Side by Side Comparison of: Purina Fancy Feast vs New Life Spectrum

The only cat food my 14 year old cat eats. I purchased a sample packet and she rejected every other brand since. Only wish that they made the larger bags with zipper closing.The only cat food my 14-year-old cat eats.

This is the only thing my finicky cat will eat and our local grocery stores only carry small pouches. This is huge and we don't have to run to the grocery store every few days for more cat food! The bottom of the bag is nice and wide, so we've never had it tip over. It also comes with a seal to use after its been open. I'm so thankful that Amazon carried this cat food in a huge size!

Not so much that I love it -since it is fairly expensive and hard to find in stock anywhere, but this is like Cat Crack and my four cats absolutely love it. I have stopped buying cat treats and use this as my cat treats. It is cheaper than treats and I know the cats will eat every piece I put out. Other than this food, my cats eat grain free due to one with pancreatitis and one with allergies to certain grains. Both of my special needs cats can eat this with no problems.

I am getting this large bag for $5 more than the on sale price for the small bag!!! WOW!! We don't even have the large bag as a choice here on our island!! I am so pleased!! Now I won't feel so guilty stealing from my babies to feed the stray cats who come to visit us daily!!!They all love this stuff!! They stick their noses up ath the Science Diet and the Iams top of the line Healthy stuff!! It just lingers and lingers.The birds end up eating those!!! So, I am thrilled to have found this in the 7 pound bags!!!I will be a regular on Amazon Prime with this one!!!

I adopted a cat three years ago who was a captured stray. His "Foster" mother fed him the Ocean Fish and Salmon combo when she brought him in and he took a liking to it. I have tried other varieties, beef for example, of the same brand, but that was not well received. A year later I adopted another stray and she took to it just as well and had the same adversion to the beef. Neither cat is overweight or unhealthy. I leave their food bowl out all day as my vet believes grazing in small portions throughout the day is better than scoffing down a bowl full of food in one feeding.

My cats, love, love, love this! I haven't tried the other flavors b/c all of my cats devour this stuff. This is the cheapest, most convenient way to buy pet food. No more, "Oops, did you buy food for the cats? We're out! Better make a run for the store and hope that they aren't out of this too!!" We have figured out our needs for a month and signed up for the automated, recurring order process: best price for this product, free shipping, and no more late night runs to the supermarket! (only one supermarket in our community of 250,000 carries this, and it's in a SMALL bag!) If you have pets, sign up for the automatic delivery. You'll never regret the convenience or savings.

I have tried all the best fish foods out there and this BY FAR is the best. Even the pickiest of fish go crazy over this stuff! My mandarin fish even paces for it, my tangs love it, predators, herbivores, whatever.. They all go nuts for it and are very healthy now. I would definitely recommend!

I used this marine dry food in an auto feeder when I went out of town for a week! My fish really live it and the fast swimmers get it first - but not all as the pellets will sink for the bottom dwellers and shrimp to feed also! They were all fat and healthy when I got back and did not promote algae growth

Recently purchased this food for my pair of clowns, they seem to really like it and seem to be reproducing more than they were before not sure if it is the food or what. They are going on 9 years old and very healthy. When switching to this food the hair algae in my tank seemed to disappear which was nice.

Wonderful quality product w/ top ingredients. I like the fact that it contains garlic which is great for repelling the ICK pest. Recently had an ICK breakout in my 55 gal. aquarium & with raising the temp to 87 - added some aquarium salt & used half strength Rid Ick (because of sensitive clown loaches) finally got rid of it. This food was recommended by a person on YouTube for helping the fish after an ICK breakout because of the quality ingredients & the garlic to repel the ICK. It also colors them up nicely. I feel that my 2 clown loaches were saved in part because of using this food. I feel very confident using it, and glad that I could get it on Amazon because I couldn't find it in local stores. I use it in all my tanks, will be ordering it again for sure.

At first my fish was hesitant to eat it, but I started soaking it in some of their previously frozen meals to entice them. A week later, they are eating away.

Good premium dry food. My cat loves it.

i like it for my cats but wouldn't pay $18 it means $6 more than previous packages. Give me a break

All the cats love 'em.

My cats love this cat food. So buy it by the bagful....

I had a fussy cat with a poor appetite due to loss of a buddy. This food got him eating again. He is now back on a healthier food (Iams).

Cats are hit and miss about this, but they are cats. One day they like it than it's just ok the next. Haven't found one they like better and I have tried quite a few brands, even some that are more expensive. This is the best I could find.

my fishes like it

I suppose its good... you'd really have to ask the jillion guppies that eat it if its really good.

This is very good but i have damsels that are like 1 1/2 inches big that cant swollow it so i have to crumble it up withch is kind of annoying

Fish love it. I just wish it sank on contact with water. I usually have to dip it in the water for it to sink right away.

Product quality is consistent. Fish readily accept this food and the small sinking pellets are the right size for my smaller fish, like my Blue Mandarin Dragonet.

Check the weight carefully before opening. I did not. I ordered a 7 pound bag and got a 3 pound bag. $15 is pretty expensive for 3 pounds. My cats love the food.

My cats liked this food but too expensive for my budget.

Cats like it but its kinda pricey

cats dont like it that much

My cat likes this food, but the ingredients leave a lot to be desired. Manufacturer must put some special coating or additive that appeals to cats. Yin is 17.5 years old and I bought this to see if she would eat more as she had lost weight. She is eating more and has more frequent and softer waste. I feel it is overpriced with all the fillers used. The main ingredients are rice and corn. I do not recommend this cat food. Purina Beyond is better.

So I have yellow tang, clown, blue Chromis, Cardinal, Lryetail, fire fish, and dottyback. NONE of them are very in to this food. I am sure it is a high quality food but none of my fish seem to care for it.

I am not sure if I will buy this food again or not. I have a 30-40 gallon tank. I have groms, tiger barbs, a catfish, and hermit crabs. I like these because they sink, but I don't like them because they keep clogging my filter. It just adds another step to cleaning my tank as I have to clean off the pipe on my filter and pull out tiny pieces of food. However, the fish really seem to like it. I mix it with flakes so it's a bit of a mixture and I use an auto feeder which it works fine with.

Not sure what it is but my fish pretty much ignore this food unless they are really hungry. I don't have picky eaters, a clown and a damsel. Every thing else's throw in the tank m they devour, this stuff they look at and watch it sink slowly... Pretty much all I do with it is just throw a few pellets in the tank every few days to watch the hermits have a battle royal over them, that's about it.

Did not work for me. My dottyback and mandarin will not touch this. They look mad when I tried to feed them this. Only my cleaner shrimp was happy but he only ate one pellet. I had to try to fish the rest out but that was a pain and they just disintegrated. Then my take broke out in diatom blooms.

I had high hopes for these pellets after hearing about it but my pair of clownfish would not eat this. The nutrition data looks good and want something good for them. They sink way to fast and my clownfish will only eat from the surface or if it can catch while the pellet is sinking. Once it hits the sand, they don't touch it or won't see it because it get's sucked into my rock. I got the Ocean Nutrition Prime Reef Flake which they went crazy for. I give it a 3 stars to meet in the middle since the pellets seem like high quality but better for bottom feeders.

MY CATS LOVE THIS...IT'S ABOUT THE ONLY DRY FOOD THEY'LL EAT...I LOVED THE CONVENIENCE OF BUYING IT ONLINE BECAUSE IT'S OUT OF STOCK IN STORES SO OFTEN....I'D BEEN DOING GOOD TILL THE PRICE OF ONE BAG WENT UP BY ABOUT $11.00....NOT SURE WHY IT SHOULD...I CAN'T PAY THAT MUCH FOR IT.... I'D OF GIVEN IT FIVE STARS BEFORE THAT HAPPENED...😐

Not great from a nutrition point of view

Bought to use with an auto feeder, but found the food to cloud the water, so I use sparingly with my other food. Won't buy again.

It's probably a really good food for fish ...smell is very strong when I opened it but I will not purchase this product again because my fish are use to floating flakes and these pallets sink quickly so they don't get eaten.

the food is too small and sinks into the gravel making it hard for the fish to find it.

I thought my fish would go crazy over this formula but he likes it about the same as all the rest. I don't like the jar that it came in, as there is no easy way to shake out pellets. You unscrew the top and have a whole jar of pellets. I would have preferred a shake out container instead, which is why I gave it only 2 stars.

These pellets float around on top until they get caught up in enough current from a powerhead to get pushed under. Specifically wanted a sinking pellet, I would not buy again. My fish seem to like it, some just don't get much to eat because they are too skitish or its against thier nature, to eat from the surface.

Cats love it, but you can purchase for half the price at Walmart.

According to my friends experience with her healthy male cat, this brand is terrible. Do not by this if you love your cat. This brand poisoned my friend's cat, and now that cat is no longer living.

We have been purchasing Fancy feast for our inside cats but this past 2 months, they have been throwing it up. After doing some online research, there have been other cases like ours. For now we have not been giving our cats fancy feast because of that.

My cats like it and think its pretty cool that they get their cat food in the mail like we all do...True citizens of the world now....Big shots...lol

This food is horrible. If my fish were able to speak, they would have cursed me for buying it for them. The fish never tried tasting this food, instead they were swimming away. It sunk to the bottom of the fish tank causing a mess and in couple days turned the tank into a foggy, dirty, and too ugly to look at fish tank.
Note: No return allowed, be aware.

Fish hate it

My fish HATE this stuff. They actually swim away from it. Plus it sinks so stinking fast they have no chance of getting it. DO NOT BUY!

The product description and picture is for 150g but the actual product shipped was 125g. I feel cheated. Worse yet. Amazon will not take back the return so I am stuck with this! I am reconsidering my Prime subscription,

I bought this for one purpose only, to sink from my auto fish timer. The problem...they float!! Right over my overflow!!! Thanks!