5 items
| Compare | |||||
| Compare All Features Differing | |||||
Side by Side Comparison of: Flexrake vs Japan vs Carrot Design
| Learn More | |||||
Learn More | |||||
Rating info | |||||
| eComparisons Score | |||||
eComparisons ScoreThe "Comparison Score" Is calculated based on the average number of times this item was compared with other items in this category by our users | 8.4 | 9.2 | 8.8 | 0 | 8.4 |
User Rating (Amazon) | |||||
User Rating (Amazon) | |||||
 | |||||
Five Star Reviews: | 67% PERFECT September 11, 2016 PERFECT for getting rid of weeds in the back yard. While I've seen some negative reviews, if you use this hoe correctly it will not disappoint. It brought the little weeds in our big yard up with just gentle back and forth motion. And for the larger weeds, it laid them flat and I could see them for easily pulling up by hand. Took just a little bit more than an hour to go from vacant lot look to a gorgeous back yard! But remember, use it gently, don't force it and try to use like a traditional hoe. Easy to use, does what it says. July 26, 2016 Great product and good quality. I had a Rose of Sharon that dropped seedlings all throughout my garden. Hundreds of little seedlings/weeds to pull - ugh! This made light work of it, and was easy to use even after a topcoat of peat moss that I didn't want to disturb too much. It definitely helps to have good/loose soil. Our veggie garden was a LOT easier to weed with this tool (a lot less muscle/effort needed), than the Rose of Sharon spot. Either way - great addition to my garden tools. Amazingly useful May 26, 2016 This is the best weeded I have ever used! I read about it in a gardening newspaper column and got one. SO glad I did!It can "shuffle" back and forth to quickly clear small weeds, or be used as if it was a conventional hoe. It clearly can be sharpened, but I have not felt the need. Nice and Easy to Use August 9, 2015 This hoe doesn't chop and won't cut through hard soil but if your soil isn't too hard it will slide through with ease and will cut off weeds below the soil line. It is also good for heavily mulched beds where weeds are growing in or through the mulch. My only small complaint is that it could be a bit sharper when delivered. A minute or two with a file (the same as I use on my shovels and spades) takes care of that. Amazing! July 13, 2015 I thought my vegetable garden was a lost cause. It was a solid patch of weeks and grass (see photo) This got every single weed right up to the plants. I am blown away! Photo is before, during and after. As the weeds bleed. May 14, 2015 So many weeds are brought to their maker as I wield this mighty weapon. I cry to the heavens in victory as I roam amongst their green carcasses and revel in the lamentations of their brethren. | 75% Impressive, reasonably sized hand hoe September 8, 2017 If you're looking for a precision weeding device while your plants are growing the Gama hoe handles the need well. Combined with a circular hand hoe and a true temper action hoe, you can basically meet all your gardening needs. The red end of the handle will come off with a little bit of use, but it doesn't hurt the performance of the hoe. While the spot weld looks weak, the unit has held up for 3 seasons now. They make large ones, but I've found them to move too much dirt and you end up tiring your wrist out faster. Extremely effective hoe. My husband saw me using it ... August 8, 2017 Extremely effective hoe. My husband saw me using it and wanted to try. He weeded the entire garden in one morning so, I would say it is very effective ; > It is probably the most effective weeding tool I have used and I've tried many. Careful because it is extremely sharp. Must have in the garden. June 7, 2017 I work both in my own garden and for others and have bought several of these through the years (my husband has to have his own, too). This, a hori hori knife and pruners are my must have gardening tools. LOVE THIS TOOL❤️❤️ May 28, 2017 Money well spent. This little tool is a life saver making my already huge weedingnoroject so much easier. LOVE THIS TOOL❤️❤️ The very best weeding tool ever! October 1, 2016 Smith & Hawkins used to sell a similar hoe, that I relied on for decades, but discontinued it years ago. Since then I've been purchasing this hoe. This is the very best replacement at a wonderful price! I use it to easily weed my flower beds. Whenever it gets dull, which isn't very often, my husband sharpens it. This tool is the best, easiest and fastest way to get rid of weeds and their roots! I'd be lost without it and that's why I always have at least 2 of them! Dirt mover December 12, 2015 In my opinion...Japanese garden tools are superior. They are generally more expensive but they are very sharp and will last a long time. Our soil is fairly hard to work and this tool will make breaking up/weeding my garden a breeze. I'm so excited that I splurged and bought a few things for "me". | 76% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
 | |||||
Four Star Reviews: | 15% A must have tool... July 3, 2017 So... I started out buying just one of these hula-ho's..... we used it last summer in my parents garden. They were weeding by hand and it took 3 people 5 hours.This spring I bought 2 more. We now have 3 of these and 3 people can weed the garden in 45 minutes. WHAT AN AMAZING TOOL !!!I'm giving 4 stars and not 5..... because of two reasons.Reason 1.... the sticker that they put on the nice wood shaft... will NOT peel off nicely. It leaves a frickin mess all over the handle. Why not use an elastic band and a card, that can be added to the metal end ?!?!?Reason 2.... I'm 6' and find the handle a little short. Would be nice if they offered a "long" version that is 8-10" longer. The handle is good length and it does work on little weeds March 3, 2017 It works on small patches of weeds not the big deep ones. The handle is good length and it does work on little weeds. Best for open spaces August 16, 2016 I have tendonitis in both of my wrists so that opening a bottle is sometimes a feat I can't handle. However, the previous owner of our house was REALLY into gardening and left us with several large gardens. This tool is good at scraping weeds off a large area of my garden and really is easier on my back and wrists than more traditional methods. However, it definitely does not work well in the corners or edges where my garden touches the stone patio and walkway. Those still have to be done by hand. I imagine it would also be awkward and difficult to navigate between closely placed delicate plants. It's probably at its most useful in new gardens-- either unplanted areas or before your plants grow too tall in the spring. It's a good tool and I would definitely order it again--just be sure it fits your needs. Good for weeding in garden boxes August 18, 2015 This hula-ho is a good quality weeder that works best in softer soils like in my garden box. It works very well and quickly loosens weeds so they can be removed from the garden. It is not effective for weeding areas of the landscaping where the ground is more compact and harder. It doesn't have have sharp edges so it's not going to cut through anything. Overall, I am pleased with this product but it will not be the only weeding hoe I use in my yard. Works as advertised but not a miracle. September 12, 2014 Edited Review:This is a great tool until you understand this only works for small weeds. I was disappointed at first as once anything that has built a thick taproot you will need to whack the dirt repeatedly to chop it up, no better than using a hoe. I live in an area with clay dirt that turns rock hard once it stops raining and this thing barely scratches the dirt so only the smallest weeds/seedlings will get cut. It works great for that purpose but you have to keep doing it several times a week because once they get too big, you may as well get back on your knees and start pulling or get the awful out of the shed. So, lesson learned, weed 1-2x a week and it's an easy quick job but if you skip that and let a few weeks go by, then time to get on your knees.I can see this being effective if you have soft dirt or work with raised beds. Best tool I know for weeding without bending February 3, 2012 I had one of these that I used for years but gave it away when we relocated. At that point, after some 15 years, the blade was losing its edge. The new one appears to be of similar quality and should hold up just as well. The wood handle feels smooth and sturdy. | 13% Great Little Hoe September 18, 2017 I must admit I was skeptical when I opened the package and saw the hoe. My first thoughts were, "Wow, it looks like a toy and there's not way this hoe can dig." This house was actually must better weeding out crabgrass than the standard weeder tool. I was able to get the entire root of the crabgrass with just a single whack. It's very sharp too. However, the handle is a bit short. Otherwise, it's a great hoe for the price. love, hate September 13, 2017 When you look at the picture that is shown online you are led to believe that the handle of this tool is one piece and not separately attached to the blade. I found this deceptive and had I known that it was forged to the blade I would not have purchased it . Overall it is a useful tool but not a terrific buy! It works well for weeding around small plants. I sit on a bench to save my back. Good Hoe at a Great Price June 27, 2017 This hoe is really great for the price. I haven't had any issues with it. A bigger handle would be nice for grip ease. Best hand weeder July 31, 2016 This is a great tool. It's very sturdy and sharp. After 8 or so hours of weeding it was dull but I was able to sharpen it again with no problems. The red cap comes off and I put it in my pocket until I finish weeding, but it's convenient for hanging. The handle could be two inches longer, but it's not a big deal. This weeder is great for dry or semi dry soil and weeds under 5 inches tall. It also does a great job removing grass that's creeping into the garden. I can see why it is a favorite tool for many people April 17, 2016 It is very sharp and handy. I can see why it is a favorite tool for many people. I also see why many people complain that the head comes off. The welding doesn't seem to be the best quality. But I think that I can keep this tool functioning for a long time by paying attention to that joint. | 11% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
| |||||
Three Star Reviews: | 8% It really is better for yards with grass and weeds October 8, 2017 It really is better for yards with grass and weeds. I have a desert landscape and the weeds are tougher to get out. But this can help with eliminating some "getting down and dirty with weeds" November 12, 2016 I get more satisfaction to pull weeds. But this can help with eliminating some "getting down and dirty with weeds" I'll need to work on it before I use it July 6, 2016 I've had these before and they do work great. Unfortunately, the one I ordered here is bent out of shape and is quite dull. The others I've had came sharpened. I suppose I'll be able to bend it back into shape when I clamp it up in my vise to relieve it of i's dull edges... Questionable quality July 5, 2016 I think I will probably sharpen it and the handle has a little wiggle that I am afraid will cause it to soon come off the handle. Wish I had gotten the fiberglass one. Works well for small weeds but not tough roots April 14, 2015 Works well for weeds that have just sprouted and is a good size for between rows of beets and lettuce. However it doesn't tear through strong rooted plants well (clover or dandelions especially). So ita not quite the miracle hoe I had heard about but still works well for breaking up soil between newly sprouted seedlings. | 7% ... is attached with a spot weld that isn't very sturdy. This is a light duty tool but the ... July 15, 2016 The hoe blade is attached with a spot weld that isn't very sturdy. This is a light duty tool but the right shape for what I was looking for in a hand hoe. Crudely Made but Effective June 30, 2016 This tool consists of a sharp triangular blade tack-welded to a length of square metal bar embedded in a small wooden handle with a short rubber covering having an eyelet. The design and functionality are quite good, but the handle is a bit short for Western hands, the rubber covering falls off the handle easily, and no effort was made to smooth or refine what is a serviceable but rough weld. Not as good as Martha Stewarts - but okay. June 20, 2016 It works well, I have a tool similar to this that was Martha Stewart brand that I LOVED but unfortunately cannot find anywhere anymore. This is good, just not as good as MS version. The little rubber end of the hoe keeps coming off which is irritating, the shaft should be longer and for the price it feels a bit cheap (again, as compared to the Martha Stewart version). Give or Take.... February 8, 2015 It does what I need it to do mostly.....The first two I bought broke under use....the weld from the handle to the blade is not hefty....and stresses out before it's time. I have seen other products of the same kind that were more robust and lasted longer....but I was not able to find one of the older models....and had to settle for this one....which is adequate but not preferred.... | 4% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
| |||||
Two Star Reviews: | 4% This Hula-Ho doesn't have a sharp edge to cut the ... September 15, 2016 This Hula-Ho doesn't have a sharp edge to cut the roots, so you're having to really use elbow grease in order to have it work. And just fair at that. Also, I feel the durability is weak. Ames Action Hoe is a better design, is of heavier duty construction August 24, 2016 Returned this due to the way it's constructed. It might be okay for light duty use but does not seem it would hold up over time. The screws which hold the blade to the yoke and the brad that holds the yoke to handle seemed to me to be too lightweight and susceptible to failure. Ames Action Hoe is a better design, is of heavier duty construction, and costs less. Disappointed August 9, 2016 Very disappointed in this weeder. Perhaps the wrong hoe for my purposes.Quality seems ok, but not a good choice for small spaces. Used once andthen went on vacation, so waited too long to return it, unfortunately. Two Stars October 30, 2015 This does not work for my California tumble weeds. It is well made but not productive to my needs. Hula-Ho a disappointment June 15, 2014 After reading other reviews I expected a much better experience. I tried weeding my already tilled garden, but it would't cut through the dirt. The Hula-Ho doesn't have much of a sharp edge at all. Will try to sharpen and see if it works better. Disappointed March 17, 2013 This is the first item purchased from Amazon that didn't meet my standards. Poorly constructed. Two small screws barely hold cultivator to wood handle. Manufacturer took a short cut that renders this item useless. Plan on replacing with longer screws, washers and nut bolts. Less than $2.00 may make this a sturdy weeder. Poor quality control! Additionally, received in large box with kraft paper loosely draped only on one side of carton. Too may short cuts from start to finish! | 3% Two Stars December 1, 2016 This is not an extraordinary tool, it broke at the weld after 3 months of use. | 6% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
| |||||
One Star Reviews: | 6% Do not buy July 30, 2016 This tool would not last an hour in my garden. It is made of cheap metal and the welds on the cheap metal are very poor. Junk June 14, 2016 A total piece of junk......flimsy and loosely held by 2 screws that are do not go all the way through the piece. The wood handle is the best part of this product. Returning it right away. REJECT before you buy! May 19, 2016 Sadly, I sent it right back! Should have read the poor reviews. This tool is not only a poor design, it's badly made. The only quality thing is the handle! The rest is so flimsey you could twist it "blade" by hand. There are lifetime quality ones on Amazon (which I now have ordered). Slightly more expensive, but you get what you pay for. My garden and back are worth it! Really Bad Products January 7, 2016 Lose screws, floppy blade, poorly assembled. Had to drill out sheet metal holes and put in correct fasteners. Wood handle was only part that was satisfactory. Would not recommend another purchase from this company; tools are of poor quality. Claims made in the USA...but it looks like much lower quality and clearly not American craftsmanship. Lowes or Home depot has better tools for the same cost. Should have gone there first. Big mistake to use Amazon Prime for this purchase. Just junk product. Thought I would save the 20 mile drive. Should have gone to Home Depot. For gental use only November 13, 2015 This hoe is flimsy, over priced. It has 1 tiny nail holding head to handel, wood seams weak, great for grandma. I went to the hardware store and bought a real hoe. This type item is hard to buy from a photo.I would never have purchased this if I saw it in person. | 2% Love it, but didn't last August 2, 2015 I loved this hoe, but it only lasted one week before the head flew off. Great tool...until it breaks September 11, 2013 I had borrowed a tool like this and loved it. Bought this one and loved it until one day the head just broke off! I really expect more than one season from a tool. I then bought two similar ones from two other companies and so far so good...but still in the first season with them. This style weeder/cultivator is my favorite gardening tool--but will not buy from this manufacturer again. | 3% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
Vote for Me | Vote for Me | Vote for Me | Vote for Me | Vote for Me | |
Pricing info | |||||
Old Price | |||||
Old Price | - | - | - | - | - |
Price | |||||
Price | $22.99updated: Mar 18, 2020 | $5.29updated: Mar 18, 2020 | $15.73updated: Feb 21, 2020 | $18.51updated: Mar 18, 2020 | $24.99updated: Feb 21, 2020 |
Features | |||||
Article Number | |||||
Article Number | 0010781104996 | 0721082168524 | 0767615500232 | 0017849104981 | 0603786232766 |
Brand | |||||
Brand | Flexrake | Japan | Flexrake | Flexrake | Carrot Design |
Length | |||||
Length | 2322.8 in | 421.3 in | 551.2 in | 240.2 in | 570.9 in |
Manufacturer | |||||
Manufacturer | Flexrake | Japan | Flexrake | Flexrake | Carrot Design |
MPN | |||||
MPN | JEN-1721 | STO_P_16_C5.05-CA | 500W | 1000B | CD32766 |
Number of Parts | |||||
Number of Parts | JEN-1721 | STO_P_16_C5.05-CA | 500W | 1000B | CD32766 |
Product Group | |||||
Product Group | Lawn & Patio | Lawn & Patio | Lawn & Patio | Lawn & Patio | Lawn & Patio |
Product Type | |||||
Product Type | OUTDOOR_LIVING | OUTDOOR_LIVING | OUTDOOR_LIVING | OUTDOOR_LIVING | OUTDOOR_LIVING |
Publisher | |||||
Publisher | Flexrake | Japan | Flexrake | Flexrake | Carrot Design |
Reviews | |||||
Reviews | - | ||||
Studio | |||||
Studio | Flexrake | Japan | Flexrake | Flexrake | Carrot Design |
Weight | |||||
Weight | 10.6 oz | 0.5 oz | 1.6 oz | 0.9 oz | 2.3 oz |
Feature | |||||
Feature | Made In the USA Heat treated blade Original design Self sharpening Replaceable blade available | Strong but lightweight Japanese hand hoe Designed for weeding and slicing Wood handle with plastic hanging loop 5" steel blade. 11" long overall. Perennial seller | Once, one of the most exhaust"g and back break"g garden"g projects was to prepare or ma"ta" the soil " an effort to establish a beautiful garden That all changed when the Hula-Ho was first "traduced " 1961 "The weeder with the wiggle" forever changed the way gardeners weed, aerate, mulch and cultivate their gardens The heat treated, self-sharpen"g Hula-Ho blade works beneath the surface of the soil Made In the USA Heat treated blade Original design Self sharpening Miniature size | Hula-Ho Wieder Cultivator Blade Once, one of the most exhaust "g and back break "g garden "g projects was to prepare or manta" the soil " an effort to establish a beautiful garden. That all changed when the Hula-Ho was first "traduced " 1961 "The weedier with the wiggle" forever changed the way gardeners weed, aerate, mulch and cultivate their gardens Quite simply, the heat treated, self-sharpen "g Hula-Ho blade works beneath the surface of the soil Made In the USA Heat treated blade Original design Self sharpening | Solid steel blade and neck. Innovative design of circular hoe weeder makes weeding by hand easy. Also cultivates the soil without moving it around -- it passes through the circle. Drag at ground level to cut weeds at the roots. Bottom is sharp and sides are dull, so you can use it near important plants and only cut weeds. See graphic in the photos for more information. 14.5 inches long, wooden handle is 7.5 inches, steel shank is 4.5 inches, actual blade has a 2.5 inch diameter Beech hardwood handle. A hand weeding tool that you'll alway use because it works so well. |
Sorry, there's no review at this time. Try changing the filter or leaving one.
Share your opinion