5 items
| Compare | |||||
| Compare All Features Differing | |||||
Side by Side Comparison of: Timberland vs Fiebing's vs YuEdge
| Learn More | |||||
Learn More | |||||
Rating info | |||||
| eComparisons Score | |||||
eComparisons ScoreThe "Comparison Score" Is calculated based on the average number of times this item was compared with other items in this category by our users | 9 | 9.4 | 8.8 | 8.8 | 8.8 |
User Rating (Amazon) | |||||
User Rating (Amazon) | |||||
 | |||||
Five Star Reviews: | 69% Fantastic Boots! April 11, 2017 Fantastic hiking boots. I have worn them quite a bit now and have to say they are extremely comfortable and surprisingly light. I haven't fully tested out their level of waterproofness, however, the minimal amount of water and much I have been in, they have worked perfectly. I have a wide foot and they have plenty of room. The toe box is roomy as well. Sizing was perfect I wear a size 10, and the Size 10 I ordered fits exactly how I was hoping. My one complaint is they could use a tad more arch support. I typically don't have issues in this area, but after wearing these for several hours, I do notice a bit of fatigue in my right arch, but nothing that would stop me from walking. Comfy waterproof all-day winner December 19, 2016 My husband needed a pair of boots to wear to work for rainy & cold days. He works at an auto auction and walks 8-10 miles a day, everyday, at work, so he needed something that would be comfortable on the asphalt and keep his feet dry. These Timberlands are fantastic! These are lightweight, waterproof, & more comfortable than his sneakers. (I know because he tells me all the time!) He has been raving about how great these are, and it doesn't hurt that they are also nice looking shoes; he's gotten quite a few compliments on them. These are definite winners. BUY THE SHOES! Love them! Hope to have them for years more! June 6, 2016 Love these boots. Still wearing them today after years! They look good and keep your feet both dry & warm. The sole is very comfortable which can be an issue for me with boots. They were also wide enough for my feet as well! The outside has outlasted the weather big time! While it is scuffed after many hikes and snow storms, it still looks pretty nice! I also used them as wader boots once when one of my wader boots got so stuck in the mud I had to ditch it. After letting them dry out, they were as good as new! Not even a bad smell! Very very happy with these boots especially for the price (which at the time was bit less then current June 2016 prices). So far very pleased with these boots June 15, 2015 So far very pleased with these boots! They are super-comfortable. I am a landscaper, so I needed a sturdy, comfortable, waterproof boot. We are outside all day, rain or shine. Given the well-known, well-established name that is Timberland I was hopeful that the quality would live up to the name. I have had these for a month or so and I am happy that I spent the money. I think they will last a while. I will mention there was a particularly wet, rainy day we worked. Toward the end of the day I feel like my feet felt like they might be slightly damp. I was a little disappointed, but I wouldn't say my feet were "wet" - they weren't really, although I don't think I would walk through ankle-deep puddles like I would with my previous boots, which were Merrill boots, and significantly more expensive. Also I should add that others have mentioned it would be wise to buy Mink Oil to rub the boots with, improving the waterproofing of the boot. I have since bought Sof-Sol Mink Oil. Summary: Good, sturdy boot that has decent support and is very comfortable - and for the most part - waterproof. great boot/shoe so far September 15, 2014 I have only had 3-days so far but the fit is very good, I can move my toes which to me is good! I put sno-seal on as so as i tried them on out of the box, i'm not sure they needed it but i like to know there is a nice base coat there. I love the laces and the catches to lace up the padded tongue really does let you lace it up tight and not cut off blood flow to your feet. I am VERY hard on shoes and boots, I work in an office environment but don't usually change my shoes to do barn/yard work and such. example the shoe i replace where ECCO that cost $220, and lasted me 2 years, they came apart at the seams............ that are still usable but i don't think they are waterproof anymore. I like a waterproof shoe/boot that covers/supports my ankles that is why i use these in the office, after having very wet feet from a downpour in the parking lot at work one time. time will tell will update at one year mark remind me if i have not | 84% There are no reviews yet | 69% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
 | |||||
Four Star Reviews: | 19% Wrong size April 7, 2017 I have enjoyed Timberland products for many years now. I get at least a year from each pair of boots I purchase. They wear well, they are comfortable and the style is awesome ! However, I don't know how, or why, but I seem to have ordered the wrong size this time ? I have always worn a size 10 wide. Somehow, I got it wrong and received a 10.5 size. I thought id just get used to the fit after a while, but its not working out to well ? I have a severe problem with my Left ankle. Its been severally broken twice, so I need lots of support from my shoes, that's why I wear this brand. Ive already put a few miles on these, I guess Im stuck till I can afford a new pair now ? If not, please let e know asap, and ill send these back asap...Thanks for the interest. Sincerely Don Warm, comfortable, and durable March 12, 2017 I first bought these boots in 2012 and by 2017 the soles are worn enough that I have to order a new pair. I mainly wear them in winter, and they've worked great. My feet have gotten wet a couple of times while stepping in puddles, but as long as the puddles aren't too deep, my feet stay dry. The best part about them is the insulation. Paired with thick socks, these boots keep my feet warm, even when the Polar Vortex hits the city. Good boot December 18, 2016 Bought these over the summer to take on a fishing and camping trip in northern Canada. After a few nights of reading through reviews of various boots, I decided on these. First thing I did when I got them was rub them down with Mink Oil. I wore them a little bit around the house to ensure that the fit was good, and there weren't any obvious problems. However, I didn't have time to put any real outdoor mileage on them before my trip. I wore these boots all day for 6 days straight without any real break-in time beforehand. They fit great, were comfortable, and I was impressed with them. The provided stable grip on the rocks as I was stomping around the bush. They kept my feet dry, despite several splashes getting in and out of the boat. I didn't sink them over the ankle, but several times I was up to the laces without any leaks. Good quality boot for hiking/walking. September 20, 2016 I have only one issue with this boot. Overall I like the boots, felt good right out of the box. With that said, I have a size 9 reg foot but on the wide side but not enough to order wider E width. The solution has always been to buy 1/2 larger ie.. 9.5 instead of 9.0. My current boots being replaced are 9.5 and I can wear heavy wool socks like I perfer. Not with these, I probaly should have returned them but with thin athletic socks they fit like a glove. I am sure in time when the breaking in has accured the boots will have more room but they really should be a bit looser from the start. What I am saying is order them 1/2 size larger than your current boot no matter what size foot you really have. On the topic of water proofing which has been discussed in other reviews, if you do what you should use a protector on them before the first use... then there will be no issue with that up to the upper eyelets at that point the lower web of the tung stops and so would the waterproofing, they will resist water for a short period of time at ankle depth but water will seep by. The issue of traction which is a big one for me, I have put them to the test in that area and I am very pleased. I have not had a slip in situations where one would exspect, after rain going over rocks and dead trees no prob. Ah yes the final piece of the puzzle is the support both shank and ankle, I am pleased to say that there pretty good in both areas. Plenty of support.. I would recommend these, just order as I stated. Good basic boot August 12, 2016 I had some problems early on with rubbing on top of my foot right behind the big toes. A new pair of socks fixed that problem. Other than that one of the eyelets at the bottom came out early on but doesn't seem to affect anything greatly. It's been three months now and the bottom sole is starting to separate. This is about typical for me as these are everyday wear and I walk several miles a day at work...and go hiking and backpacking when I'm not there. The price was very good as I got the wheat colored style though I think I might spring for the dark brown next time. | 11% There are no reviews yet | 21% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
| |||||
Three Star Reviews: | 5% Woah be careful September 2, 2017 Well traction is excellent except on black concrete/asphalt that's slick... was working through some rain landscaping and was walking down with trimmers thankfully they were off but I slipped as I went downhill right on my back lost my breathe for a few minutes and the trimmers dug into my arm though minor injury, be warned, I've been through a few timberlands and this was the cheapest at the time but also the least grip/traction Doesn't live up to the Reviews May 11, 2016 I rate these shoes as 3 stars for a variety of reasons: -Sizing is off, I usually wear a Size 10, but the 10.5 was not nearly enough to comfortably fit my foot. The shoe seemed to disrupt blood flow if it wasn't tied very loosely. The Toe box felt small. These fit well for a certain type of foot it seems, and I just don't happen to have it. -These shoes are heavy. I wear Military Combat boots and these boots outweigh them. Reading reviews of "I could hike in these all day!" make me skeptical that the person actually wore these for anything more than a walk around the park. On that note, the sole did provide great protection from the gravel and rocks I walk through everyday. -I did not try these shoes on slippery/wet surfaces. I did not test the "Waterproof" claim either. -The shoes looked really nice with some tan khaki pants, which was why I initially bought them. I did not receive these boots for free in exchange for a review as many others who posted about this product. I decided to return these boots as even wearing them once a week was not a enjoyable experience for me. Nice boots but cheaply made!!! November 28, 2014 I got this boots from here because I read some positive reviews.My husbands shoe size is a nine but I read that that they run small so I got half size bigger.Anyway I received them last week and my husband wore them 2 times to work and the day we got snow.So only 3 times and the glue came off the front. I am so disappointed because I had already thrown the box in the trash and how can I return them without a box. I hope this review helps others. This was my experience with my defective pair. "2E" is Not "W" August 4, 2014 I was expecting a "2E" boot that was wider than a "D", which it was, but since there was no option for a 4E I took a chance it would fit. Inside the tongue it gives its' width as "W." The boot, although long enough, was somewhat narrow across the ball of the foot. I've had better luck with Hi-Tech boots in this regard so I returned the Timberlands and I'm waiting for a pair of Hi-Tech light weight hiking boots. If there wasn't free shipping both ways, in both cases, I wouldn't attempt getting shoes online. The boot looked well constructed and that's why I gave it three stars. Just not wide enough for my feet. Could be better February 28, 2014 I have wide feet so I went for the 9 2E size. The boot fit perfectly and didn't require much to break into them. Bought this because of the reviews on being a great hiking boot. They were right on the money. I hiked every other weekend for about 4 months and it didn't disappoint. I loved how I was able to bend my ankles comfortably during my hikes; especially while rock scrambling. If this boot was that great for hiking, why not for work in construction. Again this boot didn't disappoint. I was stressing the limits of this boot; I worked 6 days week and sometimes hiked on the 7th. Everything was fine until about 7 months later. The rubber tip on one of the boots, that protect your toes in the front, began to peel away from where it connects with the leather material. I do light construction where I walk on even surfaces 80% of the time and I didn't expect this to happen, especially for a Timberland product. This started happening 7 months after I bought this product and 3 months after I stopped hiking. So I would have expected the peeling as a result of hiking, not from construction. The boot is entering it's 10th month of service and used only for work. The tip didn't peel off to the point where it's dangling. It's still functional and doesn't appear to peel any further. To conclude my review, I would still recommend this boot. But only for occasional beginner to intermediate hikes and not as work boots. | 2% There are no reviews yet | 3% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
| |||||
Two Star Reviews: | 3% Not so easy return for defective manufacturing. July 31, 2017 4 months of wearing these to mow my lawn and other yard work, these are falling apart. No scuffs or tears in the boot, pretty light use and Amazon would not exchange these. I am having to pay shipping to send these to Danville, KY to get an exchange. 3-4 weeks without boots. It won't kill me but it is a good argument to buy footwear locally. Comfortable Boot, But..... January 18, 2017 Very nice boot, seemingly well made and tough. I added an aftermarket padded insole and was immediately able to walk over 7 miles, three days in a row without a break-in period. HOWEVER, after just my fourth day of wearing these boots one of the riveted eyelets on the left boot broke and came out of the leather hole, so now I have to take it to shoe repair to get fixed (hopefully). If they can't fix it reasonably I'm sending them back. A shame because these are very comfortable boots. I should not have to pay for a repair because of shoddy craftsmanship. I'll revise the review as this issue progresses. 13 EE IS NOT 13 W February 12, 2015 Overall disappointed with the boot. It is waterproof so far but the fit leaves a lot to be desired. I ordered a EE boot, but what arrived was a boot marked 13W. So I'm thinking... shouldn't a boot that is supposed to be EE be a least a WW and not just W. If you are a EE size do not, I repeat do not order these boots. They also seem a bit light weight to be considered "hiking" boots. Not what I consider a Timberland boot to be like at all. Start building them in the USA again...much better overall quality. If my photo is included in this review the boot on the left is a medium not a wide fit. Soles wore out quickly February 5, 2015 I purchased a pair just over six months ago. Initially, as with any leather shoe, it's a bit uncomfortable until you break them in. After that period these shoes were very comfortable. They're waterproof as well. I often take my dog down to a river to play and occasionally I step in it or walk through wet/muddy fields and these shoes kept my feet dry and that's a lot better than the waterproofing on my last, non-Timberland, boots. The problem, and the reason for the two stars, is that the soles wore out quickly. If you look at the shoe you can see that there's that foamy-comfortable section and the harder, more durable rubber section of the shoe on the very bottom. In 6 months time I've worn through the "durable" rubber section down to the foamy section of the sole. These are my everyday shoes and I use them for hikes, etc. Had it been 12months out and I had seen this then I'd just accept it being an everyday shoe and things wear out. At 6 months, though, it seems premature. I could definitely see the tread wearing off in that time but I shouldn't see the foamy section of the sole through the bottom of the durable section. As it is, I've ordered a different pair of boots and, hopefully, I'll get a year out of them. I would have given this shoe just one star but it does get an extra star for actually being waterproof and comfortable. It's only fault, and I find it a big one, is the non-durable rubber sole. Short Lived-Boots Retired After 3 Months! September 17, 2014 First off, I am an avid hiker and works as a backpacking guide. I often recommend any shoe that is waterproof and has a full leather body. As typically those boots last and retain their waterproofing if properly cared for as compared to shoes using fancy fabrics. I put a lot of miles on my shoes and expect a lot. I am lucky if a pair of shoes last me 3 seasons! That said, reading the reviews I had high hopes for these boots. Upon arrival they fit great, and felt at home on the trail in any conditions. 3 months later the shoe has begun de-laminating from the sole, the sole is worn significantly. I take proper care of my boots, applying mink oil on a monthly basis and inspecting them during the process. When I first began wearing these boots, I raved about them recommending them to clients. Unfortunately with their short life span I will steer people clear of these boots. I will unfortunately go back to my higher end boots, and would recommend the same for anyone who demands a lot from their shoes. | 1% There are no reviews yet | 2% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
| |||||
One Star Reviews: | 4% Metal shoelace bracket ripped out on Hike #5, terrible quality. July 28, 2017 What started out as an amazing boot that was heavy-duty, light-weight, very comfortable and waterproof unfortunately turned into a disappointment. I have worn these boots on 5 day hikes and was very impressed with their grip and feel but as I went to lace my boots up by pulling on the strings to force them tight, the top shoelace bracket on the right side came flying off. I'm extremely disappointed that a solid piece of metal came flying out of the boot because I really enjoyed these. I wouldn't recommend these hiking boots to anyone - very low quality and it really is a shame. Do not but these boots! June 8, 2017 I bought 1 pair for Christmas for my son-in-law who had a pair like this in the past which he liked very much. The first time he put them on one of the cleats at the top broke off. He returned them but had so much trouble trying to get a replacement we finally asked for a refund. So I ordered a second pair at a much higher price and the same issue occurred with them. When he tried to return them he was told they were out of the return period even though they were defective. Therefore I do NOT recommend these boots or this seller. Seems like the sealant was not properly contained May 30, 2017 I have been using timberland boot for the last 20 years and they really last. This one I bought and kept it as a backup since I was travelling internationally, when I started using it, just after a few uses I discovered that a black ooze was leaking from the sole near the heal, it was sticky and messing socks, trousers and anything that touched it. Seems like the sealant was not properly contained. I just bought another one yesterday, to replace the same. Never had to discard a timberland shoe within three months of starting its use, normally they last years. They fell apart!!! January 4, 2017 With-in two weeks one of the rivets for the eyelet came off, the left toe rubbed really bad and after a month I could not wear the boots anymore. I usually have really good experiences with Timberlands, but these just suck. DO NOT BUY THESE!!! never buy again August 4, 2014 I have a Landscape business and this is the second pair I have bought. Don't ask me why. Both pairs lasted about 2 months and my feet were wet all the time. The soles come off at the front. | 2% There are no reviews yet | 5% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet | 0% There are no reviews yet |
Vote for Me | Vote for Me | Vote for Me | Vote for Me | Vote for Me | |
Pricing info | |||||
Old Price | |||||
Old Price | - | - | - | - | - |
Price | |||||
Price | $74.93updated: Mar 16, 2020 | $7.30updated: Mar 16, 2020 | $13.99updated: Mar 16, 2020 | $69.95updated: Mar 16, 2020 | $74.95updated: Mar 16, 2020 |
Features | |||||
Brand | |||||
Brand | Timberland | Fiebing's | YuEdge | Timberland | Timberland |
Color | |||||
Color | Dark Brown | White | Blue/Grey/Brown | Black | Dark Brown |
Currency | |||||
Currency | USD | USD | USD | USD | USD |
Department | |||||
Department | mens | mens | mens | mens | mens |
Height | |||||
Height | 216.5 in | 39.4 in | 68.1 in | 208.7 in | 236.2 in |
Length | |||||
Length | 551.2 in | 196.8 in | 424.8 in | 555.1 in | 472.4 in |
Manufacturer | |||||
Manufacturer | Timberland Casual Footwear Mens | Fiebing's | YUEDGE | Timberland | Timberland |
Model | |||||
Model | TB012135214 | MOIL00P006Z | YUEDGE Men 3 Pair Mix Sock | TB012122001 | TB018128242 |
MPN | |||||
MPN | TB012135214 | MOIL00P006Z | YUEDGE Men 3 Pair Mix Sock | TB012122001 | TB018128242 |
Number of Parts | |||||
Number of Parts | TB012135214 | MOIL00P006Z | YUEDGE Men 3 Pair Mix Sock | TB012122001 | TB018128242 |
Product Group | |||||
Product Group | Shoes | Automotive Parts and Accessories | Sports | Shoes | Shoes |
Product Type | |||||
Product Type | SHOES | AUTO_ACCESSORY | OUTDOOR_RECREATION_PRODUCT | SHOES | SHOES |
Publisher | |||||
Publisher | Timberland Casual Footwear Mens | Fiebing's | YUEDGE | Timberland | Timberland |
Quantity | |||||
Quantity | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 |
Reviews | |||||
Reviews | |||||
Score | |||||
Score | 8.8 | 9.4 | 8.8 | 8.8 | 8.8 |
Size | |||||
Size | 10 2E US | 6 oz | L(Men Shoe 7-11 US Size) | 10 2E US | 10 2E US |
Studio | |||||
Studio | Timberland Casual Footwear Mens | Fiebing's | YUEDGE | Timberland | Timberland |
Weight | |||||
Weight | 4.2 oz | 0.9 oz | 1.8 oz | 3.7 oz | 4.2 oz |
Width | |||||
Width | 393.7 in | 196.8 in | 307.1 in | 409.4 in | 354.3 in |
Feature | |||||
Feature | Seam-sealed waterproof hiking boot with cushioned EVA foam footbed Gusseted tongue B.S.F.P. motion efficiency traction lugs | Softens, preserves and waterproofs smooth leather and vinyl Helps prevents stains 6 ounce tub of mink oil paste Great quality mink oil paste from Fiebing's Manufactured in the US! | COMFORTABLE TO WEAR - Precision sewing socks by hand stitching,seamless valley,Exquisite design heel socks with Y-type stitching,full wrap,reduce foot pressure,comfortable to wear. SOPHISTICATED VENTILATION DESIGN - Foot side portion has a breathable mesh desige,the use of advanced weaving technology,prespiration breathable.The body produces heat moisture can be derived,regulation of body temperature and keeps you cool.Drying,drying speed is 10 times of cotton. PERFORMANCE - Full thickness and cushioning along the bottom of the foot provide the perfect amount of support while a smooth, performance fit assures there's no slipping and no blisters. FUNCTIONAL - Moisture wicking, anti-bacterial, ventilation, deodorant and smell free. IDEAL FOR OURDOOR SPORTS -Perfect for snowboard,camping and hiking,climbing,trekking,outdoor trail,sking,backpacking. | Hiker boot in abrasion-resistant leather featuring waterproof seam-sealed construction and gunmetal-tone D-ring lacing Padded tongue and collar Removable EVA footbed for all-day comfort Rubber lug sole with B.S.F.P. motion efficiency system for improved traction and durability Note: The oiled leather finish will naturally have some scuff marks | Boot with seam-sealed waterproof construction featuring D-ring lacing and logo patch on tongue;Padded collar;Fully-gusseted tongue to keep debris out;Removable EVA foam footbed for comfort;Traction outsole |
Sorry, there's no review at this time. Try changing the filter or leaving one.
Share your opinion