Side by Side Comparison of: Earthbath vs Oster

Yes! Jake was scruffy when we adopted him. Ten years worth of scruffy, and inclined to stay that way. A bath was not a part of his agenda. People would stroke his back and turn up their noses. Thick coat. Way too thick. He deserved better, but nobody wanted to dunk him! Sister recommended we try these ... daily ... for a while ... and, then, one day, Jake was clean, good-lookin', good to our feel, fine-feeling to visitors' fingers, as well as his tongue! Jakey was happy. We were happy. The world is good.

My overweight cat (we're working on it) is not able to groom himself well. We've tried all sorts of foods and fish oil supplements, but he is solid black and has HORRIBLE dander. ONE WIPE with these and he's almost completely dander-free for at least a day or 2, and really doesn't need to be wiped down again for 4-5 days. He's huge (19 lbs), and I can use one wipe on him. He's not crazy about when I wipe him in the "wrong" direction, but for the most part he does fine. And because these are all natural, I don't worry about him licking himself after I've cleaned him (when and where he's able)

I love these things! I think they're a great way to keep cat dander in control and leave my cats feeling great. One of my cats is pretty apathetic to these wipes, while the other isn't a big fan. However, neither react the same way they have to no-water cat shampoos in the past (where I'd find themselves trying to lick all of the smell off them). Instead, it's a couple of dissatisfied licks, and off they go!

These are fantastic. I have a giant cat who was raised by dogs... the poor boy never learned to clean his nethers properly. He tried, poor thing, but the dingleberries were mighty. I literally searched for "cat butt wipes" and here these were.Got these, and not only do they work well for cleanup (thick and sturdy, no surprise cat exploration), they have also stimulated him into cleaning himself more effectively. Gentle but effective, what more do you need. Woohoo!Extra super bonus, using them to wipe down his fur keeps the dander down and his shedding a little more contained.

I love these wipes. I have a 6-year-old male longhair whose coat gets a little greasy. My veterinarian said this is a common male cat "thing" and to use the Earthbath wipes on him as frequently as needed. He gets a going-over once or twice a week, and these wipes make his coat clean and fluffy. Also he has asthma and the fact that these wipes are unscented and do not aggravate his condition is a huge plus. They are also my go-to for cleaning outer ears and removing the occasional dingleberry. I use these on my other three cats as well whenever they need a "bath" and they work just great for everybody.

I use these for cleanup for my older cat who has a problem not getting all of her waste off the backside (not to be graphic).. these work great and don't irritate her at all. Will buy again.

Cat hates it, but oh I love burying my face into her 'sweet pea' scented fit after she dries!!

Cat doesn't mind it, and there is no perfume-like odor.

Recommended...I almost nicknamed her Sweet Pea.

I love the way this shampoo smells. My kitties love it too. They are super soft and fluffy after their baths. I have noticed their skin is less irritated as well.

Wow what a shampoo for cats. This year was very bad for fleas for our cats, they are inside cats and you would think pretty much safe but nope our poor kitties had to pay a price this year. We already used flea/tick medicine, we waited awhile and gave them a bath but unfortunately like never before our old brand of cat shampoo turned our peaceful kitties into little mean kitties, not their fault for their skin was so dry and full of dander it drove them crazy. Now here comes Oster Oatmeal Naturals Dander Control Cat Shampoo to the rescue. What a difference, I think we have the softest kitties in the world now. And the shampoo smells very good unlike others that smell like cedar, nutmeg and what not. And their fur was very soft even before they were fully dry. I hope if anyone else has the same problem, it does the same for them as it did for us.

Our kitten just turned a year old and is quite a little fur ball. Since we started using this shampoo, we have noticed a drastic difference in the amount of shedding and dander. My girlfriend and I are both allergic to pet dander and this has made pet parenthood possible!

I used these on my cats after I had rubbed diatomaceous earth in them a week or so ago and noticed how rough and dirty their fur felt. While they didn't necessarily enjoy the wiping part (I did have to kind of hold them down) they felt much better afterwards and didn't spend a lot of time cleaning themselves after, so I don't think it bothered them at all really.

Doesn't have much perfume, which is good because other wipes smell better but burn tender kitty parts and make both our cats vomit when they lick it off their fur. These work great - better than a personal washcloth at least!

This is the third time I have ordered these wipes for my cat. I LOVE the product!!! And my cat doesn't mind them, either. But the packaging gets worse each time! The top that's supposed to release when you depress the tab misses it's connection to the tab by....this much. If they don't connect, the top is left in the open position and the wipes are going to dry out!The wipes usually stay nice & moist, making the entire 100 of them useful. Now, however......not so much! It's a shame that a 5 star product is in a 3 star package; that's why I rated it 4:-(

well I cant expand on if it will make your animal sick or not but I am putting my trust in the ingredients, they are handy to have I have a new kitten and she seems to find every dirty to get into so yea I like them and she does not mind to much

I like them, but my kitten hates the smell - so that's a little disconcerting. Otherwise very happy with simple ingredients and no bad reactions on my kitten's skin. Great to keep for after messy kittens eat/use the letterbox and I find it helps prompt them to clean themselves.

Worked for my elderly kitty really well. He looks much better after just one use. The wipes did seem a little dry, though. Not sure if that is on purpose because cats really don't want to be wet, normally. Or if they were somewhat dried out. Either way, they did seem to work. My other cat that I tried them on was not a fan and quickly let me know.

Works reasonably well and smells great. The cat hates getting a bath but that's not the product's fault

This helped my cat with his dander control problem and made his fur super soft just after one use.

So far so good. My girlfriend is allergic to my cat but i got this to help her out. With a weekly bath and rubbing Allerpet into his coat her allergies are about 90% gone. This product does make your cat smell wonderful for a day. Would recommend this to anyone suffering from cat allergies.

Very nice cat shampoo! The smell is great, and it left my cats fur very soft and silky. I can't say I have noticed a difference in the amount of shedding. I chose these over the regular Oster Oatmeal shampoo strictly on scent as I don't think I want my cat smelling like Vanilla.

Smells great and works fine, but I had some problems rinsing it out of my cat's fur. It seemed to be out, but when I was drying her, I noticed some foam still in her fur and had to rinse her again.

The cat shampoo has a lovely smell that isnt too strong, makes my cats fur super soft BUT I havent noticed that it takes away the dander as others have stated. I still have fur on my clothes and around the house but his dander hasnt been an issue in my house i mainly bought because of scent and how people said it makes the fur nice.

A good idea in theory, but after a few uses, the lid wouldn't stay shut, so my wipes are all dried out. Now I just wet them with some water before use.

The first couple were okay, but it seems like the lid doesn't stay shut all the way. So the rest feel kind of dry now. They do work in a pinch.

I bought this to clean poop from my kitten's paws. It doesn't work for that use. The wipes are too dry and just doesn't really do anything to clean imo. What I have done is run water over the wipes and it seems to work a little better. I would recommend just getting baby wipes, that is what the breeder suggested, I should have listened.

These wipes are nice, and cost-effective. But they dry out too quickly. I have one third of the box left, and they are now dry and useless. I think the contraption mechanism on this box is deficient.

They are ok. i have used them, however i have achieved the same result with hypoallergenic baby wipes unscented. so i will finish mine but will not repurchase.

I bought these mainly for my 19 year old cat because she doesn't groom as much as she should anymore. I brush her more often to try to compensate, but that seems to cause her more dandruff. So I thought that these might work to help with her dry skin and take off some flakes and loose hair.These have a slightly odd odor, maybe that's the Aloe, I'm not sure. I'm not sure that's the best ingredient for a cat wipe, but I'm no expert. I do know that none of my cats like the smell. These wipes are rather dry, so they don't remove the dandruff/dry skin flaking. They don't even remove much for loose hair, either.Maybe they work well with dander removal--I'm lucky enough not to be bothered by that, so I can't judge. All I can say is that I won't be buying them anymore because they seem rather expensive for the results that I'm seeing with my cats.

Since getting my 2 kittens I have found my nose running more than usual. I wash them about every 1-2 weeks with this shampoo. My nose doesn't seem to have stopped running any less, but they are clean and smell nice. I wish the smell were different, but it's not bad, just a light fragrence.

Cleans well.

My cat never gives me a hard time when it comes to baths, of course she doesn't like it but she doesn't freak out. She's an all black cat and she has pretty bad dander. This shampoo smells super good but I didn't really notice a difference.

Smells nice, not much different from other cat washes, nothing special. Any bath is going to upset my kitties. The price was alright.

I bought these to help deal with my cat allergies. The first time I wiped down the cat, he was not too happy. He spent hours licking himself to get the scent off of him - which I'm pretty sure defeated the purpose of the wipes. As fast as I had removed the all the allergenic protein from his fur, he replaced it with a fresh coating of protein-laden saliva. I thought maybe he'd get used to the wipes and stop licking so much post-wipe down. No such luck. He's developed a deep hatred of the wipes and the second he sees the box, or a wipe, or even just a plain old white tissue these days, he bolts faster than if he had seen the vacuum cleaner. On the plus side, due to his huge aversion to these wipes, I can now keep him away from things he shouldn't be messing with. If I lay a wipe on a potted plant, he won't go near it to chew the leaves anymore, so they weren't a total waste, I guess.

The product itself seems fine but my lid won't stay closed. It's not broken either. Not sure if it's a product defect or I'm just unlucky. I ended up taping the door shut so it doesn't dry out the wipes and opening the entire top when I need to use one

The wipes are fine. The packaging is terrible. The lid is so loose that it falls off every time you pick up the box. There is no way that these wipes are going to stay moist with this packaging.

Product works but the container is broken so you can't close it allowing the wipes to dry out. The container was completely wrapped and no broken pieces were found but I still can't close it. It would have been nice if the shipper had contacted me about a replacement after I contacted them in a review.

Being all natural was what pulled me in to purchase this product. Besides the fact that the box it is in wont even stay closed they are barely moist. Every time i tried to use it on my cats they did not want anything to do with it. For something that costs so much they need a better quality containor to hold it.

My cat will have none of this. He runs away like I'm trying to kill him and angrily licks his fur where I managed to wipe him. If you have a fussy cat, don't expect this to work.

I foster kittens and these were ordered by a friend for me off of my wish list. They showed up with a MANGO TANGO scent.I can not use them on kittens! The label on the top THAT DOES NOT STAY CLOSED, says grooming wipes, NOT Cat Wipes.Now I am stuck with two boxes of stinky wipes that I can't use on my foster kittens! I'm hoping the other boxes they ordered for me don't show up as the same stinking wipes.I have used these for years and was always willing to ignore the fact that the box never stays closed, or it shows up cracked, but after this, I'm never adding them to my wish list again. You just lost a good customer.

I have used these cat wipes in the past and the wipes are fine. I had read reviews here that the cover wouldn't close, but since I had some of these wipes at home, I didn't imagine this would be a problem. But it was. The cover will not close at all. The wipes had no protective cover. They weren't dried out completely, but they also weren't as wet as I think they normally are. I should probably return them. I put some plastic wrap over the dispenser hole to keep them from drying out completely.

It's not that I hate this product...I couldn't smell a thing. However, my cat took one sniff and made a beeline away. Clearly something didn't smell good to him. Not worth the drama.

Do not like the smell at all. thought it would be nice to have a simple wipe to clean my cat although he's an indoor cat and he grooms all the time. But I wanted a little something too wipe his fur down, his ears and his face and paws, places he cannot reach. The smell of these are awful. I can't even hold on to him afterwards. I smell him all the time when I pick him up and he smells so good even though his breath smells like fish somehow when he grows his fur never smells like that. After using these it was horrible. He could not even stand it. I still use them a couple times.. then I thought how unfair it was for him to have to smell it. I've got the whole container only three out of it and I'm going to just throw it away. I can't even imagine anything else I would want to use them and have to smell that. I can't explain the smell except it does not smell clean

Somewhat disappointing, the sheets are quite dry and don't seem to have any impact on the fur of my two cats.

these are not moist there barley damp dont buy waste of money!!!!!

I got the DOG shampoo instead of the cat shampoo I ordered, as did other buyers. What the heck?? I like dogs just fine, but I ordered the CAT shampoo, people.

I got a dog shampoo instead of a cat shampoo. My shampoo was also 2/4 gone in the packaging because it leaked during shipment.

Received the same dog shampoo as another customer.

I ordered this cat shampoo and what i received was a DOG shampoo.