Side by Side Comparison of: Classic Accessories vs Fremont Die

Time will be the true test for this tire cover, bit I'll update that as needed.

This tire cover seems well made. It has an elastic edged opening that keeps it tight, the inside is made of a soft material that seems to not absorb water, and it has a nice looking black trim piece around the perimeter on the outside edge.

My travel trailer tires are 205/75 15, so I bought the 26.75"-27.75" size. It fits perfectly with no room to spare. It doesn't seem like it's going to fall off when driving down the road and it feels like it will hold up well. The big thing and the reason you buy this, it will keep the sun off the rubber.

I have no complaints with this cover and I feel good about my purchase.

I love this thing. I bought it to fit a 235 75R15 tire, and it fits very taught, and smooth over the tire, and the large fixture handle I made to hold the tire on the spare holder.

I have 29" Tires and I ordered the 29-29.75" and it fits perfectly. Very snug and the quality initially is great! The Stitching looks & feels strong and well done. I will edit in a few months if anything changes but for the Price idk how you can beat it!

Great value for the price. Vinyl material is heavy duty and not cheap feeling or rubbery. Description calls it "non-scratch backing", but it is actually felt which is typical of higher priced covers. Elastic cord is very heavy, about as thick as a pencil, so it is strong and holds the cover on well. Check the diameter of your tire and order the exact fit. My tire is 30" and I ordered the 30-30.75" inch cover and it fits perfectly with no slack or looseness at all.

I toiled over this purchase for a while. Quality, color and size were my questions. I wanted a cover that would look good, last a while and definitely fit! I finally settled on this tire cover and could not be happier. The cover is very high quality with a very good tension cord and a decorative piping that adds a nice touch. The grey color matched my waverunner aluminum trailer nicely. You should know that the color is definitely much lighter than what the product photo shows. It looks good though. It's more of a silver/light gray/aluminum color than the dark gray in the photo. Fit was perfect! I have a ST175/80 D 13 sized trailer tire which I measured to be just about 24" in diameter and the 25" cover fit perfect. Not too tight and not too loose.

I guess I got lucky and ordered the right size for my new (used Toyota FJ Cruiser) truck's spare but it stinks that they don't really give you a size guide in the description. I just took a chance and luckily, it was the right one. This cover is awesome. It's sturdy and well printed, it fits great and despite all the complaints I see about some wrinkles or fold marks, it's going to be like that at first out of he packaging but mine has only been on a few days and already has settled- not a wrinkle in sight. I love it!!!!

Fits on my camper and looks great. Material is hardy not like it looks in the picture. Well worth the $$

Great tire cover. If you're deciding between the smaller and larger, I recommend buying the larger. It for the factory Jeep Liberty spare quite well. A small would've never worked.

Got this as a gift for my husband, he has larger tires on his Jeep so finding one that fit was a bit harder, this is as advertized! It was a bit tricky to tie it on the tire but that was the vehicle not the product. He's had it on for a few months now and we don't see any wear and tear and it is holding up to the various weather we've been having.

Bought for the husband for Father's Day. He has a white OJ Ford Bronco and recently had it repainted white again and pin striped it with Miami Dolphin colors, so this tire cover really finishes the touch. Looks fantastic!

This is a replacement gift for our son-in-law. Appears to be very well made with nice graphics. Had to return the first one as the recipient said it was flawed (I had not opened it before wrapping it). The vendor was very nice and sent a replacement as well as emailing me a prepaid return label. THX for that! Would purchase again.

Better material than most the cheap covers but wish it overlapped on the inside of tire farther.

Well made, good material. Buyer beware on the size however. I bought the 24" to 25" for a 24" tire and it is a huge struggle to get it around my 24" tire.

The cover was exactly as expected and fit the tire perfectly. The craftsmanship did not leave me wanting and was exactly as I had expected. I would say that this is not a heavy duty cover and installation should be done evenly and without trying to overstretch the cover. I found myself pulling a bit harder than I probably should have to have the cover tuck into a narrow groove and partially poked a hole in the material.

As I mentioned it was really an over taxing thing I did and I would consider this a 5-star product if it had exceeded my expectation. A good cover at a reasonable price and fit as expected.

Tip: Be sure you locate the seam of the outer ring before you install the cover so you can decide if you want it to be at the bottom of the tire. The cover has an overlap seam on the outer ring that would probably be best to hide on the bottom side of the tire.

I bought one about 1" larger than I needed and it works fine. Stays on without any issues and blocks the sun. We'll see how it holds up over the winter. It does tend to collect a little water at the bottom, so I added some drain holes.

These covers fit nice and snug on 225/75-R15 trailer tires and have stayed put in some pretty high wind storms. They reach just about midway of the sidewall on the back side so coverage is good if the spare mounted up against a camper but could be a little better if mounted exposed on the tongue of the trailer. I have not seen any with full back side coverage so no mark down for that. How they last through a couple of summers will be the true test as others have not even lasted for their rated warranty period so time will tell if this rating goes up or down.

Bought for Christmas for my dad to put on his new 2017 Jeep Wrangler. The tire size was the standard Jeep size and it fit fine. It is a little wrinkled in the beginning, but that has finally started to iron itself out. Quality is pretty good. Hard to find anything like this anywhere else and you can't beat 2 day shipping.

I love the cover, what i do not love is that you are not given a size option... Tire covers are not one size fits all. I rated it as high as I did because the cover is good quality, and I was able to jerry-rig it so that it worked. Just make sure you have a large size truck if you are ordering this!!!

The product is ok, not great. I ordered wrong size and had to return it. It is not as heavy as I would have thought and it uses a pull string to sinch it to the tire.

Cover looks great, quality looks good, waiting to see if several wrinkles on the cover disappear. The cover is shipped in a box that could be changed to a poster tune to prevent wrinkles from folding and stuffing the cover into a box. The large cover fits easily onto Rubicon hard rock with stock BFG MT 255/75R17. Once you fit the top of the cover on the tire, center the logo, fit the sides around the tire then open the tailgate and sit on the ground behind the open gate facing the back of the tire to finish final fit and pull the drawstrings tight as you can and tie.

I received this product with some damage to the white paint on the NY symbol which I believed was due to it being folded into its packaging. It was minimal and I didn't want to go through the trouble of sending it back. I have a white Jeep Wrangler Rubicon with black and red accents, so the cover matched the truck perfectly. The quality of this product is not the greatest, but it was one of the cheapest NYG tire covers I've seen. It comes with a bungee cord that has a loop around each end. I ended up attaching a carabiner to keep it all together. Overall, I'm not crazy about the cover but I have gotten a lot of honks and thumbs up from people on the road.

The paint on the folds is flaking off, otherwise the quality is good. Fits on a 15inch tire with no problems but I would expect putting it on a 17inch tire would be a struggle. No instructions on how to tie off the rope, that is looped off at the end. Is there a reason for that?

Quality is OK but the sizing info on Amazon are not correct. If your tire has a diameter of 26, I recommend you buy the cover for a 27 tire .... ie, add 1 inch to the diameter of your tire.

Fit very tightly when it was cold, now that the weather has warmed up, it's looser. This is both good and bad; good in that it's easier to get on/off, bad in that it's not as taught. I use it to cover a spare tire in the back of my Volt; so I can't comment on outside endurance. It's fairly thin material, any thicker would've been harder to get it on when cold; but would've kept its shape better when warm.

Not a slam on the product but I just didn't like them. They're made well enough but I returned it because it was very white and didn't look right on my travel trailer. That said, they will do the job and they're not expensive at all.

I'm sending this back. While it's very high quality. It barely wraps around the back of the tire. And I bought one size larger. The purpose of the cover is to keep the tire out of the sun so it doesn't dry rot. But on a trailer spare tire mounted in the tongue the entire back side of the tire is still exposed.

Very nice cover. Looks great, fits perfectly. I have it on a boat trailer 13" wheel ST17580R13. My only complaint is that it has a cloth interior. I had one just like it but without the cloth on the inside. Fit just the same and lasted a long time. When I get my boat home I always wash the cover because most of the time a little bit of the tire and cover submerge when I launch the boat. I don't want saltwater to eat away at either the rim or the cover and when I wash this one it takes a long time to dry. I suspect the cloth will deteriorate quickly, but I could be wrong. If this was on a tire that never went into the water it would still hold water if exposed to rain. I don't know why you would put the cloth in it at all. You can't see it and it does not have an upside from my point of view. Hopefully it is not going to be an issue but only time will tell. If the only problem is extended drying time, then no big deal. We'll see.

The decals could be printed a lot better! I will be looking for one that looks better.

This is the second tire cover I've had and, want everyone to understand you get what you pay for. The first (a smaller one) is six years old and, other than fading, is still in great condition. I only replaced it because I bought a new vehicle with a larger sized tire and the old one wouldn't fit. I could tell by the weight of the package, it wasn't as heavy as my original cover, but at under $50 wasn't too surprised, What did surprise me is when it ripped all along the under seam when I tried to put it on. I am clearly disappointed because I thought I was getting a really good deal, when I was simply getting a cheaper version.

Tire Cover was way to big and looks funny on my spare tire. One size does not fit all.

good quality; right size. However, the elastic tie strings were a real challenge to stretch and tie off. Two techs at a tire shop and myself worked a half hour to get the thing on tight. Be much better if not elastic. Oh, after that hassle, the Hawks lost !

Didn't fit. Make sure to check what standard size is before purchasing

This tire cover was supposed to fit 30" to 32" tires. I have a spare tire that is 30"x9.5x15 and this tire cover is too big. Tried to tie it as tight as possible but it still looked sloppy. The product itself was everything I hoped for, but unfortunately doesn't fit my spare. I will try a smaller size.

The stitching is not very tight, but the material seems durable, time will tell if it holds ups. Either way because the stitching appears loose I will purchase another brand in the future.

Not sized to descrption. Bought 24" for a 24" tire. It took an hour to stretch it on. I'll probably have to cut it off when I need the spare.

It fit and looked great for about the first month it was installed. Then the white vinyl turned an unattractive yellow-brown wherever it contacted the tire. It's still white in the center. Note that the cloth lining did not change color, just the outer vinyl layer, so it wasn't a transfer of material from the tire itself. Must have gotten too hot in the sun. Get a black one.

in only a couple of weeks it became discolored and looks like it is years old already. It is nice and thick and it fit perfectly...but the white just doesn't stay that way. I think next time I will see if it comes in black, or grey then it would be perfect

They said to measure the diameter of tire, when I went to put it on it was very tight, the box had all the tire sizes on itCome to find out I needed the next size up.

Great fit however it's turned yellow after one month. I have a fourteen year old cover for a smaller tire that is still white and has not changed

No way to secure on spare tire. Just fits but not secure

Be careful of the size when ordering.

I guess it is my fault that it was too small but when I was trying to get the cover on the seams ripped. At that point not only was it too small for a jeep, it was ripped and useless. The company emailed me back and said they didn't have anything larger. End of story, so I bought a bigger one and now have the ripped one sitting, it seems a shame to throw it away.

Not a strong material

The elastic was out on one side and we had to restring it. The inside had what looked like tire marks inside as if it had been previously used and returned. Not happy at all

Don't waste your money. Installed on spare tire of car hauler. Tore and blew off after about 50 miles. The previous cover was 7 years old and had simply become sun baked and unsightly. This new cover didn't make it 7 hours. It was the right size and installed correctly. It is junk.

Do not buy this junk. After the first time it rained the outside started turning brown. It is now so terrible looking that I am going to toss in the garbage. Waste of money.

My tire measures 25" this doesn't come close to fitting waste of my time and money

Not durable. Cannot withstand wind. We traveled to Portland and the cover shredded before we got there. Did not one long trip.

A lot smaller than advertised scame

Will not stay on

I am trying to send this back!! It does not fit and the inside of the cover was dirty as if it was used or didn't fit on another Jeep! Totally disappointed in this purchase and Amazon.

I bought this for a Jeep which has a large spare tire but this product is designed to fit a standard car spare and I had to return it

This item (tire cover) was not new as purchased. It was torn and someone had previously used it. I was. Very disappointed with item. Will be returning it.

The cover is poorly made and when I put it on the tire I now have a tear. I would have returned it but patched with duct tape because I wanted it for the Super bowl. If I ever have to remove it I will throw away. I would have paid more for even average quality. This may be a fake NFL product because other licensed products are of better quality, The logo looks good and the tape doesn't show much.

Don't waste your money, total junk..