Side by Side Comparison of: Hydro Herbal vs CocoNara

great

Love it

These flavors are amazing...I wish it came in a different container maybe a circle one but it was still great

I like the product. I used other brands , but i am liking the hydro the most.

I love this! I ordered it on July 5th, the date for delivery was July 15th-18th. It arrived on the 10th, five days early. I was definitely happy about that. I was also able to track the shipping, which is a plus because I like to keep track of my packages. When the package arrived I could smell the shisha through the packaging (it smelled wonderful!). Upon opening the package, there were three boxes of shisha: 50g Red Lightning Strawberry shisha, 50g Tropical Storm Mango shisha, and 50g Blue Viper Blueberry shisha. I was expecting the bag the shisha was in to be messy (as is with the shisha I normally buy) but it is completely free of any oil on the outside of the bags, which I like because I'm a clean freak. They smell amazing and I cannot wait for my hookah to come in so I can finally enjoy them. I will definitely be buying from this seller again, I'm very happy with my purchase and the price I paid ($6.35 total). I would recommend anyone looking for quality shisha to buy this. It's awesome.

I bought these as a gift for my husband, who is both a hookah lover and a tobacco fiend. He swears by tobacco shisha and refuses to buy anything else, but I bought this for him on the sly for his birthday. Upon opening the box, I was attacked by the most delicious smelling little boxes I have ever had the pleasure to lay nose on. They smell SO GOOD. You also get a good amount of shisha (I'd say enough for two or three bowls per box, depending on how much you like to smoke.) I am definitely not disappointed, and we plan on ordering more. I highly recommend.

Once I discovered Coco Nara, I have not allowed myself to bother with any other charcoal brand. Coco Nara, although takes a little while to burn and start up, lasts a good amount of time and does not give the hookah a nasty burning, coal taste. The coals take longer to burn, unlike other brands which is great when you have started your hookah session. This charcoal is a must buy!

I stopped using Coco Nara for a while because it seemed like every coal I cooked smelled and tasted funny, so o switched. I recently moved and didn't have much of a choice, so I went back to Naras and they work wonderfully! They don't smell anymore and cook evenly!

Very satisfied with these coals!! I don't know what the haters are talking about, my coals last twice as long as any other coals iv ever used!! I have been an avid hookah smoker for about 4 years now, and u don't think I'll ever use anything else but coconara!!

TIP TO SMOKERS: INVEST IN A HOT PLATE!! that is how you will get the best use out of these coals. A butane lighter or torch will not light your coals to the extent of a hit plate..

I had an issue with my hookah at once, I wasn't getting enough smoke. I couldn't figure out why. I Bought a while new stem because I suspected a the stem was not air tight. The new stem was not any better. As soon as I got a hit plate, it solved all of my problems!! Thick and huge clouds now!!

Before I knew how to properly light coals and got an electric burner these did me no good. Now that I've got a burner these have to be the best upgrade for the money you can get for your hookah. I didn't realize how much the quick light coals impacted the taste and smoke amounts until I got these and wow, these are great. Huge smoke clouds and great taste. Get these right now.

When I was first introduced to the wonderful world of hookah, I was using the standard quick light coals and was always disappointed in how quickly they burned up. It was to the point that I was accustomed to having leftover shisha in the ceramic bowl that I would use at least once more before it was completely burnt up. I finally received a hookah as a present and my husband insisted that I buy these and that I wouldn't be disappointed. Don't tell him I said so, but for once he was completely right! These last 10x longer, AT LEAST! I run out of shisha before these little guys are completely burned out. I highly recommend these. The only flaw that I have found so far, is that their sizes are kind of awkward. They're too small to use just one, yet it's a little too much with two. We use two of them and place one each on the very edge of the ceramic bowl on top of the tinfoil and this is working well for us thus far. Also, just in case you weren't aware of it already, these don't light with a lighter. We place them on top of our electric stove top to light them. But we have a good system down to where this isn't even an inconvenience to us any longer. We start heating them while we're getting the hookah ready and by the time it's all set up, the coals are normally ready to be placed on top. So not a big deal, really! I definitely recommend these coals and you're getting a lot of bang for your buck! The price is incredible. Hope this helps!

Does this cause cancer or anything like that

Good and tasty but should offer more variety if you want to sell more. I liked the combo though

They smell delicious and you can't hardly feel it when you take a hit (because of the non tobacco/ nicotine) i thought it'd have a better taste but I can barely taste anything. Its kinda just like breathing.

This Herbal shisha is a relaxing tobacco-less version of classic shisa.The tastes I've tried so far are excellent, and the length of the burn per bowl has impressed me as well.If you'd like an entry level taste to shisha, give it a go, but remember that it cannot equally compare to traditional shisha.

I love the taste and smell of this shisha while smoking it! gives a pretty decent thickness of smoke and isn't harsh at all. however when storing it in between smokes the smell of the shisha is extremely strong and I had to wrap it in about 6 layers of plastic bags to get it from making my entire room smell like tropical shisha. otherwise it's fantastic!

I wanted an alternative to tobacco hookah even though no hookah is good to have. This hydro is great i like the ziplock puches they come in along with the vapor it produces is in thick clouds. The only thing i and 2 friends noticed is that it does have a tendecny to irrate your throat, that is in comparing it to tobacco hookah. But overall the best hyro hookah i have had

I'm not nearly as fond of Coco Nara coals as I am Fantasia's air-flow coals, but since there was a shortage earlier this year these seem to be the second best. We just found that using two didn't burn long enough and using three burned way too much, and I don't like having to rotate or ash my coals after using Fantasia coals, where I have to do neither.

I don't understand why people don't quite like these coals. They might not burn "SUPER" long, according to the professionals, but for my friend and I, they do the job. Up to last night we actually burnt a couple and lit them up, lasted well over an hour and honestly, we've had a few sessions, and we're still pretty shocked we have so much coals left.

Good coals. Coca Naras are great brand of hookah coals that will provide you with an enjoyable session. If you have been using instant light coals this is probably the best investment you can make. It will take 5-10 minutes to get these going but they last about 45 minutes so it is well worth the wait. There is no flavor given off these coals so you can completely enjoy the flavors of your shisha like never before! The only reason that I dropped a star from these is that if they sit around for too long they lose their longevity and will not burn as well. That being said you will love these coals, give them a try and find out for yourself.

I love these coals. I use them at home on my electric stove and they work beautifully. I took them to my boyfriends house and tried to heat them up on his gas/fire stove and it was so hard to get going. I might have the technique wrong but it was so annoying to try and get the coals hot enough. I would've thought fire would be easier but it seems electric heating coils are the way to go.

Right off the bat I want to point out that I gave this a 4 of 5 rating because these are not "easy to light" unless you have something HOT. Conventional lighters simply don't have the heat output and I don't recommend the stove idea mentioned by other reviewers simply because of the amount of power you are wasting just to light a chunk of coal. The fastest, easiest, and most effective way that I have found to light one of these bad boys up is to use a handheld propane, butane, or MAPP gas torch set up like the one seen here ([...]). Just hold the coal over the flame using your tongs and within a minute it should be hot enough that it will keep itself lit. You'll know if its ready when you blow air across the coal and it glows red. And with the heat that you are dealing with when it comes to these torches, all you have to do is expose one face of the coal to the flame and the coal should keep itself lit from there. Keep your fingers at a safe distance down your tongs while doing this, they can get a bit toasty. But once lit these things are great! They burn at a nice temperature, they keep burning for a long time (I've had a few hit 2.5 hours!), they have little to no odor at all and they dont mess with the flavor of your smokes. I love them other than the fact that they are kinda hard to get started.

A fair warning and disclosure to anyone who has never used a set up like the one I just showed, these torches get HOT HOT HOT! As in the thousands of degrees hot! MAPP gas being the hottest at 5,200+ degrees fahrenheit and butane being the lowest with 1,500+ degrees. So if you aren't experienced in dealing with a set up like this, then DON'T use this method. You can get very quickly and seriously hurt or set fire to something if you handle one of these systems the wrong way. I am not responsible for anyone's negligence, accidents, and otherwise painful or horrible experiences if you mishandle a gas torch. This is simply the method I use and the best one that I have found to light these coals but I am also experienced in handling these torches. Be smart and be safe.

It's not that smooth but it's ok

Nice flavors, I will probably buy again.

They smelled great in the box. I didn't really taste any of the flavors at all and it kind of burned my throat compared to other kinds I've gotten with real tobacco.

This was my first time buying this product and I think the pic is very misleading because It came in a box with a zip-lock bag inside without flavor labels. I have to keep them in box so I do not mix them up because then I wouldn't know witch is witch.

I wouldn't really go with these if I wanted to buy some more mix. It smells and taste good but it burns your throat. You'll be seriously regretting it the next day.

Not nearly as good as real shisha, the flavors do not come through nearly as well. It does make a good mixing agent which adds smell and flavor to whatever you want to put in there. It is okay by itself too, but I really don't see the point in doing that as tobacco in shisha helps add to the relaxation a lot. It also does not look anything like shisha, it looks like wet grass with food coloring, the least they could have done was to use leaf herbals and make it look like the real thing.

So I bought these coals bc they were pretty cheap. I was using Coco jamara before this and the Coco jamaras are way better. These naras are cut very poorly. They burn unevenly. And they don't burn as hot or well as the jamaras. These naras seem like they are packed as tight together as the jamaras which to me seems like it's causing them to burn unevenly and not as hot. When these burn there are little black dots that show it's not bringing evenly or there are small little gaps that aren't burning. I use a propane burner to light my coals and the jamaras burned so well compared to these. The jamaras make these look like a nock off brand. These also have a weird smell to them when they burn and when I blow on them they occasionally pop and crackle and spit hot pieces of coal at my face and it doesn't feel very good. But they do the job, light pretty easily, and burn for a while so that's why I'm giving 3 stars

These things ash like crazy and it's a messy ash, not the kind that stays clumped together and just falls off in layers, no. This one just falls everywhere and gets in the holes in the foil. Pieces are not very well cut or uniformly shaped. Lots of broken chunks. Shipped quick. Good value for quantity/price

They lasted about 2 hrs.. i really like this I dont care to have to put it on the stove but it works and last a long time

I've always loved Coco Naras but, after over a year of smoking hookahs with it, the cut of the coals and the quality of them are just too random. I've since tried various types and brands, I now prefer Ecocha coconut coals instead. Especially since they're HALF the price!

These just aren't the same as they used to be. They aren't as uniform and consistent and are very prone to cracking and breaking off the stove.

Do they get the job done? Yes. However, look into another brand. Coco Nara used to be my go to brand for coals, however, I won't be ordering anymore until the quality gets back to where it used to be.

expensive

this product is very stringy after a few puffs its like the liquid starts coming thru the hose/

The flavors are gross. Im Middle Eastern so I have been smoking shisha for years, the strawberry in this package is absolutely disgusting. The closest thing I can compare it to is Play Doh. Mango is alright, blueberry is not the worst. Oh and I started buying Fantasia Herbal so I'm also used to the Herbal flavor and I'm aware its a bit different than regular tobacco.

It's super messy, goops up the entire hookah, burns extremely fast. That being said it has great flavor for the 5 minutes it lasts.

So far, I have only smoked the blue flavor. It smells nice but has a very unpleasant chemically aftertaste that has been so offputting I have not tried the other two.

I wasn't pleased. Tasted very synthetic. It taste like plastic covered in dye and perfume.

Compared to Titanium these are sub par. They burn quickly and produce way too much ash. Titanium is a much cleaner way to go. I won't buy these again and probably won't use what I have.

Great coals. And always delivered on time

Update. Coals seem old or have moisture in them. They tend to turn off while using and make it hard to smoke a hookah. Most of the box will be thrown out

As much as I love coconut charcoal by Coco Nara, this one sucks!!! It takes forever to ligh up, like the bigger chunks I got before for bigger more professional hookas! Not good for home use. Not sure if they changed the product or it's just a new packaging, but I liked the old one much much more.

Normally Coco's are great. I don't know if these are fakes or I got a bad batch, but these ones didn't burn like normal coco's usually do, and seems contaminated. The ash is sometimes different colors than usual. The smoke is also harsher than it normally is.

I believe this box is the same as 108 pc by weight, just more smaller pieces

All I've tried is the strawberry and it burns the mess out of your throat(Update) they're all horrible changed my rating from 2 stars to 1

I am giving it a single star without trying it because I only received one flavor in the package. Blueberry only, where as the product description describes it to be a mix of 3. Highly disappointed!

i hate this brand soo much, The flavor is not the problem its whatever the brand uses to make these. your throat starts to hurt after 5 mins of inhaling this stuff.

Not real Sheesha, no tobacco, misleading advertising, tastes like nasty synthetic plastic.

Hated all three flavors. Smoke was very harsh, it made my throat burn and I kept coughing after each hit. Doesn't smoke good at all. An ink like liquid kept oozing out of the shisha and made a mess on my clothes and table. Although it smells really good in the packaging, it tastes awful. I threw it out. Do not recommend it at all.

I received the hydro herbal shisha and it was in a small bag with no bubble wrap. I opened it and the three boxes were bent and slightly opened. I was very disappointed that the boxes were non salvageable. One of the bags of molasses was open. I wouldn't recommend this product unless they got better shipping packaging.

Used to be good, this is a horrible quality and not what it use to be at all, not even close.
These charcoal turn from hot red to cold black, before it's consumed.

coco nara used to be good. they were my first non quick light coals i used beginning of 2014 and they were fine. times have changed and these coals don't burn as hot as other coco type coals. i tried using them in a lotus and i had to keep "refiring" the coals. they must've changed their formula or something

These simply won't light, so I'm stuck with this clunky box of charcoal. So disappointing.

No it is so inconsistent different sizes which it is not good for head management

Both boxes appear to be a mixture of tiny, ashy low heat coals and large brown-when-lit coals that emit an awful smell and flavor. Yes, I am familiar with natural coals--these were lit in a well-ventilated environment with a desktop coil burner. Have used Titanium, Prestige, Haze, Ecoal, Fantasia, etc... Would prefer any of the previous to these. Don't believe the relatively recent positive reviews; they either received old stock or aren't genuine reviews.