, he kept sucking in air. I don't know if that was a defect or if they are all like that, but ours ended up in the garbage :( Just putting it out there - these might be better to buy in a store if you can, then you can make sure there aren't any holes in the nipple end.
Not for my baby...
April 17, 2013
My baby found these very difficult to keep in her mouth, so I found myself literally holding it in for 45 minutes. I know the hospital uses these and they are supposedly wonderful for preventing teething issues, but I finally caved and bought a Dr. Browns version that is specifically made to work similarly. I think with the pacifier having such a straight piece that went in her mouth she couldn't keep a good suction on it. Also, the round back was so big it hit her nose, complicating it even further.
0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

One Star Reviews:

4%
Not worth the hassle
January 17, 2016
Not a fan!* the top area that's supposed to allow me to see the baby was bent and would not stay open.* it is very hot under the apron.* if your plus size, you will need to be careful not to show your sides (boobs).However, I did like*The drawstring in th back
Deshaped after wash.
January 15, 2016
The shape of the cover was badly damaged in one wash. Now I can't use it because I can't see my baby from the top.
Was sent wrong item from what I specifically ordered
December 14, 2015
Clicked on and ordered the "White Flower" pattern and received a totally different color and pattern that I am not interested in nor enjoy.
Wire bent so doesn't stand up.
December 2, 2015
It was stuffed into a small package and the wire that is supposed to hold the fabric out was bent. And so it didn't hold the fabric out, so I couldn't see my baby while he nursed. So I didn't use it.
Cute looking but doesn't function as it should
August 23, 2015
The drawstring in the back totally gets in the way and isn't helpful for any purpose. The rim collapses on itself so you can't peek at baby to help him latch. Very very frustrating.
5%
Breastfed baby hates these!
October 8, 2017
My baby hates these! The nipple is hard and shaped like a bottle nipple, and too thin, and he just can't latch on. He only used this pacifier once or twice and has spit it out every other time. The Nuk pacifiers are WAY better for breastfed babies because they more closely resemble mommy's nipple.
My baby didn't care for these. Our hospital used ...
September 22, 2017
My baby didn't care for these. Our hospital used normal pacifiers, so maybe that's why. She prefers the avent orthodontic pacifiers.
One Star
August 25, 2016
My son did not like this style of pacifier
A hole in the pacifier
July 31, 2016
One of them had a hole and I couldn't give it to my baby
Beware...major flaw in design
June 19, 2016
These were my baby's favorites until one morning when she got it stuck on her finger and her finger turned purple. Thank goodness I heard the cries. If it had been much longer bad things could've happened. Upon researching this I found we weren't the only ones that this happened to. I'm sad that a company so wonderful would overlook this major flaw. We immediately got rid of all of these and changed brands.
i don't recommend
June 9, 2015
They have a hole in the nipple that results in baby swallowing a ton of air. Not sure why it was designed that way but i am definitely not using this product. I would not recommend it.
0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

Vote for Me
Vote for Me
Vote for Me
Vote for Me
Vote for Me
Pricing info
Old Price
Old Price
Price
Price
$12.99updated: Mar 17, 2020
$3.19updated: Mar 18, 2020
$8.12updated: Mar 17, 2020
$44.99updated: Mar 15, 2020
$25.99updated: Mar 15, 2020
Features
Brand
Brand
Simplicity
Philips AVENT
Lansinoh
My Brest Friend
iLoveSIA
Color
Color
Grey 2
Pink/Purple
Cream
Petal
(Nude+black+light Pink)/Pack
Height
Height
43.3 in
216.5 in
70.9 in
275.6 in
122.0 in
Length
Length
303.1 in
141.7 in
196.8 in
925.2 in
429.1 in
Model
Model
88-B15010024-04
SCF190/02
thomaswi
846
S0170283P042611L
Product Group
Product Group
Baby Product
Baby Product
Health and Beauty
Baby Product
Apparel
Product Type
Product Type
BABY_PRODUCT
BABY_PRODUCT
HEALTH_PERSONAL_CARE
BABY_PRODUCT
BRA
Reviews
Reviews
-
-
Weight
Weight
1.2 oz
0.0 oz
0.7 oz
5.4 oz
2.5 oz
Width
Width
220.5 in
65.0 in
70.9 in
669.3 in
244.1 in
Feature
Feature

100% Cotton, measures 38" long x 26" wide

Offers full privacy coverage from the front and sides while nursing

Rigid neckline has adjustable wires so you maintain direct eye contact with your baby

Can be used as a nursing cover, blanket, and sunshade to protect your baby from UV rays.

Simplicity® is a registered trademark of PDS, items sold by "PDS Online" ship from the US (2-5 days).

Sized and shaped for baby's mouth

Latex free

Hospital grade silicone

Durable, one piece construction

Packaging may vary

Latex-free

Hospital-grade silicone

Durable, one-piece construction

#1 recommended nipple cream and nipple balm by Lactation Consultants and doctors in the US. Soothes and protects sore nipples

Safe for mom and baby, no need to remove before breastfeeding

100% natural, hypoallergenic, and preservative free

Trusted and recommended by millions of breastfeeding moms

Lips, heels, elbows, cuticles, eyebrows moisturizer

Adjustable silent release strap

Features wrap around design

Machine washable in the gentle cycle in warm water

No underwire and cups that drop fully away from the breast. Easy to use and discrete nursing clips, featuring one-handed access.

Removable, molded foam cups for a lining when you want it (to hide nipples or breast pads), and the ability to take it out when you don't.

Breathable, ribbed gore stretches to accomodate the normal bust size fluctuations nursing moms experience

Adjustable straps,Seamless and buttery-soft fabric that is remarkably comfortable to wear, and virtually invisible under clothing

3PACK(Black+Nude+Pink)/LOT

Sorry, there's no review at this time. Try changing the filter or leaving one.
Share your opinion
Please enter captcha code
captcha
Send