Side by Side Comparison of: Margarita Girl vs Margaritaville
eComparisons ScoreThe "Comparison Score" Is calculated based on the average number of times this item was compared with other items in this category by our users
User Rating (Amazon)
User Rating (Amazon)
Five Star Reviews:
Works like a charm
September 15, 2017
I ordered the Margarita Girl after a bad experience with a competing product arriving with a defective compressor. The shipping and price was a little more for the Margarita Girl than the competitor, however I wish I had gone with Margarita Girl the first time because it arrived quickly and works great. I look forward to playing around with it more in the future! The compact form factor is a huge plus in my opinion.
Yummy Israeli Iced Coffee!
March 10, 2017
I purchased the Margarita Girl machine so I could make delicious iced coffee slurpees like they serve all over Israel. There is nothing so delicious, and I can't stand to wait so long between my twice yearly trips there. Last trip I brought one package of Israeli Iced Coffee Mix home. Then I searched and searched the internet, found Margarita Girl, and life is sweet! The machine is fun to use and works great. It makes a party out of any get-together. My whole family loves it...beautiful adult coffee slurpees! I am on my iPad in Israel as I write this and will have a suitcase packed full of the mix when I go back to the USA. How about selling some of that mix so I can get it a little bit easier when I am not in Israel?
April 22, 2016
I ordered this machine for troops who are deployed. They use this machine every day after their missions for an awesome treat. They have had no problems except for running out of cups and slushy mix! This machine runs approximately 15 hours a day. Great purchase for a worthy group of individuals.
Perfect. Just what i was looking for.
January 27, 2016
I bought it for my wife but we both use it. You can pour a 2 liter bottle of a soft drink in it and it turns it into a sluchee. Kool aid, coke, Pepsi. It works great. Customer service was excellent. It is of commercial quality. Just like one you might see in a bar or small movie theater. Very well made.
It is easy to clean and even simpler to operate
November 6, 2014
My Margarita Girl far surpassed my expectations!! I have had 2 parties since receiving this item. At both parties the first thing I ran out of was the perfectly slushy, restuarant style margaritas this machine produces. But don't think for a minute that margaritas are the only adult beverage you can make with this machine, don't forget pina coladas and daquiris. The recipes are simple and plentiful that can be put to the test using this machine. It is easy to clean and even simpler to operate. My only regret is that I did not buy the double bowl Margarita Girl instead of the single (the more margaritas the better)! For the price you can't beat this amazing product. Completely delighted, satisfied, and quenched in St louis!!!!!
Great purchase ! 💙💙
April 5, 2017
Really like this! Takes a little bit to figure out the lids and how to line them up but after a few minutes of figuring it out, ITS AWESOME! Shaves the ice completely. Well worth it to have for that to make coffee drinks!!
July 26, 2016
Am I a bartender? No. Do people now refer to me as barkeep? Yes. Whether you're throwing a party or you just want to relax with a refreshing mixed margarita, this product is for you. It has 450 watts dual motor that shaves ice for the perfect consistency of any mixed drink. The container can make 36 oz., but if you accidently get too much tequila in, don't worry. It can carry a little bit more. It measures approximately 14-2/5 by 8-2/7 by 18 inches. The machine itself is very intuitive and comes with easy to understand instructions and recipes. The shot glass makes it very easy to control portions for that perfect mix. I've used it many times and not a single component has even slowed. So it is very sturdy and should last a very long time. The thing I love most about this is it can be used for anything. You can easily google any mixed drink recipe and tweak it very little to work. My roommate is particularly fond of strawberry daiquiris. There are two settings for the shaved ice mix. I suggest you play around with mix settings and recipes to get that perfect drink to your tastes. I was even able to make smoothies for the kids. It's so easy to use this machine for whatever you want it to be. The cleanup is very simple and it's dishwasher safe. In fact if you simply rinse it after each use it looks new again. I gave this five stars for the following reasons. First, it works exactly as the manufacturer advertised, which is the most important aspect. Second, it is very easy to use. The machine itself makes sense and the instructions are very easy to follow. Third, it produces a consistent product. It will give you exact same results every time. Fourth, the high grade materials make it durable and easy to clean. Fifth, it has an aesthetically pleasing design. It is has a sleek and elegant design that looks nice in a kitchen. The only fault I've been able to find is that the power cord is a little short so it will need to be placed close to a power socket. This isn't much of a problem as most kitchens have multiple wall sockets. Also it has a convenient storage area for the cord so you can store it wherever it looks best in your kitchen or bar area. If you get this product and I highly recommend you do I hope you have as much fun as I have had. It is certainly a higher value product than the actual price.
If you're thinking of buying this-- stop thinking and just BUY!
May 29, 2014
This machine is incredible. While there are other models that have some more fancy bells and whistles, this machine has served our needs for over two years. In the summer, this gets used everyday. Everyday. In the winter we use it at least 3 or more times a week. Since we use this thing more than we use even our coffee-makers, I bought a second pitcher about one year ago.One reason we love this machine is because while we are calorie-conscious folks, we still like to have tasty things to drink. This machine lets us create adult drinks using crystal-light type drink mixes. There are so many low-cal flavors available and while it took us awhile to learn the right proportions to produce the perfect low-cal "froco", it was worth the trouble. We've found that that amount of drink mix you'll need for good flavor is the amount you would use to make a 2 qt regular drink. The amount of alcohol varies depending on how saucy you want it but we've found that you'll need to add at least 2 oz of alcohol otherwise the consistency is a bit off (the liquid tends to separate alot from the ice). Use water to bring the liquid level up to the 16 oz mark and hit the center button! Of course, you can modify this to suit your preference (ie. less water for a more icy drink).Tip: Follow the instruction manual -- it says to let the ice sit out for 10-20 minutes before your make your drink. This may seem counterintuitive, but definitely results in a better froco.Enjoy!UPDATE: 6/4/2014 - In an unfortunate turn of events, our machine stopped working a few days ago (just a couple of days after posting this review!). The blender section still works, but the ice shaving motor is no longer functional. Very disappointing since the 1-year warranty has expired but we are considering buying a replacement soon.
Stay-cation all year long! Escape the stresses of life in about a minute! Favorite purchase this year!
May 23, 2014
So great I got one for my cousin! I'd like to get one for each of my neighbors.We like snow cones so much I started buying just ice shavers to see if we would get enough use out of them. We used them all winter and it felt like having summer in a glass. Soon I decided I like the "slushy" consistency over shaved ice, so we began adding milk to the snow cones (called a ice cap, I believe) and it was divine. So I decided to have my husband get me this for my birthday in April and I LOVE it! I use it all the time! I love that it uses ice out of the freezer and makes less noise that the othe ice shavers (no it's not quiet but you are shaving and blending ice). I cannot believe how awesome and fine it gets when using the automatic cycle over manual. I don't know why but it's so smooth and better that drinks on vacation. A little rum in the mix for "adult" slushies goes a long way for amazing texture and flavor. I buy my flavorings direct from hawaiianice.com there are small ones for sale on amazon but do yourself a favor and get the gallon size of piña colada, key lime , and maybe strawberry daquari. Get the $2 pumps, it will be worth it. I bought about 20 flavones and two pumps of key lime, 1 pump of piña colada with about a shot of milk and a shot of coconut rum is he new neighborhood favorite. There's a reason there's a song about lime and coconut! I have used with my protein powder to make healthy iced drinks and you can use to make iced coffee. I haven't tried frozen cokes yet but I don't see why not, esp with a little rum. It is fast and easy to use and clean. I usually just rinse with water unless I used protein powder. I love the ice drain at the back. I expected a glass pitcher but the heavy duty plastic is much lighter for taking it to friends houses. You may want the carry bag so you can take the party with you. My daughter is already planning on selling slushies out of our driveway. Great for pool or boat (as long as you have power) or just for mommy time when the kids are napping. Looks great on the counter which is good cause it's quite big to put away. I did not buy the version with batteries because I read reviews of battery failure. His corded model has fulfilled my very high expectations and I'm always thinking of new things to put I'm there cause I love using it so much!
June 28, 2013
I bought Margaritaville for my husband for Father's Day. We didn't use it right away but when since we started we do often. The "blender" is much taller that I expected. You definitely can't fit it under your kitchen cabinets. It looks very fancy. I even mix juices with ice with it for my children to make slushed. The whole family can enjoy it. Since I didn't read all directions at first it tool me a whole to get a hang of it. The Margarita recipe included with Margaritaville isn't the best at all.
Best Superfluous Gadget Ever
September 15, 2012
With my american express credit card "reward", I bought this -- It is nothing that I need and I can't justify it at all -- my wife and I enjoy frozen margarita's but not to the extent that we need a machine to make one on demand. That said, I bought this after thinking about it for the last few years -- I'm glad I waited - it is worth the wait - and I probably wouldn't have bought it if it wasn't for the reward money - But this is a great machine.Set up is a breeze, and it comes with a pirate map to guide you to your first drink. I still have the pirate map close to the machine, but I have not referred to it since the set up -- this is really easy to operate.I use much less ice and much less alcohol than either the setup manual recommends or what other people have recommended.Here is what I do for 2 drinks - I think this is close to restaurant quality.1 shot (the unit comes with a shot glass - dont lose it) of expensive tequila. I use 1800 silver reserve or select.1 shot cointreau.1 shot organic lime juice1 shot black currant juice -- this is optional -- but if you do it - get the unsweetend stuff from whole foodsagave nectar -- whole foods have this -- I'm not sure how much I put in -- I just squeeze the bottle - probably 3 tablespoons.fill the ice try but only about half capacity -- I fill it until the cavity is full and then a little more.This cost a lot of money -- so do it with class -- best quality all around. Don't go the lime aid way.
Four Star Reviews:
really great product. seems well made
September 6, 2016
really great product. seems well made, and sturdy enough to last a long time.shipped to north west Montana VERY fast by third party fulfillment (not amazon warehouse) - just as fast as prime - using standard shipping.this uses two stirring mechanisms - one around the front refer unit, and another on the back lid.would have given five starts if the product had a more secure bowl and lid. its possible to lift the bowl by accident while in operation, which would spill out entire contents of machine. i did this once while fidgeting with the bowl one of the first times i used it. once you know about this limitation, you should be able to avoid the problem. also, if the contents becomes very think the lid can come loose too easily - though in practice this isnt too big of an issue, as i find if the lid is popping off, the contents is too thick.freezes pretty quickly. able to turn liquid into a very think consistency. i left the machine on high, and turned my back for an hour, and came back to a pretty solid brick of ice around the cooler. i dont think you can really set and forget this thing. i found i must adjust the chill setting every 30 minuets from off - low - high to maintain the proper consistency.used these flavor mixes with good results:Orange Frusheez Slush Mix (1/2 gallon)Lemon Frusheez Slush Mix (1/2 gallon)
Defective Fan which makes a lot of noise
August 20, 2016
The seller contacted me after the review and made everything right. I hate that I had to go through all of the hassle but we received it in time for my wife's birthday and t works now. The machine takes about 2.5-3hrs to make the drink a perfect Margarita.
1 star review:
The Margarita Machine arrived much earlier than I expected but when I turned it on the fan started making a very loud noise. I'm pretty sure the fan is either damaged or hitting something. This is not normal. Waiting on a response from the seller. I did find other things wrong with it but they are not worth mentioning. I just expected better quality.
Mini Marg - my new favorite kitchen appliance
January 18, 2016
I received this as a gift becausr my smoothie n margarita habit is costing us 2 to 3 blenders a year. So far so good, it mskes 6 to 8 drinks using 1/2 recipe, in only 1/2 hour. The mix i like is a bot more expensive but worth it. Cons: the dispenser won't dispense if the mixture is too thick but with trial and error you can figure that out. And the drip catcher us a bit loose and doesn't snap to the unit. Pros: margaritas on the deck!, many flavors, and the envy of all my friends. Love it would recommend it for anyone who is looking for a slushy drink maker.
I would also be happy if it had a warranty, but there was no mention of one
July 21, 2015
Overall good product! Just make sure you put it together carefully and correctly otherwise it will leak.
We love the Margarita Girl!
July 16, 2015
We love the Margsrita Girl! Almost every weekend we will turn it on and have people over to enjoy the margaritas or other forms of slushees. It does take about 2 hours to get the right consistency so you have to plan when you will be wanting the drinks. Clean up can be a pain but overall great product!
September 23, 2016
Overall good machine. Just insure the base is tightened after cleaning. I lost an entire batch the first time I made because the base wasn't screwed on all the way. Really appreciate the back reservoir to catch melting ice remnants.
June 24, 2013
I got this because we like to make smoothies. I through some frozen fruit in the bottom with some juice, a little ice on the top and just press "start".It does all the work for you. It shaves the ice very nicely and leaves no chunks. It's very easy to clean, takes less than 5 minutes by hand. And I have just taken the pitcher apart and thrown it in the top shelf of the dishwasher a few times. Any ice left over that melts will drain out the back. There's an easily removable catcher there in the back to pour out the water.I believe it's worth the money if you like smoothies or frozen drinks.
better than most
January 30, 2013
the ice shaving feature works very well. these reviews that say the opposite about the shaving function maybe had faulty parts or didn't use it correctly. as with anything frozen that you would want to blend, its best to let it soften up for 10 to 20 mins first. i only gave this 4 stars because of the price and the blender. the actual blender is mediocre, about the same as any other $50-$100 blender - i think majority of the cost is for the ice shaving capability. this frozen drink maker is great for smoothies and alcoholic drinks. so far i have yet to find a blender that can do it all for a cheap price but this is a good start.
It is pretty cool!!!
January 2, 2013
I searched high and low. The other reviews were spot on. I gave four stars. It is really close, but I did not like how the silver cover goes up and down to remove the blender portion. I also cut my finger while disassembling the unit. I did see clearly the warning, but still cut my finger. Be careful! Very sharp!
July 19, 2012
My wife and I really like this machine. She asked me to make her a marg at 9:00am one morning! The drinks are just the right consistency. For a margarita we use a can of frozen limeade concentrate, 8~10 ounces tequila and 2~3 ounces of triple sec. Perfect every time. It also doubles as a snow cone maker for the kids, just use the manual ice shave feature. We find that we are now using ice faster than our ice maker can make it so we are now buying 15lb bags at a time.Couple of small nit picks. The ice holder seems to be pitched very slightly forward so water puddles forward. We have to remember to tip the machine back to drain it into the water tank else it drips on the floor when moved.Also, When cleaning it on the first day I sliced a finger tip off very nicely on the shaver razor. Nothing wrong with the design I just wasn't being careful enough. Be very careful when cleaning the ice shaving area. Take your time when removing the ice 'spinner', it can suddenly release (which is how I cut my finger tip off).The cord storage compartment is too small to really stuff the cord back in. One you get it out the first time you probably won't use it again.Don't see a real reason to buy the larger models except maybe the larger ice bin the have. As for the selectable drink count feature you can still make 1 or 2 cup batches with this model using the manual mode (a little trial and error needed).
Margarita Frozen Drink Maker
September 6, 2010
I ordered this item because I trust Amazon.com to deliver what they promise. I was not disappointed. I read all the reviews on it, both pro and con. The instructions were very clear and it was easy to set up. Some said the ice chute didn't seem very sturdy, but I believe there will be no problem over time with this product holding up. I was pleased with the quality of construction and the ease of making the first round of drinks. It also works well in making non-alcoholic drinks like slushies. My only con is that if you don't use a wide mouth Margarita glass, the pitcher allows some spillover around the sides of the pour spout. Be very careful when you pour. The unit is easy to clean up when ready to put away. Unused ice just melts down into container at the rear of the machine. Just remove it and pour down the drain. No drink mix ever gets into the ice chamber. Rinse out the the pitcher in the sink and let dry. Great machine.
Three Star Reviews:
There are no reviews yet
Works only on manual mode
April 15, 2017
The product shipped on time was impressed, very clean was impressed, however can't get the red light to stop blinking have tried trouble shooting with the company and nothing works. Disappointed 😔
brokwn right out of the box. the motor that ...
May 6, 2016
broken right out of the box. the motor that turns the ice shaver doesn't work and thte fault lite is constantly on, even after doing all of the troubleshooting steps from their web site.there are no clear instructions on how to install the ice tray onto the drink maker, and it's a hassle to get locked in.iF it's not slotted correctly so thst it's installed 180 degrees from the front of the machine, the fault light will stay on and the ice shaver will never engage. the instructions do not reflect this at all.
:( / :)
March 19, 2015
I just received my machine first I have to say I'm impressed it looks and feels high quality, however went to use it and the no brained measuring cup didn't come :( DISAPPOINTED when ur told something is included u expect it to come! Wished it wasn't a pain i'd return it
March 11, 2014
Nice for making a few drinks at once. I use it to make smoothies. The downfall is that the run time is way too short, so you have to stand there and the hold the button until your drink is thoroughly mixed.
Had to have it!
May 31, 2013
Nifty product but very pricey! Ordered it for the wife who will probably only use it a few times a year.
Takes up a lot of space in the kitchen
November 8, 2012
You have to experiment a lot to get the drinks to come out the way you like them, but eventually you can have fun with it.
Two Star Reviews:
Doesn't cycle, so you have to baby sit turning ...
May 22, 2017
Doesn't cycle, so you have to baby sit turning the machine off and on. If you have any mix left, you can't leave over night.
Owner was easy to work with
August 20, 2016
We ordered two of these. Both did not work. Owner was easy to work with, returned them and received our money back.
July 6, 2015
did not work correctly- 2 units tried
December 27, 2012
I was very disappointed with this margarita maker. I feel I have a blender that does a better job. The blender did not cost $130 plus dollars and it can make a much smoother drink. The reasons why I am disappointed is that you have to let the ice sit out for 10 or 15 minutes before you can use it. If you don't wait, the blender doesn't blend it because it freezes up and you have to use a spoon to get it to continue to work. The drinks we have made have not been a smooth consistency. For the cost of this machine we were not impressed.
October 29, 2010
I am very particular about my blenders and the consistency in which they are able to blend ice. I thought that because the Margartiaville blender was specifically for blending ice that it would do a far better job than it actually did. There was still large chunks of ice even after blending it more than once. While it is a pretty good blender, I am not sure if I would pay the listed price if I had known beforehand. Overall, okay blender, but I think you could find a cheaper one that does a better job.
April 26, 2010
After spending nearly $200 on a blender, I am very dissappointed in my Margaritaville. The "shoot" doesn't allow you to add ingredients while blending, but the worst part is the shoot only raises up about 3/4" which makes the blender very difficult to get in and out because it is such a tight fit. The drinks come out so smooth, but it is hard to enjoy after going through such a hassle to make it.
November 1, 2009
everything is good except for the ice shaver,the ice cubes have to be very small or they don't shave well.
One Star Reviews:
June 22, 2016
THIS IS A SLUSHY MACHINE NOT A MARGARITA MACHINE!!!!!!
Lots of flaws
January 29, 2016
Used this for the first time today... Wow is this thing LOUD!!! Imagine the noise from a vaccume cleaner!! The bowl does not even latch down!! It's just sitting on top of a gasket!! So if someone goes to move it, while its full, 2.5 gals of sticks stuff everywhere!! The top lid just sits there too, it has a second agitator in the lid, then there's a cord that plugs into the base, that cord is too short so it pulls the lid up?? Wow for an 800$ machine I would expect better!! Not worth it for the money... Update, 1 hr after placing this review I get a call from the company not happy about my review... Wow! Thanks for sharing my private info Amazon!!!! -1 star!!!
March 14, 2017
Unit was dead on arrival.
Purchased New. Arrived Used.
October 20, 2016
Product arrived used when it was purchased new. Disappointed.
t waste your money
May 4, 2015
Lower Coupler stripped and wouldn't turn blade to blend, called for repairs they don;t carry part anymore, this means un-repairable, will be tossing out to the dumps today, don;t waste your money. Thanks for nothing Jimmy Buffet
June 23, 2013
this product was a big disappointment, and I have returned it. It couldn't make 1 drink at a time and it was a littlecomplicated to operate.
sent it back
May 1, 2013
The only feature about this blender that works well is the ice shaver. Blend feature only works if you have liquids. If you have fruit or yogurt it doesn't work. It's also much bigger than I expected and barely fit on my countertop. I bought it to make smoothies and this model had excellent reviews, but I wasn't happy at all. My Kitchenaid blender works much better and it chops ice and blends frozen fruit too.
My Margaritaville Blender does not rock, it is a rock!
September 29, 2010
I bought it for over $200 almost two years ago at Costco and hardly ever used it. It came with a nice carry bag and ran well the few times that I used it. In all the time I had it I probably used it between 10 and 15 times - not that often. I went to use it recently and it started to shave the ice and then stopped, the ready light started blinking red and it will not do anything now, not shave ice, not blend, nothing. I just got off the phone with Margaritaville people and all they can say is that it is out of warranty and that it is an internal issue, and nothing I'm doing wrong. They will not give me a discount on a new one, only a $25 salt tray... how pitiful. They want me to get the equivalent of mine for $199.... If this is what I can expect after so few uses of the machine, what can I expect if I use a new one more often...I think it's time to look for another drink blender... I am very disappointed as it works well when it actually works but woe to you if you get one with a defect.
Vote for Me
Vote for Me
$799.00updated: Dec 15, 2018
$189.99updated: Dec 15, 2018
from 3 sellers
Number of Items
Number of Items
Number of Parts
Number of Parts
MANUFACTURER PARTS WARRANTY FOR 3 YEARS ON COMPRESSOR AND 2 YEARS ON ALL OTHER NON-CONSUMABLE PARTS FROM DATE OF PURCHASE
1 year limited
High-Capacity machine blends up to 25 CUPS of your favorite frozen beverage
Durable construction with high-impact plastic and stainless steel panels
1/5 HP air-cooled compressor, consistency control, freeze-up protection
3 year parts warranty on compressor, 2 year parts warranty on all other parts
Measures approximately 20.0 inches high x 10.0 inches wide x 12.3 inches deep
450-watt frozen-concoction maker blends up to 36 ounces
Dual motors for shaving ice and blending beverages; ice reservoir
Manual shave/blend option for customized drinks; dishwasher-safe parts
Shot glass, recipes, and instructions
Measures approximately 14-2/5 by 8-2/7 by 18 inches