4 items
Compare
Compare
All Features
Differing
Cole & Mason
Cole and Mason 505 Precision Pepper Mill, Clear Acrylic, Peppercorns Included - Cole & Mason
Spicy World
Spicy World Peppercorn (Whole)-Black Tellicherry, 16 Oz. bag - Spicy World
Kirkland Signature
Kirkland Signature Whole Tellicherry Peppercorns, 14.1oz Gourmet Jar - Kirkland Signature
Mr.Butler
Broom and Mop Holder Wall Mount Garden Tool Storage Tool Rack Storage & Organization for the Home Plastic Hanger for Closet Garage Organizer Shed Organizer Basement Storage General Storage - Mr.Butler

Side by Side Comparison of: Cole & Mason vs Spicy World vs Kirkland Signature vs Mr.Butler

Learn More
All Features
Differing
Learn More
Cole & Mason http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41CX7UO-7jL._SL160_.jpg
Cole and Mason 505 Precision Pepper Mill, Clear Acrylic, Peppercorns Included - Cole & Mason
Add to Whishlist
Spicy World https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/51olv4dCjDL._SL160_.jpg
Spicy World Peppercorn (Whole)-Black Tellicherry, 16 Oz. bag - Spicy World
Add to Whishlist
Kirkland Signature https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/4163q9ClSIL._SL160_.jpg
Kirkland Signature Whole Tellicherry Peppercorns, 14.1oz Gourmet Jar - Kirkland Signature
Add to Whishlist
Mr.Butler https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/41HUvd07lvL._SL160_.jpg
Broom and Mop Holder Wall Mount Garden Tool Storage Tool Rack Storage & Organization for the Home Plastic Hanger for Closet Garage Organizer Shed Organizer Basement Storage General Storage - Mr.Butler
Rating info
eComparisons Score
eComparisons ScoreThe "Comparison Score" Is calculated based on the average number of times this item was compared with other items in this category by our users
7.8
9.4
0
6.6
User Rating (Amazon)
User Rating (Amazon)

Five Star Reviews:

56%
Great salt grinder!!!
July 2, 2017
Very good grinder. I use rock salt from Ctibet. Solid and well built it does it's job well.
) This works perfectly and was a good price.
May 29, 2017
Whew. I got tired of rubbing salt rocks on my food :) This works perfectly and was a good price.
KORN
May 1, 2017
This is a quality grinder. Very sleek looking too. I decided to purchase the salt grinder also. 👍👍
Perfect pepper all the time.
September 27, 2016
While experimenting, I found that I could make it very course or as fine as talcum powder. Just turn upside down first, then tighten or the pepper corns or some of the ground pepper by the grater might prevent tightening to your needs.
Excellent product, according to the publication and all in perfect condition.
September 25, 2015
Excellent product, according to the publication and all in perfect condition. The product and the brand is strongly recommended, they are very resistant acrylic, but obviously have to be careful not to fall to the ground, the packaging tells you that you should not use the pepper mill salt for it because it is metal oxidizes it is why the salt mill system is pricisamente ceramics to avoid this, it really works and the output of the product is very thin and can regulate the output and ground to your liking. Recommending ...
I'm digging it
February 23, 2015
so far so good. I like the mechanism that is easily twistable to make finer or coarser grinds. simple build.I could possibly see someone being rough with this and breaking something, the metal mechanism seems slightly fragile, but for me I am somewhat careful and it has worked really well. the coarseness adjustment can possibly skew over time/uses changing the desired coarseness, but a simple twist fixes it and it has not been a problem for me.While not the best / strongest pepper grinder in the world, works well for the price and I would definitely buy again.
83%
Really yummy!
July 15, 2017
I was skeptical about ordering peppercorns on Amazon. These are amazing! They are much better tasting than the other brands I have tried! My hubby usually does not like freshly cracked pepper & prefers ground pepper. He really enjoys this one. I was shocked! I highly recommend.
Outstanding aroma and flavor, not your usual black pepper.
November 22, 2016
I love this pepper. The moment you open the bag, you can smell the difference between Tellicherry and regular peppercorns. They're more fragrant, and a richer, more complex flavor. Not the hard, acrid bite of regular black pepper. This pepper was, allegedly, one the 11 'secret herbs and spices' used by a certain colonel on his fried chicken.
FLAVORFUL AND PUNGENT!
August 6, 2016
I always buy Tellicherry Peppers because I have found them to be pungent, and flavorful. These arrived soon after I ordered them and are very fresh tasting. I grind these peppercorns and use on everyday, almost on everything but especially when cooking Indian, Mexican, or Chinese food. It is best to store them in a glass jar while keeping the rest in your pepper grinder for easy access.
Gourmet Quality Peppercorns - a bang for your buck!
February 10, 2016
I recommend this product! I needed some peppercorns to use in a new salt and pepper grinder set that i have. Since i was getting the set from Amazon i decided to go ahead and buy the peppercorns here! I nice heavyweight bag of peppercorns with a zip lock to close after you get out what you need. They grind up nice and have a nice smell and taste. What do you say about pepper? I am not a pepper expert, but i do know there is a huge difference between ready ground pepper and when you grind it yourself and I do know that when the bag runs out I will order the same again ! It seems that i got much more peppercorns for the money than if i would have made a quick run to the grocery store.
Pepper that is better than pepper!
September 18, 2015
It's pepper. But somehow it's better than pepper. It's like... super pepper? Ultra pepper? Crazy pepper. I like Crazy Pepper the best. I'm going to call this Crazy Pepper from now on. I've also added it to our Prime Pantry list to ship every six months.You wouldn't think there was that much difference between regular "mass produced" pepper (I feel weird even saying that) and this. But there is. Just try it. Get yourself a nice grinder.
The perfect black pepper
October 3, 2011
The peppercorns arrived on time and were sealed, air tight, in a thick plastic bag. I cook on a regular basis at home. I think tellicherry peppercorns are the best black pepper taste. I got some variety peppercorns years ago for my grinder, and I forgot what I was missing. Now I've got a huge supply of awesome peppercorns for stews and my grinder. This product is probably more the size that a restaurant would buy but it smells and tastes amazing, I'll share some with my neighbors.
0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

Four Star Reviews:

14%
Did a good job for that year tho
September 21, 2017
Broke within a year. Did a good job for that year tho!
Four Stars
June 16, 2017
Well made and good price
Fresh pepper
March 5, 2017
I bought this for my mom because our old one broke. She wanted a fresh pepper grinder. It works great.
Almost perfect.
November 17, 2016
Works well. Grinds well. Nice looking.My only objection is that it gets salt in the teeth and top rim when you refill it. This makes it impossible to get the cap on tight; letting salt leak out of the bottom until the salt in the teeth works itself out.You have to keep tightening the cap as you use it, until the leak works itself out. Then it's salt-tight again.
Decent pepper mill at a nice price. The matching salt grinder makes a nice ...
August 30, 2016
Decent pepper mill at a nice price. The matching salt grinder makes a nice combination without going overboard. I learned to shake the mills after grinding to get the last bits out before returning to the cabinet. This prevents most of the mess others complain about.
This is a fine product. But shortly after I bought this
March 23, 2016
This is a fine product. But shortly after I bought this, I bought an electric coffee grinder. Consequently I now grind my pepper corns and other spices in the electric grinder. BTW, if you grind your own coffee beans, you have a much better idea of what's in your morning cup of Joe. Hope this helps you. Ted
11%
Clean
October 5, 2016
Much larger than expected, though if I recall correctly, there were smaller sizes and I ordered the most effectively priced. The scent is musky and rich, though I am accustomed to a fruity black pepper, this should be what I want. My pepper grinder is full and there is enough to refill it again
Very Good Tasting Pepper.
June 26, 2016
This is a good-tasting pepper. It isn't quite as good as everyone stated in their reviews here, I thought. I had some peppercorns that came in a gourmet pepper mill I bought a couple of years ago that were really fantastic, and I can't find any that quite live up to that pepper. But this is much better than the peppercorns from the grocery store which mostly just make me sneeze. Very good pepper.
special pepper, says my husband
March 19, 2016
To me, pepper is pretty much pepper. The flavor does taste fresh and the smell makes me sneeze, so I guess it is good stuff. My husband, who COVERS his food in pepper says that this pepper is pretty special.
This was our first introduction to "upgraded" or "high end" ...
December 28, 2015
This was our first introduction to "upgraded" or "high end" black pepper, and our pepper use has dramatically increased. What the heck is that black powder people normally use . . sheesh. Grind it baby, grind it! It will make you sneeze Ahhhh- -chhhoouuuee, involuntary reaction, mmmmm yummy another irresistible reaction.
Good deal and a pound goes a long way!
June 3, 2015
All I can say is a pound of peppercorns are a heck of a lot. Regardless these peppercorns seemed somewhat dry but they grinded well in my grinder. The taste is also good. I also saved over $7 by redeeming my points from Amazon Card so paid only paid $5.80. Great deal either way. I shouldn't need any more for at least two years.
Good & Fresh; re-bag it
December 3, 2014
Good stuff. The only issue might be being too frugal. There are a lot of peppercorn here. If they last you over a year, you'll be well served to toss what's left and get a new batch. Sure, you could freeze them; double bag them, etc., but really?... Good... fresh ground pepper is so nice, compared to... WELL... that other stuff, why be too frugal?Bottom line tho... It's good and fresh when you get it. Just be sure to re-bag it right away to help keep it fresh.
0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

Three Star Reviews:

12%
Looks like they are trying to save money
August 8, 2017
Grinder works. Was only a quarter full of pepper. Looks like they are trying to save money.
Three Stars
March 16, 2017
I would have liked the burrs to be adjustable.
Three Stars
January 29, 2017
Can not change the grinding size.
Slight disappointment.
June 23, 2016
I would have appreciated a few more of the peppercorns they said were included. The grinder is ok. I just received it and I actually purchased it for the peppercorns. So, I guess I should have gone to the store to get a visual of what I was actually getting.
Nice grinder, few peppercorns!
March 20, 2016
I was disappointed that the grinder only had a small amount of peppercorns in it! Just had a small amount at the bottom...about one-eighth full if that. I liked the grinder and didn't feel like going through the hassle of returning, but will have to buy peppercorns soon!
The first product that I've had to author a poor review- this mill worked great for the 1st month
May 24, 2015
5/24/15 - ONE STAR. The first product that I've had to author a poor review- this mill worked great for the 1st month. I used coarse salt in it, it worked great. However, now it will not dispense any salt. I've cleaned it out multiple time in attempt to find the issue. The mechanisms are intact, it just won't dispense. Very disappointing product.7/18.15 - 3 STAR UPDATE - based on the reply/response rec'd for this item, I have updated from 1 starto a 3. It's appreciated the customer service after this type of experience. The item will be returned/replaced.
3%
Hot
October 19, 2017
Be aware that these peppercorns are surprisingly hot - much hotter than other brands I've used.
Okay Pepper
June 4, 2017
I thought I'd try a different brand and buy this, but I wasn't very happy. It's okay, but definitely doesn't have as strong of a flavor as the previous ones I've bought. Not sure if it was this batch or if that's how this brand is.
So-so
October 27, 2016
It's slightly better than the Trader joes brand. I hear penzey's is better and will try that next,
no real difference in taste
October 2, 2016
small peppercorns
Three Stars
September 2, 2016
This was ok, but not as strong as expected. Shipping was fast!
One issue with this...
April 9, 2016
Love the peppercorns however, I just pulled it out of the box and the bag had a hole in it. A small amount went all over my floor so packaging will get a lower rating. Other then that, great product when it's not falling out all over the place
0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

Two Star Reviews:

7%
Worked for a while...
August 15, 2017
I bought this in February 2016 to grind sea salt. It worked great for a while, and then stopped working. I expected more from a $10 salt grinder. I can't recommend this product.
Not a Good Grinder
August 14, 2017
This does NOT create fine salt crystals - it only produces Large Chunky rock salt. I wanted a grinder which Would actually grind my sea salt - this is NOT it.
Looks good, doesn't work so well
December 25, 2016
As far as I can tell, there is no way to adjust the size of the grind, and what is produced is much to large for many purposes. This is especially true if one is trying to use this as a table salt mill. The ground salt is far too large.
It looks sleek on the table Good size Easy to refill Cons
April 28, 2016
Pros:It looks sleek on the tableGood sizeEasy to refillCons:I am unable to adjust grain size so I constantly have huge chunks of salt in my food.Smaller grains "leak" out when the grinder is stored.I wish there was a cover for the bottom so my cabinet isn't covered in salt.
I find the mess that it makes quite annoying.
October 7, 2015
Salt constantly falls out of this every time it is moved. I find the mess that it makes quite annoying.
I wanted a grinder, not a shaker
September 11, 2015
This wholly designed in England (but actually made in China) grinder is truly one of the worst grinders I have ever used. It gets two stars for aesthetics, but zero stars for performance. The grinding mechanism is so faulty that the salt crystals simply fall straight through like a shaker - even when it sits on the counter. What a mess! And yes, I am using large salt crystals. I am envious of those that got one that works, because it really is a good looking grinder & has a nice substantial hand feel. It just doesn't grind, so back it goes.
1%
Prefer pepper that has a nice cracked pepper flavor for salads and such
July 6, 2017
Hot and flavorless. Prefer pepper that has a nice cracked pepper flavor for salads and such.
Two Stars
February 1, 2017
Bag was not full. Not a 1lb bag. Buyer Beware! Would not buy again
bad taste
May 20, 2016
has a bad "twang" to it.
Too many stems/leaves in this product
July 14, 2015
There are too much trash/debris in this product
Not a high quality product.
November 12, 2014
I usually buy Penzey's peppercorns, but thought I'd try something different this time. Penzey's come very clean, only peppercorns in the package. The Spicy World pacage contained peppercorns, stems and other unidentifiable junk. It's not bad enough problem for me to return the package, because I can pick out the "junk" by hand. However, this is not a quality product.
True Tellicherry Peppercorns?
July 21, 2011
It is said that the Tellicherry is "the largest of the peppercorns". The product that I received must be from a miniature variant. Measuring in at a scant 2.5mm, my grinder turns these little corns into dust, even at the coarsest setting. The taste however, is excellent. I will utilize these in recipes calling for "hand-cracked" peppercorns, and will use a light hand when I do.
0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

One Star Reviews:

11%
No! No! No!
August 23, 2017
The salt mill broke after less than a month!
Very disappointed. Grinder does not work properly - it does ...
July 27, 2017
Very disappointed . Grinder does not work properly - it does not grind the sea salt and the corse salt that I always use fallsout of bottom of shaker. I have and have had several Cole and Mason salt and pepper grinders and this is the first time thishas happen.
Does NOT work...
January 22, 2017
UGH! what a waste of time and money. Doesn't work at all. Too bad "circumstances" didn't allow me to use it and find this out sooner so I could return it.
NOT RECOMMENDED
June 26, 2016
I expected this salt grinder to leave dabs of salt behind wherever it's sitting, I did not expect it to leave literally piles of salt - about a tablespoon - when I pick it up.
Don't waste your money.
October 22, 2015
NO NOT BUY - this thing doesn't work as other people had wrote as well, it just dumps it out as it went in. Doesn't grind the sea salt at all. I tightened the screw as much as it can go and it just doesn't grind at all.
I do not recommend.
August 4, 2015
Horrible design. It litters the table with salt because there is nothing between where the salt come out of the bottom and the table surface.
2%
One Star
January 15, 2017
Not top quality. Grain size is small.
sticks and dust
December 28, 2016
Last time I ordered this I gave it 5 stars but this time the package is loaded with dust and pieces of sticks. We are going to have to take the whole bag and weed through it. Don't get me wrong the pepper is great but I wasn't planning on processing 16 ounces of pepper to get twigs out of it. This photo is just what I took out of my pepper grinder. My feeling is this bag was from the bottom of the batch.
This is a do not buy warning
September 19, 2016
1 star because it is pepper but it is not Tellicherry. This pepper was very bland almost dusty tasting worst pepper I've ever had. I feel I was deceived with this product and here's why. Tellicherry peppercorns and regular black pepper both come from the the same vine the species Piper Nigrum. The fruit is picked from the vines and dried into what we know as black peppercorns then the peppercorns are taken to a grabling facilities where a machine sorts them by size. The various peppercorn sizes are called different things and sold for different prices. So a Tellicherry peppercorn determined by size. When a peppercorn is 4.5 mm or larger it is Tellicherry. Tellicherry makes up only 10% of a crop and command a higher price. In the 16oz bag of pepper I received there may have been 1 oz that would make the grade Tellicherry.Absolutely will not purchase anything from spice world again .I did add some photo
One Star
August 10, 2016
Taste too bland
I really hate these Peppercorns
July 14, 2016
I really hate these Peppercorns. They are NOT Tellicherry peppercorns. I have bought real telllicherry peppercorns, these are average at best. This is fraud to call these Tellicherry.. If you want real Tellicherry peppercorns You will find they are not cheap, but they are worth it. I was buying mine from Spices etc.. They raised the price so I was looking for them cheaper. else where... I will not do it again.
I was looking forward to receiving this pepper. I ...
July 1, 2015
I was looking forward to receiving this pepper. I even bought a battery operated pepper & salt grinder to grind it. The pepper was not only hard and dry, but had other stuff in it as well. BOTTOM LINE, I COULD NOT GRIND IT. Will never purchase this again.
0%

There are no reviews yet

0%

There are no reviews yet

Vote for Me
Vote for Me
Vote for Me
Vote for Me
Pricing info
Old Price
Old Price
Price
Price
$13.80updated: Mar 20, 2020
$14.18updated: Mar 18, 2020
$9.01updated: Mar 6, 2020
$13.47updated: Feb 27, 2020
Features
Answered Questions
Answered Questions
-
-
-
Article Number
Article Number
0054067505039
0089836002488
0885720481229
0739027531142
Binding
Binding
Kitchen
-
-
-
Brand
Brand
Cole & Mason
Spicy World
Kirkland Signature
Mr.Butler
Color
Color
Clear
-
-
Gray
Currency
Currency
-
USD
USD
USD
Height
Height
216.9 in
393.7 in
117.7 in
110.2 in
Label
Label
-
Spicy World
Kirkland Signature
-
Legal Disclaimer
Legal Disclaimer
-
Information about this product is provided for informational purposes and is not meant to substitute for the advice provided by your own physician or other medical professional. You should not use the information contained herein for diagnosing or treatin
-
-
Length
Length
86.6 in
472.4 in
260.2 in
700.8 in
Manufacturer
Manufacturer
Cole and Mason
Spicy World
Kirkland Signature
-
Model
Model
H50501PT
H35C63
four21-five02-jooi2732
-
MPN
MPN
H50501PT
310847
164950
-
Number of Parts
Number of Parts
H50501PT
310847
164950
-
Product Group
Product Group
Kitchen
Grocery
Grocery
Kitchen
Product Type
Product Type
KITCHEN
GROCERY
GROCERY
KITCHEN
PublicationDate
PublicationDate
-
2011-04-14
2014-07-15
-
Publisher
Publisher
Cole and Mason
Spicy World
Kirkland Signature
-
Quantity
Quantity
1
1
1
-
Release Date
Release Date
-
-
2014-07-15
-
Reviews
Reviews
-
Score
Score
7.8
9.4
-
6.6
Size
Size
-
1 lbs
14.1 Ounce
-
Studio
Studio
Cole and Mason
Spicy World
Kirkland Signature
-
Title
Title
-
Spicy World Peppercorn (Whole)-Black Tellicherry, 16 Oz. bag
Kirkland Signature Whole Tellicherry Peppercorns, 14.1oz Gourmet Jar
Broom and Mop Holder Wall Mount Garden Tool Storage Tool Rack Storage & Organization for the Home Plastic Hanger for Closet Garage Organizer Shed Organizer Basement Storage General Storage
Weight
Weight
0.0 oz
0.6 oz
3.1 oz
4.9 oz
Width
Width
86.6 in
393.7 in
120.9 in
157.5 in
Feature
Feature

Machine cut carbon steel precision mechanism creates a smooth and even turn

Easily fill the pepper mill by removing the top

Conveniently select between fine or coarse granules by adjusting the knob on top

Unique 5.5 inch tall doorknob design with premium balance and weight

Lifetime Guarantee, hand wash with damp cloth, do not submerge

If we had to select just one spice to flavor our food, pepper, the master spice ,would be a wise choice.

Whole black peppercorns.

Frontier Herb Peppercorns - Whole - Black - Tellicherry Grade - Bulk - 1 lb

One of the world's most popular spices, black peppercorns are actually unripe green fruits (berries)

14.1 oz jar

Hand harvested for best berries

Product of India, packed in U.S.A.

Robust, pungent, and fruity flavor

Add flavor to beef, chicken, fish, soups, stews and vegetables.

THE MOST DEPENDABLE APPLIANCE IN YOUR KITCHEN: Specially designed to hold even the most obscure kitchen accessories, Mr. Butler offers you a helping hand in storing everything you need to keep your kitchen in order. Tested and proved to be one of the most durable and long-lasting products of its kind, take confidence in Mr. Butler for all of your storage needs. We guarantee customer satisfaction.

ORGANIZE YOUR KITCHEN WITH MR. BUTLER: 5 ball slots and 6 industrial grade hooks help you organize up to 11 cleaning accessories in one place. Hooks can easily be folded up to make way for additional storage and space. Mr. Butler is easy to install and can be applied to just about any open surface. Fight the clutter and make more space for what matters! When you need help in your kitchen, look no further than Mr. Butler.

NEVER SLIPS, NEVER SLIDES: Premium rubber grips ensure that your kitchen and cleaning utilities won't slip and slide. Mr. Butler's tight hold keeps accessories in place so you don't have to worry about the mess or the hassle. Even the thinnest and smoothest of handles are no match for the strong grasp of Mr. Butler! Mr. Butler also comes with additional screws and anchors to make sure it is always securely fastened to the wall.

MR. BUTLER GOES EVERYWHERE: Use Mr. Butler anywhere you need help organizing your busy life! In the kitchen, the garage, laundry, storage closet, office, and much more! You can count on our premium quality and always fair pricing. With Mr. Butler, no organization is too daunting! Depend on Mr. Butler when your space needs a quick and efficient clean.

MONEY BACK GUARANTEE: If you are not completely satisfied with Mr. Butler, we will replace or refund you, no questions asked! We are that confident in your satisfaction with the Mr. Butler organizer!

Sorry, there's no review at this time. Try changing the filter or leaving one.
Share your opinion
Please enter captcha code
captcha
Send