Side by Side Comparison of: VERDUGO GIFT CO vs Plow & Hearth

love the look, arrived on time and it was just as described.

Beautiful and functional. Great for pet safefy!

very nice.

Looks like really expensive screen. I joke that the scene looks like it's out of Bambi when the fire is raging, but we are very happy with the quality of the screen.

I definitely would buy this again....BUTPay attention to the paint detail on the pine cone needles.Some of the very fine wire pine cone needles were missing paintwhich I easily fixed with a Black sharpie.I love this screen and I almost knocked off a star if it wasn't so easy to fix.

The screen gives a little bit of country charm to my living room. They are well made and I am very happy with it. the sparks can't jump over the screen so I feel very safe.

I cannot stress enough how much I absolutely love this fireplace screen! I procrastinated many months because of the price. But everything else I looked at, for less the cost, was never exactly what I wanted. Then, I decided to just make the purchase. Amazon is great about returns if it doesn't work. This screen is very, very, sturdy. It's high quality and beautiful! I'm so very glad I made this purchase!

Can't recommend this screen highly enough. Superb fit/finish for the money, and absolutely beautiful. Pictures don't do it justice.

This screen is very nicely made and looks very nice in front of our fireplace. The only thing I don't like about it is the fact that it obscures the fire. That is no reason to lower its rating though as it is pretty obvious that it will do that when you look at the pictures of it. It is very stable though and keeps any flying embers from flying out. The doors are kept close with a magnet. The magnet has just the right amount of attraction to keep the doors shut but not so much that they are difficult to open.

As I read in the reviews I didn't put the rear legs on to get it closer to the brick. Pictures don't do it justice as the flames are cool with the beveled glass. Seems to be built OK and we hope to get years of service out of it. It only took a few minutes to assemble with real tools (drill with phillips and wrench. They send cheap hand tools if you don't have any to put the nylon nuts on 4 bolts for the legs. Self explanatory but they have good instructions.Also, something I didn't consider until using it is I wouldn't leave a stack of logs burning with this unit unattended as the doors are only held shut by magnetics. I thought this would be nice as the old one I had was a hassle to bi-fold open, but it was safer if a log rolled off. It does NOT have a separate screen. The middle,sides,bottom,and above the doors are screen with the rest being beveled glass.

beautiful ! I had my fireplace made and added this as the finishing touch. see attached picture

I order this never having bought one before. we have gas fireplace that we never use and I wanted to hide/make it look better. I am very happy with look of this product. also stand very sturdy. have 11mon & 2 yrs old that have played with doors and never tipped or moved out of place.

VERY GOOD

Worked for me

It fits in with the room's decor make over. Only thing I would change is the tabs on the back keep it from fitting all the way back against the fireplace.

Looks amazing with our fireplace! Latch is a little cheesy and handles heat up a bit when fire is going but we make it work

the stands are a little cheap thin metal and there is no leveling adjustments to account for the base needing to be pushed up.

Looks as advertised, and does the job. No complaints here.

BeAutiful, sturdy. I tonight it would fit over the opening with a little extra room it so it looks covered from all angles. It doesn't do that from the sides it looks like it's too small

Great fire screen. The only thing I would want is screening behind the glass.

Love this fireplace screen...the only thing is that there is not a screen behind the glass doors so you have to close the doors if you don't want embers popping out of the fireplace. It looks great and fits my fireplace opening perfectly.

Looks nice and easy to use. Sturdy and adds elegance to your fireplace.

I gave it 4 stars only because when I received the screen it had a few nicks & scratches. Nothing that can't be covered up. Otherwise it's nicely made and the beveled glass panels give the fire a nice glow. Over all I am satisfied with the piece. The price was not too bad. I'd recommend this item.

Screen looks great, and it's the perfect size for my fireplace. I would have given it 5 stars but for the $70 price tag for an obvious visual problem. The largest of the 3 trees is in 2 pieces, and the joint is obvious and distracting. Can't believe China can't come up with a single piece of metal at an affordable cost. If you look closely at the color photo, you'll see the joint.

Beautiful but the solder around the glass is what would be found in stained glass windows and does not stand up to high heat from larger fires or hotter burning wood. I used an infrared heat gun to determine my heat levels which never exceeded 500 degrees which is a pretty hot fire. Great for gas burning fireplaces and smaller fires but don't expect to use one of these in a fireplace used to heat a house. That said, I like it enough to buy another for ambiance fires but will use something else if I need to use my fireplace for heat.

This is a beautiful fireplace screen and fits perfectly at my fireplace. Unfortunately, the screen arrived in a battered container and the screen had a quarter size hole. I didn't return it because of the bulk and weight of the packaging. Instead I hammered the screen hole and I am the only one who knows it is there. Disappointing!

This is not a good fireplace screen if you plan on burning wood in your fireplace... if you plan on using the screen as decoration, then this might work for you. Here are the flaws that I found in my unit:- I cannot fully attach one of the leg stands to my unit because the hole in the stand doesn't match up with the screw coming out of the main body. To make matters worse, the screw was damaged at the factory or in shipping and the nut won't even thread on.- Door on my unit does not open/close very well; unit is not bent, just doesn't seem to fit together correctly. There is a locking mechanism that does not work at all (deadbolt style system) because the bolt doesn't line up with the hole it's supposed to go into.- Large tree on left side is made from two pieces of metal (joint clearly visible)