Side by Side Comparison of: Woodland Imports vs Panacea Products

So elegant. Really dresses up my fireplace.

This looks great on my fireplace. Nicely disguises or at least distracts from the ugly 80's brass fireplace. This was a little bigger than I was expecting which was a bit of a disappointment for me since now I don't have room to set anything on my hearth in front of this, but that's probably for the best. Seems high quality. I've gotten compliments on it. Definitely dressed up my living room and the price can't be beat.

Just as described. Very nice!

Exquisite!! My friends rave about it..it is elegant..It was delivered in 2 days.I am an amazon girl for life...make me a thirty anazon!

Shipped quickly and fits perfectly with our outdoor fireplace. While it is a gorgeous piece, we bought it to really keep our dogs from going in to fireplace and digging! It's definitely a sturdy enough deterrent for our two Labs.

I love this fireplace screen! I looked everywhere...including Garden Ridge and Home Depot! The other screens I found didn't compare to this one and especially for the price. I was a little leary of ordering because of some of the reviews and when I received mine it did have a couple of defects in the screen...looked like where the screen had overlapped and pressed but the company gave me an adjustment and I couldn't be happier with my purchase! And I am very ticky...ridiculously so! Perfect size and weight! And looks gorgeous! Thanks Amazon!

Great for keeping my grandchildren away from the fireplace.

It's beautiful and we really like how light it is. It's great.

Came in on time and just as nice as I expected worked perfect for fireplace

Looks really nice, lightweight without being flimsy (wont topple easily nor would it squash a child or pet if it did... well maybe a cat or small dog). packaged securely. The only blemish on the item is a patch on one of the side panels to cover a hole in the screen, the patch is about 3/4 inch square and covers a 3/8 inch hole. Fortunately the location behind the scroll work makes it hardly noticeable, but I wouldn't have bought it full price that way in a store.Overall I like the product and would get it again, or for someone else.

This screen is beautiful! No question regarding that. I was looking for a new screen and this was advertised as "handmade" (per the description) and the price was very reasonable based on the actual list price.However, as lovely as it is...it IS NOT handmade. The tag attached to it (like an item tag in a store) and even the box it came in said "made in China". I am disappointed it was not handmade as advertised, but it is quite nice. The "list price" is overly inflated, but it is a nice screen and the shipping was fast with Prime.

This was very pretty to look at if you are looking for the color black, it was a little too light in weight for a large open fireplace for me. But like I mentioned it nice to look at and it doesn't clog the view of the fire.

It's nice as the pictures show - but it arrived in undamaged packaging yet had a dent in it. It's hard to see the dent because we also have black marble around our fireplace, so probably not bother returning this.

Quality was ok, not high end like I expected. Screen is beautiful and had only one small flaw.

I'm torn on this because I really love the screen, but I have had to return it twice. The first one had a blemish about the size of a quarter on it. The second was really bent on the top and there were numerous holes in the screen. I'm just debating on if I want to try this one one more time, or if I should move along!

The build itself is nice quality for the money but I was under the impression the background screen would be lighter it's all black, still looks nice but not what I thought.

Would have been better but it had scratches all over and you can see where someone tried to cover it up with spray paint and did not do a good job. Noe that I cleaned it up and got it all same color it looks good.

The pictures look like it's a bronze color, but it's not. It's black. All the products came in bronze, but this one arrived and looks out of place.

Quality bad ..

This fireplace screen is really beautiful. The reason I give it only two stars is because the screen that I got is damaged. It has several holes in it.

Pretty screen but very poorly made. We bought for 65 and noticed a recent increase in the price. Definitely not worth more than that. It came damaged and I had to return it. Hoping for something better in quality.

This is a pretty fireplace screen, don't get me wrong, but it is cheaply made. I should have gone with my gut feeling after reading previous reviews. It is not worth the money I paid for it. It's very light weight and easily bends. We had bought one at Target that was much better quality and better weight for less that we were replacing for this one only because it was taller. I would suggest you keep looking if you don't want to be disappointment.

Did not meet my expectations, product is poorly made, flimsy metal is thin

The screen has three very obvious holes in it, one of which is front and center, which has a horribly apparent patch job. I don't know know if this is what was meant by their description of "handmade...blemishes", but the item is being returned. Also, the screen is black. It looks more bronze in the picture. Lastly, does not stand evenly. No thanks. You get what you pay for.

The fireplace screen is flimsy with a capital "F", and is poorly finished. If your screen is going to be in a lighted area, save yourself time and trouble because this is a piece of junk. Please look at pictures supplied. The metal surrounding the screen is poorly soldered and painted. The screen has areas where the solder fills in the holes in the screen. If your screen will be in an area with a lot of light, you will NOT be happy with this screen. As I was cleaning the screen I noticed there are areas where they burned holes thru the screen, but attached it to frame anyway. This must have been done by child laborers. Pathetic workmanship.Regardless, I am keeping this screen because I mainly wanted a black screen. I will spend the hour or so it will probably take me, inserting a pin into the solder covering every little hole in sections of the screen plus I will spray paint it to improve the look. My fireplace is in a poorly lighted situation or I'd be sending this piece of junk back. If you look at it from a distance, it looks ok.

As soon as the box arrived I was quite surprised as the description nor one single customer review stated that the middle panel curved inward at the top towards the fireplace opening. This may seem like a safety feature for a fireplace screen, to curve towards the flames to keep sparks inside the fireplace, however this prevents the side panels from being able to lay flush against the opening thus leaving a 3 inch gap between the screen and fireplace. Sparks can easily escape through these two gaps. Because we never leave a fire unattended and make sure the fire is completely extinguished before going to bed or leaving the house, you all should do the same by the way, we were not going to send the screen back.The screen looks very nice in front of a lit fireplace and the construction appears to be fairly solid. However, after just 3 weeks of ownership, and about 4 uses of this screen the left side panel fell completely off while I added another log to the fire. I went to reattach the panel only to notice that the part the pin that joins the panels broke completely off. This part was welded and it literally just fell off. There is no way to repair this except to weld it once again. I am not a welder nor do I have access to a welder. I could have returned this product but return postage would have cost at least $40 which is a bit expensive. For now we will just MacGyver it by wiring the panel back on until we find another screen that is actually large enough for our extra large fireplace opening.Overall, the screen cost approximately $90 but was supposedly originally a $400 screen. I am sorry, but there is no way this screen could ever be worth $400 unless it could add logs to the fire for you. I am hard-pressed to say that this screen is even worth the $90 price tag. If it had not broke after 3 weeks then the price would have been worth it.

This screen looks nice when set up but it came with a defect. Looks like the manufacturer tore the metal mesh screen and tried to patch it. It also started to rust after a few days.

This product came in with a hole in the screen, but beside that, it is way too light to safely put in front of a fire.