Compare | |||||
Compare All Features Differing |
Side by Side Comparison of: Stanco vs Mainstays vs Frigidaire vs JUMBL™
Learn More | |||||
Learn More | |||||
Rating info | |||||
eComparisons Score | |||||
eComparisons ScoreThe "Comparison Score" Is calculated based on the average number of times this item was compared with other items in this category by our users | 8 | 8 | 9 | 0 | 0 |
User Rating (Amazon) | |||||
User Rating (Amazon) | |||||
Five Star Reviews: | 58% Perfect replacement! March 16, 2017 Perfect fit for my GE range. They aren't the highest quality of metal, but I didn't really care. I was moving out of an apartment and didn't feel like trying to clean the old ones. These fit perfectly and look very shiny...the apartment manager was extremely slow and shiny things made her happy, so there were no problems at all. Perfect! December 7, 2016 I was a little worried about these fitting my stove--they were not ones that said they were appropriate for my model. But they fit perfectly, and they are much better than the ones I had. These have a bit of a texture, so they are not as shiny as the old ones. And I think these will clean up better. Plus, the little notch actually does lock the elements in place so they are not sticking up unevenly. I'm so glad I found these! Perfect Fit for My 15 Year Old GE Spectra Electric Stove September 7, 2016 These fit my GE Spectra Electric Stove perfectly. They replaced the GE Part #'s I needed WB31T10010 (6") & WB31T10011 (8') and, of course, were much cheaper than ordering from GE. As pictured, the drip pans have one notch for the burner leg directly across from the hole that the burner plug goes through (when reading the reviews before I ordered, this seemed to be an issue for some). The quality of these are fantastic! Much heavier than the ones that originally came with the stove. The burners sit flat in the drip pans with no problems. I'm very happy with this purchase & my stove looks new again! Great Bowls April 24, 2016 These are the best reflector bowls I have purchased for my stovetop. They are heavy duty and do not feel flimsy. I have purchased some universal bowls before, but they seemed fit very loosely. I saw these and thought I would try them.I have a teenage boy that likes to cook and so stuff falls under the burners all the time. These are easy to clean after a messy adventure with the boy. They have kept their original shine.Another issue I had with other bowls was that the burners did not sit flush and had a slant. The burners fit perfectly in these. There is an amazing difference in the way these performed relative to the bowls in the past. I would recommend these bowls. Fits Great Stanco Bowls September 28, 2012 I bought these because they were the only ones that had 3 slots showing in the bowls and didn't cost an arm and leg. I was worried they wouldn't fit based on other reviews but guess I am one of the lucky ones as they fit perfectly. My stove is a Frigidaire about 15 yrs old or older (I rent so I don't know actual age). Oh, as I type this, I've only tried the larger ones first so don't know if smaller ones fit. I also inserted foil protector inserts after plugging in the burners. Still fits great. Great Reflector Bowls December 5, 2009 By far one of the best items for the price I have ever purchased on Amazon. These lines are a heavy gauge metal and though I'm not sure exactly what it is it's at least twice that of the lines that came with the stove. I purchased the GE/Hotpoint porcelain ones.Speaking of those that came with the stove... they were a polished aluminum that stained easily and were very difficult to clean. The last straw with my original inferior liners was when we used a large pressure cooker on the stove and the liners burned to the point that they couldn't be cleaned... they were in shades of black & blue on both sides. Since they were silver in color the stove top then looked terrible and the burning would have come from the use of any large or oversized pot. The stove was not a cheapie and I'd expect the liners to hold up better but I was wrong and since the liners had to be replaced... or covered in foil for eternity... I opted to try these and I'm glad I did. These also sit in place and do not move around!These are not only black but they are also enameled and much easier to clean. Since the stove is white with a black door and control panel these look great and enhance the look of the stove. Since they're black every speck of crud that falls isn't very noticeable and I can stop being as anal retentive about cleaning. The only drawback to them is that they transfer the heat and get very hot... much more than the original ones... and that heat will transfer to the range top. I wouldn't call them "Reflector Bowls" because they don't reflect as much heat as they absorb.Lastly, these lines also only accommodate one set of alignment tabs so if your stove elements require three of those alignment slits in the liner then these won't work... as another reviewer point out. However, the description does state they have a locking notch and not three locking notches. If you don't have a GE or Hotpoint they perhaps the Universal is what you need. | 57% Love them! April 22, 2017 Solved my problem of dirty drip rings around my burners. Wish I had found them sooner. Unless you are a very messy cook they will work for you and when they do get dirty, you just toss them! I used to scrub my catchers and line them with foil about twice a year. What a pain to do, these make the job a snap. I will always use them on my stoves from now on. A great time saver! January 7, 2017 These are perfect for my stove top and save a lot of time from having to clean the steal ones. They last a long time and when I am ready to clean up under the burners, I just swap out the old with the new. The old ones go in the recycling. Quite a time saver! I will definitely be purchasing these again! I wish I bought these a long time ago! August 14, 2016 I wish I bought these a long time ago!Okay, so everyone seems to have had them before but me, but now that I have them, I am tickled at how much easier they are to clean that the actual pans they cover. If they ever became too difficult to clean, of course, they are designed to be just thrown out. I love knowing that a clean stove isn't a ton of work away! Big time saver! March 24, 2016 These are the best things I never knew I needed. I got so tired of cleaning/scrubbing drip pans I just gave up. Then a friend told me about these. Murphy's Law-I bought them and didn't spill/drip anything in them for months! Ha ha ha! But when they get dirty, just switch out for another one. Easy peasy! Nice find May 11, 2015 I have a very old stove (it's avocado color - 70's). The newer pans will not fit, so I was pleasantly surprised to find these were still available. They fit great and keep the stove looking clean. Exactly what I needed to keep for continuously having to ... October 13, 2014 Exactly what I needed to keep for continuously having to buy stainless steel drip pans. Protects them and if the liners get stains from overflow, I can throw them away and insert new liners. | 76% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
Four Star Reviews: | 14% Nice clean up. September 22, 2017 They clean up great, but don't fit perfectly...don't line up with the holes on my stovetop. They lay flat though, so are ok. Not able to find another brand that is Teflon. Good enough and best price around!! September 12, 2017 On my Model RB757WH5WW HOTPOINT ELECTRIC RANGE, the 6-inch trays fit perfect. The 8 inch fit good enough but have a smaller edge than the 6 inch so it doesn't cover the surrounding stove top perimeter as the 6-inch covers. When I discovered that I started out to return but changed my mind because for the price and the fact these fit good enough to serve the intended purpose I changed my mind and decided to keep them. No one is going to notice but me anyway lol. perfect fit for GE/Hotpoint August 9, 2017 4 stars because the "fit" is perfect for GE/Hotpoint range model #R B757B H1WH. Otherwise, I would have only given the drip bowls 2 stars, as I confused myself by expecting the drip pans to be made out of the same materials and heft as the oven lining itself which is porcelain enamel. I believe these black porcelain drip pans are the same as the originals that came with the stove. The originals rusted and wore through within less than a year just like the chrome ones that I have purchased as replacements. I don't always remember to wash and dry drip pans after each use, so that probably contributes to more rapid corrosion of the pans. However, I have paid as little as $5.00/set and as much as $15.00/set for replacement drip pans, and they still end up rusting quite rapidly. GE says not to line the drip bowls with aluminum foil so as to avoid hotspots...so there you are. I can't really fault the quality of these yet as they haven't been given time to please or disappoint, but I will keep searching for baked enamel drip pans. These were good, but for whatever reason the bigger ones just ... May 31, 2017 These were good, but for whatever reason the bigger ones just didn't fit quite right. They are a touch too big. Still a good price! I rent so I'm not going to stress about it. Tall but good quality May 31, 2017 Fit nicely, look good. A tiny bit higher than my originals but since replaced all they are symmetrical. If only replacing one it may feel as if your stove is lopsided as flat surface is slightly lower than burners. But works great for me Darker, more dull appearance but certainly functional April 29, 2017 Entirely satisfactory and perfect match for my stove top. The only surprise is the darker, more dull appearance when compared to the shiny chrome pans that were being replaced by these new ones. | 16% Good value August 17, 2017 These were very cheap for a 12-pack, so the value is definitely great. The foil pans are a bit thin but I don't mind as they're replaceable. They do the job they're meant to do. Does a good job for the area that it covers August 14, 2017 Does a good job for the area that it covers. Does not cover the inside rim of the eye so food can get on that that area and then fall under the drip lip of the drip catchers. Improves the situation greatly however. They fit in the stove well and are easy to wipe food out of so you don't have ... April 25, 2017 We didn't receive mainstays but I guess that doesn't really matter. They fit in the stove well and are easy to wipe food out of so you don't have to replace them every time they get dirty. Will buy again March 27, 2017 i was pleased there were more than 4 things in a pack. they don't secure the best but they do what they were intended to do. will buy this again when all mine get dirty again. Good solid quality drip pan coverings! March 22, 2016 These could be a tiny bit larger to fit around the standard drip pans better, but still good quality as it is not flimsy. I was able to take these out and wash it and put it back. Let's hope it lasts! These drip pans are pretty good. January 31, 2016 When I first bought these, I thought they were of cheap quality. However, although they are thin, they still do a great job. And because of being thin they can be shaped to fit any stove top. | 11% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
Three Star Reviews: | 9% Not a great fit for my stove top but okay June 23, 2017 Not a great fit for my stove top but okay. Will get something else next time I replace the pans. Not cooking with gas! May 8, 2017 Says it fits hot point. Small rings do but big rings do not. I bought these as replacements and was disappointed. Weird fit March 31, 2017 The small burners fit perfect but the larger ones dont fit right wich makes the whole burner tilt slightly. Odd fit. Somewhat disappointing.... September 16, 2016 They are at least 10% smaller than the porcelain coated ones they replace. They very nearly didn't fit the surface holes for my older Hotpoint, The material is also more lightweight than I was expecting. I may revisit this review after some use depending on the performance of the material in high heat, etc. Will do the job but looks cheap March 29, 2016 Bought these for my mother to replace the drip pans on her electric range that needed a bit more love than scouring would handle. I wish I checked the range first to see if I really needed all the notches because I didn't - but that's the smallest issue. Everything did fit properly though. They look shiny and nice, don't get me wrong, but they don't scream quality. While I'm happy that she has new shiny drip pans on her stove, I wish I spent a bit more to get her something a bit higher quality. Doesn't fit style "B" ranges - GE, Kenmore,Hotpoint, RCA February 8, 2013 Reflector bowls look great but the larger ones don't fit my Kenmore range well as they are too small and slide around. Recently I found out there are two styles of drip pans - styles "A" and "B". The larger pans for style "A" are smaller than the style "B" ones. Style "B" ranges include Kenmore, GE, Hotpoint, RCA, Roper, Moffat, Monogram, and Profile. If you have any of these ranges look for style "B" drip pans in the description. | 7% They do the trick March 3, 2017 The pans are thin and little pricy, but they do the trick. Very hard to find them in the stores lately. Okay October 31, 2016 Nothing exceptional, but it does the trick. The shipping could be better as they come all bent up. Will work August 25, 2015 While they fit in the drip pan you have to do a little work to get it to mold to the actual shape & size. They only fit on the bottom of the drip pan, do not cover much up the sides of the drip pan so grease, food and other items could still drip down into the bottom of the drip pan by rolling down the side. Three Stars July 18, 2015 These are very very thin. Save yourself the time and line burners with foil wrap. | 5% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
Two Star Reviews: | 9% Odd design causes coils to sit at a slant. October 29, 2017 These look nice, but the fit is goofy and causes the coils to sit at an angle. This requires adjusting with every use and still, the coils are at a slant, not good for cooking. Would not buy again. Did not fit my Hotpoint. Lip to Lip on large is 8.5" diameter. Measure yours and compare. September 18, 2017 Did not fit my Hotpoint stove. The diameter of these is 8.5" from lip to lip. My stove is only 8.25" The style B's are about the same, so those don't help either. Yargh.Update: Not sure if it helps anyone, but I finally found a drip pan that fit my Hotpoint stove...the Non-GE/Non-Hotpoint drip pans fit perfectly. Who knew. I just picked them up at Home Depot with a tape measure in hand. They had big bold letters saying they won't work with GEs and Hotpoints, but ironically it was the only one that did.I think here on Amazon the only thing you can be sure of is that the NONE of the GE/Hotpoint compatible ones will work if you have a Hotpoint with an 8.25" diameter. You'll specifically need to try the ones that say they don't fit GE/Hotpoints. What a nightmare. The chrome looks more like a brushed steel and the 2 larger pans had ... September 3, 2017 Ordered the universal chrome, but got the GE/Hotpoint chrome. The chrome looks more like a brushed steel and the 2 larger pans had only 1 slot for the burner's tines instead of the 3 in the picture. I had already opened the package and installed the smaller pans. So I had to bend 2 of the tines on the larger burners to fit the pans.. Product did not match the picture provided. Frustrating and annoying Two Stars August 4, 2017 NOT universal in notch placement. Fits crooked, i should have shopped around a bit more. Smaller ones didn't fit the oven. July 8, 2017 Supposedly these were universal, but only the large covers fit in the Roper stove and not the smaller ones. You get what you pay for. July 4, 2017 Slide around a lot, seems like I am always re-positioning them in the hole. Will not buy these again. | 6% These didn't provide great coverage for my burners September 22, 2017 These didn't provide great coverage for my burners, just barely enough. I wish they would have also covered they outer rims instead of barely the inside. They do an OK job, but they could be MUCH better. They are cheap and can last awhile if you're careful, but I feel like there are probably better products out there if you're willing to spend just a little bit more. Save some money and use aluminum foil. April 3, 2017 Okay, so here is the deal. First off, these are quite lightweight and were somewhat squished in the shipping package they arrived in. Second, while it was not difficult to cut around to fit my stove's element - I would not consider this item to be a "universal" fit. Third, I, actually think using aluminum foil would be just as effective and significantly less expensive since one probably has it in the house already. (I would use the heavy duty type.) It was not expensive and I AM using them (why wouldn't I - I bought them) but it is unlikely that I shall reorder. Don't waste your money February 16, 2016 Don't waste your money. These aren't worth more then .25-30 cents apiece. Pretty flimsybesaides I had to re cut them to fit my Hotpoint 6 & 8 inch drip pans Cheap, thin, & overpriced for what they are November 17, 2015 Cheap; really cheap. Except for not having to use up and shape aluminum foil, they're not much thicker. Amazon putting them in an over-size box with two heavy items, made re-shaping necessary anyway.You get what you ay for, but these should have been more like $4-5. | 3% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
One Star Reviews: | 10% Do not fit.. October 28, 2017 I was so excited to get these since they have a non stick coat. The small ones fit perfect but larger ones do not. they move around when you put them on and when you try to put the elements on the holes do not line up. I will have to look somewhere else. The describe is Not true October 3, 2017 The description says that this is not sticky, but every time you use it, it is possible to damage the surface coating if you do not clean up the sticky material every time. Very difficult to clean up Not a good fit September 9, 2017 The big ones fit my stove a bit big even though my stove was listed on the ones it would fit. it was not clear that it was 2 small and ... June 20, 2017 it was not clear that it was 2 small and 2 big and did not match B replacement. sorry i misunderstood but description was misleading.and will never buy again. Defective; faulty design. May 22, 2017 There were only one hole to accommodate the one of three eye prongs to seat properly. I returned this for a full refund. These were a half an inch too big and a ... May 17, 2017 These were a half an inch too big and a little on the flimsy side. I purchased them PRIME, but when I attempted to return them, they charged me almost $8 for shipping. What a joke. | 14% What a RIP OFF !!! August 13, 2017 This is a very poor product ! It really doesn't cover what I wanted to cover. It does cover part of it but not enough. I will never but this again & I will tell my friends how bad this product is. Waste July 8, 2017 Don't waste your money. Go to the dollar store to buy these. I thru them away as soon as I saw them. just needs to be a bit wider March 28, 2016 just needs to be a bit wider so it can sit on the drip pan, rather in it, but will have to use it for now and will look for new ones WASTE OF MONEY. March 11, 2016 DID NOT fit the stove it is listed as fitting. It's too small. WASTE OF MONEY. Not Happy November 7, 2015 I was duped. I thought these would be extra heavy duty drip pans.. They were exactly like the ones I finallyfound yesterday at a discount store , and theirs were... 6 for $1.00!! Not happy with purchase and notgoing to go through the process of returning them.. | 5% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
Vote for Me | Vote for Me | Vote for Me | Vote for Me | Vote for Me | |
Pricing info | |||||
Old Price | |||||
Old Price | - | - | - | - | - |
Price | |||||
Price | $10.97updated: Mar 17, 2020 | $2.15updated: Mar 19, 2020 | $10.78updated: Mar 10, 2020 | $17.42updated: Mar 10, 2020 | $9.99updated: Mar 10, 2020 |
Features | |||||
Answered Questions | |||||
Answered Questions | - | - | - | - | |
Article Number | |||||
Article Number | 0076363055568 | 0689214265414 | 0048172040578 | 0048172040530 | 0989898540365 |
Binding | |||||
Binding | Tools & Home Improvement | - | - | - | - |
Brand | |||||
Brand | Stanco | Mainstays | Frigidaire | Frigidaire | JUMBL™ |
Color | |||||
Color | - | - | black | Black | - |
Currency | |||||
Currency | USD | - | USD | USD | USD |
Formatted Price | |||||
Formatted Price | $14.99 | - | - | - | - |
Height | |||||
Height | 98.4 in | 66.9 in | 315.0 in | 39.4 in | 77.6 in |
Label | |||||
Label | - | - | Frigidaire | Frigidaire | JUMBL™ |
Length | |||||
Length | 383.9 in | 216.5 in | 315.0 in | 39.4 in | 307.1 in |
Manufacturer | |||||
Manufacturer | Stanco | Mainstays | Frigidaire | Frigidaire | JUMBL™ |
Model | |||||
Model | 5556 | - | 316442301 | 316439801 | - |
MPN | |||||
MPN | 5556 | - | 316442301 | 316439801 | - |
Number of Parts | |||||
Number of Parts | 5556 | - | 316442301 | 316439801 | - |
Number of parts of item | |||||
Number of parts of item | - | - | - | 316439801 | - |
Product Group | |||||
Product Group | Home Improvement | Home Improvement | Home Improvement | Home Improvement | Major Appliances |
Product Type | |||||
Product Type | MAJOR_HOME_APPLIANCES | MAJOR_HOME_APPLIANCES | MAJOR_HOME_APPLIANCES | MAJOR_HOME_APPLIANCES | REFRIGERATION_APPLIANCE |
Publisher | |||||
Publisher | Stanco | Mainstays | Frigidaire | Frigidaire | JUMBL™ |
Quantity | |||||
Quantity | - | 1 | 1 | 1 | - |
Reviews | |||||
Reviews | - | - | |||
Score | |||||
Score | 8.2 | 7.6 | - | - | - |
Size | |||||
Size | Universal, Chrome | 1 - Pack | - | - | - |
Studio | |||||
Studio | Stanco | Mainstays | Frigidaire | Frigidaire | JUMBL™ |
Title | |||||
Title | - | - | Frigidaire 316442301 Element for Range | Frigidaire 316439801 Smart Choice 6'' 4-Turn Surface Element for Range | DISPOSABLE FOIL BURNER LINERS - ELECTRIC STOVES SET OF 18 BY JUMBL |
Warranty | |||||
Warranty | 1 year Warranty | - | - | - | - |
Weight | |||||
Weight | 5.1 oz | 0.7 oz | 2.6 oz | 1.8 oz | 0.6 oz |
Width | |||||
Width | 383.9 in | 216.5 in | 118.1 in | 39.4 in | 303.9 in |
Feature | |||||
Feature | Heavy Duty Chrome Plating Universal Plug In Stove Elements | 12 stove liners in two sizes 6 large --Size: 8.25" diameter AND 6 small --Size: 6.25" diameter Material: aluminum Disposable Save time - Makes cleaning your stove EASY! | 8 Inch Surface Element Universal Element Genuine Replacement Part | This part works with the following models: Frigidaire CCRE312GWWB, Crosley CCRE312GWWC Frigidaire CFEF210CS5; Frigidaire CFEF311GSC Frigidaire CFEF312GBC, Frigidaire CFEF312GSC Genuine Replacement Part Dimensions : Width 6 inches (exterior) | Insert to cook, toss when dirty Set of 18 has 6-8" and 12-6 1⁄4" diameter. Stove top stays clean and neat longer Catches messy spills and boil overs |
Dimplex CS-12056A Compact...
Duraflame DFS-450-2 Carleton...
GE PS950SFSS Profile 30"...
Frigidaire FFEF3048LS, 30 Inch...
Waring DB60 Portable Double Burner
Stanco 4 Pack Universal Electric...
Electric Stove Disposeable Drip...
LG LRE3083ST 30" Stainless Steel...