Side by Side Comparison of: Garden of Life vs Green Pastures
Learn More | ||
Learn More | ||
Rating info | ||
eComparisons Score | ||
eComparisons ScoreThe "Comparison Score" Is calculated based on the average number of times this item was compared with other items in this category by our users | 8.8 | 8.6 |
User Rating (Amazon) | ||
User Rating (Amazon) | ||
Five Star Reviews: | 75% It's all about technique March 15, 2017 This goes down pretty easily and doesn't seem to come back up, just a bit of a minty aftertaste. Still, I find it helpful to put the spoonful towards the back of my mouth, toss my head back and swallow in one quick gulp ;) Good Stuff March 7, 2017 This cod liver oil is easier to swallow because of the lemon and mint flavor. It helps! The least amount of capsules and softgels that I take in my supplements the better. Glad I bought this! I love this cod liver oil January 21, 2017 I love this cod liver oil! The taste is good. I give it to my kids every morning. It helps keep their skin clear of excema. Didn't think I liked this at first (certainly not straight - made me ... August 10, 2015 Didn't think I liked this at first (certainly not straight - made me sick to my stomach) but it's great blended in smoothies and yogurt. My daughter loves it, doesn't notice a fishy taste at all! Try this one. Do it for YOU. February 10, 2015 Hey, I thought cod liver oil was supposed to be gross. Why did I listen to all those people all these years ?!?! I HATE fishy taste, and this is mild, and lemony. Get it? Lemony !!! Love this company, and I hope they come out with some other flavors. My husband is not a lemon fan, so.... he's waiting. But he WAS impressed with how this oil didn't taste awful, and how mislead he felt also. Only advice, shake well. Doesn't say it on the bottle, but I felt the lemon taste was not as strong after it was shaken.Way to go, Garden of Life !! Great product. GREAT. Fabulous fish oil! December 28, 2014 I love this fish oil. It never burps back up. The taste is happily disguised by the lemon mint addition. Cod liver oil greatly decreased the pain I experienced from my periods/endometriosis. An excellent product! | 70% Five Stars June 20, 2016 Great product. On time. I think I'll finally be immortal by the end of my second bottle. love IT!!!! October 29, 2013 It is the best for overall health!!! I Know I sleep better when am taking my COD LIVER!!! My skin is also alot less dry!! |
Four Star Reviews: | 15% Four Stars September 14, 2017 No problem at All with taking this.4stars now 5 if I see any improvements in myself Great product! February 28, 2017 I like the taste of this product much better than the previous brand I tried, so this is my 2nd order of this product. I'll keep ordering. It also came with an unexpected free lotion sample, who h was a nice surprise! Recommend this one September 21, 2015 The taste is pretty good for Cod liver oil , I don't taste fish at all just strong citrus very easily palatable. The only downside for me is the outer bottle keeps getting sticky . I keep washing it off but it stays sticky which is kind of freaky when your ready to take it .. Toddlers thinks it's yummy! April 18, 2015 I was surprised how easily I could get my daughter to take this cod liver oil. She thinks it tastes yummy! (My husband is not so pleased, but I think that's only because he knows what it is and can't get over the thought of it!) | 12% Good Quality, not to fishy. June 16, 2015 These are better than taking the oil from a spoon! They are a bit fishy, but easy to take. Thank goodness for capsules January 5, 2015 Excellent manner to take cod liver oil. I do not really understand the fermented part, but from what I read that is the best formulation. |
Three Star Reviews: | 4% Awful packaging May 13, 2017 Great taste but the bottle is awful. They need to add a pour spout to the top. It's very messy and you lose a lot of the product... the oil runs down the sides of the bottle. I love Garden of LIght products January 30, 2016 I love Garden of LIght products, but at times the taste can prevent me from taking them. This taste was great and the mint was mild but stuck out to take away from a fishy taste. I am just not sure I have noticed any difference in my health since taking it, but I am sure it is doing something. Good April 23, 2013 I've used Carlson in the past - wanted to save a couple of dollars and give this a try. It's good - but I do detect more of the fishy flavor with this. That is the only difference. To me (being a fish hater...which is why I need to get this in my diet) that's a big deal. But..it's not so bad that I won't trudge through it and use it up. If it was too detectable - I wouldn't be able to touch it. Satisfied April 11, 2011 I am satisfied with this product, however it can leave a lingering minty taste in mouth and stomach. | 5% I didn't expect the oil inside the capsules to be ... February 15, 2017 I didn't expect the oil inside the capsules to be brown and solidified but I figured that they were still ok. I think the capsules have something to do with my nails being healthy. They are a lot stronger than usual and as a result I am able to retain length. I hope they will have a positive impact on my teeth, skin and hair. I just want confirmation as it relates to the expected appearance. I bought these capsules after hearing great things about them from friends June 13, 2016 I bought these capsules after hearing great things about them from friends. Little did a realize that the capsules are extremely cost prohibitive given the recommended dosage. A much better option is to buy the FCLO outside of the capsules and take with a spoon. Blue Ice Royal Butter Oil / Fermented Cod Liver March 17, 2016 The taste is really strong and smell, my teenagers are sued to nasty health foods but i have had a hard time getting them to take these and they aren't cheap :( I'd go with a flavored one next time. Used the bottle, can't tell if there is a difference May 17, 2015 I've taken the whole bottle and can't tell any difference from the regular unfermented $20 bottle of fish oil I was taking before. Ordering a bottle of the regular fermented fish oil they offer since it's cheaper, and seeing if I can tell the difference using that from this. good product April 8, 2013 this product was great for my hair and skin, but it did make me break out a lil more than usual with acne. i have oily skin though so that may be why. i got it originally for hair loss reasons, but it ended up just making my skin softer and smoother. hmmm, not complaining just not what i had hoped or intended it would be good for. oh well. all in all it is worth trying. it did make my hair softer after all.=) |
Two Star Reviews: | 3% A gamble? October 7, 2017 Product tastes ok.I ended up wondering if it was tested for mercury.I went to manufacturers web site and asked.They never got back to me. So, I switched to another brand. NOT Fermented Cod Liver Oil January 23, 2013 It's OK. The reason I can't say better is because I was very specifically looking for Fermented CLO and this appears in the search results. After reading the description, it doesn't specifically say fermented but it is "olde world". In the "Olde World" CLO was always fermented, so I assumed wrongly that was what they meant.I took the entire bottle as directed without noticing any positive results. I've since switched to Green Pastured FCLO and was shocked with a noticeable difference within 2 days,which have only gotten better over the past few weeks. This product didn't hurt/help, so I can't recommend. | 4% If you can get past the taste & smell.... July 24, 2016 These are highly recommended by so many people, but YUCK - just opening the bottle made me gag. Trying to swallowed them was horrific. The fish burps afterwards were unpleasant. I've heard if you freeze them, it'll help, but it didn't work for me. Don't feel like it did anything and the pills taste like low ... August 21, 2015 Bought this to help boost testosterone naturally as part of the Tim Feriss plan. Don't feel like it did anything and the pills taste like low tide at the pier. It's also extremely expensive. Cannot recommend. but the recommended dosage is 4 capsules November 23, 2014 These work, but the recommended dosage is 4 capsules. The taste is terrible, and I had a really hard time getting them down. I have switched to the cinnamon tingle gel and that is better. I think I might rather have the cod liver oil in flavored capsules separate from the butter oil, that way the flavor would be less of an issue and only 2 capsules. Maybe I am a weenie, but this just did not work for me. This bottle was ransid September 12, 2013 I take this everyday, but for some reason this purchase was awful, bad after taste, even smelled bad. I store in the freezer for this reason, the capsules don't even look the same as my last bottle. I was really disappointed. it's very expensive and I would hope there would be more consistency. |
One Star Reviews: | 3% I'm gonna pass January 11, 2017 I got a colon infection shortly after using this. No idea if it was from this product. Not worth while January 4, 2017 I was hoping to use this as a healing oil, the smell is so strong it was not something I could not tolerate the smell. I had to wash the washcloth 3 times to remove the smell and take 2 showers. Nothing changed June 19, 2013 I didn't notice any difference while taking it. It also ran out pretty fast. I started with 1 tsp a day then upgraded to 2 when I didn't notice a difference with 1. I broke out on my face and shoulders more. That's about it.... | 9% Very disappointed July 20, 2015 The package was dented and it was expired a couple weeks later. I spent a lot of money on this product and now it is worthless. Did not work for me, have to send it ... March 21, 2015 Did not work for me, have to send it back. The side affects were too much for me: stomach cramps, jaw pain, ear aches and my teeth hurt. I also got a metal taste in my mouth. Saw no changes... May 20, 2014 Not only is this product expensive, but I saw no changes in my acne or health at all after one bottle. Worried about integrity of product January 7, 2014 I understand from other comments that if your pills are yellow colored and not dark brown, then they don't contain any cod liver oil. Well, mine are yellow and I'm very annoyed that I'm being ripped off like this. It was also very disconcerting when I opened the bottle and the 'for your protection' seal popped off by itself from the pressure of pulling off the cap. I don't even want to try taking these pills because 1) they're not the right product and 2) I'm suspicious that they've been tampered with. I will be returning these and order directly from Green Pastures instead. |
Vote for Me | Vote for Me | |
Pricing info | ||
Old Price | ||
Old Price | - | - |
Price | ||
Price | $13.99updated: Mar 18, 2020 | $42.98updated: Mar 16, 2020 |
Features | ||
Answered Questions | ||
Answered Questions | ||
Article Number | ||
Article Number | 0658010111362 | 0705105297903 |
Binding | ||
Binding | Health and Beauty | Health and Beauty |
Brand | ||
Brand | Garden of Life | Green Pastures |
Color | ||
Color | Lemon Mint | - |
Currency | ||
Currency | USD | - |
Formatted Price | ||
Formatted Price | $17.46 | - |
Height | ||
Height | 98.4 in | 173.2 in |
Legal Disclaimer | ||
Legal Disclaimer | * These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. **Always refer to the manufacturer's label on the product for description, recommended dose and p | Actual product packaging and materials may contain more and different information than what is shown on our website. We recommend that you do not rely solely on the information presented and that you always read labels, warnings, and directions before usi |
Length | ||
Length | 206.7 in | 98.4 in |
Manufacturer | ||
Manufacturer | Garden of Life | Green Pasture |
Model | ||
Model | 658010111362 | - |
MPN | ||
MPN | 100004 | X3-IE4S-I2A1 |
Number of Items | ||
Number of Items | 1 | - |
Number of Parts | ||
Number of Parts | 100004 | X3-IE4S-I2A1 |
Product Group | ||
Product Group | Health and Beauty | Health and Beauty |
Product Type | ||
Product Type | HEALTH_PERSONAL_CARE | HEALTH_PERSONAL_CARE |
PublicationDate | ||
PublicationDate | 2013-07-26 | - |
Publisher | ||
Publisher | Garden of Life | Green Pasture |
Quantity | ||
Quantity | 1 | 1 |
Release Date | ||
Release Date | 2013-07-23 | - |
Reviews | ||
Reviews | ||
Score | ||
Score | 9.4 | 8.8 |
Size | ||
Size | 8 oz | 120 Capsules |
Studio | ||
Studio | Garden of Life | Green Pasture |
Weight | ||
Weight | 3.1 oz | 1.1 oz |
Width | ||
Width | 98.4 in | 98.4 in |
Feature | ||
Feature | One serving of Olde World Icelandic Cod Liver Oil provides over 750mg of EPA and DHA Omega-3 fatty acids Olde World Icelandic Cod Liver Oil has an all-natural lemon mint flavor The vitamin a in olde world Icelandic cod liver oil supports eye health, normal skin and hair structure, and healthy immune function | Blend, High Vitamin Butter Oil, Fermented, High Vitamin Cod Liver Oil, Capsules 120 Capsules 60 Servings (2 per serving) Green Pasture Products have chosen to use the "Manufacture Date" as many other companies are currently using instead of the Expiration Date, so you will receive the freshest product available when you order. |
Blue Ice Royal Butter Oil /...
Blue Ice Fermented Cod Liver Oil...
Carlson Norwegian Cod Liver Oil,...
Carlson Lightly Lemon Cod Liver...
Blue Ice Fermented Cod Liver Oil...
Nature Made Cod Liver Oil -- 100...
Garden of Life - Olde World...
Sonne's Old Fashioned Cod Liver...